13 ms·
This Bubble's Got Legs
- randomgyatwork 10y agoIsn't it always a thing before a bubble pops where everyone says the bubble wont pop.
- dageshi 10y agoA lot of people called housing a bubble a long time before it popped.
- drcode 10y agoEconomist cover June 2005: http://www.tradersnarrative.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/after%20the%20fall%20house%20prices%20economist%20magazine%202005.png http://www.tradersnarrative.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/a...
- esja 10y ago"It's different this time"
- HillaryBriss 10y agoThe article lost me at "... given the driver is cash printed by central banks, indications it could pop are scant."
- TheLarch 10y agoThis is a good read. https://www.amazon.com/Extraordinary-Popular-Delusions-Charles-Mackay/dp/0486432238 https://www.amazon.com/Extraordinary-Popular-Delusions-Charl.... Market participants often do know there's a bubble. However, if your neighbor keeps making more and more money selling tulips (that was a thing), then you will be tempted to buy some tulips yourself, knowing full well that you are commanding an absurd price. Bubbles can be more "musical chairs" than rational pricing.
- rtpg 10y agoSo my vague understanding is that QE and stuff is technically printing money, but the resulting money isn't really being used for anything. Is a bubble a bubble if the extra bubbly-ness is from stuff that doesn't get used? EDIT: actually, answered my own question. QE raises asset prices (even if the sellers aren't really doing anything with the money), and at one point people will be like "wait, none of this is worth the price it's at" and then panic (unless QE Infinity).
- benmarten 10y agoYes, i feel the same when I look at houses in San Francisco. The shittiest houses are valued at almost 1mio. I'm just saying, nope, I'm not buying that. ;)
- trapperkeeper79 10y agoSame here. The QE+low interest rates have delayed our home purchase perhaps indefinitely. We feel a bit like migrants .. can't afford homes in the city we grew up. It used to feel very miserable ... I'm looking at it positively now that I don't have "roots" that take away my job mobility. This also means we just have cash for retirement .. no housing at all. I suspect we'll end up moving to an ultra-low cost location when that time comes , and try to stretch out our savings + social safety net. It is a raw deal people of my generation got .. but I guess it could be a lot worse when we look at history (wars, famine, etc). As an aside, it is just sad that the only popular politician calling out the Fed is Trump :/
- CalRobert 10y agoAdd it being nearly illegal to build a home in the bay area for the last several decades to the list of reasons. The supply is grossly, artificially constricted.
- hibikir 10y agoI'd not blame QE+low interest rates for this, because the problem is not national, but limited to very few markets. Almost anyone can afford a house in most US cities. Changes in QE wouldn't magically change demand in SF and NY. When we look at SF, what we see is a city that has A LOT more people wanting to live there than there are houses: Heck, I'd move there if the prices weren't insane. Investors/speculators are just a sliver of demand, and they only invest there precisely because the real demand to live there is that high. When there's high demand, and no increase in supply, prices go up to the levels we see now. If the only people that wanted to buy a house in SF were software developers, prices would still be high, and we'd have enough of those that we'd see prices go up so that mortgages are about 50% of household income, just like in every other place, ever, that had high demand. And guess what? that's the current prices already. So while I am sure the fed would be able to lower prices across the board by doing something that craters the economy, housing prices in desirable places to live are not the problem. As far as retirement goes, it doesn't really matter if you own a house, or the equivalent in stocks. I can't tell you if you are saving enough, you are living beyond your means, or should just move somewhere else, as I have no details in your situation. All I can say is that it's a wonderful time to be a software developer in the US, economically speaking. It's pretty possible to work remote or at a satellite office of a big tech employer and save crazy amounts of money.
- steeleduncan 10y agoThe graphs offered as evidence seem to have very carefully picked axes to fit the story. e.g. looking at the first MSCI graph with the x axis extended back to the 60s[1] it is hard to draw the same conclusions [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSCI_World#/media/File:MSCI_World.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSCI_World#/media/File:MSCI_Wo...
- skman 10y agoWhile I don't disagree, the graph you're referring to excludes 2013-2016. (+30%)
- bogomipz 10y agoI was thinking about that as well, particularly the "complacency index." I have never heard of this composite before, of course I am not an economist but I do follow finance. Can anyone speak to if this is an exotic index?
- soVeryTired 10y agoBanks make up dozens and dozens of these indices for marketing purposes. The idea is that when a client trades with a broker, the broker provides "free" research to the client as a sweetener. That research mostly consists of dodgy trade ideas based on their proprietary "sentiment index" or whatever. The research tends to be low quality in general. I'd guess that the researchers are treated as a cost center rather than a source of business.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoSo, the article says dotcoms caused first bubble in 2000, houses in 2008, but this one is driven by central banks printing money. And there is no way they will stop printing so this is an infinite bubble There is sooo much wrong with that. As @rtpg says, that s stops not when Fed stops printing money but when market realises that the high asset prices "globally" become obviously unsustainable. The issue is that when that happens, it happens across the world simultaneously- which is why they article refers to the complacency index. (It is possible the article is more sarcastic than I could read into it)
- dharma1 10y agoI don't think they say it's an infinite bubble, but one that may continue much longer than non central bank driven bubbles. I guess the hope is that real economy growth starts improving and QE can be tapered and prices auto correct over time, rather than a sudden pop in inflated asset prices and adverse effects to real economy from that. Where the growth is supposed to come from (within next 5 years) I'm not sure, so the money creation might continue for quite a while.
- rybosome 10y agoWhat could the economic growth come from other than advanced technological development? Regardless, I don't see how the dependency on constant growth is sustainable.
- dharma1 10y agoYes, definitely technological development. And there is a lot of poorly allocated of capital (non-productive asset bubbles, corruption, ineffiency etc) that could be put to better use. But I don't think that will change much in 5 years
- patti_os 10y agoLike you, I wonder about the 'sarcasm quotient'. Coming from Ireland, every time I hear someone say "There's no end of this boom in sight ... it's not going to happen this time", I get scared. To quote Charles Dickens's Pickwick Papers(1837) "Never say never."
- Wildgoose 10y agoThe financial problems originated with excess debt, but debts that are so large that they cannot be paid back - will not be paid back. Inflating assets via QE doesn't really address the real underlying problem. The only long-term solution I have seen is Debt for Equity swaps. It won't work everywhere, but it does help. For example, when the Banks were technically insolvent then the opportunity should have been taken to forcibly re-arrange their financial underpinnings rather than shoring up the existing rickety structures by using taxpayer monies to in effect bail out the rich. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_restructuring#Bondholder_haircuts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_restructuring#Bondholder_...
- bogomipz 10y agoIndeed. China who's massive economy growth of the last 20 years is using "debt for equity" swaps for SOEs(state owned enterprises) and it looking at possibly extending this beyond SOEs. It's hard for me to wrap my head around this for a state owned enterprise and not think its a shell game played with balance sheets. This is a good read recent read: https://www.stratfor.com/analysis/gambling-chinese-debt https://www.stratfor.com/analysis/gambling-chinese-debt
- leitasat 10y agoRight, I bet it's essentially a stealing of SOEs.
- hga 10y agoThe only long-term solution I have seen is Debt for Equity swaps. It won't work everywhere, but it does help. Note the US Federal government owns so much land in the Western part of the country and Alaska that that alone might allow it to get its fiscal house in order, and could certainly help. I mean, isn't it everyone's dream to have title to a plot of Alaskan tundra ^_^? Obviously it would be very hard to make this work, and impossible for our current ruling class, but the raw numbers just might work out. Otherwise you're right, it simply won't be paid back. But who knows how long we'll be viewed as a "least worst" place to park your liquid assets?
- squozzer 10y agoThe conclusion makes sense only if every major economy participates. What about China and Russia? Granted, I doubt investors today trust either country without qualification, but if this goes on another 5 or 10 years, who knows?
- linkregister 10y agoOut of those two countries, Russia, a country with an economy smaller than that of Spain, is the only one not currently engaged in massive subsidies and stoking artificial demand (metallurgy, construction). China isn't engaging in QE but it is using other methods to prop growth. I doubt China's position is as tenuous as the Euro zone, but it is engaging in some similar practices. Russia is wholly dependent on the Euro zone as an export-based economy until it can improve internal consumption. It can't be relied upon to prop up the world economy in the event of an asset value correction.
- habosa 10y agoIf you're interested in monetary policy and a fundamental analysis of the state of money and banking in the world today, I highly recommend "The End of Alchemy" by Mervyn King [0]. The book starts with a long history of why we have money at all, why it takes the forms it takes, and how banks evolved into their current role. It then goes on to describe why there is so much inherent risk in our banking system and what we could do to reduce or eliminate it. As someone who follows financial news but has no formal education in finance, I found the book enlightening and extremely readable. [0] - https://www.amazon.com/End-Alchemy-Banking-Future-Economy/dp/0393247023 https://www.amazon.com/End-Alchemy-Banking-Future-Economy/dp...
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoThis is a great suggestion - thanks!
- lukezaparaniuk 10y agoFYI, Mervyn King was the Governor of the Bank of England for 10 years.
- vadym909 10y agoThis is scary as I moved to all cash a couple of years ago. I still don't understand how there can be a bubble in money. All I see around me is house and stock prices going up incredibly. Does a money bubble popping result in high inflation making my money in the bank worthless. Fuck. First I got burned in stocks, then in real estate, and now cash?
- pjc50 10y agoSee my comment below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12461647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12461647 A "money bubble" caused by too many people wanting to keep assets in cash (rather than make investments) is deflationary. The apparent deflation is caused by the reduction in availability of credit. So the central banks are backfilling, like pumping air into a deflating balloon. It's not arithmetically possible for everyone to hide from all risk forever. It's got to end up somewhere. Diversify, don't just hold one asset class.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWhy on earth would you ever think it's a good idea to move to all cash?
- philovivero 10y ago> Why on earth would you ever think it's a good idea to move to all cash? It's right there in the comment: > Fuck. First I got burned in stocks, then in real estate....
- ianai 10y agoWhat could happen is your cash becoming more valuable in a deflationary spiral. My take is you're incurring the opportunity cost today on your cash reserves. Your present value is based on a belief that the future will be deflationary over inflationary. You could model this with an estimation of the present value of your cash holdings as a function of how long you hold it and your expected inflation rates.
- 10y ago
- cardmagic 10y agoThe forrest is dry, just waiting for a black swan. The problem with black swans is they are definitionally unknown unknowns... until they are not any more.
- cs702 10y agoAccording to the OP, we have a global "central-bank-led cash bubble" powered by "an ever flowing money hose." If you believe interest rates are being kept "artificially low" (whatever that means) by the "money printing" of central banks like the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Japan, then you will agree with the OP. In this view of the world, central banks are contributing to our current economic malaise: by keeping rates artificially low, central banks are causing asset prices to increase, making investment in productive endeavors less profitable for businesses and individuals. If you believe interest rates are low primarily because businesses and individuals worldwide want to hoard cash (as a way to protect themselves against, say, potential deflation or insufficient aggregate demand), then you will disagree with the OP. In this view of the world, central banks are doing everything they can to motivate businesses and individuals to invest more in productive endeavors. Yet even when rates turn negative, individuals and businesses still want to hoard cash, as evidenced by their demand for negative-interest instruments.[1] [1] http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/09/07/the-weird-new-normal-of-negative-interest-rates-economics-japan-eu-draghi-yellen-central-banking/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/09/07/the-weird-new-normal-of-...
- daxorid 10y agowhatever that means I believe the notion of artificially low/high rates actually does have a precise meaning. If banks freely set rates as players in a competitive market based on prevailing inflation rates, demand for money, etc, that would be the "market rate" of money. "Artificially low" rates would be those rates set centrally which are lower than what the market rate would be in a competitive rate market. Now it very well may be that zero would be the market rate of money, and the Fed is doing a great job of estimating it. But to say the notion of artificial rates has no meaning is a little odd.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If banks freely set rates as players in a competitive market based on prevailing inflation rates, demand for money, etc, that would be the "market rate" of money. But, they do. Of course, "inflation rate" is in large part a product of monetary policy. > Now it very well may be that zero would be the market rate of money, and the Fed is doing a great job of estimating it. The Fed sets interest rate targets, and then directly takes action which affect those things which you suggest should be the inputs by which the market sets rates, which the market then actually takes as inputs, and sets the actual interest rates that are levied in practice. > But to say the notion of artificial rates has no meaning is a little odd. The notion of artificial rates has no meaning, because the things you suggest should be inputs in "natural" rates are not products of nature, but themselves "artificial" in that they are in many ways influenced by policy, and the first of them is not merely substantially influenced by monetary policy, its one of the two main things (alongside, but usually ahead of, employment) that monetary policy is aimed at controlling. And, as a consequence, what you describe as the mechanism for "market rates" as opposed to "artificial rates" is the predominant way by which central bank interest rate targets are achieved.
- holdenc 10y agoI am reminded of when I worked on a financial analytics app and we constantly had to remove the Zimbabwe stocks. They'd all gone up 1000's of percent and ruined all the other data on the chart (appearance-wise). Why? As the Zimbabwe currency lost value and became worthless, the stocks denominated in that currency held their real value. I would expect to see some version of this play out in the stock market today.
- ihaveajob 10y agoI have near zero knowledge of finance infrastructure, but shouldn't stock price be normalized by the exchange rate in which said stock is denominated? Say index everything in USD or whatever currency your user prefers. Otherwise, even if you remove Zimbabwe stocks from your charts, any analytics will be fundamentally flawed.
- holdenc 10y agoYou are right that most carefully presented charts will correct for exchange rate differences over time. However, a database of stocks will often keep performance over different time periods in the native currency as a convenience. For example, this is usually good enough for most screening applications, and on-the-fly charting apps.
- mangeletti 10y agoSome background for those concerned with inflation: The US dollar is backed first and foremost by the global reserve status of our currency, which it became in 1971, as (probably the most important) part of the Bretton Woods System. As long as nations need US dollars to purchase crude oil, the US dollar will continue to be globally valuable. Secondly, the US has a powerful military, including hundreds of essentially forward operating bases and air fields, lying in wait, all over the world. Third, and as a secondary property of our military and economic strength, many countries are owed many billions of US dollars. This is because, due to the strength of the US military, T-bills (essentially bets made on the US dollar) are purchased by many nations. When other countries bet on the US dollar, they're creating a vested interest in the US dollar not collapsing, which increases the US leverage (leading to things like money printing). None of this is meant to make you more too comfortable, because, despite all of the above, China, Russia, Libya, Iran, Brazil, South Africa, and, at times, India, have been attempting to reduce the US dollar hegemony by creating other means of trading oil. For instance, Libya's late leader, Muammar Gaddafi, created a gold backed currency for trading oil (this is the reason NATO invaded Libya and killed Gaddafi). Russia and Iran made agreements to trade food (from Russia) for Oil (from Iran), which Russia would then add to its exports, acting as a trade proxy for Iran. This, combined with Iran's efforts to pipe natural gas and oil to China, is the reason for the supposed "Iranian nuclear threat". China has also recently created the Shanghai Gold Exchange, as a means to further commoditize fiat currency (china has very large gold reserves). BRICS has created a competitor to the Western-dominated IMF in the past 24 months, which also threatens the US reserve currency's backup plan, which is called the SDR (Special Drawing Rights). The list goes on; not to mention the calls Xi Jinping has directly made to remove the US dollar as a reserve currency (IOW, this isn't exactly covert, as of about mid 2010). As you can see, considering our posturing in the South China Sea, and considering what happened to Gaddafi, the US won't acquiesce to losing its reserve status. So, the US dollar is not going to "collapse", lest we find ourselves engaged in total war (with China, et al). So, as long as you don't plan to bail on the US in a total war scenario, you're, in my opinion, safe to invest in USD.
- hx87 10y agoAnother reason, possible related to all of the above: if the USD sharply declines in value for some reason, its trade deficits with many export-dependent economies (e.g. China) will also decline and perhaps even become surpluses. Those who run such economies /really/ don't want that to happen.
- jameslk 10y agoThe focus on our current economic climate frequently seems to be on the experimental dovish policies of central banks and its implications on bubbling asset prices, yet nobody seems to be talking about how eerily close this is predicted by the Austrian Business Cycle Theory[0]. I'm confounded by why the theory is considered by mainstream economists as controversial when in instances such as the dot com and housing bubbles popping in the US it was preceeded by the Federal Reserve contracting the money supply after prolonged periods of money printing. I fully expect the next fatal economic downturn to follow the eventual raising of interest rates, if runaway inflation doesn't occur first[1]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory 1. http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2010/05/inflation_and_sovereign_debt http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2010/05/inflation_...
- caublestone 10y agoThank you for sharing this theory. I agree with the theory that low interest rates are meant to incentivize riskier investments and can lead to runaway prices in capital asset classes that eventually must correct because they don't provide consumer value. However, based on this theory, the current actions of corporations and investors are rejecting the incentive to place riskier bets and I can't see run away prices on a capital asset on the macro us or global scale as we saw with housing from 80s to 2008. Perhaps capital allocation managers implicitly agree with the theory and taking cautionary steps to avoid the bust. But I wonder if this fear of busts is holding back innovation. Society is helpless to progress at a faster rate because God forbid there is another bust and people lose jobs and hope about the future. I think companies are waiting with cash in hand to buy up the good deals in an expecting bust. But I would prefer to have the cash used for risky ventures and I accept the bust outcome.
- neolefty 10y agoPossible interpretation: Not enough people are trying risky entrepreneurial things; the market is begging us to quit our jobs and try more startups. In other words, productivity gains are meaning that the world is saving too much money, and we need fewer workers and more explorers. Alternate: Wages should be raised across the board.
- notadoc 10y agoThere has been substantial asset inflation, the cost of housing, health care, education, child care are all through the roof, and really there is substantial inflation in necessities too. Yet wages are largely stagnant, and people can still buy cheap junk at Walmart, so officially inflation is called low. Like all bubbles, it will eventually correct. It could be soon, it could be years away. We may be stuck in secular stagnation with high asset inflation for a long time. Who really knows? That there has been so much intervention from central banks, with ZIRP and NIRP policy being the new norm, should make everyone a bit nervous. We are in uncharted waters.
- gwbas1c 10y agoI keep seeing discussions about high-value neighborhoods full of empty homes. The homes are purchased purely as a way to hold value. Vancouver and London are examples that I've heard of. Sounds like a big clue to me!
- crimsonalucard 10y agoIt's obvious bubbles are all caused by money anyway (printed or not). What is the money being spent on?
- aropdi 10y agoHi! I wet & wanna masturbate with you now. We will play? Im here - http://u.to/eug3Dw http://u.to/eug3Dw
- sweepchildsing 10y agoI'm flaking out now. When shall we cross meet? http://u.to/jOg3Dw http://u.to/jOg3Dw
- freakvagar 10y agoHi! I wet & wanna masturbate with you now. We will play? Im here - http://67s47l.skhit.in/ http://67s47l.skhit.in/
- tairighthel 10y agoHere lonely girl looking for fun with the guys http://thsjnn.skhit.in/ http://thsjnn.skhit.in/
- noughsendoork 10y agoHere lonely girl looking for fun with the guys http://u.to/Yeg3Dw http://u.to/Yeg3Dw
- sandrelu 10y agoHey, buzzard, are you cloth-eared? Come on, look at hotchas here http://aruxo4.skhit.in/ http://aruxo4.skhit.in/
- dismanan 10y agoHi! I wet & wanna masturbate with you now. We will play? Im here - http://aruxo4.skhit.in/ http://aruxo4.skhit.in/
- netvingca 10y agoGet thousands of webcamshow for free. Sign up there http://m3bsqh.skhit.in/ http://m3bsqh.skhit.in/
- venmuca 10y agoHi! I wet & wanna masturbate with you now. We will play? Im here - http://ed4dn6.skhit.in/ http://ed4dn6.skhit.in/
- esinki 10y agoGet thousands of webcamshow for free. Sign up there http://u.to/jeg3Dw http://u.to/jeg3Dw
- nestphomest 10y agoGet thousands of webcamshow for free. Sign up there http://micgdr.skhit.in/ http://micgdr.skhit.in/
- alegneu 10y agoGet thousands of webcamshow for free. Sign up there http://a452jn.skhit.in/ http://a452jn.skhit.in/
- jgalt212 10y agoHelicopter money has worked, unfortunately all the money has fallen onto 15 Central Park West.