6 ms·
A libertarian explanation is that in the age of the Regulatory State, it's often more important to be the biggest lobbyist than to make the best product. "In t
by BurningFrog 10y ago
A libertarian explanation is that in the age of the Regulatory State, it's often more important to be the biggest lobbyist than to make the best product.
"In the Game of Crony Capitalism, you lobby or you die."
- jcfrei 10y agoA much more probable explanation might be the increasing importance of economies of scale (software is a prime example).
- jhayward 10y agoIt would be helpful if you would supply the Libertarian explanation for the Facebook, Google, Microsoft, and Amazon monopolies as products of the regulatory state and crony capitalism.
- pessimizer 10y agoI actively dislike libertarians, and even I think that they would have no trouble explaining those particular examples.
- rayiner 10y agoThe problem with the libertarian explanation is that it contradicts the actual facts. The "age of the Regulatory" state started in the 1930's. It has been in decline for decades--with major sectors of the economy being deregulated in the 1980's and 1990's. In the 1950's and 1960's, regulatory agencies often had the power to directly exclude potential competition and set prices for goods. They have a fraction of those power today. Surely, that decrease in regulatory authority would be linked to a decrease in consolidation. But consolidation has increased during that time. Moreover, there is a difference between a plausible theory and showing actual causation. How is lobbying helping Amazon and Wal-Mart to replace smaller retailers? Point to something concrete. Because it looks like the real explanation is the massive efficiency advantages those big firms possess. Looking at other sectors of the economy: why are Apple and Samsung taking almost all of the profits in the smartphone industry? Are they better at lobbying the "Regulatory State" than HTC or Nokia?
- BurningFrog 10y ago> It has been in decline for decades I don't have time to put together a great convincing case, so I'll just say that this is very different from my view. Some high level regulations have been removed, sure, but meanwhile almost every corner of life now has regulations and regulators that have to be obeyed and asked for permission. It would be nice to have some kind of objective measure(s) of the overall level of state regulation, rather than trade anecdotes/gut feels. Some economist has probably done that already.
- rayiner 10y agoI would guess your view derives from the fact that the parts of the regulatory state that have grown since the 1970's have more direct effects on individuals and small businesses: environmental, workplace safety, anti-discrimination, anti-money laundering. But there isn't much money in gaming those. The big-money sectors of the economy: telecommunications, transportation, manufacturing, and finance have been deregulated. And software has become a big-money sector of the economy and has remained almost completely unregulated. I handle appeals in regulatory cases, so I have occasion to research historical regulatory treatment of different areas. It's really eye-opening to go read ICC, FCC, or FERC opinions from the 1940s and 1950s and compare them to ones from today. Agencies back then had vast powers: they could deny entry of a competitor into a market if they felt it would harm the revenues of incumbents. If you were an air carrier, you had to publish your prices, and if the agency did not like them it could impose prices on you. Those agencies are a shell of their former selves. Agencies used to have to power to structure industries top-down as they saw fit. Today, they might have thousands of pages more regulations covering various minutia, but nobody is going to build a "corporate colossus" lobbying to influence agency treatment of minutia.
- ahh 10y agoI am unclear how that's an argument for thousands of pages of regulations covering minutia.
- hx87 10y agoIt's probably safe to say that business-level regulation has fallen while product-level regulation has risen.
- dv_dt 10y agoThat line of explanation was never satisfying to me because it doesn't adequately address what happens when any company gets so large that they can apply a full range of non-regulated techniques to extract rents far above value provided? Without government don't you get the the same place faster?
- rdtsc 10y agoIsn't this a common libertarian fallacy - that government and private enterprise are 2 separate entities. Government is bad and should be restricted from interference and private enterprise should not be regulated and market forces will auto-converge to some nice maximum. In reality there is really not that much difference between government and large enterprises. Funny enough that can also be reconciled with the libertarian dream, perhaps by simply viewing bits of the government as extensions or private enterprise. So FDA is a subsidiary of Monsanto, FCC of Verizon and so on. So what is the fastest and easiest way to make a most profit - change regulatory environment, lobby, and so on. This works for large companies and down to individuals as well. We just saw in latest DNC leaks, there is a price you pay and you get named ambassador in some picturesque European country.
- hnnicker 10y ago> Government is bad and should be restricted from interference and private enterprise should not be regulated and market forces will auto-converge to some nice maximum. That is not how I understand libertarianism. It is not that government is bad. But that government's role is to be the rule maker and referee. The government should not be playing the game. Rather than "regulate" a large company, the government should make sure the rules don't hinder competitors. Ultimately, it is more competitors each trying something different that drives price down and quality up.
- ftlio 10y agoTwo sources I like on this topic: https://mises.org/sites/default/files/15_3_3.pdf https://mises.org/sites/default/files/15_3_3.pdf and Debt: The First 5000 Years by David Graeber Conceiving of the government and private enterprise as separate entities really doesn't make sense. They both exist as a matter of energy and resource economy (in the sense of managing resources). They're adversarial and mutually beneficial, as is pretty much anything in any ecology.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoAdvertising. A democratic republic is ruled by advertisers - the ones best able to persuade the public.
- ersii 10y agoDo you mean politicians and bureaucrats? (I'm not joking, I'm asking)
- sbov 10y agoSome seem ridiculous, and some don't. That said, I've seen some called ridiculous that I thought made sense. E.g. I've seen people call requiring nutritional data be available a ridiculous regulation. Maybe the ones I find ridiculous makes sense to some people out there.
- ersii 10y agoHm, I do like products with nutritional data. But isn't the non-regulatory solution here to just not buy products without nutritional data if so? I mean, I'd certainly contact my favorite brands and request that. If they won't hear me, then maybe there's a local alternative that could?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sbov 10y agoFor some people, if nutritional value is out of sight, it is out of mind. I know that when I order at a restaurant, if the menu contains calorie content of meals it changes my ordering habits. But if you don't care about that segment of the population making an informed decision on what they eat, then yes, your recommendation is a solution.
- jimbokun 10y agoNo, they won't. It's more profitable for all of them to use cheaper and less healthy ingredients, and lie about what's actually in the food. Cost to consumers to figure out what's really in every package on our own would be overwhelming.
- Noseshine 10y agoDid you check out the "lemon market" theory? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Market_for_Lemons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Market_for_Lemons
- ersii 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nvarsj 10y agoIt's not just regulation. The government actively subsidizes our largest industries - tech research via military spending, agribusiness via farm subsidies, oil firms via direct subsidies and global military intervention, and on and on.