17 ms·
A Theory of Creepiness
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RodericDay 10y agoThinking about movie stereotypes about ie: people who collect hair, I think a distinction should be made between those described as merely "scary" and those described as "creepy". Take a horror movie. If said collector is a recluse who's history nobody knows about, they're described as scary. If they're out and about, visiting neighbors, trying to relate and engage with people, they are much more likely to be described as creepy. As such, bringing it back to everyday behavior, I think the critical aspect that determines whether something is creepy or not is whether there is a mismatch between what the person is explicitly informing they want to do (be a friendly neighbor), and whether the person on the receiving end suspects there are ulterior motives (they want to collect hair).
- wincy 10y agoI think it's really naive to brush aside the fact that almost all women elicited thoughts of men as being creepy. Women are scared of being raped or worse happening to them, and they're constantly on the lookout for it. This has nothing to do with "categorization", and everything to do with "potentially dangerous". Being afraid of a creepy guy who won't leave you alone is very different than being creeped out by a clown or an abandoned building.
- ndthp 10y agoIs it very different though? Both fall within, as explained in the article, the ambiguity and mental paralysis coming from being unable to determine whether or not a threat exists.
- omginternets 10y agoAgreed. I think a good approximate description of "creepy" might be "ambiguous or novel, absent overt signaling of pacific intent". Or, more crudely: "wtf" - "oh, it's harmless". What's interesting to me is that under such a definition there's a clear notion of intentionality. Something can only be creepy when it's behavior is directed towards an object. While it might be tempting to point towards places that are creepy (e.g. abandoned hospital), I would suggest that these are eerie rather than creepy.
- sargun 10y agoI was hoping that the article would explain the increase in the popularity of 'creepy': https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=creepy https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=creepy https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=creepy&year_start=1800&year_end=2016&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Ccreepy%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=creepy&year_st...
- mwfunk 10y agoThere's a similar surge over a similar time interval for 'scary', so maybe it's just correlated with other properties of the content they're sampling (not unlike https://xkcd.com/1138/ https://xkcd.com/1138/): https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=scary&year_start=1800&year_end=2008&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cscary%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=scary&year_sta...
- icanhackit 10y agoI'm stating the obvious but it's spiking every October in anticipation of Halloween. Ignoring those spikes and looking at the growth trend that began around 2007, it looks fairly organic and has remained relatively flat since mid 2014. What kicked it off in 2007 I don't know. The term has simply become a short-hand way of describing something that brings unease. The problem with the term is that people aren't actually describing what characteristics are bringing that sense of unease, thus someone who's a little awkward gets lumped in with far worse characters. So it can be used indiscriminately but it's an easy way to describe something that's difficult to define, hence its ongoing popularity.
- Jerry2 10y agoI found this essay interesting: >It’s not “creepy” if he’s hot. I freely admit it. When a very attractive stranger approaches me and tells me I’m beautiful, it brightens my day. When a guy who is short, fat or balding does it, it makes my skin crawl no matter how tactful he is about it. I just want him to go away. I’m not alone in feeling this way. Most women feel the same, but hide the true extent of it when the guys are around. http://theplacetorant.com/ugly-creepy-guys/ http://theplacetorant.com/ugly-creepy-guys/
- millstone 10y agoI know this was a hyperbolic rant, but it's deplorable how this author literally dehumanizes men. The essay may be interesting, but it's mostly just monstrous.
- acaciapalm 10y agoI think you're being a bit sensitive. It's a writing style meant to provoke.
- millstone 10y agoDenying essential humanity to anyone is always and everywhere unacceptable. "Unattractive men are animals, not human beings" isn't provocative, it's totally beyond the pale. If the essay called an ethnic or religious group animals, would you still link to it and characterize it as "interesting" and "provocative?"
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoIn the context of the article, "animal" is meant to be understood as "something having non-human features". An ugly guy has both human and "non-human" features, so a mind is split in those both directions, and the split evokes the feeling of creepiness. Just because you feel bad about something it doesn't mean it's false.
- brhsiao 10y ago
- jshevek 10y ago> a peculiar smile; having greasy or unkempt hair, bulging eyes, abnormally long fingers, very pale skin or bags under the eyes. Did Steve Buscemi help define creepiness for the polled group, or did he hit a genetic jackpot of pre-existing ideas of creepiness? (Or both?) Edit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Buscemi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Buscemi
- mbrock 10y agoAnecdotally, I know more than one straight woman who finds Buscemi really attractive. I'm not surprised. He's cool.
- qrendel 10y agoJust take comfort in knowing that female attractiveness usually drops off a cliff far earlier than male attractiveness does. The same girl writing that essay will one day be 40+ and begging for any of those "genetic superiors" to give her five seconds, while the same male "uggo" with a stable income and decent hygiene will be able to take his pick of a bunch of nicer women who didn't view the whole of humanity through the lens of the beautiful people master race.
- saiya-jin 10y agoyeah, female skin ages faster, and skin is what we see on others. this ain't fair, but we can't fool genetics (for now). unconscious behavior like this made me lose much of the respect I had for women (and I started with lots of it!). the better I knew them the worse it got. sheepish mentality, playing all kinds of weird mind games all the time, frequent need of assurance of attractiveness and constant looking in the mirrors, never fully saying what they think directly to the person/man, and the list goes on and on (really, damn too long). once I stopped treating my partners as fully equals and started to be the dominant person in the relationship (this doesn't mean being an ahole, just a confident partner and a bit more), things started to be much better. women need THE man, alpha male, to gently/firmly dominate them. truly dominant ones ie successful in manager positions have usually just a string of failed relationships, since their partners are either less dominant -> submissive, and that doesn't breed much respect in relationship long term, or they are even more dominant which means usually pretty horrible persons and constant fights over nothing. Infrequent exceptions that work are just that, exceptions. Just to clarify - I don't have an experience with shallow and 'not-so-clever' ones where this behaviour is more pronounced, rather doctors, stock traders, cellular researchers, managers etc. just my 2 cents, I hope YMMV significantly :)
- Red_Tarsius 10y ago> Unconscious behavior like this made me lose much of the respect I had for women. I agree. What really gets me is that you're told to open up and talk about your emotions. They paint to bottle up as a negative trait, but women usually lose all respect for men – friends and partners – who share their own fears and worries. One time is enough to ruin your image and dismiss the good times. Empathy is replaced by disgust, since they don't want to be seen around with a weakling. I still believe everyone is worthy of respect and dignity. But I'm not going to put my trust on women. Sensitive men are creepy.
- wallflower 10y agoI've developed my own thoughts about creepiness, since coming across as creepy is one of my biggest fears. 1) The theory of mirror neurons. This theory states that if you are nervous, the other person will pick up on it subconsciously. As the article states, false confidence, even if you try your best to hide it, will come across as a barely disguised nervousness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_neuron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_neuron One of the things that I've observed while watching some pick-up artists practice is that those who eventually become "successful" are basically asking nothing of those who approach. They don't fear rejection. In fact, they can be quite entertaining and good listeners. However, for most of these individuals, they probably had to go through a lot of rejections to get to the point where they didn't honestly care what the reaction was. 2) The hover zone/kill zone Commonly used in pick-up artist terminology. This is easily described as wanting to talk to a specific individual, even approaching within several feet, yet not doing it. I know we've all done this, at some point, at a bar or even at a friend's party. You know the person knows that you are interested in them. 3) Reciprocity In one of Pedro Almodovar's movies, in the director's commentary on the DVD, there is a man in a woman's apartment who is looking through his host's stuff. The director makes a statement along the lines that "liking without reciprocity" makes it stalking (or worse). In the very rare times, where a woman who has explicitly hit on me, asking lots of questions, showing interest that is out of norm with the pace of conversation (e.g. we just met), I can attest that it feels creepy as in (What have I done to make you so interested?). In more common circumstances, I recall people who are seemingly interested in you but quickly steer the conversation to something like network marketing. Given these factors, what can be done to not come across as creepy? First, don't hover. Talk to someone right away, even if it just a quick introduction. Second, being quiet can actively work against you in most social situations. Especially when you are meeting new people. To this day, I can be enjoying a party by meeting new people in a group and listening to their stories and (usually) extroverts will ask if "are you having a good time?". Even if I am, it doesn't outwardly show, at least in the manner they'd expect. Third, the answer may lie in being mindful of reciprocity. For example, talking to a cute individual, what is it about him/her/they that you find interesting (that is not related to something she cannot easily change, like her looks). When I've talked to my good looking friend girls, they basically say they have to ignore all the attention/cat calls when they walk down the street. Fourth, to escape the friend zone, you have to make it explicitly clear that you are interested in someone romantically and tell them why. Asking someone out to coffee to talk about their job v. asking someone out to a picnic because you like them. One last side note - if you walk into a party with a couple good looking friends (male or female), people will automatically ascribe a higher status to you, whether you care to agree with the theory and practice of social proof or not.
- sprash 10y agoInteresting side note: The words "Awkward" and "Creepy" don't exist in German and there are no direct or inderect equivalents. It goes so far that it is culturally impossible to have creepy or awkward behaviour.
- detaro 10y ago"creepy" has been adopted into younger people's language. And while there may be no direct translation that has all connotations of the words, I believe the concepts expressed with other words are basically the same. Do you have an article/other reference discussing the differences?
- sprash 10y agoI think it is well explained here, including additional links: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wuCy_UkKBcs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wuCy_UkKBcs
- pluma 10y agoDon't get me wrong, I like her enthusiasm and some of her videos are fairly entertaining, but she tends to get things wrong (or at least overly simplistic). Her experience of Germany seems to be largely filtered by living in Munich and the kind of people she's talking to (i.e. her "filter bubble"). At times it seems like she's basing entire points around individual conversations with one or two friends at a pub. "Dibs" -> "Meins". "I call dibs on the last cookie" isn't one word either, so of course you wouldn't use one word in German either. However if you put it like that, you'd just say "Das ist meiner". But that'd be rude, which is why you're more likely to hear "Möchte noch jemand den Keks?" ("Does anybody want this remaining cookie?"). This isn't a translation problem, it's a culture problem. "Creepy" -> "Gruselig". A person can be "gruselig". It means exactly the same thing. Yes, there are additional meanings to the German word that don't match the English word and there are additional meanings to the English word that don't match the German word but that's how language works. Good luck finding a single word pair in both languages that matches exactly -- it happens, but it's the exception, not the rule. "Backwash". That seems oddly specific. I guess "Sabber" ("drool") would be the German word used in the described scenario but again her example seems fairly rude. If you don't want to share someone's drink, you don't tell them it's because you don't want their spit in your mouth (because that would imply there's something disgusting about how they drink or that they're somehow unhygienic). "Awkward". Again, this is a cultural thing. There is not one German word for each meaning because the different meanings are lumped together in English but not in German. A social faux pas is "peinlich" (my favourite slang equivalent of the valley girl steoretype "Awkward!" is "Schwierig!", which in this sense doesn't translate well either -- it literally means "difficult"). "Cooties". Again, culture. There is no German word because this isn't a thing in German. "Attitude" -> "Einstellung". "Having an attitude" is not one word, in fact it strongly suggests an omission (because on face value the sentence is trivially true about most people). "Don't give me an attitude" is not one word either and I'm pretty sure "Stell dich nicht so an" (or even "Reiss dich zusammen") is a reasonable equivalent -- an armchair psychologist might observe something about the German version being more about the person demonstrating the behaviour and the English version more about the person inconvenienced by the behaviour but armchair psychology is rarely meaningful. "Jaywalker" -> "Rotgänger". Yeah, there's not really a verb for it in German but again this seems awfully specific. From her companion video on German words: "Schunkeln". This is kinda like arguing there's no English word for "Umlaut". Why should English have more accurate words for this if it isn't a thing in the English-speaking world? Also, how familiar you are with this term as a German speaker strongly depends on where in Germany you live, though I'd wager few Germans don't know it at all. She's in Munich and Schunkeln suits itself to Oktoberfest because of the beer benches, so she'll probably be exposed to it a lot more than the average German. "Kummerspeck". This is fairly specific and only works because "Speck" is already a slang word for (belly) fat (not even limited to overweight people). I'd wager it's actually originally a play on words: "Babyspeck" is "baby fat" which toddlers typically lose as they grow up, so "grief fat" would be something you typically lose as you stop grieving). I don't see any obvious reason "grief fat" isn't a word in English. "Schnapsidee" -> "brain fart". Yes, it's not a direct translation, but the literal meaning is almost never intended for "Schnapsidee" either. It's just a "stupid idea". And of course "brain fart" can be more general whereas "Schnapsidee" usually refers to a specific plan that had easily predictable flaws. "Treppenwitz" -> "fridge logic" (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FridgeLogic http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FridgeLogic). I don't even know what this word specifically is supposed to be. I guess this is a Bavarian thing? I've never come across this word in 30 years. Yes, the TV Tropes term is not an exact match but it is the exact same idea. "Verschlimmbessern". Yes, this one is originally a pun ("verschlimmern" + "verbessern"). Puns don't translate well. This is probably a genuine example but the concept exists in both languages -- I'm pretty sure there's already some obscure slang word for this I'm not aware of (other than "fixing" -- with the scare quotes). Bonus: "Gemütlichkeit" -> "Comfy"/"Cozy". Yes, the German word can also be applied to people in the sense of "relaxed". I think the kids these days use "chill" in pretty much the same way (i.e. things and people can be "chill")? As you can see, some of these don't have exact matches but a claim like "Germans have no word for Creepy so creepiness doesn't exist for Germans" is incredibly daft.
- visakanv 10y agoI found this reddit comment interesting: > [–][deleted] 3796 points 2 years ago*x2 Lots of Indian dudes are great guys. Most, even. Smart, funny, sociable, kind, handsome, eyes to kill for, the works. But just as with every group, some aren't. Some are creeps. Usually creeps have no idea that they're creeps, don't understand why they're creeps, and get mad when people call them creeps. So why are Indian dudes so often creeps? Well, for the same reasons any guy is a creep, with a few cultural factors thrown in. I'll try to explain why in a way that encompasses creepdom as a whole, and which I think might be comprehensible to creeps. Now, if I could establish an informal Creepiness Quotient to describe the feeling someone gives you in the first few seconds they're hitting on you, I would do it as follows. Creepiness = ( (Awkwardness x Forwardness) / (Attractiveness) ) ^ Persistence Now, let's look at the factors here, with "you" being a nonspecific potential creep who is hitting on "me," a nonspecific person of sexual interest: Awkwardness is the extent to which you demonstrate your inability to operate effectively in my chosen social environment. A person who cannot initiate or maintain a comfortable conversation with me is an unappealing choice of partner. Immigrants often score highly on Awkwardness, which is natural--they're working in an unfamiliar social environment. I think that's unfortunate, because usually it's not at all their fault. Forwardness is the extent to which you convey that your goal is purely to use me as a sex-thing. If I think you like me because I'm interesting, this is noncreepy and good. If I think you like me because my part fits your part, that is creepy and bad. Men from some cultures tend to be more forward than men from others, depending on the appropriate gender roles in their societies. In my own personal experience, Indians are high on the Forwardness list. I'm not remotely qualified to offer a guess as to why, beyond "lol culture" which is not explanatory of anything. Attractiveness is a saving grace! Maybe you're hot, maybe you've got a great voice, maybe you've got nice arms, maybe you told a great joke, maybe I like your clothes, maybe you belong to the same subculture I do. Maybe you aren't an obese scuzzlord with halitosis who smells like BO and salmonella. Rules #1 and #2 aren't all there is, but they definitely help. I don't think your ethnicity makes you more or less likely to be attractive as a rule, though some individual people have some degree of preference. Persistence is bad news. Persistence is when you don't take "no" for an answer. Persistence is when you apply pressure, is when you get aggressive or defensive, and is when you demand explanations for why I won't date you. At high levels, persistence is when you start to give off rape vibes. Persistence is what you get when someone believes they are entitled to sex with me or entitled to a relationship with me, and my opinion on the matter is an inconvenience. Persistence is a creepiness multiplier. An awkward, unattractive dude who says "ey, you got nice tits, I got a nice dick, so, wanna fuck" then leaves when I say no? He's creepy, yes. A dude who is otherwise normal but who won't leave me alone? Way creepier. In my experience, this is where so many Indian guys lose it: the entitlement/persistence factor. Begin with traditional gender roles, teach them to a child of a rich businessman in a society with sharply defined social classes, who has always gotten everything he wants, and who is somewhat inclined to see people 'below' him as less deserving of consideration. Then turn that child into a STEMlord engineering student who has had minimal successful contact with actual human beings. That's a recipe for a guy who thinks he deserves women but doesn't have any idea about how to 'get' them. So he gets persistent, because hey, that's how you succeed at anything, right, you just find what you want and take it? And now he's creepy as fuck. This whole thing is of course not limited to Indian dudes. Any guy can be a creeper, for similar reasons as above. But if you're asking why so many Indian students in Western universities are creepers, well, that's why: unfamiliarity with their new nation's social norms and gender roles (Awkwardness and Forwardness) combined with a disturbing sense of entitlement and an inability to handle disappointment (Persistence) means high creepiness. EDIT: Women can be creeps too, of course. In the above, I assume the creep is a man, partially for ease of pronoun use, and partially as an reflection of the relatively higher incidence of male creeps. - https://www.reddit.com/r/cringepics/comments/21gf9b/i_get_more_pussy_than_u_ever_will/cgd2x3b https://www.reddit.com/r/cringepics/comments/21gf9b/i_get_mo...
- Noos 10y agoThe article isn't about the creepiness described in the comments here. It's more about creepiness in general, like in clowns. It's pretty standard stuff actually...creepiness isn't just physical threat, it's a sense of impurity or a pollution of a thing's essence. Clowns are impure in the sense that they are humans gone wrong, with waxlike and distorted features.
- afarrell 10y agoI think a lot of people have a lot of anxiety around the concept of creepiness and when something that looks like an opportunity to try to discuss and maybe resolve this anxiety presents itself in a community where they feel at home, they jump to discussion. Of course, an openly-readable Internet forum is a risky place to open yourself up emotionally.
- afarrell 10y agoWhen going from riding a bicycle to learning to drive a car, it is very easy to feel a lot of anxiety about it. After all, driving a car on American roads is a very morally strange thing: you are in fact imposing upon other people a risk of death or lifelong-debilitating injury. And you have to work to accept this. Of course you can and should avoid exacerbating that: only drive when sober and well-rested. Don't text and drive. Don't have complex discussions when driving. Scan your mirrors for bikes and motorcyclists. But as long as you are going to get up and go to work, you cannot reduce risk to 0%. And you have to work to accept this. There are even things you can do to actively be much better than most drivers: do the Dutch Reach[1] when you open your door. Spend $10 on a wide-angle mirror[2]. But ultimately you are still imposing an increased risk of death on others. And you have to work to accept this. Likewise, when going from reading things like http://tinyurl.com/schrodingers-rapist http://tinyurl.com/schrodingers-rapist, or various blogs written by and for those on the receiving end of stalking and street harassment, it is very easy to feel a lot of anxiety about the possibility of creeping someone out. But humans are strange and varied people who have all sorts of backgrounds and perceptions. And you have to work to accept this. You still must avoid doing things that will cause a reasonable predictive model of people to feel fear: Keep a situationally-reasonable distance from people. Don't shout things at people on the street. Don't present sexual/romantic intent to someone with a high cost to removing themselves from the situation. There are ways you can trade time/money or your preferences for other's comfort if you choose: learn to choose and wear nicer clothing. Speak in a slightly higher pitch. Avoid facial hair or tattoos. Have a friend smell-check you if your nose is impaired. But ultimately, people percieve things in different ways and some might perceive you as a threat. And you have to work to accept this. [1] https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/09/08/this-cyclist-wants-drivers-dutch-reach/V2Ei5bEiOCfU6ubxX1r8VN/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/09/08/this-cyclist-wa... [2] https://www.amazon.com/Fit-System-RM011-Clip-Mirror/dp/B001A0J2JO https://www.amazon.com/Fit-System-RM011-Clip-Mirror/dp/B001A...
- crumpled 10y agoThe article states a couple times: "cognitive paralysis is what generates the sensation of creepiness." It's the most confident statement in the article, but without supplying a reference. Can this be validated?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- johntaitorg 10y agoI sort of explored this a few years ago in a story. A scientist creates rabbit-human hybrids and it causes all kinds of problems precisely because they can't be treated as animals and can't be treated as human. https://github.com/johngtait/mixie-novel/blob/development/frankenrabbits.md https://github.com/johngtait/mixie-novel/blob/development/fr...
- anotheryou 10y agoI don't get the "essence" and living things thing. I think it boils down to unknown, potentially threatening behavior. The big eyed, tail wagging mix of a dog and a mouse is not so creepy. Walking on to cobblestones and they feel like they are floating scares us. A house painted in perfect white, all lights turned on, but without furniture or any people is creepy. The funeral director and taxidermist is creepy, because he isn't creeped out by death himself. edit: reading the other comments: this is about scary creepy, as in "freaks me out", not creepy as in "ugh, leave me alone you perv". Though there are overlaps of course.