4 ms·
The whole credit reporting system is a money making racket and there is zero interest in keeping the information in it accurate. No one is held responsible for
by sschueller 10y ago
The whole credit reporting system is a money making racket and there is zero interest in keeping the information in it accurate. No one is held responsible for mistakes and the suffering people go thought because of it.
- themartorana 10y agoSame goes for every credit rating agency in the country (world?). Remember all those AAA rated swaps? It is disturbing how the entire economic system is set up to make life harder on those it's hardest on. Poor, in debt, barely making ends meet? You're lucky if you can get a credit card for under 30% APR. Mortgage rates historically low? Not for you. Need a loan? Sucks to be you. Finally clawed your way out of debt, trying to get ahead? Tough shit, your credit report will haunt you for the better part of a decade.
- wyager 10y ago> Poor, in debt, barely making ends meet? You're lucky if you can get a credit card for under 30% APR. What about that doesn't make sense? The person you described carries an incredibly high default risk. If credit scores are unfair to the poor, it's because they don't provide accessible way to fix errors. If your credit score is low because you're in excessive debt and unlikely to pay it off, then the credit scoring system is doing its job.
- sbov 10y agoI don't think they're saying it doesn't make sense. The point is, we help those that don't need help, and hurt those that are already hurting. We give better rates to people with high credit scores, but people with low ones probably need it more. It can turn into a feedback loop where the only way out is some form of outside help.
- wyager 10y agoCredit scores are not a charity mechanism; they are a way of estimating someone's default risk. People with low credit scores don't get high loan rates because their credit scores are low; they get high loan rates because they're probably extremely risky borrowers. If you want to help poor people, the way to do that is not to ask banks to take on irrational risk for no good reason. In fact, making loans more accessible to people who are in bad debt might actually be actively bad for them.
- sbov 10y agoThey are generally just as accessible to people, just at a higher APR. Certain states passed predatory lending laws a long time ago but the US federal government smacked them down. There's a reason why all the national credit card companies have their headquarters in the same couple of states. Beyond that, credit cards can adjust the APR on existing balances.
- tn13 10y agoIt makes perfect sense. Loans are borrowing you need to pay back. If you dont pay back then some honest hardworking person loses his savings. When we ignored the basic laws of economics we had a mortgage crisis and thousands of people lost their savings and jobs.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWhich honest hardworking person shoulders the burden when the federal reserve poofs a billion dollars into existence? Why no outrage over that, but we complain about those who default when the default rate is priced into a financial product's APR and profit margin?
- zo1 10y ago> "Why no outage over that" There is plenty of outrage over that and all sorts of other things, just not enough to change the way things are. Too many interests, too-many individuals with their entire lives and mindsets invested in the way things work at the moment. As someone that advocates less state-involvement at all levels, I find it incredibly frustrating to watch day to day things unfolding. Every single facet of our lives is affected and skewed by the state in one way or another. Sometimes in a good, and sometimes in a bad way.
- themartorana 10y ago"...some hardworking person loses their savings" No they don't. Loans are insured against default. Interest rates more than cover extremely low default rates and then some.
- tn13 10y agoClearly you don't understand banking.
- themartorana 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_default_swap?wprov=sfsi1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_default_swap?wprov=sfsi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateral_protection_insurance?wprov=sfsi1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collateral_protection_insuranc... http://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-banks-dont-need-your-money-make-loans.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-ba... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Economic_Stabilization_Act_of_2008?wprov=sfsi1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Economic_Stabilizati... Clearly you spend more time attempting to belittle than understand the conversation.
- tn13 10y agoMost things in this world are about making money. Credit reporting system works pretty well and it is evident by the fact that we have seen mortgage bubble burst (where government forced banks to ignore credit ratings) and student loan bubble building up (ditto as housing loans). The marginal gain in making it more accurate is not very much so I am pretty sure banks will not put efforts in that direction. Also, banks don't care if 1 in 10000 get screwed up because of their mistake because there is plenty of more fish in the pond. But that is how the world works.
- lreeves 10y agoCan you elaborate on your point about government force? My understanding was that Moodys and S&P aggregated poorly rated mortgages and then gave arbitrarily high ratings as a whole. This of course created perverse incentives to sell mortgages to people with bad or no credit ratings whatsoever, as long as they could be repackaged and sold upwards.
- sverige 10y agoThe error rate is far higher than 1 in 10000. More like 1 in 4, and 1 in 20 with serious errors. The credit rating idea was born out of the Southern morality culture. "Are they good people? Let's put a number on it and sell it!" The flip side of that is that they can't possibly be wrong unless you prove it, and even then, they're so butt hurt that you called them out on it that they'll take their time fixing it, if ever. The idea is that they're right, you're wrong, and they have powerful friends who protect them from being sued for slander.
- sidlls 10y ago> Credit reporting system works pretty well Citation needed. > (where government forced banks to ignore credit ratings) This is simply not true. The mortgage bubble burst when big investment and gambling/speculation institutions could no longer cover the shorts against mortgage bond derivatives and the incentive for packaging questionable mortgages into the underlyings disappeared. These mortgages weren't all (or even mostly) to poor people with no ability to pay, and the government didn't force anybody to do anything. These same banks paid ratings agencies to ignore the bad mortgages in these securities specifically so they could increase the volume of mortgage bond sales. So your example is actually one that shows that ratings agencies' products are not necessarily accurate (some might call them fraudulent, even).
- lreeves 10y agoI would hope the entities purchasing the credit reports (landlords, employers, whomever) would care about their accuracy but usually this doesn't seem to be the case. From what I've seen any false negatives around bad credit just ends up in a person being passed upon during evaluation as a tenant or employee and nobody follows up with the ratings agencies.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoWhen you see that happening, please urge the affected to correct the record and to take to court any entity that makes decisions off the false information. Fees and penalties can be recovered and awarded.
- lreeves 10y agoUnfortunately I've just been a third party in both situations and the people urged did not complain :-(
- bsbechtel 10y agoSo do you have a suggestion for a system that works better, or do you prefer banks lend the money from your savings account without any sort of evaluation of how likely it is to be paid back?
- swalberg 10y agoI don't think the credit score itself is the problem, it's that it's the only thing banks use. There is no discretion for cases where the mode doesn't have enough information. As one example that has affected me, I moved to the US a year ago. Go to buy a used car last month with bank statements showing a good salary and enough cash to buy the vehicle outright, a check for 1/3 of the car price, and phone numbers of my employer and landlord. All the banks the finance department contacted automatically denied me without looking at the stuff I brought. I went to my local bank branch thinking a human might help. I got automatically denied, the manager tried to escalate given the information I provided, but I was still denied. In the end my loan was through the car manufacturer at a fairly high rate. I realize I am fortunate in that I can afford to take a crappy loan solely to build a credit history and play this silly game. But the way the model is used treats people who are new to obtaining US credit and people who have used credit terribly virtually identically.
- adrianmacneil 10y agoThe problem is of course that these decisions have to be made consistently across the country, and the banks don't want to try on the "gut feel" of some random bank manager. Of course the system/criteria could be improved, but wanting consistency is not surprising. Anyway, I had a similar issue with car loans when moving to the US. I've since realized that it's pretty trivial to increase your credit score if you pay a small amount of attention to it. Simply sign up for credit karma, get a few no annul fee credit cards, and put a small purchase on them every few months so that they don't get closed due to inactivity. Within 12 months your credit score will be stellar.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoIt's a blessing and a curse. Yes, if you've recently moved to the U.S., then you are screwed for your first year or two - need to get a secured credit card, and everything will be a hassle without credit history. Nobody will care about your salary, bank statements, assets or anything. But then, after 3-4 years, it's pretty damn convenient not needing to mess around with lengthy applications for credit (except for possibly on a mortgage), and having a credit reputation that's completely portable across providers. It pretty much makes sense that newly arrived residents are a corner case that isn't worth worrying about too much for the banks and credit reporting agencies - at any given time, the number of residents who have been here for less than, say, 2 years is going to be a pretty small, somewhat risky part of the market (less assets in the country, more likely to leave).