6 ms·
>> Researchers teleport particle of light six kilometres I'm sure they did nothing of the sort. At best they transferred an unknown state of a photon to anothe
by phkahler 10y ago
>> Researchers teleport particle of light six kilometres
I'm sure they did nothing of the sort. At best they transferred an unknown state of a photon to another photon six kilometers away, then confirmed via measuring both.
- fizx 10y agoIn other news, words can mean more than one thing.
- Rooster61 10y agoTrue, but that doesn't mean you can use words that fundamentally change the meaning of the sentence and then pass it off as the same thing.
- sowbug 10y agoI could care less.
- spdustin 10y agoCouldn't?
- kbenson 10y agoAt the risk of being too pedantic, that's the point. The incorrect phrasing is often used to mean the original thing, when the incorrect phrasing fundamentally changes the actual meaning of the sentence. That said, this is a chain of comments that skirts dangerously close to not-contributing IMO, since I'm not sure making cryptic comments that lead readers that don't happen to reach the right context sensitive interpretation to produce more comments asking about it aren't actually worse than a pure non sequitur, from a discussion point of view. Having a clever counter-example (as the GP does) is good. Leaving it unexplained and ambiguous is not.
- ZoF 10y agoClever.
- booleandilemma 10y agoFor all intensive purposes
- fitchjo 10y agoI (hopefully) see what you did there :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wybiral 10y agoUntil someone reads them and their meanings collapse. :)
- asimuvPR 10y agoAt least we have a link that point to where this comment is at any time. ;-)
- marcosdumay 10y agoWe just don't have any idea where the thread is going...
- asimuvPR 10y agoWe do have the HN god particle: dang. He can alter its trajectory to point towards the trash can. :)
- nabla9 10y agoNot so fast. There is a good reason to call it quantum teleportation and not quantum facsimile. When you move matter from one place to another it moves, it's not copied. When move classical information (or state) , you can retain the original or multiply it many times. Quantum teleport demonstrates interesing aspects of quantum information that makes it work like material thing. When information (quantum state) moves, it can't be copied (no-cloning theorem). You lose the original from the sending end just as you would lose a physical object you send to other place. Quantum theorems like no-hiding theorem, no-deleting theorem, no-cloning theorem makes quantum information act more like material substance than classical information. There is no physical of philosophical argument differentiate between "real" teleportation and "just moving state".
- lossolo 10y agoIt does not work as material thing that is teleported. When you make measurement quantum function collapses and something that we don't know is happening and it's not teleporting anything because state is changed faster than speed of light, and no information or material can travel faster than that. This is a known paradox. Anton Zeilinger (father of quantum entanglement) is describing this in his books in more detail.
- nabla9 10y agoWhy the assumption that teleportation means faster than light travel?
- lossolo 10y agoBecause Anton Zeilinger has proven in his experiments that "teleportation" can happen faster than speed of light. It's what Einstein said was "spooky" about "quantum teleportation" that it contradicts theory of relativity.
- nabla9 10y agoInformation in teleportation can't travel faster than light. Teleportation is not finished until data is transmitted at light speed.
- empath75 10y agoParticles do not have individual identity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_particles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_particles Since there is always some degree of uncertainty w/r/t location and velocity, there's no way to tell which particle is which over time.