3 ms·
TLDR: a person who knows nothing about music or music theory gripes about music and music theory. Admittedly knows nothing, right off the bat and several times
by andrepd 10y ago
TLDR: a person who knows nothing about music or music theory gripes about music and music theory. Admittedly knows nothing, right off the bat and several times throughout the text. How can you declare something to be "terrible", "the worst notation for anything ever", and so forth if you admittedly know nothing of the subject? I know nothing about databases, would reading the Wikipedia page on NoSQL entitle me to declare it "absolute garbage"? o.O
- phyzome 10y agoIt can be clear to a newcomer that a system has problems without needing to understand everything, or even very much. Sometimes the newcomer is wrong, but a quick scan of the comments here indicate that a number of musicians agree.
- rvense 10y agoFunny, I skimmed the comments and actually came to the conclusion that I did not need to write another one stating that music notation, not unlike many other complicated tools, is perhaps at first sight arbitrary and odd, but after working with it for a while you find that all the little quirks, like having multiple ways to write the same note, are actually very helpful.
- andrepd 10y agohttps://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/
- sebastos 10y agoIf reading the Wikipedia page on NoSQL offered you a completely opaque and unhelpful window into how NoSQL worked, and if every tutorial and typical description of the subject seemed to assume you already understood NoSQL, then yes. It would.
- tux1968 10y agoInteresting objection. To my eye it read as relatively humble and playfully thoughtful.
- torrent-of-ions 10y agoYeah. The author should learn to sight read music. Oh, and do it with every instrument in the orchestra too, not just piano. Then maybe you'd be qualified to suggest improvements to notation. When you actually learn to read music you quickly discover that you don't "see" the notes but instead see the intervals. You simply can't see intervals between characters from the Latin alphabet. There are no spaces for sharps and flats because those are accidentals. If your melody contains a ton of accidentals then it's not in the key you think it's in. I'm a geek, and I understand where the author is coming from. But music is played by musicians. This is all useful information if you want to program a synthesiser. But it's pretty much useless if you want to actually play music. Music is read by people who actually play music.