4 ms·
Ask yourself, why is the United States the only country in the world where advertising prescription medicine to consumers is allowed? Why is it even needed? I
by FireBeyond 10y ago
Ask yourself, why is the United States the only country in the world where advertising prescription medicine to consumers is allowed?
Why is it even needed? I know some people say "education", but that's backward.
You have a problem. You go to your physician. He works out a treatment plan for you.
For drugs advertised for specific conditions? To enlighten you to alternatives? You can oftentimes assume that alternatives exist, for most common complaints.
For those that don't? Those ads are such a dragnet of wide ranging and vague conditions that oftentimes, the majority of the population would qualify ("Are you feeling run down? Do you have trouble getting to sleep? Ask your doctor about trying XXX". No. Ask your doctor about your conditions. Let them decide whether to try XXX. Or YYY. Or just to get more sleep).
There's no justifiable need that I can see that prescription medication need be advertised to anyone other than physicians and practitioners.
Oh, and it's not "often" that they spend "more". There is not one of the top ten pharma companies that spends more on R&D than marketing. Every one outspends on marketing. And by "more", the smallest gap is "four times more" leading up to "seventeen times more".
And we wonder why healthcare is so expensive here...
- GordonS 10y ago> why is the United States the only country in the world where advertising prescription medicine to consumers is allowed? I believe it's also allowed in New Zealand. But I totally agree with you, it's a ridiculous practise
- FireBeyond 10y agoI knew it had been and appears to still be, but I believe it's been already decided to end, if not already.
- SilasX 10y ago>Why is it even needed? Because, contrary to popular belief, doctors aren't gods, and have about the same fraction of slackers as any other occupation. Unless we're ready to have a really aggressive program for revoking licenses of doctors who don't keep up with modern advances, they can and do miss available treatments. "Hm, I could eagerly search all the latest treatments that might be relevant to my patents, or I could write them up something based on gut feel and what I learned in med school 30 years ago. Both pay the same."
- mikeyouse 10y agoDoctors / nurses / pharmacists are required to submit dozens of hours of continuing medical education every year to maintain their licenses. There is an approximately 0% chance that a patient with no background in medicine will learn something useful from a TV Commercial that everyone in the treatment plan doesn't already know.
- SilasX 10y agoYou're seriously claiming that no doctor has ever modified a treatment plan due to research provided by a patient?
- mikeyouse 10y agoI'm seriously claiming that no patient committed to modifying their treatment plan has ever started that process due to a TV commercial and that the societal loss from doctors acquiescing to patient demands for treatment for Restless Leg Syndrome or whatever other made-up disease far outweighs the benefits from airing said commercials. Any patient engaged enough and knowledgeable enough to participate in improving their care plan is also knowledgeable enough to know that TV commercials for drugs are complete garbage and offer 0 substantive benefit.
- SilasX 10y ago>I'm seriously claiming that no patient committed to modifying their treatment plan has ever started that process due to a TV commercial and that the societal loss from doctors acquiescing to patient demands for treatment for Restless Leg Syndrome or whatever other made-up disease far outweighs the benefits from airing said commercials. Well, originally you said that no doctor could ever learn about anything that they didn't already aggressively seek out due to their diligent efforts to stay in compliance with the continuing education requirements. Now you're recognizing that it happens but the costs outweigh the benefits. Could you update your original post and be a bit clearer about your actual claim in the future? I wouldn't want people to be misled.
- harryh 10y agowhy is the United States the only country in the world where advertising prescription medicine to consumers is allowed? Because the US has the strongest freedom of speech protections in the world.
- gizmo 10y agoFreedom of speech is for humans, not for corporations. Otherwise you also have to accept the bizarre citizens united decision that permits companies to spend an unlimited amount of money to campaign on behalf of political candidates. Extending personhood rights to corporations is a really bad idea.
- harryh 10y agoCorporations are people, my friend.[1] Which is to say, they are made up of people. My right to free speech is not diminished by the fact that I choose to work with other people for a common goal. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlPQkd_AA6c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlPQkd_AA6c My second favorite republican quote that was mistakenly maligned by the left. In first place is, of course, Rumsfeld's rumination on the nature of unknown unknowns.
- kasey_junk 10y agoThe known unknowns speech ought to be engraved on every engineering school in America