9 ms·
To be protected against DDoS it sounds like you need to be hosted by Google, CloudFlare, or Akamai. Yet these companies are so influential and critical to the I
by wmf 10y ago
To be protected against DDoS it sounds like you need to be hosted by Google, CloudFlare, or Akamai. Yet these companies are so influential and critical to the Internet that journalists need to feel that they are free to criticize them.
AFAIK Google Drive, Dropbox, Amazon S3 etc. will drop you in a second with a "we're not getting paid enough to deal with this" error message if you bring a DDoS down on them.
- pjscott 10y agoCloudFlare is saying all the right things in this relevant blog post: https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-free-speech/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-free-speech/ I'm fairly optimistic that they mean it -- and that if they don't, playing censor would be way more trouble for them than it could ever be worth.
- eastdakota 10y agoThis is such an important point. And it is exactly why, when we launched Project Galileo, CloudFlare's initiative to protect politically or artistically important work online, we decided it was critical that CloudFlare wasn't the one deciding what was "politically or artistically important." Instead we rely on the input of civil society organizations like the EFF, CDT, ACLU, Access, etc. If one of the partner organizations says something meets the criteria then we have committed to protecting it, for free and no questions asked. https://www.cloudflare.com/galileo/ https://www.cloudflare.com/galileo/ We offered to protect Brian's site under Galileo for free. Had he taken us up on our offer, which remains open, I would hope he would continue to be as critical of CloudFlare as he always has been. And I hope we've established some credibility in not abusing the position of trust we occupy. For instance, when we protected Spamhaus from a large DDoS attack years ago we specifically made it clear we'd never ask them to treat us any differently than any other organization they monitor. And we haven't. And, to this day, Spamhaus remains one of our biggest critics. And they remain a CloudFlare customer. Here's a talk I gave last year at Blackhat about the risks of ideas being suppressed on an Internet that is increasingly controlled by a small handful of providers: https://youtu.be/V-Pj0lrr168 https://youtu.be/V-Pj0lrr168 It's something we worry about all the time and I'm glad more people are beginning to discuss the risks it poses.
- fdsaaf 10y agoDoes Project Galileo cover political expression you consider problematic though? It's easy to support free speech with which you agree. The real test is whether you support it when it's reprehensible
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThis is kind of an oblivious response to > we decided it was critical that CloudFlare wasn't the one deciding what was "politically or artistically important." Instead we rely on the input of civil society organizations like the EFF, CDT, ACLU, Access, etc. If one of the partner organizations says something meets the criteria then we have committed to protecting it which is in the first paragraph of the comment you're "responding" to.
- eastdakota 10y agoYes. There are lots of things that I personally believe are incredibly abhorrent that use our network. I'm not proud of them, but I am proud that we don't censor them.
- kyledrake 10y agoIt seems to me that a vast majority of the for-profit DDoS attack sites (https://www.google.com/#q=ddos+booter https://www.google.com/#q=ddos+booter) use Cloudflare to protect the component of their operations that take the payments to attack people like Brian Krebs, including the one he wrote about that triggered this entire thing (http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/cloudflare/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/cloudflare/). Forget "state sponsored actors", people executing these attacks are just as likely teenagers with a spare $20 that can use these DDoS attack services to execute a serious DDoS attack in minutes, just for the hell of it. The point Brian is trying to make in this article is that DDoS attackers have become the true censors of the web. By protecting their ability to profit from DDoS attacks, are you protecting their "free speech rights", or are you instead protecting the real censors of consequence here? I know you take action on malware and phishing attacks being propagated from your service. A lot of us out here in the NOC world struggling to keep the internet running (and now starting to fail at it) would really appreciate it if you added "DDoS attack sites" to that list.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoJudging by the earlier HN commentary, Krebs was hosted by Akamai.
- bcook 10y agoIs it common for the hosting company to know which client is being targetted by the DDoS?