11 ms·
BMW Plans Board Shakeup, Change in Electric Cars Strategy
- mtgx 10y ago> In addition to the fully electric “i3” models, which have been in production since 2013 What? BMW selling "fully electric" i3's is certainly news to me. Weren't all i3's hybrids?
- weinzierl 10y agoMaybe you are thinking i8. The i3 is fully electric, in the sense that the wheels are driven directly by an electric motor. It is available with an optional "range extender" which is a combustion engine that produces electricity but doesn't directly drive the wheels. Also a electric MINI is no news. They had a fleet of them since at least 2009 but as far as I know didn't sell them publicly. I applied to test one for a year in 2010 but unfortunately wasn't selected.
- surfy 10y agoA friend of mine had an electric mini for a year several years ago. It was awesome. They could sell a lot of these at the right price. I repeat. They had this car years ago. It was awesome.
- lispm 10y agoThe 60Ah battery-only version is rated to have a 160km range. With an added optional range extender they make up to 300km. The new battery will have 94 Ah, instead of 60Ah. Which will extend the range a bit. With some maths this might be: 250km with battery and 390km with added optional range extender. http://www.bmwblog.com/2016/06/17/2017-bmw-i3-specs-revealed-surprises/ http://www.bmwblog.com/2016/06/17/2017-bmw-i3-specs-revealed...
- sammydavis 10y agoAmp hours seems like the wrong measure. How many volts are the batteries? Tesla's kwh is much clearer. A tesla with 85kwh is rated for 425 km (265 miles). The only reason I can imagine to use amp hours instead of kwh is to hide the fact that their batteries have way less capacity than a Tesla. Can someone explain why you'd use amp hours? The article below says the 94 Ah battery is 33kwh. Wow, that's a lot less energy than an 85 or 100kwh tesla. The article below says range of "up to 115 miles". Tesla 85kwh is EPA 265 miles, which is no doubt more real than the manufacturer "up to" mileage. Why doesn't BMW make a bigger battery car? Expense, weight, ability to keep it cool while charging? They seem far behind. The roadster, that came out in 2008 had a 53kwh battery (last year they offered an upgrade to 80kwh for $29k). Tesla needs better competition to keep them honest. Maybe in 2018 when the all electric Porsche comes out, and the model 3, they will be closer. http://insideevs.com/official-2017-bmw-i3-gets-33-kwh-battery/ http://insideevs.com/official-2017-bmw-i3-gets-33-kwh-batter...
- jeffwilcox 10y agoThey're a blast to drive! Here in Seattle (and also Portland) we have BMW's ReachNow drive sharing network, so are able to drive the i3 for about 40 cents per minute point-to-point. It's great since BMW handles the fleet management and electric charging, we just open up the iPhone, find the closest one and jump in, driving off. The future! I have to wonder: how many people have gone out and bought or leased an i3 after experiencing the thrill through ReachNow?
- seibelj 10y agoI would like to buy an electric car. I live in a city, so range issues aren't a big deal. But I don't want to pay too much of a premium for an electric car, and I don't want it to look "weird". Just make your normal cars electric. I don't want to drive in something that attracts unnecessary attention for looking strange, like the i3 does.[0] Obviously the price issues won't be solved for a while, but in 5 or so years I hope to be purchasing an electric BMW, Lexus, etc. without too much of a premium. [0] http://www.bmw.ca/content/dam/bmw/common/all-models/i-series/i3/2013/at-a-glance/charge%20slide%203.jpg/jcr:content/renditions/cq5dam.resized.img.585.low.time1447951029346.jpg http://www.bmw.ca/content/dam/bmw/common/all-models/i-series...
- weinzierl 10y ago> I don't want to drive in something that attracts unnecessary attention for looking strange, like the i3 does. I see i3's daily and they blend in well. The only thing that looks strange are the extremely narrow wheels. I think the image you linked is of the concept car the real thing looks more like [1]. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5a/BMW_i3_014_BSB_01_2015.JPG https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5a/BMW_i3_0...
- seibelj 10y agoFair point, but I still think it looks a little off. Why not make the 3 series electric without any significant restyling? It is a well liked, high-selling model, and I don't see why you need to "weird-it-up" with odd angles and styles.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoPeople buying an electric car are already in a mindset for experimenting, so they are good candidates for design departures. BMW and Mercedes have lost their edge in styling, any experimentation is a good thing.
- weinzierl 10y agoIt looks a little off, but keep in mind that it is was designed from scratch as an electric car. For example the batteries are not in the trunk but form the bottom of the car which gives the car a very low COG. Most of its internal structure and body is made from carbon-fiber reinforced plastic which has other constraints than metal. It's just not a traditional chassis retrofitted with an electric motor, its a completely new design. Given all that it looks surprisingly normal in my opinion.
- weinzierl 10y ago> and replace Friedrich Eichiner as chief financial officer. Just to mention: As CFO Eichiner is also head of the BMW's IT division.
- jseliger 10y agoI like Paul Graham's Tweet: "BMW management meets to decide whether to follow in the footsteps of Nokia" (in reference to this article: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-bmw-electric-strategy-exclusive-idUSKCN11F25Y http://www.reuters.com/article/us-bmw-electric-strategy-excl...). Not too long ago, of course, no one could possibly catch the cell phone king Nokia: https://twitter.com/azeem/status/773991128370647040 https://twitter.com/azeem/status/773991128370647040.
- stonogo 10y agoAll that tells me is that Paul Graham doesn't understand what Nokia's problems were, or else he doesn't understand the market for electric cars. If Nokia's executives skipped dog-and-pony shows in order to focus on making coherent decisions, they would still be a major player in the handset market. In addition, as you move, demographically, farther afield from tech millionaires, interest in electric cars drops precipitously. People are interested in a car that meets their needs; if that car is electric, they'll buy it. If it isn't, they won't. It really is that simple.
- weinzierl 10y ago> People are interested in a car that meets their needs; if that car is electric, they'll buy it. If it isn't, they won't. It really is that simple. Electric cars are subsidized in many countries [1]. This makes sense because it is in the general public's interest to keep pollution out of cities and densely populated areas. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_incentives_for_plug-in_electric_vehicles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_incentives_for_plug...
- achamayou 10y agoBut the subsidies are already being reduced, and are likely to disappear completely as soon as EVs become reasonably widespread. What's more likely to have an impact is the move by cities like Paris and London towards banning vehicles with high emissions from the city center altogether.
- 10y ago
- nimish 10y agoMaybe they'll stop using the autobahn as their yardstick and focus on real world usage outside of germany.
- daenney 10y agoGlad to hear they're considering doing something. The i3 is the Fiat Multipla of electric cars. An electric 3 series is much more appealing to me. Though I'm all for trying out new designs there's something to be said for not going completely overboard. Tesla stuck to a much more traditional design but that doesn't seem to have hampered them. I'm reminded of Renault a couple of years back, they've also toned down their "cubic" design a lot.
- LargeCompanies 10y agoI will never buy another German car as their maintenance and getting the right parts is a pain. I bought a 2002 VW Jetta with 88k miles on it in 2013. I'm not one who needs a fancy car and or car payments. The upkeeps on this thing has a been a headache(mechanic shops don't have great access to VW parts and it costs a lot) and it's on it's last legs; lucky if it lasts me to the end of the year. My last car was a 1997 HOnda Civic in which I bought in 2006 (88k miles on it then too). I drove that til 2013 until I ruined it mistakenly; still would be driving that now at probably 250k miles on it. Civics are reliable beasts ... Hondas in general are. VolksWagens stay away from if your anything like me. This possibly holds true for other german cars to in terms of reliability and more so maintenance.
- tthayer 10y agoAs a counter point, buying any 12-year old car (2002 model year would have been built in 2001ish) comes with it's own set of caveats. Also, there is more than enough information out there on common issues with Mk4 Volkswagen's of era to help inform your buying decision. I'm definitely not defending the car, as I owned a 2001 Jetta for a while and it wasn't the best.
- colechristensen 10y agoVW did have some quality problems with Mexico-built models in the 90's and early 2000's.... but also a 14 year old car that's on it's last legs isn't particularly surprising. It probably also depends on how it was treated in the first 88k miles.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoSince we're on the subject of sweeping generalisations, my 1999 VW T4 Transporter is bloody reliable and I've had no problems getting new genuine or after market parts, or second hand parts. It's got just over 250,000k on the clock. You're mileage may vary.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- LargeCompanies 10y ago
- larryalgorithm 10y agoYou're mileage may vary
- sunstone 10y agoDamned if they do and dead if they don't.
- intrasight 10y agoThey, like the majority of car companies, are doomed no matter what they build - because people won't be owning cars.
- m_mueller 10y ago"Miele is doomed! Now that there's laundromats and pickup by mail, no one will buy a washing machine anymore!"
- intrasight 10y agoNot comparable. There will be no washing machine tax. For cars, there will be a) a road tax b)insurance. My claim is that there is going to be a state transition once the cost of personal car ownership becomes much higher than automated transportation. This state transition is going to be very painful for car manufacturers.
- m_mueller 10y ago'on an infinite timescale' (as Siracusa likes to say) you could be right but looking at the political realities I don't expect this within my lifetime. Take my home country Switzerland: We already have ~50% of commuting done by public transport, no automation needed. You could certainly make an argument that it would be much cheaper for the other half to switch as well so the roads can be used by buses and delivery vehicles - yet noone would even get that idea. Cars have become such an integral part of culture that it will take a long time until you find majorities for restricting access (with the exception of inner cities where this is already happening). Plus, even in Switzerland where there is practically zero stigma in taking a bus, there are lots of regions where not having a car is impractical even once automation is there (an auto still has to get to you when you live in a tiny mountain village).
- intrasight 10y agoThe "restricting access" is naturally going to spread out from the city centers. There are powerful economic forces at play, plus the changing mindset of the new generation. The cost of building roads is going up faster than the rate of inflation.
- osi 10y agoan electric mini would be awesome
- rurban 10y agoHa! After they lost all the heads of their previous electrical team to China because the company didn't follow their initial EV plans, they are turning now 180. The electric Mini is back. The Handelsblatt failed to mention any of these internal conflicts. But the question is: Will the old team come back? What about their much better plans they initially had? In-wheel motors? The i8 is already much better than the Tesla S, but had no chance against it. The i3 is arguably better than the new Tesla 3.
- sammydavis 10y agoIt's questionable to say the i8 is better than the Tesla. The i8 is cooler looking than a tesla. But it's a hybrid, with about 15 miles electric only range. It's just a plug in hybrid. After having had a tesla, I'd never go back. I might consider a hybrid if it has large electric range 100+miles, and cool styling plus awd and cool interior like a tesla. But that doesn't exist. Maybe the all electric porsche will be a cool all electric, but it won't have a supercharging network. They claim 15 minute recharge time but there are 0 recharge sites in the world. They won't be able to invest too much in it, they will also be afraid of cannibalizing their existing gas sales.