5 ms·
This article is, frankly, childish. Apple was a fading platform when Adobe made that decision, and it made perfect business sense. Until about 2008, the last t
by barrkel 17y ago
This article is, frankly, childish. Apple was a fading platform when Adobe made that decision, and it made perfect business sense.
Until about 2008, the last time I had even seen a Mac on this (Eastern) side of the Atlantic was about 1991 or so.
- Asa-Nisse 17y agoThe point is that flash is a fading technology now... in a few years HTML5 will replace it for video purposes. The iPhone is a better gaming plattform. What if Apple released a similar technology to run Obj-C applications in the browser (think of the market for the already developed games to the iPhone)
- pan69 17y ago"What if Apple released a similar technology to run Obj-C applications in the browser" Like Mircosoft tried to with with ActiveX? I don't think so...
- watty 17y agoAfter what we've seen lately it seems that many Apple users WOULD love it. The end users are the ones here getting hurt by these grudges - why can't they see it? There are great Unity3D, Appcelerator, and Flash apps that will never be made on the App store. How does that not bother you as an end user?
- heresy 17y agoHeard of Google NaCl? Yeah. Native code in a browser without the security implications.
- tedunangst 17y agoAnd without all that pesky portability either.
- andrewvc 17y ago* flash is a fading technology now... in a few years HTML5 will replace it for video purposes. * In a few years people will be using HTML5 video, and fall back to flash where not available. A few more years after that, maybe things will be different.
- ahk 17y agoI dont think so. All the big sites are converting to HTML5 now since the highest paying audience is on the iPad. New features will be targeted to that market first as well. The flash audience will be second class citizens. But with users needing only to change their browsers for a better experience, I think they will do so surprisingly quickly.
- langa 17y agoOH YEAH!! Because users are renowned for updating their browsers. Flash has 99% of the market. I would gather that 90% of users on the internet don't have a friggin' clue what this whole debate is about and wont care how they view their videos. I like the idea of HTML5, but if it takes off like many preach, users will probably notice how everything is a little less polished and a little more crappy. Then they'll still not care.
- wvenable 17y agoI see no evidence that Flash is fading technology -- I suspect it's usage is increasing a regular rate even now. Almost every game on the web is a Flash game. How many millions of people play Flash games on Facebook? HTML5 may replace it for video purposes but that's only one (recent) thing that Flash is used for. If you have an iPhone 3GS right now, Apple will have long stopped providing updates before HTML has supplanted Flash for all things. Hell, HTML5 isn't even a standard yet.
- wvenable 17y agoAlso Apple had been dicking around with their OS strategy for years before Jobs came back into the fray. Initially Apple was not going to provide the Carbon API and tried "suggesting" Adobe (and other software firms) to port their software to this entirely different OS. Without the benefit of hindsight, Adobe made the correct decision.
- protomyth 17y agoThe funny part is that they had at least one product running on NeXTSTEP (Illustrator I think).
- n8agrin 17y agoApple is in the business of controlling its platform and that's how they think they can make money selling design driven consumer computer equipment. So, from that perspective, Apple's choice to have a restrictive list of supported languages makes perfect business sense too. Not saying I agree with Apple's choice, but it's theirs to make.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoI think the article is unduly harsh but I think it makes a valid point. It's sort of a live by the sword, die by the sword thing. Adobe made the right business decision in 2002 and I don't think you can fault them for that. But Apple's making the right business decision now and I don't think you can fault them for that. So I think the bottom line is that Adobe's falling victim to the same thing that they did to Apple back in 2002 and that's just the reality of the world.
- csomar 17y agoAdobe at that time could not support the development of an extensive platform for a small user base OS. But right now, there are no reason why limit the options to develop for the iPhone OS.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoI'm sorry, but that's just not true. As the recent OS4 demo showed Apple has put a lot of work into creating custom features on the iPhone. If developers start using Flash and developing one application for every platform they'll stop using those custom features. If developers stop using those custom features then they make the whole platform less valuable. If that happens then the iPhone no longer holds any advantages over say Google android at which point Apple loses its market share.
- csomar 17y agoNot true, as the iPhone gets more popular, Adobe will take care of those custom features. There will be custom features for iPhone, Android or Windows Mobile. It'll make developing for mobile more fun, because you don't have to develop each application alone and use a specific machine/os for each phone.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoDo you work for Adobe? If not I don't see how you make the claims that you're making right now. I certainly wouldn't bet my business on those claims. Which is what you're asking Apple to do.
- mgcross 17y ago"Innovate or die, bitches." Childish at best. And I'm certainly no stickler for grammar and style, but I had trouble reading past this one: "Matter of fact, it was sure of its decision to forget OS X development that it focused Premiere solely for Windows only to see Apple turnaround and buy a Macromedia offshoot, repackage it as a Final Cut and cut Adobe out a lucrative stream."
- kelnos 17y agoMore style than grammar... the sentence is mostly grammatical, but could use a couple more commas and be a little clearer about what the pronoun "it" stands for. Not to mention that "turn around" is two words. Anyway, though, a critique on grammar and style is hardly the best way to evaluate its message... which I think was a good one. The cheap shot at the end was unfortunate, but the rest was reasonable, I think.
- prgmatic 17y agoFrankly, it all makes business sense. Apple's decisions today are all part of their strategy to increase the pie, increase their piece of the pie, and create new pies. People are analyzing the shit out of Steve Job's decisions as of late, but when you look at it from a business perspective, objectively, it all makes great sense. Furthermore, Steve Jobs does not answer to the tech community, at the end of the day he answers to only one group of people: the shareholders. *Note: I know that he is a major shareholder himself, but the point is still valid.
- wvenable 17y agoNobody is saying it doesn't make business sense. Nike having children in China sew their shoes together makes business sense too. It's still just a crappy thing to do.
- bruceboughton 17y agoUnfortunately it's not such a crappy thing to do that it affects sales... hence it makes good business sense
- billswift 17y agoUnless it turns off developers to such an extent that it affects the quality of apps on the platform. For that everyone will just have to wait and see - the big disagreement here is mostly on what the effects will be.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agohealth outcomes for people working in factories is still superior to the ones doing back-breaking rural farming which is the default.
- protomyth 17y agoI think comparing "not being able to use your favorite language" to "children doing grueling factory work" is a little bit over the line.
- johSho7w 17y agoNot to mention that Apple had just burned Adobe with the whole ditching Copland fiasco. I'm sure Adobe was thinking, "Oh, sure yet another framework from Apple." Also, remember at the time Apple was promising windows availability of OpenStep as a reason to port to Yellow Box. Where's Windows Yellow Box today? iTunes/Safari for Windows. i.e. Apple's use only.
- kelnos 17y agoLong-term, though, it was arguably the wrong decision. Hindsight is of course 20/20, but they've had 14 years to revise their decision, based on clear evidence that Apple was re-emerging and growing rapidly. And yet, no change... until now. And Adobe is surprised that Apple doesn't care to support them?
- demet8 17y agoAdobe screwed itself. Point blank. Karma is a b*.
- tomlin 17y ago"Innovate or die, bitches." Adobe isn't perfect by any means, but their business decision to focus on one platform rather than another is no more selfish than any other software company I've seen. Apple having a "quality control" platform that keeps their proprietary technology from being effected by other proprietary technology is all this is about.