14 ms·
Microsoft to shut London Skype office putting 220 jobs at risk
- mapleoin 10y ago> Microsoft reviewed some London-based roles and made the decision to unify some engineering positions. What does that mean?
- wnevets 10y agoProbably means some people are getting fired and others are being merged into other teams.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>Probably means some people are getting fired I think the proper term in this case is "laid off", since the company is eliminating those positions by closing that particular office.
- creshal 10y agoSince the Skype team hasn't actually done anything worthwhile in the past few years, they can stop pretending and just kick them out.
- dm03514 10y agoengineers do everything: Product management, testing, ops?
- WorldMaker 10y agoFrom an outside perspective, it sounds like Microsoft finally decided to merge various "Skype, but not efforts". There's the obvious in that Skype has had a bunch of different platform clients that were never quite all aligned and is now trying to merge everything into a single UWP client. But it also sounds like Microsoft is also finally slowly starting to merge in the efforts from the business side (Yammer, Skype for Business aka Lync) and unify those communication efforts a bit more than just how Skype and Skype for Business share a brand but not much else. (All of this in an effort to present a more unified front versus Slack, HipChat, and others currently eating into the enterprise space and Whatsapp, Facebook Messenger, and others into the consumer space.) From that perspective it's easy to imagine there have been quite a positions that have been redundant between the various teams.
- BooneJS 10y agoIt seems it's another way of saying "redundancy" in the UK.
- r_smart 10y agoBusiness speak for human centipede.
- cylinder 10y agoThe product does not seem to have ever changed. It's clunkier than ever too. You can find me on Duo.
- MichaelGG 10y agoIt still can't sync message status across devices. Now and then I get re-ordered messages. Some messages repeatedly keep showing up as unread. It's quite bad at the messaging side. The dumb UI I sorta excused as being, well, made by a small team not a big US retail company. The fact MSFT didn't overhaul it all is really annoying.
- toast0 10y agoFrom my brief experience running Skype on multiple devices; if you can get both of them online at the same time for a while, it'll sync up eventually. If it's always one or the other, good luck (there's a reason I stopped running it on two devices)
- MichaelGG 10y agoI have my phone running right next to my laptop. It still doesn't handle things right (Signal does). If one is offline for a bit then sometimes it syncs, sometimes it leaves unread indicators.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoOn Linux you have the choice between "never changed, clunkier than ever" and "OMG, this is completely different" (https://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and-calling-on-chrome-and-chromebooks/ https://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and...)
- creshal 10y agoThe "new" Linux interface is roughly comparable to what Windows/Mac users have had for a while now.
- lukasLansky 10y agoI wonder what that means for the Prague office.
- falsestprophet 10y agoPrague is a lot cheaper than London. Skype pays employees with title Software Development Engineer II: US$46k in Prague [0], and US$82k in London [1]. And I suspect life is a lot more comfortable in Prague on $46k than London on $82k [0] https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Skype-Prague-Salaries-EI_IE35331.0,5_IL.6,12_IM989.htm[0] https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Skype-Prague-Salaries-EI_IE... [1] https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Skype-London-Salaries-EI_IE35331.0,5_IL.6,12_IM1035.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Skype-London-Salaries-EI_IE...
- 0xmohit 10y ago(82-46) * 220 = 7920 $7.92 million of savings. Somebody could see the bottomline improving and stock price rocketing higher.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoIf one wants to cause a stock price to rocket, I don't think finding $8M in a $500B company with $85B in revenue is going to cut it.
- 0xmohit 10y agoI thought that the pun was obvious.
- themihai 10y agoPeanuts
- jhoechtl 10y agoYour milkmaid calculation misses the taxation part paid by the employer. London might be sort of a tax-haven compared to Prague.
- Ensorceled 10y agoSkype is the worst business tool that I use day to day and it continues to get buggier with each new release. I now have permanent ghost notification icons and I had delete Skype on my iPhone so my desktop app could receive calls reliably. Headwinds indeed.
- creshal 10y agoAt least we now have an HTTP API so we can write our own Skype clients.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoGood news unless, of course, it's the backend that is causing all the issues.
- zanny 10y agoI was astounded when Skype showed up in KDE Telepathy in last months release. So yeah, backwards compatibility with the insecure backdoored hell that is Skype is great going forward.
- jobu 10y agoSkype really went down the toilet when Microsoft bought them. At one point (~5 years ago) they were the best video chat and VOIP product by a long shot. Text chat and user search were clunky, but at least the notifications were reliable. It was a great tool for working with a remote team spanning multiple continents. Now, the voice quality is still pretty good compared to a landline call, but the calls tend to drop, video quality has gone to crap, and the call/text notifications are broken. (I just got a notification on my phone about a text from yesterday, and it never showed up on my computer. WTF!??)
- imglorp 10y agoAfter purchase, Microsoft changed the architecture from peer-to-peer to client-server, which incurs extra latency obviously. https://blogs.skype.com/2013/10/04/skype-architecture-update/ https://blogs.skype.com/2013/10/04/skype-architecture-update... http://arstechnica.com/business/2012/05/skype-replaces-p2p-supernodes-with-linux-boxes-hosted-by-microsoft/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2012/05/skype-replaces-p2p-s...
- moneyman101k 10y ago"The company said it was consolidating its London offices and moving workers to a new site in Paddington." It's not that big of a deal, they are just trying to consolidate all of the good engineers into a cheaper office and letting go of the dead weight.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoWell maybe their jobs could be saved by dedicating them to reliable tone production over TCP/IP. Ever try to access a mailbox or navigate a customer support call center through Skype?
- chrisseaton 10y agoHow can the fact it's TCP/IP interfere with the tones? TCP/IP only sees bytes.
- thanatropism 10y agoAudio compression optimized for psychoacoustics, I figure. I doubt you'd be able to plug a dial-up modem into skype and achieve a working computer connection. Pure tones (as from key presses) is a less extreme case, but it's a conceivable problem.
- vetinari 10y agoTo add to your point: Skype uses SILK codec, on which OPUS, the currently preferred codec for internet-audio, was based.
- gcp 10y agoIf you do an outbound call (i.e. outside Skype, to something that would actually use DTMF) Skype doesn't use SILK/Opus on the outbound connection. You can tell because the quality is way worse. There are also issues with the echo cancellation Skype uses. If you have issues with DTMF, that's the likely cause, not the audio codec.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoBut echo cancellation should not be a problem on mobile devices.
- gcp 10y ago
- 0xmohit 10y agoSkype hasn't really changed in years now. Linux support doesn't exist despite claims of embracing it. This is an official sign that it would be strictly in maintenance mode.
- mkonecny 10y agohttps://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and-calling-on-chrome-and-chromebooks/ https://blogs.skype.com/2016/07/13/skype-for-linux-alpha-and...
- collyw 10y agoI use Skype on Linux. Its a few versions behind, but to be honest last time I looked at it on Windows it was full of unnecessary flashy effects with no real purpose. I don't care about those as the Linux interface is fine for me. The call quality is crap whatever platform is being used.
- ansgri 10y agoSkype for Linux' UI is definitely better than the ad-ridden Windows counterpart. BUT it doesn't work. At work we have a lot of group chats, and some of them simply aren't shown in the Linux Desktop client. And Skype for Web is utter crap (no non-latin search in contacts, WTF?), though it displays all messages.
- geomark 10y agoIt is pretty bad that a company with a global product doesn't include global support. In addition to the lack of support for non-latin characters in search, here's another one. I live in a country that uses the Buddhist era calendar. So the year is 2559 not 2016, a difference of 543 years. Skype sent me a notice that one of my contacts had a birthday and had turned 579 (she turned 36).
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoIt doesn't sound like you're even remotely informed of what's going on in the Skype world lately. Basically, the old infrastructure was peer-to-peer, and over the last couple of months, Microsoft has been moving Skype over to a cloud version. That's why you'll notice the announcements that a lot of older clients and platforms would stop working, and brand new apps have been made for all of the current platforms... including a brand new Linux client. If anything, this year is the biggest change Skype has EVER HAD.
- btreesOfSpring 10y agoWhen the product began to display connection status at launch, it was a welcome update but it made me wonder why the recent decision to add this to the UI. If things are moving along smoothly, there doesn't tend to be a need to add gauges and indicators to your instrumentation. What is most likely are some backend issues after some migration or update was leading to a lot of inconsistent messaging problems. Adding connection status was a sanity check for troubleshooting these issues. It was one of those improvements that helped explain why things seemed to be a bit flaky recently. There is a lot of competition in this space and I sort of feel that Skype was a Windows Phone play that didn't pan out for MS after the Windows Phone failed (along side the Nokia deal). Unfortunately for the London office, the product heads are not really sure how to right this ship. Hopefully everyone lands gracefully, whatever happens with the product.
- WorldMaker 10y agoAlso an outsider, looking in, but I get the feeling it was more the opposite, Microsoft bought Skype for its brand first, users second, and left alone as a fiefdom to itself. I think Windows mobile efforts (phone) have actually been part of the kick (along with external pressure from Slack, HipChat, Facebook Messenger, Whatsapp, et al) to finally unify efforts, beyond just unifying brands.
- btreesOfSpring 10y agoThe contrary perspective is appreciated. My outside take was the MS acquired Skype for the reasons you mention and in addition they also thought they had a VoiP solution that would be the killer app for Windows Phone. Then that ran into the obvious telecom incumbent push back that Apple and the iPhone seemed to navigate with such ease. MS arrogantly disregarded the telecoms positioning in this time period period since the telecoms were going to lose their voice revenue before having worked out mobile IP pricing and caps. The telecoms didn't want a voice service competition. So then Windows Phone was without its killer app and everything started to atrophy (Windows Phone/Skype/Nokia).
- 10y ago
- mtgx 10y agoA Skype write-off is probably coming in the next 2-3 years, along with many more layoffs. Microsoft will never make its $8 billion back on Skype.
- collyw 10y agoI hope so, and maybe a decent VOIP client will gain market share.
- heidar 10y agoIs one really needed? Facebook has VOIP, Slack has VOIP, most modern games have decent built in VOIP. It's not an interesting problem anymore and it's available everywhere.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoNetwork effects. Skype is the only thing resembling a de facto standard for talking to any two random non-technical people. Skype has literally 100x the monthly active users of Slack, and barely anyone is on slack to make VOIP calls, especially with people outside of their team.
- GFischer 10y agoThat's what WebRTC promises to solve, and there are already great tools using it (Appear.in for example). What they don't solve is the discovery/network aspect. My own side project/startup wannabee uses WebRTC to enable random non-technical people to talk to companies that use our product :) ( https://keveo.tv/en/ https://keveo.tv/en/ ).
- heidar 10y agoThen it's good enough. Facebook is bigger than Skype and you can have a chat/VOIP call with anyone on Facebook, even if they're not your friend. Then there's Google hangouts as well. Slack is meant for teams. Gamers use Discord.
- 10y ago
- jaimehrubiks 10y agoThe weird part is that Skype, like it or not, has become worse every year. If you asked me 2 years ago I would never imagine it could loose users ever (like, whatsapp for example) now I see that I was wrong. Not only they did not improve or add functionality required by some users, loosing to competitors, but also their software has become buggier somehow.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- harigov 10y agoThat's what terrible management does to products
- electic 10y agoYea, the UI blows but one of the biggest concerns with Skype is that it is a leaky box. I know a lot of friends who have left skype because of government tapping. By tapping, I mean multiple governments all over the world seem to have unfettered access to every call and chat on the system. When you are using the tool for business, that is a deal breaker.
- skrebbel 10y agoWhat alternatives do you suggest for business?
- warbler2012 10y agohttps://switch.co https://switch.co works pretty well
- whyoh 10y agoIt says nothing about encryption, so I assume it's not encrypted.
- warbler2012 10y agoLooks like they changed their name, but heres their doc on encryption: https://storage.googleapis.com/switch_static/Cloud_Security_Overview_1110-2.pdf https://storage.googleapis.com/switch_static/Cloud_Security_...
- atmosx 10y agohttps://jitsi.org/ https://jitsi.org/
- fataliss 10y agoSlack? Might not fully replace Skype as I don't think there is screen sharing. But for calls and chat, Slack does an outstanding job. Plus all the possible integrations with their API etc.
- Philipp__ 10y agoAnd what irritates me the most is that we don't have any real alternative.
- oneplane 10y agoYou don't have a real phone anymore? Because that's what I'm using...
- mrweasel 10y agoWhen consultants, partners, sales people, anyone really, send me a invitation to a Skype call, or a Google Hangout thingy, I always ask that they call me on my office phone. If that's not okay, then we'll just have to make due with email. I'm not going to look for my headset, figure out how to use the right inputs and output, or sign up for a Google account because someone wants to call me. I have function telephone with a good wireless headset that just works.
- markcerqueira 10y agoHave you ever gotten a negative response to your "landline or bust" philosophy? It just seems a bit inflexible to me.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoI do the same, but international phone calls are still rather impractical compared to Hangout / Skype-like tool of choice. And this is coming from a Linux user who doesn't get supported by many such tools :) At least most tools have a way to dial into them from a standard phone.
- Philipp__ 10y agoI use it the most, but that is not comparable. I am just saying that, because I had X situations where somebody told me "Add me on skype", and then i say look, no.
- ckozlowski 10y agoTake a look at Wire. (http://wire.com http://wire.com) Good Skype alternative, and E2E encryption. I've been enjoying it quite a bit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- withinrafael 10y agoMicrosoft is also reportedly working on yet another Skype client, alongside their Skype Universal Windows app. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/microsoft-shuts-down-skype-office-in-london-as-it-develops-yet-another-client http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/09/micros...
- tucaz 10y agoFunny to see how comments about pretty much the same subject [1] are completely different depending on the company on the spotlight even when the number people getting laid off is way higher here. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640
- oneplane 10y agoNewsflash: big company does strategic business and decides to clean up redundancies... I get that it's sad when your job no longer exists, but you can't really expect a business to pay for people it doesn't need anymore. I see a lot of outrage as people seem to think it's unethical to have your job lose it's right to existence, but it's just a fact of life if you're working for a larger business: you might be needed at some point, and at some other point, that might no longer be the case.
- boardwaalk 10y agoSometimes I wonder about the invisible costs of a popular messaging system that often drops messages and/or notifications. How much miscommunication and missed connections has it caused? It's really shameful to not have something reliable after we've had SMS for 2 decades with <1% failure rate and iMessage/Hangouts is generally okay. It really irks me in the worst way, being someone who has enough problems keeping in touch with people.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- planetjones 10y agoI wish Skype for business was a decent product but it's not. Strange UI quirks. Limits on the length of messages for no good reason. Emoticons which only appear once the message is sent - SQL statements are rendered to nonsense. All images are converted to thumbnails which need to be opened. Audio quality issues galore too. A lot of companies have moved to Skype for business for IM and VoIP. Not an enterprise level product.
- vosper 10y agoIsn't Skype for Business just Lync with a new name? I'm not sure it has any relation to the original Skype?
- PeterStuer 10y agoYes, even the .exe is still called Lync
- planetjones 10y agoExactly it's like someone said let's turn Lync into Skype. Rather than building something useful they added the Skype name and kept the same dodgy implementation. Pat on the backs all round...
- chapium 10y agoI think it is, but lync 2011 and SFB seem like very different products.
- douche 10y agoA lot of the dodgy stuff is because there are a lot of internals that haven't really been changed since it was Office Communicator 2007. I've spent far too much of my life dealing with these oddities, and I'll assure you, it is a trainwreck. If you want to really have fun, write software that uses their terrible SDKs to plug into and extend Lync/Skype for Business. Still, since it's bundled with Office and Office365 Exchange, lots of people are using it and dropping SameTime or XMPP or other options in large corporations.
- 10y ago
- stuaxo 10y agoAh, "Unify some positions", - the old - "we are not sacking YOU, but your role doesn't exist any more". I believe this works around some relevant labour laws.
- robert_tweed 10y agoThis is precisely how redundancy works. Sacking is generally related to personal performance. Not the same thing.
- shostack 10y agoIn the UK is there a material difference from an employee perspective? In the US, if you are fired with cause, the company can fight you on paying out unemployment. If you are terminated without cause, it typically doesn't matter what the reason was behind it--you're still eligible for unemployment.
- robert_tweed 10y agoYes. In the UK at least, there are 3 forms of payment someone might receive: - Unemployment benefits, paid by the state if they don't get another job straight away; - Their usual salary during the notice period, or pay in lieu of notice if they are sent home immediately (common in IT for security reasons); - Redundancy pay. The last one only needs to be paid in the case of dismissal "without cause". However, it's not called that. Redundancy refers to the fact that the job doesn't exist anymore. E.g., because the office closed down as is happening at Skype London. You can't just sack someone on a whim and say it is "without cause". Where things get a bit more complicated in a case like Skype/Microsoft is that they have an obligation to offer their existing employees new jobs elsewhere in the company if possible. This isn't an especially strong obligation, but it does make things awkward if they keep, say, 50% of the staff, because there needs to be some reasoning as to why they kept that particular 50%, which needs to be seen as fair.
- senthil_rajasek 10y agoThat feels more like firing a team for not producing, not making bottom-of-the-stack-rank cuts because you need to free up budget.
- firasd 10y agoBrilliant. Thanks. (For the uninitiated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640)
- rett12 10y agoIt is there another alternative to Skype that is peer-to-peer, has encryption and works on Linux?
- luxpir 10y agoA few, but none with enough momentum to win over the mainstream. See Tox, Vector/Matrix, Jitsi with OTR... Otherwise there are web-based solutions that work well. Is it talky.io? EDIT: Not forgetting Signal, of course. But I think you mean video comms?
- Arathorn 10y agoI'm cautiously impressed by Matrix's momentum, to be honest (although I'm biased given I work on it) - we've got over 300K users on the matrix.org server now and around 1000 other servers visible from matrix.org. Meanwhile Riot.im (the app previously known as Vector.im) is hopefully pretty mainstream friendly...
- ripdog 10y agoI'm looking forward to Matrix too. It's still very immature right now through, as (as I understand it) we're still waiting for E2E encryption on mobile and group video calling(?). It's hard to see Matrix as a standard right now too, with only one server and one client even remotely complete. Would love to see a multiplatform native client! Thanks for the work you do, I realllllly hope matrix attains some success.
- vetinari 10y agoSkype has not been peer-to-peer for years, already. You can safely remove peer-to-peer from your requirements for an alternative. If you are looking for an desktop app accessible to mainstream users, you can try viber.
- idobai 10y agoViber. You can also try Jitsi. There are many WebRTC-based services too(not peer-to-peer, though).
- lispm 10y agoFounded in London? I thought it was registered in Luxembourg and had a marketing office in London. Development was in Estonia...
- romanovcode 10y agoFirst it was developed in Estonia, then they sold it to eBay for couple of mil. Then eBay sold it to MS for couple of bil.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djhworld 10y agoI only ever use Skype to talk to my parents back at home, it works OK. I'm wondering if there is a better system though, the main issue is my parents are used to using Skype, it would be an uphill struggle to get them to feel comfortable with something new.
- dagurp 10y agoI really hope this is the end for Skype for Business. Everything about it is terrible
- rezashirazian 10y agoSkype is broken. A while ago I saw multiple charges on my MSN account which is linked to my skype account. It was for Skype credits through some odd russian account that was messaging me on skype and some how getting my account to purchase credits. I quickly changed my password and removed my CC from my account. When I tried to get the issue resolved no one from Microsoft's support was able to help me because I couldn't verify the date I opened up my skype account (it was a long time ago I couldn't remember) I managed to get my money back only when I went to Visa and told them these charges were fraudulent. Microsoft returned my money the next day and I haven't used skype since then.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoA few weeks ago, after more than 8 years having not used Skype, I got a random email saying my password was reset. Knowing it wasn't me and now remembering I have a Skype account, I decided to just close the account. To reset my password I had to verify my email address and answer about 15 questions, most of which I didn't know the answer to (but was still able to reset it). It took 45 minutes with support to get the account closed. I realized later that I never got a pre-verification email for the initial reset and was nervous my email might have been compromised, but I really don't think that was the case. I think it was reset through some other method, possibly internal since it bypassed the email verification. I did have a $1.03 balance on my account and my theory is that someone inside Skype is targeting stale accounts with a balance or CCs still on file.
- brianwawok 10y agoA few weeks ago was a big data leak. I would check your email from there. Much more likely than someone at Skype wanting to steal your $1.03
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- philfrasty 10y agoAnyone else has these creepy scam-ads on the frontpage of the Skype-client? Á la „Loose 50 pounds in 2 weeks“
- swingbridge 10y agoThe whole merger of Skype with Microsoft's legacy products (Communicator and Lync) has been a disaster. Lync was a solid product in the corporate world. Now I dread getting a Skype meeting. I can't remember the last time where I've been on a Skype for Business meeting where at least one person wasn't having serious issues. They took a solid product and made a mess of it.
- iamleppert 10y agoSkype has gone down hill terribly since being acquired by Microsoft. You can almost draw a line in the sand it's been so bad. I used to use skype for texting people, but it's now completely useless for that. They can't receive any SMS messages from any phones (at least in the US), and who knows if what you send actually goes somewhere. Nevermind they advertise this feature when you're signing up. Its shocking they would allow a feature like that to still exist and just be fundamentally broken. They did recently move it to some obscure place in the UI in a recent "update" and not even one of their support people knew where it had gone; I had to find it again myself. That said, all the recent UI updates have been horrible. Not just talking buggy, but the general look and feel has gone way down hill. I had an old laptop with an older version of the Skype client and its amazing the different. They should have left well enough alone. Add in the super annoying birthday notifications as chat messages, the spam that has gotten out of control, broken payments recharge/web UI, it's a wonder Microsoft should just shutter the entire product down. It's ruined and I have stopped using it. It's clear they do not care about their end users, or improving the product in any sustainable way. I wonder how long before the same happens with LinkedIn (which is already on the deathbed in terms of how bad and buggy it's been getting lately).
- randomfool 10y agoMaybe it was the gutting that Skylake did to optimize profits when selling to Microsoft. http://www.businessinsider.com/skype-scandal-silver-lake-2011-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/skype-scandal-silver-lake-201...
- sandGorgon 10y agoThere's another news article on Twitter closing its India office and firing a team of barely 20 .. Which is dominated by discussion of how Indian programmers suck (and about the quality of English language spoken in India). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12538640 This thread is about Skype.
- nojvek 10y agoIt's just not skype, even Skype for business (former Lync) has gone down the drain. It still baffles me why I can't paste 10 lines of code. Copying is wonky, messages go to wrong computer. Calls barely work. Don't even get me started on the UI.
- Myrmornis 10y agoThis is a sad thread to read, I'd read so many positive things about Microsoft recently. Are people from Microsoft bothered by such a strong negative consensus regarding Skype?
- amaks 10y agoMicrosoft is laying people off left and right. Every year lately.