13 ms·
Scientists Have Found Another Species of Crow That Uses Tools
- fl0wenol 10y agoI was under the impression just as the scientists at the reserve in Hawaii that the tool use was more common than in just the broad-faced island crows. Also, I'm rooting for the captive alalā population to grow more robust. I enjoy living in proximity to crows and hate to hear of them struggling.
- digi_owl 10y agoWell there is a video online of an European crow playing with a jar lid on a snow covered rooftop. I think it comes down to what we define as "tool use".
- ygjb 10y agoIt's not that complex. The crows were using(defined below) a tool (defined below) to get food (a particular function). tool to͞ol/ noun noun: tool; plural noun: tools 1. a device or implement, especially one held in the hand, used to carry out a particular function. "gardening tools" synonyms: implement, utensil, instrument, device, apparatus, gadget, appliance, machine, contrivance, contraption; informalgizmo "garden tools" a thing used in an occupation or pursuit. "computers are an essential tool" a person used or exploited by another. "the beautiful Estella is Miss Havisham's tool" synonyms: puppet, pawn, creature, cat's paw; More minion, lackey, instrument, organ; informalstooge "the beautiful Estella is Miss Havisham's tool" Computing a piece of software that carries out a particular function, typically creating or modifying another program. 2. a distinct design in the tooling of a book. a small stamp or roller used to make a tooled design. 3. vulgar slang a man's penis. a stupid, irritating, or contemptible man. "that guy is such a tool" verb verb: tool; 3rd person present: tools; past tense: tooled; past participle: tooled; gerund or present participle: tooling 1. impress a design on (leather, especially a leather book cover). "volumes bound in green leather and tooled in gold" dress (stone) with a chisel. synonyms: work, fashion, shape, cut; More ornament, embellish, decorate, chase "tool leather into a saddle" 2. equip or be equipped with tools for industrial production. "the factory must be tooled to produce the models" 3. North Americaninformal drive or ride in a casual or leisurely manner. "tooling around town in a pink Rolls-Royce" Search Results use verb verb: use; 3rd person present: uses; past tense: used; past participle: used; gerund or present participle: using 1. take, hold, or deploy (something) as a means of accomplishing a purpose or achieving a result; employ. "she used her key to open the front door" synonyms: utilize, make use of, avail oneself of, employ, work, operate, wield, ply, apply, maneuver, manipulate, put to use, put/press into service More "she used her key to open the front door" exercise, employ, bring into play, practice, apply, exert, bring to bear "the court will use its discretion in making an order" take or consume (an amount) from a limited supply of something. "we have used all the available funds" exploit (a person or situation) for one's own advantage. "I couldn't help feeling that she was using me" synonyms: take advantage of, exploit, manipulate, take liberties with, impose on, abuse; More capitalize on, profit from, trade on, milk; informalwalk all over "he just felt used" treat (someone) in a particular way. "use your troops well and they will not let you down" apply (a name or title) to oneself. "she still used her maiden name professionally" informal one would like or benefit from. "I could use another cup of coffee" informal take (an illegal drug). "they were using heroin daily" 2. describing an action or state of affairs that was done repeatedly or existed for a period in the past. "this road used to be a dirt track" 3. be or become familiar with someone or something through experience. "she was used to getting what she wanted" noun noun: use yo͞os/ 1. the action of using something or the state of being used for some purpose. "a member of staff is present when the pool is in use" synonyms: utilization, usage, application, employment, operation, manipulation "the use of such weapons" the ability or power to exercise or manipulate something, especially one's mind or body. "the horse lost the use of his hind legs" a purpose for or way in which something can be used. plural noun: uses "the herb has various culinary uses" synonyms: need, necessity, call, demand, requirement "composers have not found much use for the device" the value or advantage of something. "it was no use trying to persuade her" synonyms: advantage, benefit, service, utility, usefulness, help, good, gain, avail, profit, value, worth, point, object, purpose, sense, reason "what is the use of that?" Lawhistorical the benefit or profit of lands, especially lands that are in the possession of another who holds them solely for the beneficiary. the characteristic ritual and liturgy of a church or diocese. the action of taking or habitual consumption of a drug.
- matt_kantor 10y agoHere's the video: https://youtu.be/mRnI4dhZZxQ https://youtu.be/mRnI4dhZZxQ
- SurrealSoul 10y agoHow many more years until we can arm the crows and start a private bird militia?
- swayvil 10y agoIf I was the bird master race and I wanted to wipe out the metal monsters (that's us) I'd probably do it with a very slow acting degenerative disease. No symptoms for 5 years then wham, retards you in 6 months. I would distribute it via birdpoop.
- cygx 10y agoYou don't always need smart (bird) soldiers, just well-trained ones. Case in point: The dutch police is experimenting with eagles to bring down drones[1]. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/12/eagles-v-drones-dutch-police-take-on-rogue-aircraft-flying-squad https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/12/eagles-v-drone...
- forinti 10y agoI wonder what sort of defences people will start adding to their drones. Sharp blades or electric shocks will probably dissuade a bird from going near a drone again.
- btilly 10y agoIt is surprisingly easy to train a number of species of birds to attack any small object. Just have a room with a curtain and a bird on each side. Show one bird an actual threat, like a picture of a hawk, as the other is shown the object you want to train it on. Hearing the alarm and seeing only that object, the bird will learn that this thing is dangerous. The trained bird can then easily train a whole flock. I have long thought it would be funny to train birds to attack the little flags that you see on limousines that carry foreign dignitaries. Then release a flock of trained birds during some public event.
- draugadrotten 10y agoThe French could train their birds to fear burkinis.
- conistonwater 10y agoI found it confusing, but it's a crow species, not just one crow.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sctb 10y agoOK, we've updated the submission title.
- joering2 10y agoThe ending of the video is interesting -- while first Crow helped another, the second one that got the food out of the hole didn't share it. The first did not do anything other than help the second one once again... and again didn't get the food. Wonder if it means that the might be very skilled but also can be very dumb?
- balabaster 10y agoPerhaps the first one didn't want the food... if it did, it wouldn't have helped the other crow but would instead just have done it on its own and taken the food. After all, if it's able to use the stick to probe on its own, wouldn't it stand to reason that it didn't even need to have helped the other crow except out of benevolence?
- joering2 10y agoDid you watch it? Clearly wants the food twice.
- Udik 10y agoReminds me of the sad fate of the software developer :)
- strictnein 10y agoSort of related: I have two dogs. Dog #1 (the larger male dog) requests food from us and when food has been provided he sort of goes and gets Dog #2 (a smaller female). He then stands guard over her until she's done eating and then he eats his food. Could be a similar dynamic at work here?
- eternalban 10y agoAlternatively, they are so smart that they understand the benefits of social credit. The first crow could have been repaying past favor, or, making an investment.
- MaulingMonkey 10y ago"Fine Bob, you can have that one... again? Damn it Bob, stop being an asshole." People can be that "dumb", I wouldn't read too much into it. Also it looked like the "first" bird "stole" the stick from the "second" bird in the first place, so it could just be some well deserved payback ;)
- swayvil 10y agoWe should dissect it without anesthetic to find out how it does that. Maybe use some big electrodes.
- lossolo 10y agoI've heard about crows that take a nut to the street, leave it on street, wait for a car to get over it then wait for red light and get the nut. Such an intelligence in such a small brain, incredible.
- nneonneo 10y agoVideo, narrated by David Attenborough: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BGPGknpq3e0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BGPGknpq3e0 The cleverest crows drop the nuts on the pedestrian crosswalk, so that there is a long safe duration to grab the cracked but.
- PeCaN 10y agoSee also the Portia spider, which is somehow capable of planning ahead and following prey even when it's out of sight. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/01/160121-jumping-spiders-animals-science/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/01/160121-jumping-sp...
- DanAndersen 10y agoI assume you've read the book Echopraxia?
- PeCaN 10y agoNope.
- agumonkey 10y agoThere's a TEDxTalk about them https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fiAoqwsc9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fiAoqwsc9g 22min worth of 22min.
- finid 10y ago> Such an intelligence in such a small brain, incredible. With time, we'll come to accept that intelligence has nothing to do with the size of the brain. Compare the computing power of the processor in the computer you carry in your pocket with the one that powered desktops of a decade ago.
- redwards510 10y ago> Also, every year, the zoo staff try to weigh the birds by baiting a weighing scale with fruit—and the crows would often foil them by just raking the fruit off with a stick. This sounds like evidence of a playful sense of humor, unless there was a different reason the crows didn't want to get on the scale! They say tool use is a sign of intelligence, but it is probably more accurate (and intriguing) to say it is a sign of a higher level of consciousness. Using a tool means you are not just running on pure instinct, reacting to the environment. The crows see those inaccessible grubs and think "Cant get that food. But I can use this stick to poke them!" I am fascinated by crows and have begun carrying a ziploc bag of peanuts around in my car in case I stumble across any. They are extremely wary birds (unlike seagulls), so you have to be very subtle in how you feed them. At first I would just throw the peanuts in their direction, which scared them. This can be really bad if you do it with crows near your house because they remember faces and share that knowledge with others, so one incident can make you a "bad person" for a long time!
- ogig 10y ago> They are extremely wary birds (unlike seagulls), so you have to be very subtle in how you feed them. They also know where you looking at, and they don't like to be inspected too hard. It passed a month before the crows near my house would get near the food I left with me still present. Nowadays they fly by at centimeters of my head and stay within meters for hours. Keep it up, is very rewarding.
- tunap 10y agoI concur. I have had ravens & have currently grackles on my property. They are smart & playful once your presence is tolerated. Harris Hawks are also fascinating & tolerant if you get to know them young.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> At first I would just throw the peanuts in their direction, which scared them What should one do instead?
- Symmetry 10y agoIt was recently discovered that birds, like primates, have a number of neurons in their brains that scales linearly with brain volume. http://www.pnas.org/content/113/26/7255.full http://www.pnas.org/content/113/26/7255.full That's pretty impressive in the animal kingdom.
- M_Grey 10y agoAt some point we're going to have to take something like responsibility for our actions in the face of other sentient species... Or accept that we do things only because we can, and abandon even the semblance of ethics. It's starting to become very clear even with a strong degree of skepticism, that while we may be the most advanced intelligence on Earth, we're not the only ones. That should have implications for our species, if we let it.
- coliveira 10y agoHumans don't respect even their own species, good luck with respect for other sentient species...
- M_Grey 10y agoDepressing, but no less true for that.
- eanzenberg 10y agoNeither do other animals...? We're not all that different.
- wavefunction 10y agoMost other animals won't fight to the death. They might fight far enough to determine a victor, but usually the fight or conflict is over quickly or before the conflict actually takes place. Humans on the other hand will pursue the illogical course of self-destruction for the slight chance of "moral victory."
- coliveira 10y agoAnimals have not created the concept of "wealth" and "money" to justify the death of other animals. In this regard, other animals are way ahead of our species.
- Ma8ee 10y agoMost of us actually do. Not all humans respect all other humans all the time, but most of the time we behave quite decently against each other.
- lamarkia 10y agoIf humans were to grow up without social structure or education, they would not be very effective at survival. It is due to learning skills through education, etc that makes humans effective. What we have here is specific populations of corvid species that grew up in relative isolation/protection that enabled them to have social structure to exist between generations. It should be feasible to influence other corvid populations to show such remarkable feats. As long as there is no big mortality, the younger birds should learn from the older.
- eridius 10y agoDid you read the article? They tested newly-hatched chicks that had never seen a tool be used, and the chicks still instinctively tried to use tools (though they were clumsy at first, and gained skill at using the tools over a few months).
- raddad 10y agoIn the 70's in high school we saw a film where a crow dropped pebbles into a glass of water in order to raise the level of water so it could get a drink.
- yumraj 10y agoWe have a birdbath in our front yard. A few weeks ago I saw a crow which had ~2 inch long piece of something which looked like dried white bread in its beak. As I watched it from inside, it moved around the birdbath on the railings, very carefully, for sometime, making sure that there was no danger. Then, it sat on the edge of the birdbath and dropped the piece in water - waited 1-2 seconds and picked it up and then ate it. I'm really bummed that I didn't capture it on video but to me it was a sign of intelligence that the crow knew that it could soften that piece of bread by dipping in water so that it could eat it.
- flukus 10y agoI used to work near one that someone would throw bread out for. It would make a hole in the slice then put it around it's neck and fly off to eat it.
- jarmitage 10y agoI don't understand why this genre of news still frames this as surprise... Have scientists found a species of crow (or other probably-more-sentient-than-we-realised species) that DOES NOT use tools? That would be surprising
- int_19h 10y agoAs the article points out, only one species of crow was previously known to be capable of using tools, and many others were explicitly known to not be capable.
- avodonosov 10y agoBuilding nests - is it a use of tools?
- ori_b 10y agoThe interesting part for me is this: > The captive adults all did so spontaneously and exactingly. Rutz even tested seven recently hatched chicks, which had never used sticks before and had no chances to observe tool-proficient adults. Their human keepers had been briefed to never use tools in front of them. > And yet, when confronted with a weekly baited log, all the chicks picked up nearby objects and tried their luck at probing. I'm very curious how much of the tool use is instinctive, how well they generalize to other situations, and how they learn and pass on concepts.
- andrewflnr 10y ago...and some even modified their tools to improve them. Dang. I think they may have buried the lede. I wish they had more details on this.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agoThere is an interesting popular book on Ethology by Frans De Waal. “Are we smart enough to know how smart animals are?” https://www.amazon.com/Are-Smart-Enough-Know-Animals/dp/0393246183 https://www.amazon.com/Are-Smart-Enough-Know-Animals/dp/0393... Here is a great review of this book http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/how-animals-think/476364/?single_page=true http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/how-anim... the passage that got me hooked: “a better way to think about other creatures would be to ask ourselves how different species have developed different kinds of minds to solve different adaptive problems. Children and chimps and crows and octopuses are ultimately so interesting not because they are mini-mes, but because they are aliens—not because they are smart like us, but because they are smart in ways we haven’t even considered" for example different species have different approaches to problem solving: Chimpanzees try to comprehend/model a problem while Monkeys are solving tool building problems by trial and error (that's from the book)