4 ms·
A more political way to state this is to say that those of us who were trained in biology and medicine find it frustrating when people who are successful in Sil
by dekhn 10y ago
A more political way to state this is to say that those of us who were trained in biology and medicine find it frustrating when people who are successful in Silicon Valley making a product that makes money, but isn't particularly valuable in a social sense, suddenly think they can transform all of healthcare in a rapid way, simply because "it's easy", only to learn "it's actually really hard! there are structural problems in addition to engineering and research problems that require decades of work!"
That said I've read what Zuckerberg said, https://www.facebook.com/notes/mark-zuckerberg/can-we-cure-all-diseases-in-our-childrens-lifetime/10154087783966634 https://www.facebook.com/notes/mark-zuckerberg/can-we-cure-a..., and his thesis is not completely lunatic. It's more nuanced, and actually hits most of the critical points:
1) he's talking about disease amelioration, not true cures for all diseases.
2) he's got a more realistic timeframe (not "solve cancer in 10 years")
3) he's focusing on tool building, and addressing some key structural deficiencies around how research is conducted
4) he's got a great collection of leaders to run the institute
5) it's tightly integrated with the existing research system, so it's likely the results of the research will be published in prominent journals
This places Zuckerberg and Chan in the "likely to show impact over time" category.
That said I still have to deal with lots of short-sighted people in Silicon Valley who believe that machine learning is going to cure cancer tomorrow, and that is myopic, naive, and, well, isolated from reality.
- dang 10y agoThis is an interesting comment. It could be summarized as: "1. Some people are idiots; 2. The people in this article aren't idiots, have done their homework, and are getting this mostly right. 3. Still, some people are idiots." The secret to substantive discussion on HN is having the discipline to address the specifics of what's interesting in a story, and resisting the temptation to let loose on unrelated idiocy. That's hard, because letting loose on unrelated idiocy feels good. But it stuffs the discussion with junk. (This is a general point, not just about your post. If everyone did it the way you did we'd all be much better off.)