5 ms·
What about going to a different planet makes you think we won't just be taking those same problems with us? The earth isn't the problem - The problem is the hu
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
What about going to a different planet makes you think we won't just be taking those same problems with us?
The earth isn't the problem - The problem is the human brain. We aren't genetically capable of processing the world we have built.
Expect there to be Trump IV vs Clinton IV 2117 hosted live on Mars if we haven't made significant improvements in human engineering.
- aerovistae 10y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding but you seem to be saying "Let's not be excited about colonizing another planet-- life will be just as depressing there."
- pasquinelli 10y agoit's a fair point.
- saiprashanth93 10y agoI think the point being made is life will be just as depressing in Mars if we are running behind things in Mars like we do here.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoYou misunderstood. Nowhere was it implied that we shouldn't be excited about anything.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wolfram74 10y agoIt's more like unless we are conscientious about what dependencies we include, we will have the same headaches with bloat using python as we have using ruby. And if the environment change is going to cost a very large amount, it would be prudent to see if any improvements can be made locally first as a form of low hanging fruit.
- lloeki 10y agoAlternatively, those are orthogonal problems, and we can pursue improvements and achievements in both.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThat's actually not a bad way to put it! Think about it this way. What if there was an uninhabited island out in the Pacific that was hard to get to. What makes it worth trying to get to? There isn't anything any more special there than here. In fact from all we've seen so far it's much less special. Same goes for Mars. What is the value in being "multi-planetary?" I mean the idea that this is a hedge against some existential threat to humanity is silly. Mars is more hostile to human life TODAY than earth would be after a massive ELE asteroid - and the likelihood of an ELE asteroid is actually higher for Mars as it does not have a stable barrier atmosphere as good as Earth's - meteorites are more frequent as a result. So best case scenario is that we have a group of people who put 75% of their time into just surviving because there is no atmosphere or biome to support them. On top of that these people have the same biological makeup - including cognitive limits, biases etc...as the rest of us on earth so even if they sorted everything out, tribalism and the rest of our hardwired heuristics would just make them behave like the rest of us. The better approach is to start engineering our faults out using data to make us better, more resilient processors of information and discovery. Improve humanity and everything is easier.
- maxerickson 10y agoI bet the first people that landed on Hawaii were pretty excited about it. The technical challenges on Mars will probably only compound the political problems. Double plus fun.
- vkou 10y agoHawaii has an extremely productive ecosystem. When your primary needs are food, shelter, and warmth, it's an absolute paradise. The first people who landed on the Galapagos islands were also pretty excited about it. Once they realized that there is no fresh water there, they got the hell out.
- raizinho 10y agoIf humanity lasts, in about a billion years the Earth will be no longer be in the Sun's habitable zone. Might as well start preparing from now.
- M_Grey 10y agoI think anytime someone plays to the deeply held hopes and dreams of a given community, especially ones that are related to long-term survival, "destiny" and the like... be very very careful and very very skeptical. That's not to say you should be depressive and cynical, but you should ask questions and seek motives. We're really not close to being a "multiplanetary species", and the major bottlenecks have nothing to do with the rockets to get us out there. A lot of smart people are aware of just how much trouble our species is in over the next century or so, and there's an element of understandable misery and panic. That really is no excuse however for cheering and weeping with joy when the guy selling the rockets points to the stars and says, "Humanity's future!"
- nitrogen 10y agoThat really is no excuse however for cheering and weeping with joy when the guy selling the rockets points to the stars and says, "Humanity's future!" Why not? Just because he's selling something doesn't mean his actions aren't useful.
- M_Grey 10y agoI said a lot of other things in that post which answers that question, before the one sentence you decided to reply to.
- nitrogen 10y agoMy reply is to your whole comment. I am still not convinced that it is inappropriate to celebrate SpaceX, if for no other reason than to encourage others to join in the vision of a multiplanetary society.
- M_Grey 10y agoCelebrate SpaceX for what they're actually doing, which is impressive as hell, not for empty talk.
- tcoppi 10y agoThroughout human history, there has always been a new/unexplored land to emigrate to for new opportunities or to escape political persecution. Nowdays there is nowhere left for someone in the West to emigrate to that is not substantially the same or worse. Mars and the stars could potentially offer that opportunity, which might be why some people are excited.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWhy not the oceans? Much easier to populate than Mars.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- miloshadzic 10y agoYou would enjoy this game: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BioShock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BioShock
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- breuleux 10y agoEarth's oceans span twice Mars's entire surface, too. Lots of room!
- unprepare 10y agoDoes that protect people from the event of a major nuclear war? Would it be immune to accelerated climate change on Earth? availability of land isnt the only factor here. (i dont actually know the answer to these questions, and obviously it would likely depend on the details of this water habitat)
- mnem 10y agoIf you're trying to escape climate change making a place uninhabitable for humans, you probably don't want to aim for Mars.
- gallonofmilk 10y agoNo don't expect that, if Clinton wins there won't be a United States left by then! :)
- kamaal 10y ago>>The earth isn't the problem It is. If you are yet not convinced, you might want to take a look at how many species go extinct every day. There are a many threats to human existence beyond human behavior and preparing for them is a good move forward.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoOr you know...discovered [1] Also, show me the species on other planets. Far as we know there aren't any and none of the planets seem to be habitable. Stop living in fantasy land. [1] http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/new-animal-species http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/new-animal-species
- kamaal 10y ago>>Also, show me the species on other planets. Exactly, lets go there and see for ourselves.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoSend robots.
- 91bananas 10y agoi lol'd
- wyager 10y ago> and none of the planets seem to be habitable. You surely don't mean that no other planets could be used to sustain life with technological assistance? Mars has water, accessible nitrogen (HNO3), carbon (CO2), hydrogen (H2O), oxygen (all of the above)... technologically assisted humans could absolutely inhabit mars.
- the_af 10y agoEven from that point of view, Mars is even more hostile to life (as we know it) than Earth.
- mikeash 10y agoThat's fine. The goal isn't to escape our problems, it's to explore new places, live there, and set up humanity so one big asteroid won't kill it.
- logfromblammo 10y agoLet's expand that from "humanity" to "a minimally viable Earth ecosystem" and not pretend that our species would be just fine without some of our favorite plants, animals, and microorganisms.
- mikeash 10y agoIs anybody actually pretending that?
- logfromblammo 10y agoHollywood, usually. They're really good at pretending, but not always so great on putting the science in science fiction.
- fixermark 10y agoThe problems we take with us aren't the problem this project addresses---there is one problem we unequivocally leave behind if we successfully colonize Mars. For all our accomplishments, the human species is one unavoidable planet-scale disaster away from total extinction. We know this class of disaster has happened in Earth's past, and we know we lack the capability to stop it. Colonizing Mars gives the species that much more chance to extend its survival past the terrestrial-impact threshold. There are myriad other ways we could wipe ourselves out that myriad people are working on. None of them matter if something kills Earth's biosphere (much like this project doesn't matter if something like war kills us off before we succeed). They aren't mutually exclusive.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoAll of this is true. Going to Mars fixes none of these problems however and wastes a lot of energy in the process.
- fixermark 10y agoI'm talking about asteroid impact. It fixes asteroid impact.
- goatlover 10y agoWouldn't it be cheaper to defend against an asteroid impact? We only need detect and deflect in time.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoNo it doesn't. Mars today is likely less habitable than post-asteroid earth. Also, Asteroids can hit Mars with the same likelihood - but with less protection from an existing dense atmosphere. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/508906/mars-astronauts-likely-to-witness-1-megaton-asteroid-impacts/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/508906/mars-astronauts-li...
- elihu 10y ago
- wyager 10y ago> What about going to a different planet makes you think we won't just be taking those same problems with us? It'll just be wealthy people for a long time. Wealth is strongly correlated with intelligence, peace, and other desirable factors. Perhaps the social baseline will be a lot higher. This is hard to predict given that we don't really know what the psychological and epigenetic effects of going to mars will be.