7 ms·
Only Select Developers Can Publish Google Daydream Apps Until 2017
- steventhedev 10y agoThis confused me until I remembered that Google is recycling the term Daydream. Search for Android Daydream and you'll find a few results for the old lockscreen API (after all the VR hype). Can we get a VR added in parentheses to disambiguate the title?
- elaus 10y agoThis reuse of "Daydream" has been bugging me for month whenever I read about the VR project. Seems like not many people ever took notice of (lockscreen) Daydream or otherwise Google wouldn't just recycle the name.
- MBlume 10y agoMy guess: badly done VR makes you nauseous. Humans remember under what circumstances they've become nauseous. Google does not want their platform associated in people's minds with nausea, so they're curating.
- 1_listerine_pls 10y agoThey did the same with google glass, nausea wasn't the reason.
- ktta 10y agoCurating is the reason. When a new platform is released (and Daydream is as exciting as a platform can get, till widespread AR atleast) you want the initial experience to be the best possible to increase standards.
- CM30 10y agoIn other words, trying to avoid what happened to the smartphone app market where it turned into a wild west mostly devoid of quality control. I guess I can see that.
- _ZeD_ 10y agoMy 2c guess: porn.
- markatkinson 10y agoHa. There is already enough VR porn that out there.
- ungzd 10y agoGoogle is against this greatest sin to save humanity from Fiery Gehenna using DRM.
- apatters 10y agoI encourage developers to wait for a more open platform before jumping on the VR bandwagon. We don't need Google to curate VR apps for us. The PC did just fine with anyone being able to develop and distribute whatever kind of app they wanted, in fact it created far more business opportunity for developers than mobile ever did. We screwed up when it came to mobile by letting Google and Apple get away with their land grabs. Now we're paying them until the end of time for the privilege of being able to market our own software. We don't need Google owning and taxing this space as well.
- gman83 10y agoWhat? The PC didn't do fine with distributing software at all, at least not before Steam came along. On Linux the situation was ok with package managers like apt, but on Windows it was terrible. You basically couldn't buy any games online, you'd have to install from DVD, and every game basically had to implement an inbuilt update/patching system. Google Play/Steam/iOS App Store may be a tax, but let's not pretend something similar isn't necessary.
- oblio 10y agoFor a long time we needed DVDs not just because online installs were not available, but because broadband internet wasn't widely available. It was hardly a nice experience to have to wait 12-24 hours to download a game. Steam was a little ahead of the curve, true. And regarding updates, the OS makers could just create an official update library that everyone can use. App Stores are just an OS maker powerplay, a cash grab.
- dovdov 10y agoBut.. open.. and.. Apple's walled garden.. and..
- twblalock 10y agoGoogle would have better products if it had the focus and control of Apple. Google's products have suffered in the past from a short attention span and early abandonment, not to mention fragmentation. I'm glad Google is taking a page from Apple's playbook and paying more attention to quality control.
- andybak 10y ago> Everyone else will be allowed to publish apps “early next year.” Assuming this happens, aren't you overstating your point?
- detaro 10y agoWhat do restrictions for apps on the Play store have to do with walled garden vs open? If the block you from loading VR apps from outside the store, that would be a walled garden. The stores itself IMHO are very similar already.
- rjknight 10y agoWhy are they curating by choosing which developers to allow, rather than by choosing which apps to allow, similar to the iOS App Store?
- rspeer 10y agoI think because it's so hard to do VR well that they'd have to reject almost all the apps. They'd have a choice between a terrible first impression for users, or a terrible first impression for developers.
- markatkinson 10y agoI suppose it isn't as clear cut as that. If you check the application form you do actually submit links to content related to your app. So I imagine it is a combined, developer/app review.
- markatkinson 10y agoMe and a partner have been developing a game for the release of Daydream this year on Unreal. We are hobbyists who decided to take a stab at doing something more professional. My concern is that just because we lack a track record of game development we will get rejected from DAP. Now there is a mad rush to get a website up, and content on the internet for the curators. I must be honest I didn't see this one coming! Anyway, we are excited to get our content out there and have put in a lot of time and research into understanding what makes a good game. From consistent and strong game thematic, to many many hours of play-ability testing. Will definitely post a link to HN once we have our content up.
- _pmf_ 10y agoGoogle sure is consistent in guaranteeing that their innovation projects are dead at arrival.
- msabalau 10y agoTo be fair, this is slightly less lame than Glass, where even the published developers were prohibited from making money by either charging for the app or advertising.
- Shorel 10y agoGoogle is trying to test the 'VIP club' effect that worked so well for gmail and facebook in the past. However, they are not the only kids in the block this time.
- Rezo 10y agoI can understand them wanting to curate at the start, first impressions are critical and shovelware (quickly ported existing Android games and apps) could poison the well. I'm personally highly interested in developing for Daydream and VR in general, I believe Google's trying to make VR affordable for the masses. Waiting a few months isn't a big deal, if it will help establish a quality bar for what is a good mobile VR app.
- arpit 10y agoHonestly, I do think this is a good thing. The problem I have with VR isn't just the number of apps but the quality and differences in experiences (I am not much of a gamer and the stores are 90% games. Would love to see more 'apps'). DayDream could be a lot of people's first introduction to VR and so having a smaller library of high quality content for a few months before opening the floodgates may not be a bad idea.