4 ms·
I just read a review of "How Brains Make Up Their Minds. Thanks for mentioning that. It looks like a good book with mostly correct information (based on the r
by ilaksh 10y ago
I just read a review of "How Brains Make Up Their Minds. Thanks for mentioning that. It looks like a good book with mostly correct information (based on the review).
From the summary, I can tell you that researchers in fields such as AGI, deep learning, robotics, etc. have absolutely been working from many if not all of Freeman's assumptions for years and almost all (if not all) of that has been integrated into various research programs and systems. Freeman's pragmatist view is now the most popular.
Of course, all of Freeman's ideas aren't _usually_ together in every one of these systems or the conceptualization of them, but there are at least a few that have most of them.
Certainly AGI researchers are aware of the concept of higher-level abstractions being formed at root on the basis of sensory input and action output. And most of the recent serious AI research such as pretty much any NN for example demonstrates the idea of meaning from global patterns.
These are some interesting AGI videos in case people haven't seen them.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCCwJ8AV1zMM4j9FTicGimqA/playlists https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCCwJ8AV1zMM4j9FTicGimqA/pla...
- AndrewOMartin 10y agoI strongly object to the ideas in that book bring described with the terms such as "higher-level abstractions", "sensory input and action output", and "meaning from global patterns". As I read it, they were precisely the notions Freeman was arguing against. There is no "input" when the history of a being, it's current sensitivities and orientation in the environment are all inseparable and mutually defining. There are no higher level abstractions, and none needed, when you're so poised in a situation with your whole brain and body that any appropriate stimulation is already meaningful. Freeman, for me turned thought upside down. I.e. we don't go, "I've detected that as being food, so I may eat it", rather we go "I've noticed I interact with all these things in a similar way (e.g. eating) that's how I recognise them as related".
- ilaksh 10y agoYour conclusion aligns with my statements. So I think you are interpreting what I wrote incorrectly.