9 ms·
The Real Heroes Are Dead (2002)
- johnfjacobi 10y agoI think this article could have been a lot better / more touching had they chosen people who were more relatable. Both Susan and Rick pretty much embodied the stereotype of the people close to the towers --- rich and privileged, aloof and out of touch to the Everyman's concerns, etc. Of course, that doesn't change the message of the story, but it does affect how powerfully it will be heard.
- ralfd 10y agoI think the point of the article is not how everyman Rick Rescorla was, but how _exceptional_ he was. Because of him almost all employees of Morgan Stanley survived and he died a selfless heroes death in the tower.
- johnfjacobi 10y agoI agree with you, and I may be missing the point. I just know that a lot of the people who are callous about 9/11 are that way because "it was a bunch of rich people" or something like that. So a person who was more of an Everyman might have been more convincing. Then again, maybe there was no Everyman who conveyed what Rick did as well (and who the reporter had enough information on to write a good story).
- Mvandenbergh 10y agoI think this comment could have been a lot better / less embarrassing had you chosen to read the article. A couple in their early sixties who live somewhere in New Jersey in a house that they didn't even own outright is not wealthy. A month after he died, she had trouble paying the mortgage on the house. That isn't very privileged. She had a job as an administrator at a college which she took to support her children after her marriage didn't work out and she found herself without many job skills. He had a job that he'd like to retire from at the age of 62 but an inadequate retirement fund. You almost literally could not invent a more "everyman" couple in their early sixties.
- johnfjacobi 10y agoI did read the article, and I would remind you: > Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Let me be clear: I'm not just talking about money here. Rick clearly had money for the vast majority of his life. But even Susan was described as being part of a high socio-economic class: > It was obvious to Hill that Susan was from a higher social class, which made him a little self-conscious. You may have gotten a different impression, but it's not like mine came out of the blue. The article paints them as pretty well off, especially eventually.
- Mvandenbergh 10y agoFair enough and apologies for saying that I didn't think you read it - I wasn't trolling, I was genuinely surprised by that reading. I don't think it is clear that Rick had money for the majority of his life, he looks like someone who grew up in modest circumstances (his mother was housekeeper!), enlisted at the age of 16, ended up eventually joining the US army, was eventually selected for OCS, and then used military benefits to go the University of Oklahoma to study literature and law. He taught for a while, then moved to do corporate security in his 40s. That sounds to me like a relatively clever working class boy who eventually worked his way up to a pretty good professional job. Susan is obviously from a higher social class - note in the article, the contrast is between Rick's friend and her, not between Rick and his friend - but by the time of the article she is essentially working a non-career track pink collar job. That's not unusual for an upper middle class divorced woman of her generation of course but it's a big economic step down from her previous life.
- nl 10y agoIn October, Susan’s mortgage payment came due. Though her husband had earned a good salary at Morgan Stanley, he wasn’t paid like an investment banker, and, after alimony and child support, they weren’t wealthy. Their town house was attractive but hardly ostentatious; the mortgage and maintenance payments combined would barely rent a studio apartment in a Manhattan high-rise. Susan had to draw on a home-equity line of credit they’d opened to help pay for Rick’s memorial at the raptor preserve.... Susan felt that she was all but reduced to begging for money. She appealed to the United Way of Morristown, which did come to her assistance. And the National Red Cross eventually sent a check. Lazy assumptions are lazy.
- orthogon 10y agotl;dr 9/11
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 10y ago"He’d fought against Communist-backed insurgencies in Cyprus from 1957 to 1960, and in Rhodesia from 1960 to 1963." Are there any reasons to think Communist influence was deciding in either case? UPD: After reading Wikipedia, to me it seems to be the case of "Let's call our opponents communist, make Captain America do whatever pleases us".
- rodgerd 10y agoIf you fought for Cecil Rhodes, you aren't a hero.
- arethuza 10y ago"He’d fought against Communist-backed insurgencies in Cyprus from 1957 to 1960, and in Rhodesia from 1960 to 1963." Cecil Rhodes died in 1902? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecil_Rhodes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecil_Rhodes
- mxfh 10y agoIt's about the country which is now known as Zimbabwe, which still had this colonial name up to 1980.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoWould you call Zimbabwe a success?
- jahnu 10y agoPeople prefer to make their own mistakes and not have "order" imposed upon them.
- noelwelsh 10y agoIt's not necessarily the case in war that either side is "good". It certainly wasn't the case in the Rhodesian war, though we have to be careful to distinguish the actions of the leaders from the actions of individuals who get caught in events outside their control.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThis addresses the second Main Russian Question but not the first one: "Who's there to blame" but not "What's there to do". What's there to do with Zimbabwe now? And other post-decolonization failed states?
- noelwelsh 10y agoOther heroes who are dead: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mosaddegh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammad_Mosaddegh tl;dr: The 9/11 attack was just one event in a long history of western governments making a mess in the Middle East.
- jonyt 10y agoHow is the overthrow of a secular prime minister of a Shiite country related to an attack by Sunni religious fanatics?
- noelwelsh 10y agoI don't think you're asking in good faith, so I won't spend much time on this, but in case I'm wrong here's a quote from Wikipedia: "According to former CIA analyst Michael Scheuer, who led the CIA's hunt for Osama bin Laden, the al-Qaeda leader was motivated by a belief that U.S. foreign policy has oppressed, killed, or otherwise harmed Muslims in the Middle East,[56] condensed in the phrase, "They hate us for what we do, not who we are."" You can also look at the intellectual legacy of Ayatollah Khomeini (who succeeded the Shah who succeeded Mohammad Mosaddegh) and how that ties into al Qaeda's ideology.
- jonyt 10y agoBin Laden lists a rather long litany of grievances stretching all the way back to the crusades. He also blames the US for East Timor's independence[0], not a very terrible crime unless you believe in Islamic supremacy. Are you seriously suggesting that bin Laden would not have become a racist mass murderer had the US not helped overthrow the Iranian government? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beliefs_and_ideology_of_Osama_bin_Laden#East_Timor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beliefs_and_ideology_of_Osama_...
- noelwelsh 10y agoNo, that's not what I'm suggesting. I'm suggesting the events in Iran and the ideology of Ayatollah Khomeini are some of the many influences on his ideology. I think this would be obvious to anyone arguing in good faith, so I'm out of this conversation.
- andrewclunn 10y agoIronically, this doesn't make me want to be a hero. Instead it makes me see the thanklessness of duty. Society loves a dead hero because they can be used without asking for anything.
- zeveb 10y agoThe hero chooses to do his duty even though he knows he won't be thanked, even though he knows he will die. I don't know if I'd be a hero, but I hope I would.
- andrewclunn 10y agoFor my family? For those I love and those who I really care about? No question. But for some abstract like society, as part of a job for a paycheck, or out of some internalized sense of duty? No.
- pjc50 10y ago"A man does not have himself killed for a half-pence a day or for a petty distinction. You must speak to the soul in order to electrify him." - Napoleon Bonaparte, as quoted in Civ 4
- Graphon1 10y ago> Ironically, this doesn't make me want to be a hero. Not everyone is capable. > Instead it makes me see the thanklessness of duty. I dunno. Lots of people are very thankful that Rescorla saved their lives, or the lives of the people they love.
- bootload 10y ago"The real heroes are dead" This is a quote attributed to Cyril Richard Rescorla. Rescorla was British and originally trained as a Paratrooper in BA. He later found himself as a Platoon leader in AirMobile Infantry [0] distinguishing himself in la Drang Valley 1965 in the first American encounter with NVA. Hard-core as they come. A measure of a persons character is how they conduct themselves under extreme pressure. Rescorla would sing Welsh tunes to calm his troops in that desperate battle reported by reporter Joe Gallaway. A book was co-written with the Commander, Hall Moore and later turned into a film, "Once we were Soldiers" It was reported Rescorla, a Security Officer for Morgan Stanley also present in the '93 bombings (great side story, Rescorla infiltrated and identified a radical Iman at a NY Mosque who was later charged) made his views clear that MS should have moved out of the WTC. Rescorla was in his office on the 44th floor at 8:48 a.m., when the first plane struck the neighboring tower. At 9:10 a.m., a plane hit the second building where Morgan Stanley, an international financial services firm, had offices between the 43rd and 66th floors. Survivors said Rescorla grabbed a bullhorn and cleared out 3,800 workers from 20 floors. [0] In being unsuccessful, Rescorla organised and drilled all MS employees every three months in fire evac procedures. [1] "Rick could be heard saying "... be proud to be an American ... everyone will be talking about you tomorrow," and singing God Bless America and other patriotic and military songs over his bullhorn to help evacuees stay calm as they left the tower." [2] The title of the article comes from when Gallaway put the image of Rescorla [3] on the front cover. Rescorla is reported to not have read the book, nor wanted any recognition saying, "The real heroes are dead". [0] http://www.weweresoldiers.net/rick.htm http://www.weweresoldiers.net/rick.htm [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Rescorla https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Rescorla [2],[3] http://history.army.mil/news/2015/151100a_Rescorla.html http://history.army.mil/news/2015/151100a_Rescorla.html
- gaius 10y agoI wonder how that worked - certainly today I doubt you could just show up in the US as a foreign national and get a commission in the US Army. The nearest equivalent would be enlisting in the French Foreign Legion.
- 10y ago