4 ms·
This scarily accurate extraction of our personality and needs is advertising gold, and advertisers will pay a lot more for it. I once liked a dance company on
by onion2k 10y ago
This scarily accurate extraction of our personality and needs is advertising gold, and advertisers will pay a lot more for it.
I once liked a dance company on Facebook because I know the person who made their website. Now I see adverts for dance productions. That's not advertising gold; that's a waste of advertising money.
I reckon most people's profiles are like this - a few likes or posts about something that you'd never actually buy and all that ad money is just thrown away. 90% of the adverts could be getting your profile wrong but simple confirmation bias makes us notice that 10% far more than the useless, poorly targeted adverts, so when advertisers survey people they get the impression their profiling is working. Or worse, the ad networks know that the profiling doesn't work but they carry on the myth in order to charge advertisers more.
I might well be wrong on this, but while I see adverts for things that have no appeal to me I'll keep suspecting profiling doesn't actually work.
- sparkzilla 10y agoAdvertisers don't really care about the wasted clicks; they care about the successful ones. If Facebook can give more efficiency (even 10% more) than other forms of advertising, which it tries to do through targeting, then it will attract more advertisers.
- nsxwolf 10y agoAs long as this is the case this is a recipe for encouraging users to block ads. I'd welcome relevant ads. I'm always about to buy something. If you could predict what I was about to buy and give me truly relevant ads, I'd be delighted. For instance, right now I'm really looking for the best way to deep clean the upholstery on my couch. Let's see what's in my Facebook feed right now... 1. A mortgage ad talking about HARP... nope, don't qualify for that 2. Home Depot wants me to buy the Arctic Cove Fan... In the midwest, in mid-September... 3. Vizio... I'm not in the market for a TV, but I do like TVs I guess... but who doesn't... 4. HTC Vive... already own it It just goes on and on.
- mootothemax 10y ago>I once liked a dance company on Facebook because I know the person who made their website. Now I see adverts for dance productions. That's not advertising gold; that's a waste of advertising money. I think it may be more subtle than that. - not all clicks are created equal: clicks advertised to people like you might be cheap, so why not pad out the "gold" budget with a few chances elsewhere? - the advertiser might be targeting incompetently and hoping for the best (possibly even succeeding!) - you might coincide with 90% of "gold" clicks --> still worth it - your demographic might be an experiment - etc. etc. etc. Marketing seems - to me - to have an awful lot of "let's make assumptions and test them" about it. With anything like that, you're going to reach people who aren't interested.
- Canada 10y agoYou can go into your Facebook advertising preferences and fix that, so you can still "like" the dance company but not see ads based on that. Or just block all ads if you prefer.
- pessimizer 10y agoStockholm Syndrome.
- bsenftner 10y agoThe inefficiencies of advertising and marketing is the True Barrier to Entry for modern companies. One needs to have the financial resources to throw away 90% of one's advertising dollars - because that is not really throwing it away, it is padding and paying the Internet infrastructure that will pad and prop your company's reputation because you're a good revenue source for them, as you buy ads from them.
- zer0gravity 10y agoThe reality is that not all progress can be brought by for profit organizations. There simply are systemic improvements that can't be monetized. These should have been the job of the governments, but unfortunatelly, those too are the puppets of big corporations and private interests.. Some people should just break the cat and drive this type of change as an open source movement. I for one am dedicated to try.. I don't think it's a coincidence that Linux, the SYSTEM of OPERATION that actually runs the world is supported by an open source movement..
- r_smart 10y agoIt's interesting you would blame a lack of government progress on businesses. Historically businesses are happy to jump on R&D the government has done and made public. I suppose for any potential innovation there are those that are opposed, but there are those eager to profit from it too.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoBut there's a pretty specific analysis tool for this distinction. Goods like this are called "public goods" and they are both inherently non-rival and non-excludable. What you say is fine, so long as this tool is in used. But people don't tend to do that. Also, don't assume that the manner in which open source came to dominate software was inevitable. Had AT&T and SCO been able to come to an accommodation there's no telling what the world may have looked like. Plus, Linux is exceptional because Linus was exceptional. He's a stubborn guy :)
- zer0gravity 10y agoActually on a second thought, I don't think that supporting data privacy is the job or the interests of governments. In fact, they are usually the first ones ready to sacrifice privacy in order to provider you with "security" services. I wouldn't even define data privacy as "public goods" because you now, it's private, it's really a whole different thing than what governments are willing to provide. Profit making is again in conflict with data privacy, because there are much more money to make by profiling the hell out of your customers then by selling technology to aid real data privacy. So there's this niche of progress that can't be pushed neither by governments nor by businesses. So in order for it to happen, there's the need for another force to drive it. And in my oppinion that force is the open source / grass root movement . And I don't agree that linux is special because Linus is special. We're talking about a mindset here, and Linus is not the only one having it.