6 ms·
I toured an open house in Sunnyvale yesterday to have a look at what $1.7M buys you these days. 1900 sq ft, four bedrooms, two and a half baths, a nicely remode
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I toured an open house in Sunnyvale yesterday to have a look at what $1.7M buys you these days. 1900 sq ft, four bedrooms, two and a half baths, a nicely remodeled kitchen and a small patch of yard. And I asked the realtors if they expected to get any offers. They already had offers but they are waiting until Monday to sit down and sift through them. And then the big question, could they describe the type of people buying these houses?
The answer was couples where both parents worked in the tech industry with a combined income of over $300,000. Usually one child and often one on the way, many have houses already further away (Livermore, Gilroy, Morgan Hill) that they are selling.
Now that is unscientific, it is the experience of one broker who is sitting in one open house, showing the house to prospective buyers and gently quizzing them on their financials in order to understand if they are good prospects or not. But I can see other evidence that its probably accurate, the folks moving into my neighborhood fit that profile. A lot of people looking for "good schools" because if you don't pay private school tuition that saves you $15,000 per kid per year you can put into house payments.
My point being that the houses are being listed and sold in a short time frame. That suggests that the housing market is pricing appropriately for the buyers. That there are more buyers than houses pushes up the price and pushes out the buyers who do not earn as much. However, unlike San Francisco, there is a lot of residential building being put up on the peninsula and south toward San Jose. Across a wide spectrum from apartments to condos to single family attached, and single family detached. Sunnyvale has a ballot measure (https://sunnyvalepubliclandsact.com/ https://sunnyvalepubliclandsact.com/) that is seeking to limit how the city can transfer park land to developers to turn into houses (or hotels, or office parks). That measure is an artifact of all the building that is going on.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> My point being that the houses are being listed and sold in a short time frame. That suggests that the housing market is pricing appropriately for the buyers. I'd call that a seller's market. Houses may be selling quickly because of a lack of supply and elite buyers are moving asap. A buyer's market would be one where buyers are not in a hurry, one where houses stay on the market for a while, negating any need to bid high and fast. I'm currently in the ultimate seller's market (Vancouver, north shore) with a <1% rental vacancy rate and houses selling within hours. I laugh a little at the prices in the OP. 1.7m won't get you much in my neck of the woods. Some 35 new apartments (2Br 2Bath) in west van just pre-sold for 7.5m each. And they haven't even broken ground on the building. The city/province is starting to take drastic steps as the young flee and shops close. The market is in a bit of a panic, but that is what drastic steps were meant to do.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoIt's not exactly a reply, but in nearby Fremont, there's more going on than Californians relocating from nearby commuting communities. There is a non-trivial amount of money coming in from other countries to bid up property as well. Offering my own anecdote, I received a flyer in the mail about a year ago from a local realtor who is well known and has a sizable business (I don't want to promote him by naming him here). He explicitly stated in his flyer that sellers should dress their homes specifically to market to Indian buyers, because Indians made up 90% of his buyers at the time.
- ori_b 10y ago> * There is a non-trivial amount of money coming in from other countries to bid up property as well. And how many of them were engineers moving over for jobs? It's not just Californians relocating from nearby communities, sure -- I moved from Canada (via a few years in New York), for example. But it's unlikely to be some foreign absentee landlord.
- tamana 10y agoIn my experience foreign absentee landlords aren't even very bad, because they care mainly about parking their assets outside of China, more than maximizing or even collecting rent.
- throwaway_exer 10y agoForeign absentee landlords are terrible to municipal services in California, since Proposition 13 makes them reliant on sales and franchise taxes instead. In the case of Vancouver, they have made a hollow city.
- ajmurmann 10y agoNot caring about collecting rent often leads to empty houses that now nobody can live in. That's about the worst that can happen if we want to get housing costs down.
- imtringued 10y ago
- boulos 10y agoI was with you until the "unlike San Francisco" about building. Unless you mean single family homes, San Francisco is seemingly permitting and building about the same per person as Santa Clara County (http://my.paragon-re.com/Docs/General/SixtyFortyImages/New-Construction_by-County.jpg http://my.paragon-re.com/Docs/General/SixtyFortyImages/New-C... from http://www.paragon-re.com/San_Francisco_Housing_Development_Report http://www.paragon-re.com/San_Francisco_Housing_Development_...) while San Mateo is way underweight: with almost the same population as San Francisco, San Mateo county approved about half as many units. So while it's true that most of the new units are in SOMA, I think they still count ;).
- ChuckMcM 10y agoA fair point, and I was not aware they had approved as much housing as they had in San Francisco of late.
- frutiger 10y ago> I toured an open house in Sunnyvale yesterday to have a look at what $1.7M buys you these days. 1900 sq ft, four bedrooms, two and a half baths... That seems quite cheap compared to Manhattan[0][1][2][3], and only one of those is in an relatively desirable neighbourhood. 0. http://streeteasy.com/building/richmond-condominium/9a?featured=1 http://streeteasy.com/building/richmond-condominium/9a?featu... 1. http://streeteasy.com/building/439-east-51-street-new_york/6b http://streeteasy.com/building/439-east-51-street-new_york/6... 2. http://streeteasy.com/building/355-east-19-street-new_york/3 http://streeteasy.com/building/355-east-19-street-new_york/3 3. http://streeteasy.com/building/circa-central-park/5g http://streeteasy.com/building/circa-central-park/5g
- phamilton 10y agoYes, but Manhattan isn't suburbia like Sunnyvale is.
- TuringNYC 10y agoThe comparison is really apples and oranges: 1. One is in the center of a job district where you can often walk to work (Manhattan) and the other (Sunnyvale) has some jobs but is generally 30min to 120min from the center-of-gravity of jobs. 2. How much do you value your time? I'd pay that much in Manhattan because it would allow me to spend 2.5h more per day with my family (when I worked in Manhattan, i strolled to work) 3. Property taxes are generally higher in CA, as is upkeep and insurance on these homes 4. You need 2 cars in Sunnyvale generally, but in Manhattan you can live very comfortably w/o cars and overspend on the apartment. There are so many things that make this an apples-to-oranges comparison, the above list is not comprehensive.
- frutiger 10y agoThanks - I stand corrected. I've been to SF and much further south, I didn't quite realise/remember that the suburbs start so close to the bay.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI actually agree with your general point, which is that Manhattan presents a much more single car friendly work environment but disagree with your characterization of Sunnyvale. I chose to buy my house in Sunnyvale because it was near the "center" of things (and for a time that was a bit more literal than I expected). Within ~30 minutes of downtown Sunnyvale by bike you can work at Apple, Google, LinkedIn, HP, Yahoo!, NetApp, Intel, AMD, and Amazon. Not walkable but not particularly bad either.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoCombined income of $300K, Looking at $1.7M? What are these people thinking? That's a lot of debt.
- refurb 10y agoI looked at a house in SF that was listed for $2M (probably go for $2.2M). At 20% down, that's $500K upfront, then ~$9,000 per month all in for mortgage and property taxes. If you assume you shouldn't spend more than 1/3 of your gross income on a house, that would mean the homeowners should be making $325K/year (and already have $500K saved they can plow into a house). Wow.
- neffy 10y agoNot so hard if you assume it's their second house, and they bought the previous one a few years back. Once you're on the housing ladder, you're protected to some extent from the increase in the price of the house you want to buy, by the increase in the price of the one you already have.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis was my experience, the small house my wife and I bought originally, then after a few years we were vested in our options and had some equity in our house, the combination let up step up to a larger house with essentially the same payment (rates had come down, our down payment was bigger).
- refurb 10y agoI don't disagree. If you've been owning in SF for the last 20 years, you're good. But how many people in SF arrived in the last 5-10 years?
- billhathaway 10y agoExactly: we bought in San Jose in Sept 2011 and have seen our townhouse's value increase by approx 60% since then (which seems ridiculous to me). We really lucked out on our timing. The seller who had originally owned our home sold for a ~20% loss over their purchase price (purchased in 2007).
- throwaway_exer 10y agoOverhead conversation in Mountain View in June: Seller: "Who can afford to pay $1.85 million for my house?" RE Agent: "Chinese couple. Husband works at Google, wife works at Facebook."
- sliverstorm 10y ago...that is seeking to limit how the city can transfer park land to developers to turn into houses Christ, are they already doing that?
- runamok 10y agoBy conventional standards a couple making 300k should have a loan of about 3x that income. So 900k. Perhaps that is the case coming in with an existing property but do they really think they will have 30 years of prosperity and one parent won't take some time off to raise their kids? I can't help but assume many people are going to lose their everything come the next recession...
- usaar333 10y agoPrior property isn't needed and I'm not sure where the 3x rule comes from. Non-housing costs need not scale linearly with income. $300,000 a year is $190,000 post-tax. Assuming 20% down, a $1.7M home would cost somewhere in the range of $8,000 a month after factoring in the mortgage income tax deduction. That leaves $94,000 a year disposable, which is a lot anywhere. This family can readily get a full-time nanny for the early children years, ensuring no parent needs to take time off.
- runamok 10y agoRight. Until one person gets laid off, has a car accident, wants a divorce, etc. 8000 in 12 months is 96000 so now one salary goes only to the mortgage... Now make those salaries for the next 30 years. Your point is valid in that as you make more money more of it can go to housing because a smaller portion is required for things like food, clothing, gas, transportation, etc. 3x gross income was the conventional rule of thumb but truthfully that was back when interest rates were 7% or so. However, just because you can afford something doesn't mean you should.
- dcosson 10y agoThat rule of thumb was probably intended for more "middle class" wages though, no? Above a certain level your other basic costs like food, clothing, travel (especially if you're having kids and can't do much traveling or fine dining) don't have to increase with your income so you can afford to spend a higher percentage of your pay on housing if you want/need to.
- mrexroad 10y ago> My point being that the houses are being listed and sold in a short time frame. That suggests that the housing market is pricing appropriately for the buyers. i live in sunnyvale. along the ~0.6mi route between my house and the kids' school, 3 houses in past month or two come to market and each sold after just a single weekend of open house. i've actually been surprised at the speed of sales in recent weeks. > Sunnyvale has a ballot measure (https://sunnyvalepubliclandsact.com/ https://sunnyvalepubliclandsact.com/) that is seeking to limit how the city can transfer park land to developers to turn into houses (or hotels, or office parks). That measure is an artifact of all the building that is going on. kinda. this is more about what happened w/ raynor park after selling the adjacent school, but there are a few other deals in sunnyvale (e.g. city buildings). i spend a lot of time over at raynor with our little league, and my biggest issue is that a private school now has priority use of the fields during specific hours. oh, that and they paved over one of the baseball fields (well, backstop + grass) after the city gave away the small strip of land along the school. over in santa clara there's been some f'd up tactics around Levi's stadium to get park land (using term loosely) developed. BMX track and soccer fields will be missed.