12 ms·
To everyone complaining about the $250K (see edit, it's actually 200K) per person in salary (which seems to be everyone at the moment), a few things to keep in
by jedberg 10y ago
To everyone complaining about the $250K (see edit, it's actually 200K) per person in salary (which seems to be everyone at the moment), a few things to keep in mind:
1) That includes benefits
2) They are in Silicon Valley and have to compete with everyone else in Silicon Valley
3) Given what they have accomplished with such a small team, these are probably high caliber people.
4) In SV there is a good 25% premium you pay for engineers with security expertise.
As someone who runs a business and has to hire talent, I can say that I'd consider myself lucky to get such a team for such a great price.
Edit: A bunch of people are saying "why not remote". I think they are in fact mostly remote, but they still have to compete with SV wages because really good people command those wages whether they are here or not.
Edit2: As has been pointed out multiple times, the blog post was not clear, and it is actually 200K per person, all in.
- vowelless 10y ago> I can say that I'd consider myself lucky to get such a team for such a great price I am concerned that they might be being underpaid for doing the type of work that they are. Let's Encrypt is not only a great service, but an important one too. I assume they have a good stock plan to make up.
- zachlatta 10y agoSince they're a project of the Linux Foundation, they most definitely don't have any sort of stock plan – since you can't have equity in nonprofits.
- generalledger 10y agoI don't want to put words in the parent commenter's mouth, but I think the implication was that they would need to make up for NOT having a stock plan.
- Anasufovic 10y agoNetflix level pay would seem about right to me.
- aioprisan 10y agoSo, double? $400k loaded? I'd buy that.
- ashitlerferad 10y agoLF is more of an industry consortium than a nonprofit public interest charity.
- the_duke 10y agoI would hope they have high caliber programmers and ops people, considering the problem space. Those don't come cheap. Can anyone comment on tax overhead for the company in SV? What net salary do 250k amount to? (net as in minus the tax for the company, not the employees income tax)
- jedberg 10y agoIt depends a lot on corporate structure and actually HQ address for tax filling. Each city has their own business license rates and deductions. And some cities (like SF) have extra taxes per employee. Their website lists their HQ as SF, but it would be impossible to know from the outside what their exact tax situation would be. I guess my point is though from a company perspective not much more than anywhere else. The biggest cost to a company here is competing on wages.
- mikeyouse 10y agoI've worked in finance for a medium-sized SF company and a small (~50 employee) startup in SV. Our standard assumption for 'all-in' employee cost was to add an additional 30% on top. For highly paid employees, this actually gets reduced a bit since FICA cuts off at $118k. To get to $250k total outlay with an admittedly outdated spreadsheet, the salary would have to be $200k (benefit load of only 26%). Of course this depends greatly on PTO, Health Care, Worker's Comp, etc.
- ryanobjc 10y agoThere isn't as much as people bitch about, generally speaking you have a few items: - FICA payroll tax - this is US wide, so not really more expensive in CA. - CA state payroll tax, this isn't that expensive, just a few percent. - Workers comp, could be cheaper in other states, but coders/office workers have cheap workers comp. - Health insurance, maybe a bit more expensive in CA Basically hiring people isn't expensive because of the taxes, but because of benefits and just generally having a higher income rate. In my experience it was about 10%, and if you add health care another 10-15% so about 25% total overhead.
- bryanlarsen 10y ago
- Swizec 10y agoI'm in Silicon Valley and I would love a $250k salary. But I also didn't graduate college and incur the immigrant tax. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ What I'm saying is, not everyone gets $250k and the MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME in San Francisco is $90k. If you're not making that much, don't sweat it, you're likely way above median either way. Edit: to clarify further. As an Engineer with a reasonably-employed girlfriend, I still get to live in SoMa, and I'm not complaining. But statistically speaking my household is an outlier. $250k/year for a household puts you in the top 1.5% in the country[1]. That's probably top 5%-ish for San Francisco. That means that for every 5 households that make this much, there are 95 that don't. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affluence_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affluence_in_the_United_States
- zachlatta 10y agoThey're not actually making $250k each. Keep in mind that this includes employer taxes and benefits, which add up very quickly.
- ryandrake 10y agoOK, so $200k in salary then. Still stupendously good. WOW! Maybe there _IS_ something to all these "I know this guy who's brother's roommate makes $300K at Google" threads. It just seems so unbelievable.
- jaas 10y agoThe 2M staffing budget in 2017 is for ten people, not eight. Was not clear enough in the blog post initially, apologies.
- jcoffland 10y agoActually it is for 8. Two of the people are being paid by another company. At least that's what I understood.
- jedberg 10y agoHeh, I'm pretty sure OP actually works for Let's Encrypt.
- tzakrajs 10y agoLololo
- jaas 10y agoIt is ten (I made the budget), but I apologize for not making that more clear in the blog post. We have eight employees now, and have budgeted for ten in 2017.
- jcoffland 10y agoOK, thanks for the clarification. You guys are doing a really awesome thing but this post makes me worry about your longevity. Does Let's Encrypt have plans for other sources of revenue? Like selling support services?
- nxzero 10y agoMore to the point, if anyone truly believes they're able to do it for cheaper... Do it, don't comment about it.
- berns 10y ago> Edit: A bunch of people are saying "why not remote". I think they are in fact mostly remote, but they still have to compete with SV wages because really good people command those wages whether they are here or not. This doesn't make sense. In the case of remote workers it's the San Francisco workers that have to compete with global offer/demand because nobody cares how much you are paying for housing.
- jedberg 10y agoIt doesn't make sense but it is true. If you're really good, someone will make you an offer for an SV salary, and now everyone needs to compete with that. Besides, it's only fair. Your value shouldn't be tied to where you live per se. It's true that people in some areas make less because they have fewer options in their area, but for a high caliber person, they have plenty of options whether they move their physical location or not. I'm pretty sure we're going to see a trend as remote work becomes more popular where there will be a much smaller delta because of location of the employee.
- imsofuture 10y agoYes, exactly. Remote is incidentally a way to save some money on salaries, but mostly it is a great way access a much larger pool of talent.
- pc86 10y ago> Your value shouldn't be tied to where you live per se. If that was the case people wouldn't make $200k in SV, $75k in Omaha, and $9k in Phuket for the same job.
- eropple 10y agoPeople who are near the top of the skill curve, and can present a business case for being paid like it, don't make $75K in Omaha for that job. (They may make $9K in Phuket, but there are additional factors on top of that.) If I left Boston today, I'd still make what I make here. I have considered doing exactly that.
- prdonahue 10y agoI can't speak for everyone on the project—I've only really interacted with one person—but I just wanted to say that $200k all-in is an absolute bargain for him (if that's in fact how it breaks down) given his skills, experience, and ability to operate/drive the project.
- prdonahue 10y agoI can't speak for everyone on the project—I've only really interacted with one person—but I just wanted to say that $200k all-in is an absolute bargain for him (if that's in fact how it breaks down) given his skills, experience, and ability to operate/drive the project.
- lojack 10y agoWould their staffing cost also include office space (even remote companies have headquarters)? Or would that be included somewhere else? Or do they actually not have an office?
- Spooky23 10y agoComplaining about that is insane. To put it in perspective, almost any Fortune 500 is paying $200k for a contract Level-2 helpdesk analyst.
- Matthias247 10y agoShort term contracts might be different, but 95% of normal software engineers in germany will e.g. never reach 100k. Including those in the large corporations. I think 200k might be barely in reach for a senior manager. In other countries/regions this will even be far lower.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's a nonprofit looking for next years funding. An engineer defintatly ought to be paid as if it's a short term gig.
- jcsvyu789jh 10y agoThis might be part of the advantage America has over some European countries when it comes to elite talent.
- dogma1138 10y agoGermany has horrible pay, a senior software engineer for Amazon and the likes is making 60K Euro's....
- resmote 10y agoNo one I've ever known makes that in support roles. Consultants can get that easily though.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe worker makes $30, the contractor and body shops take the rest.
- astrange 10y agoWhat does it mean to analyze a helpdesk?
- ryandrake 10y ago> To everyone complaining about the $250K (see edit, it's actually 200K) per person in salary I don't think people are _complaining_ about it, just expressing surprise/shock. It's one thing to read the anonymous "I know a guy who's brother's roommate makes $300K at Google" comments that you have to take with a grain of salt, but another thing to see an actual company's data. Eye opening for sure.
- dragonwriter 10y ago$200K per person staffing budget isn't $200K per person salary. Benefits, employer share of payroll taxes, and other things that don't show up in top-line salary are in there. You are a lot bigger cost to your employer than your gross salary.
- secabeen 10y agoYep. Here at UC, the non-salary costs can be in excess of 60% of salary.
- sndean 10y agoAnd in the federal govt it's at least that percentage... Anecdotally, in one department within the DoD, it's ~90%, which sounds insane.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Anecdotally, in one department within the DoD, it's ~90%, which sounds insane. If you consider how little uniformed military personnel are paid and how high the other costs associated with them are to start with, I'm actually not all that surprised that somewhere in some specialized area in the DoD this ratio is reached.
- omegaham 10y agoThis was interesting when I was in. I was making $25k a year as a corporal, but I was saving almost all of it because I wasn't paying for rent, utilities, health insurance, food, or the gym. My expenses were Internet, cell phone, and car insurance / gas. That was it. I make three times as much in the civilian world, but I'm saving less.
- zeveb 10y agoI think $200K/person is fine, but I do quibble with this: > They are in Silicon Valley and have to compete with everyone else in Silicon Valley Why? Why compete for talent in Silicon Valley when there are people all over the country who'd love to work on something like this? I can get why they might prefer not to do remote teams (it's a challenge), but there are cities like Seattle, Boston, Denver, Dallas, Kansas City, Houston — all of which have folks quite capable of building this. In fact, for some folks not being located in SV is a huge plus!
- jedberg 10y agoAs covered elsewhere, most of the team is remote. But they still get SV salaries because great people get those salaries no matter where they are.
- resmote 10y agoIt doesn't work that way for all the remote jobs and contracts I've worked.
- jlukanta 10y agoMaybe you aren't a great engineer?
- resmote 10y agoThat's pretty insulting to suggest in any case and borders on a reprehensible attitude to take personally against someone.
- danellis 10y agoI think what jlukanta is saying is that the greatest people get the salaries they demand regardless of location. If you're insulted by the suggestion that you might not be in that top category, maybe you're letting your ego respond instead of thinking about it rationally.
- codyb 10y agoI thought it was totally reasonable considering the domain their work exists in (cryptography and security), the average salaries of professionals in our fields (especially in SF), and the overhead of benefits and taxes. Really happy to see a member from EFF and another from Mozilla as well, two very respectable foundations in the fight for user and citizen privacy in the digital age. I shall absolutely be donating in the future. (Especially since a 10 dollar per month donation is less than two ssl certificates at godaddy. Love your work!
- mattmaroon 10y ago$200k, including benefits, employment taxes, etc. is probably more like $150k in salary. It's not at all egregious for good programmers. I've had employees make near that in Ohio and have friends in the field who make considerably more. Also it's a budget, so I suspect it's intentionally padded to a small degree. While prices haven't converged on SV everywhere, it does have a ripple effect.
- wyager 10y agoYou're overestimating their final salary. Per-employee expenses are usually almost the salary all over again. Payroll taxes are a real bitch. It's probably closer to $110-$120k salary per employee.
- snuxoll 10y ago"Payroll tax" (more appropriately known as the employer-side of the FICA tax) is only 7%, it's really not what I would qualify as "a bitch". My wages are 80% of my total compensation (my employer provides a nice breakdown of insurance costs, 401(k) match, etc), factor in 7% of my wages going to FICA and their total cost to employ me with my total compensation package is ~125% of my annual salary. I also make a fairly lower wage than the industry average since I'm not in SV, insurance rates don't increase proportionately with salary so if this is what I'm seeing at $75K/yr then at $200K/yr gross these employees are most certainly seeing at least $150K/yr in their salaries.
- wyager 10y agoNot in CA. http://www.adp.com/-/media/Compliance/2016%20Fast%20Wage%20and%20Tax%20Facts/2016FastFactsCA.ashx?la=en http://www.adp.com/-/media/Compliance/2016%20Fast%20Wage%20a...
- snuxoll 10y agoAh, yes, forgot about UI and workers comp, so let's make that ~130% (assuming an employer doesn't have egregious numbers of unemployment claims which cause their UI to skyrocket).
- jondubois 10y agoThat's a pretty damn high salary regardless. But I think that's fine if most of that money end up paying for the engineers who do the actual work and not the management.
- softawre 10y agoYou have a general problem with engineering management? Just like the old "if you don't get paid enough, go somewhere else" mantra, if your manager is shit - go somewhere else.
- erpellan 10y agoIf they provided an identical quality of service with 25 employees for $2m nobody would bat an eye. I'd say the fact that the team is so lean is justification for higher salaries in and of itself.
- bduerst 10y agoI think this is a better point. They seem to be incredibly capable for such a small team with such a large impact.
- thesimon 10y agoCould they provide a better service with 25 instead of 10 for $2m though?
- jjn2009 10y agoAssuming the salary cost scales with the skill of the employee linearly and assuming that 25 people causes extra management overhead I would say no.
- CiPHPerCoder 10y agoI think $2.91M is a modest (if not lean) budget for the important work they're doing. How many websites now have HTTPS because of LetsEncrypt? How much would they have needed to pay for certificates from an incumbent CA?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI agree in terms of results and like them. Yet, I'll ask you since you're still in industry: "Wouldn't it be cheaper if they got hackers in Germany like close to Berlin? And not be operating in a police state with secret courts and such?" The latter is ironic given Germany's history. Legal aside, I've seen plenty of folks over there putting together OS's, VPN's, cryptophones, etc. Most doing heavy lifting don't make SF wages or have office costs that high. Plus, one could poach some veterans in PKI from one of the big security companies. At least one of them. I doubt it's the only such place given all the country names in my files on cutting-edge research.
- CiPHPerCoder 10y ago> Most doing heavy lifting don't make SF wages or have office costs that high. I work remotely from home and don't make anywhere near as much as someone in the valley. However, I'm quite happy with my cost of living. :)
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI see you playing it smart. Good for you! :)
- morganvachon 10y agoI agree completely, especially regarding benefits. A lot of folks will look at a base pay rate and turn down the job because they will have $1000/month less "fun money" than if they take the job across the street. What they don't understand is the job across the street has shitty healthcare plans, little or no investments/stock options/pensions, less or less flexible paid leave, and so on. I went back into government work specifically for the benefits, even though the pay was no more than I was already making at a private company. That company wasn't offering me any health insurance and I had to fight tooth and nail for any time off, paid or otherwise. At my current job, while it's not as mentally stimulating, I can retire at 50 years old with my sanity, full benefits, and retirement intact, and work for myself in my golden years without fear of losing health and life insurance.
- rexreed 10y agoForget the salaries - you're getting REAMED by your laywers! $350,000 a year for legal and administrative is ridiculous, especially given that this is not for your salaried employees.
- aisofteng 10y agoI agree and want to corroborate from another point of view, speaking as someone that's hired at and been a technical lead at multiple organizations: it's very hard to find actual talent, and paying a higher salary for one actually talented engineer is almost always a better investment than paying average salaries for, say, three average engineers (conservatively). From that point of view, which I am convinced of, I not only see no problem with this - I see it as a good sign, and have more faith in the organization because of it.
- daniel_iversen 10y agoSeems totally reasonable, also I don't know about the US but in other parts of the world there are other kinds of staff related costs you have to consider too like fringe benefit tax etc. Seems like let's encrypt is a great meaningful endeavour that produces good results for the world on a pretty elegant idea and lean implementation.
- stryk 10y agoConsidering what this team is doing, creating, and providing to everyone free of charge-- especially keeping in mind the scale of it, and the magnitude of it's impact on the entire Internet-- I'd say pay them more than $200k. They maybe should offer top tier salaries, in order to attract and keep top tier talent (not meaning to disparage the current team in any way, they could be best in show for all I know -- what they've done thus far is pretty incredible and they're just getting started)
- balls187 10y agoAccording to https://letsencrypt.org/jobs/ https://letsencrypt.org/jobs/ "All of our positions are remote, and we can only hire in the United States and Canada." Curious how benefits are worked out for remote employees? Also its ~200k per person, which is all the costs including overhead: salary, benefits, equipment, etc.
- balls187 10y agoAccording to https://letsencrypt.org/jobs/ https://letsencrypt.org/jobs/ "All of our positions are remote, and we can only hire in the United States and Canada." Curious how benefits are worked out for remote employees? Also its ~200k per person, which is all the costs including overhead: salary, benefits, equipment, etc.
- gbuk2013 10y agoThere is an "Executive Director" mentioned in the list of employees. I wonder if that persons's salary is really the same as the engineers'? ;-)