3 ms·
Those hospitals' standard rates should be paid by direct reimbursement from the government at their set rate. In the event they're out of line with the expected
by mindslight 10y ago
Those hospitals' standard rates should be paid by direct reimbursement from the government at their set rate. In the event they're out of line with the expected market (no idea what that distribution looks like, but obviously there would be one), then the hospital would be investigated for price gouging all their customers (as customers of this industry are less able to shop around).
The problem we have here is the exact same problem as with taxis/Uber (and telcos somewhat. and actually that public code thread we argued about the other day, too). Rather than just directly subsidizing infrastructure for poor people, governments enticed businesses to provide some service at a loss by giving them special privileges across the board. As the market finds more efficient solutions, the reality disconnect becomes painfully apparent. Market consumers grow sick of the incumbents' overhead, while simultaneously the businesses gradually renege on their unprofitable obligations.
- harryh 10y agoI wonder if it might be possible to start some kind of group buying organization to negotiate insurance like rates without the actual insurance. I would seriously consider going without insurance except for the highest cost goods & services (say over 100k) except for the fact that it will cost me more to go to the doctor for a check then my insurance company currently pays. The group discount without the risk sharing would be a very interesting product for me. I wonder how many other people would be interested in such a thing.
- mindslight 10y agoThis would be pretty great, but so would real healthcare reform where businesses were simply required to publicly post uniform prices. I think a fundamental problem of trying to privately implement this idea is that medical businesses have an extreme amount of overhead simply to deal with insurance companies, but they don't precisely ascribe it to insurance as payment. From a doctors' office's perspective, the "actual cost" of providing you cash service still includes paying all their back office rather than just actual services rendered. Coming from the other direction, you have high-deductible plans that effectively do this in many more words. Plus that whole tax subsidy that fueled the growth of this institutional cancer in the first place.
- kasey_junk 10y agoIsn't the risk sharing a component in the discount? That is, aren't the providers more likely to collect from people participating in a risk sharing arrangement?