7 ms·
Other people getting screwed: Custom IEM wearers. I had a $300 set of Alclair Audio IEMs made so I can use an in-ear audio system on stage while making live mus
by exabrial 10y ago
Other people getting screwed: Custom IEM wearers. I had a $300 set of Alclair Audio IEMs made so I can use an in-ear audio system on stage while making live music. These use impressions that an audiologist takes of your ear canals for an _exact_ fit that completely seals your ear.
There's not a snow-balls chance in hell I would have these be wireless, or a proprietary standard:
1) Latency. Anything over 2ms is not acceptable for live music. That's the difference between a band sounding "in-time" to "needs practice"
2) We use various tablets, phones to control the mix to our ears, and sometimes in between sets, listen and review music.
3) Removing the 3.5mm pretty much means Apple is exiting professional audio because it's now incompatible with 100% of everything.
4) There is no way in hell my $300 pair of custom-molded IEMs bound to a standard that Apple is going to change in 3 years. Not only would I have to replace my IEMs, but any equipment that's not Apple would have to be updated to match. Not going to happen.
- azinman2 10y agoSo use the dongle?
- snerbles 10y agoDoes the dongle add latency?
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoUnlikely; the audio had to be converted from digital to analog on the phone previously so now that's being moved to a dongle so it's still the same process (roughly). If it does add latency I would bet it's very unnoticeable (like sub milliseconds when compared to the built-in solution).
- makomk 10y agoEntirely possible. Onboard DACs use I2S which adds basically zero latency; one of the ways of getting audio out over Lightning is to use USB which requires additional latency-causing buffering. It's possible that there's another lower-latency way of getting audio out over Lighting but only Apple knows.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoFair enough. Now I'm interested in this topic but am not an electrical engineer so I've skimmed through about 5 wikipedia articles semi related heh
- cmdrfred 10y agoAn Android phone costs less than the dongle.
- mbrd 10y agoI know you're joking, and I'm not agreeing with the headphone jack decision, but the dongle is $9. http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MMX62AM/A/lightning-to-35-mm-headphone-jack-adapter http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MMX62AM/A/lightning-to-35-...
- stonogo 10y agoI have four android phones. None of them cost me a dime. They all have headphone jacks.
- citruspi 10y ago> None of them cost me a dime How so? If they were through carriers, you probably still paid for part of it through your monthly bill, and part of it was subsidized by your carrier. Either way cmdrfred's > An Android phone costs less than the dongle. is incorrect. Most people are paying for their phones in some way, whether Android or iOS, whether directly or via their carrier, and the dongle is free with the phone.
- Stratoscope 10y agoUnless these were gifts, you paid for them. If the phones were "free" or just a penny from a mobile carrier, the real price of the phone was hidden in the monthly service charge. That's why you had to sign a long-term service contract to get the "free" phone. Thank goodness the carriers have been moving away from that kind of deceptive pricing.
- citruspi 10y agoThe dongle comes for free in the box[0]. > In the Box >> Lightning to 3.5 mm Headphone Jack Adapter [0]: http://www.apple.com/iphone-7/specs/ http://www.apple.com/iphone-7/specs/
- calebgilbert 10y agoYeah, use the dongle unless you need to charge it at the same time.
- otterley 10y agoWait a month, or maybe even a week (manufacturers are pretty quick these days). There will be an adapter that lets you do both. If there's one thing to be said about Apple products, it's that there's no shortage of doohickeys that connect to them.
- mixedCase 10y agoHello 2007. https://i.imgur.com/NqxYlb0.jpg https://i.imgur.com/NqxYlb0.jpg
- mediocrejoker 10y agoWhat is this a photo of? Looks like some sort of barrel jack to AC mains adapter?
- devy 10y agoThat looks like a Sony Ericsson proprietary connector (called FastPort)[1] to 3.5mm audio jack to me. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FastPort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FastPort
- robotresearcher 10y agoIt's a custom edge connector to 3.5mm audio dongle.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sigmar 10y agoThe dongle: probably has a poor quality DAC, gets lost easily, and prevents the phone from being charged or tethered to a computer.
- gambiting 10y agoI imagine it doesn't have any DAC. The DAC is still inside the phone, just like on previous iphone, the dongle is just a physical adapter to the 3.5mm standard.
- sigmar 10y agoI had assumed it had a DAC since I haven't seen apple use lightning for analog audio yet. I could be wrong, but couldn't find any source for clarification (upon googling). This slide from yesterday seems to suggest lightning is being used for digital out: https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/ghvFaov2v5hQ-mZ8y-r6VM5oTWI=/800x0/filters:no_upscale()/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/7059533/apple-iphone-watch-20160907-5163.0.JPG https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/ghvFaov2v5hQ-mZ8y-r6VM5oTWI...
- CarVac 10y agoDoes it actually have a DAC, or does it just provide a physical interface to one of the Lightning pins which gets connected to a DAC inside the phone?
- sigmar 10y agoI assumed it had a DAC, but can't find a source that says either way.
- legulere 10y agoThen the lightning dock.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe dongle is a passive converter the lightning interface has a pinout for analog audio.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoGreat points, and reminds me of how Apple treated those who invested heavily in Final Cut Pro 'server farms' (so to speak) for professional production, only to see FCPX and nearly pick up torches and pitchforks. Actively slicing away utility and, well, consideration for professionals at the expense of greater revenues from consumers seems to be ingrained in the Apple business model. I don't like it but I can see it with these kinds of decisions.
- notyourwork 10y agoAlthough your points are completely valid for your demographic I think Apple's focus is on mass audience. Additionally, they have not yet announced the ipads and macbooks are divorcing with 3.5. So its possible you still have hope, just not on your iphone. Either way I feel your pain and hate this decision.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> Although your points are completely valid for your demographic I think Apple's focus is on mass audience. How many times you can ignore 1% of your audience until you have none? It is being interesting to watch and discover.
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> "3) Removing the 3.5mm pretty much means Apple is exiting professional audio because it's now incompatible with 100% of everything." They removed it from the phone, nothing else. In what scenario are you using an iPhone with custom IEM's in a professional audio setting?
- paavokoya 10y agoI think Apple seriously underestimates its appeal towards creatives. I've been buying Apple products for 10 years because of their ease-of-use with creative software. As they slowly move away from PC's and professional media standards I see their market share diminishing. They are heading down the path of lowest common denominator just like Microsoft in the early 2000's. I expect the same fate awaits them as someone else fills that role.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoWhat have they specifically done that has made your creative work more difficult? I'm a creative using a MacBook Pro and it's just as good for me doing audio work as it was 5 years ago. They've also been doing a good job with Logic Pro, with some big updates of the last couple of years. Even if they removed the headphone input from their laptops (which I don't ever see happening) it's not going to effect creative professionals because they don't use it anyway.
- paavokoya 10y agoWhat have they specifically done that has made your creative work more difficult? Final Cut Pro X is now unusable due to them engineering the UX for beginners (it's basically an iMovie Pro) and similar moves to cater to the lowest common denominator. After installing Little Snitch, I noticed my mac was calling home to apple servers for basically any action which slows processing/rendering.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ohitsdom 10y ago> Anything over 2ms is not acceptable for live music. That's the difference between a band sounding "in-time" to "needs practice" Obviously you want your in-ear sound to be as exact as possible, but a 2 ms difference will not make a band sound bad. I remember hearing 9 ms was the threshold for live music, but I can't find any references. If it truly is lower I would love to read some source material. There are very few people in the world that would be capable of playing within a 2 ms tolerance (but maybe you're just holding you in-ear reference to a higher standard to allow for human error). Edit: here's an interesting resource, not much data but they did find problems start between 10-20ms. http://blog.highfidelity.com/blog/2013/05/how-much-latency-can-live-musicians-tolerate http://blog.highfidelity.com/blog/2013/05/how-much-latency-c...
- soundwave106 10y agoThe problem is Bluetooth audio, from all sources, is far higher than 2ms latency. The best codecs seem to be (per sources like this -- http://stereos.about.com/od/glossary/fl/What-is-aptX.htm http://stereos.about.com/od/glossary/fl/What-is-aptX.htm) 40ms or so. "Typical" Bluetooth audio seems to have a latency of 150ms-200ms. Musicians can compensate to some degree of latency, but not when your audio is delayed by approx. an 1/8th note at 140bpm. (1/8th note at 140bpm = 214ms). Even 40ms isn't terribly tight. So rule Bluetooth audio out for this. The dongle is an option, of course, but it probably is not as robust as a soldered-in 3.5mm jack. I'm sure in-ear monitoring with an iPhone is unfortunately too much of a niche application for Apple to care much, though...
- exabrial 10y ago+-2ms is with unpredictable jitter, you can go up to 6ms-8ms with predictable latency, anything over 10ms it gets difficult. Source: personal experience in the field with various in-ear and stage monitor systems, and lots and tons of research over the years
- paperpunk 10y agoI think you are overstating things. 3.5mm isn't really the standard for professional audio. Much more common is 6.35mm, RCA, S/PDIF, XLR, and USB. All of which would already need an adaptor for the 3.5mm. But I doubt I'm saying anything you don't already know. Yes it's annoying if you already are set-up for 3.5mm, and yes I can see why you wouldn't want to use a consumer wireless audio standard for live music performance, but it hardly equates to Apple "exiting professional audio".