8 ms·
The "labor-exploiting" argument seems a bit disingenious to me. It's not like someone sees an ad for Uber and tells their boss to shove it, as they're quitting
by prostoalex 10y ago
The "labor-exploiting" argument seems a bit disingenious to me. It's not like someone sees an ad for Uber and tells their boss to shove it, as they're quitting their full-time job, forfeiting all the benefits and 401(k) matching to start a brand new career as an Uber driver.
The alternative for many drivers is simply unemployment. While there's zero possibility of labor exploitation, it reminds me of Flight of the Conchords quote "There is no more unethical treatment of the elephants. - Well, there's no more elephants, so..."
- jrockway 10y agoOne wonders if driving for Uber could compete with basic income. The Internet keeps telling me that all Uber drivers are unhappy. I use Uber from time to time, and about 90% of the time, the driver seems super happy to be driving for Uber. They seem happy with their compensation. Maybe all the drivers are new, this is their first week, and it all sounds good on paper. But maybe they actually like the job. I don't know.
- hkmurakami 10y agoI'd be afraid of a bad review if I told a passenger I'm not happy driving for Uber. What do I have to gain from sharing this info? At best I'm where I was before and at worst maybe an Uber employee is testing me for fidelity and I could be punished. The truth is somewhere in between, and a non zero number of passengers would rate me a non-5 star if I complained about my condition. So take the info with a grain of salt.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI don't mind a driver mentioning they're not happy driving for Uber and Lyft, or that the rates have gone down in the area, or that they've had a lot of short trips today. That alone wouldn't cause me to rate a driver poorly, though I can imagine that it might for some people. I do mind when I get a 20-minute rant for the duration of the trip, though. I've had that happen once or twice, once accompanied with a less than subtle "it's possible to tip in cash".
- jpkeisala 10y agoUsually I would not mind but then again if I am tired or busy which I usually am when commuting. I don't feel like listening other people problems.
- jrockway 10y agoI don't ask anymore (for exactly these reasons; why would anyone trust me with this information), but you can kind of get a picture of how much the person likes their job by the general interaction.
- xg15 10y agoExcept they're "disrupting" the taxi industry to get to that point. So they're destroying jobs and replacing them with less secure, less paid ones. (Wether or not that disruption has a positive effect for society in the big picture is another debate - but in terms of labor you can't ignore it)
- prostoalex 10y ago> replacing them with less secure, less paid ones My understanding is that people got in deep debt to the medallion owner, which they slowly repaid from taxi revenues. Are taxi jobs at the lowest rung that secure and well-paid?
- pdkl95 10y agoThe "medallion" system has its own problems, usually relating to monopoly power. The debt issue you mentioned is an example of that. However, Uber (and similar businesses like airbnb) are really little more than the exploitation of legal loopholes to bypass the usual costs of employment law and industry-specific regulations. Socializing expenses is always profitable, and its easy to beat existing players if you aren't paying the same expenses. Regarding job security, normal employees at least have a collection of legal protections that cover the employer-employee relationship. It's obviously not going to stop every type of abuse, but it's better than nothing. Some jurisdictions have started to catch up and force Uber et al to act properly, but as usual law is (very) slow to update.
- icebraining 10y agoTaxi drivers were already considered contractors. In fact, they are in a lawsuit against the taxi companies over that: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-26/news/chi-suit-taxi-drivers-should-be-considered-employees-20140326_1_taxi-drivers-yellow-cab-taxi-industry http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-26/news/chi-suit-... Which costs of employment that taxi companies paid is Uber bypassing? Please be specific instead of relying on rumor and propaganda.
- ezzaf 10y ago
- mweibel 10y agoOf course having a job is better than no job. That doesn't excuse Uber from having good working conditions, though.
- norikki 10y agoYou understand that the people at WaPo who you got that argument from are just using it as an excuse to take back control of the industry with political maneuvering. The solution to not enough high paying jobs is to raise demand for workers, and lower supply. Not pass a law requiring all workers to get lots of benefits they may not want coming out of their paychecks.
- lambda 10y agoSeveral of the Uber/Lyft drivers I've talked to are actually former small business owners; they owned bakeries and pizza shops, and are now retiring from that by driving for Uber or Lyft, which over much better and more flexible hours than having to work 12 to 16 hour days that they do running their former businesses. Others are people with seasonal or part time work; they work in real estate or as relationship therapists, but use driving for Uber and Lyft to cover for the times when they're less busy. Some more are people who are just bored during the day, and want to give people rides. A few are college students, trying to make ends meet as they pay their way through school. And a few more are doing this full time; some are former cabbies, who find they get a lot more business this way, some are people who never would have been cabbies, but are able to find some income from Uber or Lyft.
- matt4077 10y agoThe most common alternative, and the actual net change, is taxi driver. The only difference being a 50% reduction in wages. It's a giant app-based redistribution of wealth from the front seats to the back seats. And even if the alternative were unemployment – how does that mean that there shouldn't be a standard for such kinds of work? If people have to accept any working conditions because otherwise they'd starve to death, is that really an argument for the mighty benevolence of the free market? Considering that it appears as if there's plenty of food to go around, it doesn't strike me as the perfect outcome of 300 years of capitalism that we apparently still need to have 10% of every generation suffer, not because of any real scarcity but as a necessity for the other's motivation.
- kartickv 10y agoIt would be a redistribution only if Uber drivers are earning less. Do you have data to prove that? Maybe the lower prices and better quality of service are incenting more people to take Ubers than taxis, which may mean that drivers are earning more, in aggregate and/or individually. I've taken a couple of dozen Uber trips that I wouldn't have taken by taxi. That's a redistribution from me to a poorer driver — a good thing.
- gjolund 10y agoTheir employment is only temporary unless they are developing skills that are in demand.