4 ms·
I don't think reproduction is a good line at all; HN could still be guilty if someone posted an unlicensed copyrighted work (say, a news article). Intention an
by icebraining 10y ago
I don't think reproduction is a good line at all; HN could still be guilty if someone posted an unlicensed copyrighted work (say, a news article).
Intention and knowledge is the best dividing line, in my opinion, and courts certainly take it into account. HN blindly reproduces what people post, whereas the link in question was posted by the site editors themselves - that's a clear distinction, and in fact many lawsuits (in the US) were based on it.
I do disagree with the court's decision to presume that any publication for financial gain is done with knowledge of the copyright status, though.
- jacquesm 10y ago> I don't think reproduction is a good line at all; HN could still be guilty if someone posted an unlicensed copyrighted work (say, a news article). There are 100's of these on HN already. Just a few samples: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6262777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6262777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10862279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10862279
- icebraining 10y agoYes. If HN had no Safe Harbour protection, it could be sued to oblivion for those infringements.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoWhen they said copying was what should be seen as the line I assumed that was within the framework of current Western laws, so things like intent (mens rea) are a given.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 10y agoIANAL, but it seems they are saying that the financial gain shows mens rea.
- logicallee 10y agoare you and your parent referring to me by "they" (as a gender-neutral term)? What I meant with my comment is that a pretty clear example of copyright would be, for example, hosting and including the copyrighted content. (If the content is literally on the hosting server - posting full text is obviously an example of this. Hosting full images is another example.) A less clear example would be hotlinking. (So that the pictures are loaded and shown by the browser, and it appears to be part of the article, but is in fact an offsite image anchor.) An even less clear example would be a URL link. That is what we're reading about. But What if it's not clickable? (hxxp:// whatever(dot) whatever - replace hxxp with http and (dot) with . -- what then?) An even less clear example is telling you explicitly what Google search to search for, and how you can know that you've found it. (e.g. words like "Search Google for leaked playboy pictures from 2011, and click on the first link, which should be a site named after a fish." - I'm making this up.) But a less clear example still would be "It's easy to find. Just search for [vague reference but one that is clear enough]" So you want to use the standard of "mens rea." How can we REALLY judge what someone's reason might be? For example, it could be that the real reason to report on something is so that interested readers might find it. Example: "The Pirate Bay is now hosting the entire (name something)". It could be that the primary reason to say that is that it provides people information that they can immediately use to start infringing the copyright of (something). But what if it's couched in any other report? "What the fact that the pirate bay is hosting (something) says about democracy and our copyright laws"? Should that be an illegal post to make? You understand what I'm saying. It's an extremely slippery slope. But one very, very clear line is: "are you ACTUALLY yourself hosting the content"? Because if not, then there's an actual target to shut down. I guess it's like the difference between selling drugs, and saying "you know you can just ask the kids hanging out on the corner of 6th and 8th streets, they'll hook you up." Whether that latter shows criminal conspiracy or whatever, it doesn't really matter - you can actually just shut down the kids, you don't have to shut down the free speech around it or judge mens rea.. . .
- icebraining 10y agoBy "they" I meant the judges. Personally, I think not having mens rea as a standard is killing any possibility of user-generated content, since any such site could be convicted if any of its users posted an infringing work. The Safe Harbour provision is one of the few good parts of the DMCA, but it requires judging mens rea, and once you have to judge that, adding linking doesn't have bring any further issues. In Brilliant v. W.B. Productions Inc., the court ruled that the phrase "I may not be totally perfect, but parts of me are excellent" was copyrighted. Under your black-and-white standard, without judging intention, HN would now be guilty of infringement. How could it continue to exist with this threat? Mens rea might be hard to prove (and presumption of innocence should be applied), but strict liability becomes absurd.