9 ms·
> Something on the lines of don't collect any data, besides name, password, email address. This information can never be sold. Would you then pay for the servi
by chii 10y ago
> Something on the lines of don't collect any data, besides name, password, email address. This information can never be sold.
Would you then pay for the services in full that you now could use for free?
- bonoboTP 10y agoMaybe yes, maybe not. So what? It should still be forbidden. If it turns out that not enough people want to pay for it, then tough luck for the company, they should design something that people will pay for. For example it is forbidden to take organs from people as payment. We could forbid taking certain private data from masses of people as payment.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoIf you put trade in organs in the same basket as trade in conclusions from personal data, then I have to wonder what you put in the other basket, the one where consenting adults are allowed to freely enter into agreements. If you are criticising that people are not willingly and knowingly entering into agreements with Facebook or Google, that is another debate. Yes I think there should be the utmost level of transparency and regulatory action on that front is justified in my view. But telling people that they cannot trade access to personal data for access to services goes way beyond the role I think governments should have. If that sort of thing is prohibited, how can a government allow its people to make any decisions that potentially affect their safety and their future, like choosing a career path, choosing a place to live, making decisions on health, education, kids, etc?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoThe reason why government should forbid it is not to protect the individual that's agreeing to give away their data, but to protect society from the externalities of those transactions when they occur en masse. Privacy is a necessity for a democracy, without it, democracy falls apart, that is extremely dangerous, and that's why a democratic society should protect itself against it.
- fauigerzigerk 10y ago>The reason why government should forbid it is not to protect the individual that's agreeing to give away their data, but to protect society from the externalities of those transactions when they occur en masse. And now please explain to me what sort of voluntary agreement does not have negative externalities when it occurs en masse! Voluntary agreements inevitably create markets and markets have well known negative externalities. Even the democratic process itself has negative externalities. On that basis you can ban everything. I'm not against all regulation, but your justification is way too general. It leads straight into authoritarianism.
- bpchaps 10y agoHow does it lead to authoritarianism? You're making some pretty sweeping statements there..
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoBecause there are no personal freedoms that cannot be taken away if negative externalities alone are a sufficient justification. Outright bans are the strictest form of regulation. They should only be used as a last resort. We don't even ban industrial scale cruelty towards animals and now we should ban voluntary trade in personal data? That seems completely out of proportion.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoAre you suggesting that externalities alone cannot ever be sufficient justification for a ban, no matter how bad the externalities are?
- jerf 10y agoNo. "X is not always a sufficient reason" != "X is never a sufficient reason."
- 10y ago
- treehau5 10y agoWe already allow our government to make decisions on access to personal data for services -- it's called HIPAA. The difference between that and seemingly "ordinary" data is that HIPAA data can be used against us unfairly. I argue that's the case now, and we have proof it is already happening. You better bet your bottom dollar insurance companies and the likes are mining social media to charge different prices based on silly facebook posts http://www.cnbc.com/2014/04/16/data-mining-is-now-used-to-set-insurance-rates-critics-cry-fowl.html http://www.cnbc.com/2014/04/16/data-mining-is-now-used-to-se... It's only a matter of time before police forces will begin to use these same techniques to "optimize policing" We live in a different time now. Our data is not as harmless as it used to be. Hackers can attack various sources of services and build complete picture of peoples lives. Companies are using data mining techniques to leverage people's private interaction with friends and families against them. The worst part about it is -- it's complicated, and we have a technically inept Congress that barely understands the implications of all these technologies, and we will soon have a technically inept soon to be incumbent president, so these legal issues are not going to get any better. this, plus what zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC mentioned, until we have the right to "be forgotten" or the ability to have our records completely purged after a period of time -- like you do with debt, like you do with criminal records, like you do with basically any public record, we will have these privacy issues. Right now if you want to purge false information about yourself on the internet, you have to go through hell and back (trust me, I've tried, Salon has had a completely fabricated story about me for almost 10 years now. I send an email every week asking them to redact my name from that article. Unless I seemingly spend hundreds of thousands to fight their legal arm, it's probably never going to change.)
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoI'm not arguing against all regulation. I'm arguing against an outright ban on voluntary trading of personal data.
- ska 10y agoOut of curiosity, how do you feel about regulation on the disclosure side of this, and/or informed consent. For example, if you are not allowed to accept personal data without detailed (and interactive) information about possible uses, perhaps signed. Or if you constrain the actual uses to those that have been enumerated, in full detail, before consent was given. One the primary "banning" arguments I hear basically boils down to "people don't understand what they are agreeing to", which I think holds some truth.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- forgottenpass 10y agoconsenting adults are allowed to freely enter into agreements. I accept as a fact of modern life, that I unless I want to go be a hermit in the woods, I'll find myself entering into many contracts of adhesion that go against my ideals. And that as much as I try to limit this (not using facebook or whatsapp) I can't actually escape them entirely. It is disingenuous to think that either (a) people fully understand and knowingly make the agreements they do w/r/t data or (b) do so willingly. To draw the conclusion that it's just adults freely consenting in light of the previous paragraph is sophistry.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoI don't deny these issues at all. That's why I said regulating to make sure people understand what they agree to is fine. I also think people need to be able to change their mind. There are a lot of specific things that I think are unacceptable (such as employers or landlords demanding access to facebook accounts). As I said, I'm not against all regulation. But if most people are in fact fine with granting access to their personal data in exchange for services then peer pressure on the rest of us who refuse the deal cannot be justification enough to ban the entire business model. I'm in the same boat as you. I refuse to use Facebook.
- ricksplat 10y agoAbsolutely! I am a big believer in paying for things. I wish sites would give me the "option" of paying and thus not being mined and spammed with stupid irrelevant advertisements (advocates often saying these two phenomena should cancel each other out and I have yet to see it ...) but most sites that I do pay for want to do all this stuff anyway! To be honest I don't mind the mining so much, as long as I know there is some "protection" for my data - as is under discussion here. I do object to annoying poorly targeted ads though.
- eitland 10y agoThis particular case is proof that yes: for certain services we happily pay a modest recurring service fee. Edit, clarification: - this does not mean that I want to pay an monthly fee to use pro features on static apps. Anyone who does this instantly loses a star in the review as soon as I get around to it. - however I also understand and appreciate that I sometimes can pay a higher up front price to support the developer(s) for apps that works offline without a service connection. - feature keys or even donation addons etc to support further development are also well received. This nicely aligns the incentives for developers/users. - and finally, for some select projects I would think it would be OK with a subscription that gave me all new features as they arrived.
- icantdrive55 10y agoYes--I didn't bring up advertising. They could advertise like the old days, like news papers did. They just couldn't target market their advertising--like they presently do at nausium. I still think they would make their nut. They would still be winners! And yes--I would pay for the right service, if they couldn't manage to compete by being hobbled with not targeted advertising. I paid for many websites before Google made advertising a science. (My post has nothing to do with advertising. I get advertising. Just leave my info. out of it.)
- belorn 10y agoIf a sale person stood on the street and offered people to install tracking software in their phones that will record every move, every call, every text, which the customer is told will be sold at a nice profit to any one thats willing to buy it with no oversight. At the end of one year, non-poor customer that the company earned profits from from will get a one time compensation of $20. How many people will accept the deal, and why doesn't it already exist? Or to ask a different question, will companies demand $20 for the services instead of offering it for tracking-as-payment? How will they fare against less polished services that are given away for free by people who run it on their spare time?
- Klathmon 10y agoThey exist, and they do very well. Things like Nielson and others have been doing something similar for many years, as well as countless surveys that can pay you, and both of my parents have installed on seperate occasions a toolbar which pays them pennies per day they keep it enabled, and when asked about it they were fine with it recording everything as long as they get their payout.
- belorn 10y agoI have seen those, but they are like you say about "pennies per day". Google could not survive on that. If we are comparing a regular $40-$20 software sale to pay-by-tracking, then the people being tracked need to generate personal information that is worth equal amounts. It need to have mass market appeal in order to generate billions. How will pennies per day tool-bars do that?
- s3r3nity 10y agoWell the information is not "sold" per se, as much as it's bundled with many other people, decoupled from PII, and is the equivalent of saying "10% of people talked about the football game today." Further, I believe a service like Google Contributor does what you're implying, but it doesn't get much press - which doesn't surprise me: the overall market deems free content worth that privacy "trade-off." I don't understand why this is necessarily a "bad" thing -- it's like the equivalent of a real-estate broker telling me that 10/20 houses on a block have 2 bedrooms, and the other 10 have 3 bedrooms, even though I know nothing about the people living in those houses.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoYou cannot use it for free now. Just because the currency isn't US dollars, doesn't make it free.
- danarmak 10y agoI would gladly pay for every single service I use - email, messaging, social networks, various sites - in exchange for no advertising and no user data collection.
- networth 10y agosorry for shameless plug: http://minutesworth.launchrock.com http://minutesworth.launchrock.com It's a mere launch rock page, but i am gauging interest on the project. I actually have a big portion of ready, and rest under work, but finding people to pick up the idea is tough. Everybody say they'll pay, but it's different from actually doing.
- danarmak 10y agoThat's interesting, but from the copy on the page it seems to target micropayments for reading content published on websites. Which is an important and hard problem. On the other hand, paying a dollar a month to use a service like email doesn't pose a technological problem. But since most services, unlike email, are walled gardens, I can't pay a provider to give me access to e.g. WhatsApp or Facebook without serving ads or collecting my data.
- networth 10y agoRight. Web is first target, apps is second. Think of an app you install on device, and apps registering as a publisher can talk to this app to get your subscription status, and not show you ads. The promise is with sufficient adoption by users and pubs, new pubs will have incentive to do this. Except maybe apps by large corporations.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 10y ago> Would you then pay for the services in full that you now could use for free? I don't use them free, I pay with my information. I just don't know exactly how much I'm paying. I'm happy to pay in either form, as long as I know exactly what I'm paying.
- Klathmon 10y agoThis I could get behind. Make legislation that forces a company to disclose the information they collect in an explicit way. As a consumer I'd also like a way to force my data to be deleted, and be notified if my data is being sold or transferred by an acquisition or something, but I'm not sure how that would work. What I don't want is not having the ability to "pay with data". I don't want to subscribe to everything out there, and paywalls threaten the web as we know it. Plus there are times where I want to be tracked. If a company has info on how I use the product, they can improve it for me.
- ashark 10y agoI say make any company collecting info (beyond maybe some very bare-bones basics that any company providing a service pretty much has to have, like name, address, phone number) about its users provide that info, say, once a year, on request. Kinda like the annual free credit reports from the credit agencies. ALL of it, too. Every time. Not just what was collected since last report. Even require that they provide it on physical media if desired. Again, for free, including postage. "But that will be so expensive because we collect so much and never get rid of any!" ... yeah, so what? Now they're free to do it but can't hide what they're collecting and can't hold your data hostage. And there's some cost associated with collecting more than is absolutely necessary.
- bogomipz 10y agoI for one would pay for a service that agreed not sell my data and afford me basic privacy assurances. I don't think I am alone in that either. And Whatsapp did have a subscription fee in the past, before it was bought by a dominant player for 19 Billion. But I can't see why a company like FB would be interested in offering a privacy enhanced version of this service. What could they reasonably expect a user to pay, 10 dollars a month? User data brings in far more revenue than that 10 dollars per user per month. I would think that 10 dollars is peanuts to them by comparison.