6 ms·
Science in the age of selfies
- ColinWright 10y agoLots pf people have moaned about this problem, but this is a clean description of the situation, the forces that might be creating it, and a clear, simple possible solution. No doubt the proposed solution has problems of its own, but it is certainly an interesting idea.
- return0 10y agoWrt basic science, that would imply that two people can reason and understand deeper than one person, which afaik is not true.
- teddyh 10y agoThe article fails to mention patents, which have come to cover more and more.
- Fede_V 10y agoThat doesn't really affect university research that much. It's a much bigger deal in private companies, obviously.
- Futurebot 10y agoGreat piece. It's a great example of the dark sides of results-orientation, accountability, transparency, and the fear of punishment from spending "Other People's Money." These things are good, but when they take over the entire process, we've got problems; things need to swing back and settle into a new equilibrium that's more tolerant. These are exactly the kind of things that governments and universities with large endowments were good at funding. Right now, we're dependent on large corporations like Alphabet subsidizing moonshots to do this kind of basic research (and as some recent articles indicate, investors are already getting antsy about these.) Short-termism discourages deep thinking and deep working. VCs already understand that one winner subsidizes all the losers; so too is it with basic / speculative research. Until we're will to culturally accept, openly and without reservation, that there will be waste and that fact is OK, we're not going to get anywhere.
- tribune 10y agoThe article mentions how many discoveries come from individuals. I think it's worth considering that human knowledge and technology may be so advanced that a single individual, however great their creativity and intelligence, simply can't make a large contribution like they used to be able to.
- auggierose 10y agoIn principle I like the article, because it points out the problems with doing research today. But I don't like that the proposed solution is given so quickly, without more discussion about the ups and downs of it. Basically the article falls into the same trap that it describes.
- return0 10y agoThe main reason imho is that academia is overcrowded. When a field becomes crowded, popularity starts weighing more than inventiveness, perseverence, creativity and risk-taking. It may sound counterintuitive, but maybe they should reduce public spending for research.
- nicklaf 10y agoI think this is a very good point. Population density seems to play a crucial role in the dynamics of group behavior, not just in phenomenon of the article, but in many other aspects of society as well.
- digi_owl 10y agoCould be. Both sides in the cold war pushed education as a social "cure all". And thus many that would be quite happy in a hands on job as long as it offered decent pay has gone on to get a degree.
- denzil_correa 10y agoOvercrowding could also lead to a swarm of ants solving problems and finishing them versus a few superstars solving the same.
- cs2818 10y agoAs someone who has been in grad school way too long this article provides a succinct description of the reason I hesitate to consider an academic career. However, I'm not sure the suggested solution at the end of the article is viable. Many successful researchers have learned that funding and reputation are based on creating and managing a brand, with scientific substance being a secondary consideration. I feel like it will be difficult to prevent that from factoring into hiring decisions regardless of the metrics used.
- suchow 10y agoThe premise that scientific progress has been slower in the past 50 years than in the 50 before that, and incremental in a way that it was not in the past, seems untenable to me and consistent with the authors being nostalgic for an earlier time that perhaps does not exist. I’m pretty sure someone in 1965 would be impressed to hear that (1) we can engineer viruses that allow in vivo neurons to be controlled by light; (2) we can build robots that use reinforcement learning and ML techniques to drive around a city; or (3) we discovered that humans interbred with Neanderthal, by means of sequencing 40k-year-old bones. To me these projects seem as impressive as any of the past. They all benefited from massive collaborations and would have been impossible to do alone, even by a world-class genius with a plenitude of coffee, time, and tenure. I also object to a few more minor points. Today we have many of yesteryear’s Bell Labs and new ones spring up every year. I think we might be in the most active time period ever for independent and industrial research labs — consider for example OpenAI, the Allen Institute, RAND corporation, Charles River laboratories, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Facebook, 2AI labs, Draper Laboratory, YC Research, IBM Watson Group, Communications Design Group, Xerox PARC, fivethirtyeight, New York Times R&D lab, Microsoft Research* , Google* , Bose Corporation, and SRI, not to mention the hundreds of biotech startups and tech companies that do applied reseach (*s because they are acknowledged in the article). Interestingly, I think Nokia Bell Labs might itself qualify as a modern Bell Labs — it still exists, and in 2014 a scientist was awarded the Nobel Prize for work done there in the 1980s, which is after the authors’ cutoff. Furthermore, I’d be interested in seeing evidence that discoveries of the past can be at least in part attributed to a lack of communication between the scientist and others, and that today’s levels of communication are greater and that it has a negative impact. I have evidence that at least one world-class scientist of the past, Francis Galton, spent a ton of time communicating with others and used what he learned from that communication as a core part of his most important works (see, in particular, his autobiography, which discusses his communication in detail). Similarly, at least some classic big discoveries of the past, such as Watson & Crick’s DNA work, was possible only because there was more than one person involved — in fact, more than two.
- skosuri 10y agoCannot agree with this more. I'm a little sick of all these articles on how science is in so much trouble and is doomed. I've been a biologist now for ~18 years. In that time, I've seen so much advancement and real breakthroughs I'm at times astounded and giddy. If folks are really disappointed in the progress in at least biology over the last two decades, people aren't paying attention. I am also very optimistic that progress will only continue to accelerate. I'm not saying it's a perfect system, or it wouldn't be nice to a be a little less competitive, easier to get longer-term grants, more stable and certain paths for careers, etc – but to say the system is not producing important results is in my opinion wrong.
- user402 10y ago"This is not to deny that our time traveler would find the Internet, new medical imaging devices, advances in molecular biology and gene editing, the verification of gravity waves, and other inventions and discoveries remarkable, nor to deny that these developments often required leaps of imagination, deep mathematical analyses, and hard-earned technical know-how. Nevertheless..." You have to be enormously jaded to list off a bunch of huge advances and then basically say...meh. How doesn't this line invalidate everything that follows it?
- gumby 10y agoI disagree with the author but this position is consistent with his thesis: that basic science hasn't advanced as dramatically in the past half century as it did in the preceding half century, even if its exploitation has. The reason I disagree with the author is that there's an ebb and flow, and the advances of the period 1915-1965 built on a lot of other interesting work done before 1915 (the period from Maxwell to the end of WWI were amazing too; Einstein's three astonishing papers dated from 1905 and of course themselves built upon prior work). I think we're just in a tough period where we've reached the limits of our current tools (both theoretical/mathematical and experimental) -- essentially the rowboats of physics and biology are wallowing while people understand the implications and try to catch up.
- user402 10y agoRe: "basic science", what about "advances in molecular biology and gene editing"? I don't know exactly what the authors have in mind, but CRISPR-Cas, recombinant DNA, RNA interference, identity of the hox genes, DNA sequencing...all of these were huge advances in basic science in the last 50 years (some of them are also now being used practically). I guess it's tough to really put myself in the shoes of someone living 75 years ago, but from where I'm sitting (I'm a biologist) the basic science is moving so unbelievably fast it's exhilarating.
- aj7 10y ago1. Hand someone from 1965 an Iphone. 2. Let her be discharged from the hospital the next day, after robotic surgery for stage 1 ovarian cancer. (A lot of tissue was left in the hospital.) 3. His slower (535mph vs 600 mph) cross country round trip only cost him $60 in 1965 dollars. 4. Oh, we've detected 2 gravitational wave events. 5. Oh, we've detected an elementary particle with the mass of a Barium atom. 6. We've detected superconductivity at temperatures higher than dry ice. 7. Lasers are ubiquitous and some are more than 50% efficient, energy in to laser energy out. The developed world runs on 1.5 um laser light. 8. Two groups figured out how to control-x control-v DNA. But yes, the share of innovation due to professors has gone down, as complex work is now done by millions, and driven by consumers, not philosophical questions.
- merraksh 10y agoIn academia, the two most important sources of feedback scientists receive about their performance are the written evaluations following the submission of papers for publication and proposals for research funding. Unfortunately, in both cases, the peer review process rarely supports pursuing paths that sharply diverge from the mainstream direction, or even from researchers’ own previously published work. Hmmm. All referee reports I receive or write usually revolve around novelty of the idea. Incremental work gets published too, but not if it's only a small delta w.r.t. previous work.
- outerspace42 10y agoScience was so much elite, now it goes OpenSource (say BioHacking)! There is this "official" science treadmill, paid and with reputation. And there are thousands of scientist that quit, some continuing in their garage. Eventually, they get a place in industry. And as the cultural shift continues, they will come back and publish their results. Platforms for such scientific exchange already exist. Prior art is key!