6 ms·
> Did you really think you could create links to illegal content for money and get away with it? Yes, and that's a horrible ruling. Almost everything can be co
by kstrauser 10y ago
> Did you really think you could create links to illegal content for money and get away with it?
Yes, and that's a horrible ruling. Almost everything can be construed as "for money". Are you a newspaper with paid subscribers? Everything you link is "for money". Do you have a Google ad on your hobby blog? Technically, you're getting paid for it. Someone will make the argument that you're driving traffic to your ad-sponsored blog by linking to infringing content, so obvious you're profiting from piracy.
It's also ludicrous to pretend that the linker is guilty of the crime. If I link to Silk Road and you go there to buy drugs, I am not involved in the transaction. I didn't buy drugs. I didn't sell drugs. I had nothing to do with you ordering drugs other than telling you where they were.
Google links to things that are illegal all over the place. Should they be guilty of linking to Muhammad cartoons because that's taboo in certain countries? Of course not, even if they get paid for it.
- tormeh 10y agoThe law is rarely interpreted so literally in court. Accordingly, few laws are written for literally-minded courts.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThis isn't a hypothetical abuse of the law. This actually happens. Sites are shut down for linking to things. Sites are considered 'commercially' violating copyright because they have a banner ad that gives then a thousandth of a penny. Look at the current incarnation of the pirate bay. It doesn't even link to infringing content. It just gives you the ID code of a file that helps you find infringing files. There's no tracker, there aren't even .torrent files. Now look at how many places it's banned.
- tormeh 10y ago> Look at the current incarnation of the pirate bay. It doesn't even link to infringing content. It just gives you the ID code of a file that helps you find infringing files. There's no tracker, there aren't even .torrent files. Now look at how many places it's banned. Was this really the best example you could come up with? Because that's clearly the law working as intended.
- Dylan16807 10y agoEven if that's the intent, it's pretty hard to reconcile how copyright law acts nothing like anything else. If I make a website that describes the effects of various designer drugs in glowing terms, and the closest I get to helping you buy some is telling you the chemical ID, I'm very easily on the legal side of things.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> closest I get to helping you buy some is telling you the chemical ID How are those things in any way comparable? Knowing the chemical formula of a drug doesn't get you any closer to possessing it, but knowing the ID of a torrent lets you immediately download it. At the end of the day, would you want law to be based on technical trivia, which can rapidly change, or do you want it be based on the intent of the persons involved?
- Dylan16807 10y agoYou can put the ID of a chemical into a black market search engine just as you can put the ID of a torrent into the DHT search mechanisms. Both require that you know where to go, and use a third party search system to find the people that actually have the illegal material. At the end of the day, I want the responsibility to be on the people actually performing illegal distribution. And when someone provides a listing of what is available illegally, without who or where to get it from, that should be legal. In your opinion, if someone writes a highly-convincing page encouraging you to smoke opium, is that intent okay? Because to me that seems about equally far-removed from any drug crime as your typical torrent search engine is from infringement.
- smallnamespace 10y agoBut the distribution of profit is completely different in those two cases, and that's legally relevant. When you go on the dark web and buy something illegal, the money goes to the seller, whereas presumably nobody is directly profiting from the torrents.
- user5994461 10y ago> they have a banner ad that gives then a thousandth of a penny Forget about thepiratebay. It's children pocket money. Remember the time of RapidShare/Megaupload? They were paying something like $5 per thousand downloads. Let's imagine a popular DDL/streaming site sending one video. The next week it's been downloaded 100k times. That's $500 easy money for one upload. Multiply that amount of money by the amount of movies, of tv show episodes, of video games (whose 20GB are split in 20 separate files). That was the hell of a business model. Now, let's think about the modern streaming sites. It doesn't monetize that way anymore. Instead it's putting aggressive ads on every fucking page + misleading widgets opening ad popups + affiliation with streaming services + useless redirection so visitor are forced to open more pages. Illegal download/streaming are a very lucrative business and that's why there are so many of it. Noone is talking pennies there.
- Dylan16807 10y agoBut those sites you're talking about are actually distributing content illegally. They're not linking to things, or doing even less.
- user5994461 10y agoThese sites are exclusively linking. They NEVER host anything.
- s_q_b 10y agoToo much ambiguity in the law creates the opportunity for arbitrary enforcement.
- csomar 10y agoGoogle has an army of lawyers on the other hand.
- MollyR 10y agoProbably another law that will just be applied to the "little people".
- stephenr 10y ago> other than telling you where they were. That hardly seems like "nothing", if you're giving specific directions.
- 0x0 10y ago> Everything you link is "for money". Do you have a Google ad on your hobby blog? Technically, you're getting paid for it. So why do people have Google ads on their hobby blogs? Could it be that it's actually for money, not just "for money"? If it's not for money, why even bother running ads? Sounds to me like a pretty good indicator of intention.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoBecause hobbies cost money? It's not their day job, they're just looking to maybe pay for their hosting and a little more, generally.
- manmal 10y agoIf you can prove that you only took as much money as required for hosting (and donated the rest), a court might be fine with that.
- soufron 10y agoExactly.
- function_seven 10y agoIt's irrelevant what you plan to spend the revenue on. My hobbies cost money as well, but I don't subsidize them with ads. I pay for them with my own money. If you want to run a blog as a hobby, great. Spend your own money to buy hosting and be done with it. If you want to generate revenue off your hobby, that's fine as well, but know that it's not purely a "hobby" anymore. Even if the amounts are small or you're not profitable, it doesn't matter. EDIT: Sibling comment may be more accurate. If you show non-profitness, (I'm speaking abstractly, not in relation to linked court decision), that would be enough to sever the link between the otherwise infringing links and your revenue.
- plandis 10y agoI use ads on my hobby site to pay for my hobby site. I make like $10 a year off of it. I run ads because I'd rather not pay out of pocket but I hardly consider it as something that makes me money for the sake of making money.
- soufron 10y ago1. not everything is done for money, I see no ads on this website for example 2. If your question is to know wether a journalist would be concerned by the decision, it's easy to see he would not. 3. If the linker is linking to illegal content knowingly, and because he hopes a gain from it, I don't see how he would not be guilty. In your example, you would be guilty as hell. 4. Google don't know what is legal and what is illegal as long as nobody told them. They're protected in Europe as intermediaries by the Directive at least.
- kstrauser 10y ago> 1. not everything is done for money, I see no ads on this website for example A VC-sponsored tech chat website has monetary value.