12 ms·
The Metaprogrammer
- taurath 10y agoAh the never ending lament about programmers asking for nice things. Sorry, $4k in capital costs for someone you're paying well into 6 figures for to make your business exist isn't that bad. A fast pc is necessary depending on what you're doing - making knowledge workers more comfortable effects their output.
- w0utert 10y agoIn addition to that, I fail to see the relation between people who like to talk about programming through whatever medium ('metaprogrammers') and people who like to have decent tools to work with. Literally every developer I have ever met wants to have a decent computer, multiple screens, fast internet, and access to the proper software tools required to work efficiently. It strikes me as an incredibly stupid argument to make if anyone thinks you someone is spoiled for preferring good tools to do the job. Imagine a mechanic who can only use even-sized spanners, or a drywaller who can only use 5-liter buckets at a time.
- tempodox 10y agoMaybe I'm not a decent programmer but I definitely don't want multiple screens. I would perceive such a set-up as unergonomic and creating too many distractions. Nothing against the rest, though.
- erelde 10y agoThat's your workflow. Some prefer two monitors. I prefer to have two computers and two screens instead of two monitors and one computer. (double the keyboards)
- truth_sentinell 10y agoWhy would you do that? Two keyboards sound a waste of time
- erelde 10y agoI'm just used to it, there's no good reason. First, I had a desktop, then bought a laptop, kept the desktop in front of me, the laptop on the left. At some point the desktop left my desk and I only had a laptop, then after many minor changes over time [skipping a lot] I found myself in front of two desktops. But it doubles the power! Isn't it how this work?
- truth_sentinell 10y agoIt depends. How do you coordinate the work between the two computers?
- erelde 10y agoCurrently, one of them mostly acts as a server, and I work with network shares and symlinks. But that's how I work, I won't force it on anyone else.
- calgoo 10y agoHave you tried synergy yet? Im using it, and apart from some keyboard mapping issues its working quite well.
- caseymarquis 10y agoProbably has more to do with preference and what you're working with. In Web programming having a debugger, the rendered page and your code all up is really nice. I actually have 3 monitors for this. Doing other stuff you can have stackoverflow, your code, and a gui for version control. Doesn't hurt to have the extra real estate for command lines, file explorers, email, a crm, remote support sessions, etc. I think I need more monitors...
- noir_lord 10y ago1 -> 2 made a huge difference for me. 2 -> 3 much less (so much so I went from 3 to 2 at home because I wanted the desk space back). Working on one screen for webdev though is frustrating I agree, I hate working from my laptop now.
- PeterisP 10y agoFor me, the main use of multiple screens is to separate the "place" where I'm writing from the "place" that I'm looking at - there are many cases where I need to look at something else while editing code or docs, and I'd want to do that without task switching. So my code would be on monitor 1 and stay there forever, but the various things that I'm reading, e.g. input (documentation, specification, sample data) or output (debug output, logs, testing app) would be on the other screen. The alternative is a large monitor and keeping things side-by-side.
- calgoo 10y agoIt depends on what you are working on as well. When Im doing UI stuff, I love having at least dual monitors. That way I can have the result GUI /web page open on one screen, code and console on the second. This lets me reload without switching windows or workspaces continually. When im doing backend stuff, I can have several consoles doing testing and also for example the design document open while working so i can glance quickly at it. In the end it comes down to what you do, and what you like. I now use a ultra wide 29" screen instead and it works equally or better sometimes. My second monitor only keeps playlists, IM and email open now.
- Can_Not 10y agoI only use multiple monitors because 4k/5k screens have not been affordable in the past 10 years. Are you saying that you don't need additional workspace on your screen or that you don't want a workspace divided down the middle?
- MichaelBurge 10y ago> for someone you're paying well into 6 figures for My first programming job was $32k/year out of college(this was in 2011).
- kayoone 10y agoeven then, as you are probably not employed for only 1 year (in which case the perks could be transferred to someone else) the costs for a good setup are negligible compared to the total mount spent on a developer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- catmanjan 10y agoExactly, all these things are tools of the trade - tradesmen spend money on the right tools for the job because that (and experience) is what separates them from the DIY-ers
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoon the other hand only a poor craftsman blames their tools.
- catmanjan 10y agoA good craftsman never has to, because he has the right tools ;)
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoyes, that is the implicit meaning. But then are programmers, whose tools are generally provided by their employers, actually craftsmen (craftspeople)? That question being part of the general discussion around this post. On edit: I should clarify there is another meaning, which is that a good craftsperson can do whatever they need to in their chosen craft with substandard tools - this is also the viewpoint the original post seems to ascribe to. I personally like to use the simplest tools possible to achieve a task, even if that means I have to do more work to achieve the task, because then I don't spend time learning my tools. This means I use a crappy laptop with no external monitor, a simple text editor, the command line for just about everything. When I do end up on someones machine where they have the good tools I find that I am but a simple caveman, confused and enraged by the complexity of other people's worlds. All this does not mean I am a good programmer or craftsman, it just means I find doing without the better tools and hardware suite me better.
- amyjess 10y agoAnd have you noticed that you only hear these laments when it's programmers? Nobody laments when somebody in the sales, finance, or marketing departments wants nice things. Hell, in the business side of many companies, getting a nicer chair and/or a bigger office is just as much a part of your promotion as the title, raise, and direct reports are. But it seems that there are people intent on cutting programmers off from the same perks that MBA types consider essential. It would be one thing if this backlash came from management; at least that would make sense as a cost-saving measure, but in the case of this article, it's coming from other programmers. It seems that not only are programmers undercompensated, but other programmers are actively seeking to keep us undercompensated. Is this crab mentality [0] at work or just ignorance of how non-technical people get compensated? Either way, it makes me wonder if I went into the right profession. I went into software engineering because I love computers, and coding is fun, but I have to wonder if I'd be better off if I got my MBA instead of a CS degree and went into finance or marketing or something (I know I don't have what it takes to do sales). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crab_mentality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crab_mentality
- berntb 10y agoCome on now, we real metaprogramming wimps carry our own keyboards with us and don't even bother to complain about the one provided. :-) Otoh, as an Emacs user my mouse costs about as much as one of the black espressos I exclusively drink for coffee. :-) Edit: This made me feel like the wimp I am. Time to stop the singer songwriters on my headphones and play some black metal. (And go to the gym for deadlifts or squats this evening.)
- dozzie 10y ago> Otoh, as an Emacs user my mouse costs about as much [...] I didn't know a mouse can be an Emacs user. Where did you get one?
- dasmoth 10y agoWith a real, live, META key?
- berntb 10y agoI don't think I've even seen that key since I was a student... "Das Keyboard" have that? Should order. (Just got the best feel I could find in the stores. I paid 70 Euros, maybe not cheap but fram from extreme. I only play a snob on internet. :-) )
- bloat 10y agoThe Happy Hacking Keyboard has a meta key. Not cheap though... http://www.google.com/images?q=Happy+Hacking+Keyboard http://www.google.com/images?q=Happy+Hacking+Keyboard
- asher_ 10y agometametaprogramming (verb.) The act of talking about people talking about programming, rather than doing any actual talking about programming.
- kpmah 10y agoSo is your comment metametametaprogramming?
- fao_ 10y agoEvery comment talking about ('meta' times n)-programming is ('meta' times (n+1))-programming :) So your comment is meta(metametametaprogramming). But this comment isn't meta(meta(metametametaprogramming)), because of this sentence :D
- TuringTest 10y agoWhen did the term lose its original meaning? [1] Or am I missing some kind of joke? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaprogramming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaprogramming
- dagw 10y agoIt hasn't. The blog post is making a joke: "You might have thought that metaprogramming meant macros, type introspection, that kind of thing. Nope, I'm hijacking the word for today:"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- midgetjones 10y agoCan't believe he didn't mention text editors or indentation!
- wingerlang 10y agoWhy would he? I think the general consensus nowadays is that Sublime and tabs is the best option.
- tempodox 10y agoI beg to differ ;-) See my own $0.02 sibling comment.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y ago> tabs is the best option You nearly got me.
- tempodox 10y agoRight. The spaces-versus-tabs debate is fully capable of inciting religious wars. And don't even mention vim-versus-emacs!
- turbo104 10y agoTabs vs Spaces: I hit the tab key and let the IDE manage whether that translates into X spaces or a tab. I set the IDE up to use the language convention. :) Text Editor/IDEs.... I'll leave this holy war for the truly devout to fight :D
- dasmoth 10y agoThere's a balance here. I don't like the idea of talking without producing either, but using this as an argument to shut down all discussion about working environment isn't going to help matters. Headphones are a big topic of discussion because default working environments are so far from what many of us find optimal (and, indeed, what seems to be empirically optimal if you look at the studies in Peopleware).
- q1t 10y agoMoar stickers!
- gavinflud 10y ago> "You post an article about a new programming language, you'll get 10 replies." A quick search pulls up results that would contradict that statement. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7436401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7436401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10901054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10901054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8735892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8735892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10177716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10177716 I realize four search results isn't enough to completely debunk the author's statement, but in my experience programmers love to talk about programming languages. If you start a conversation about an interesting new language, more often than not people will want to give their input. Programmers also love to talk about their ideal working environment. Things like office chairs, keyboards, monitors and office perks are important to them because the majority of their time is spent at work.
- junke 10y agoLanguages are part of the ergonomics of code writing.
- efaref 10y agoHaving decent chairs, keyboards and monitors is also important for health. Yes, I could work on a kitchen chair hunched over a crappy keyboard and illegible monitor for 10 hours a day, but after not very long I'd have headaches, RSI and back pain so bad I wouldn't be able to work at all.
- d3ckard 10y agoI do not see anything strange in it. Author seems to be forgetting that while there is a myriad of frameworks and programming languages, we all share similar work setups and needs. Also, while a newbie might be afraid to talk with 'pros' about advantages of hygienic macros, he knows what headphones make him comfortable at work. I would redefine 'metaprogramming' as 'stuff that most of the programmers have in common'. That's why they talk so vividly about it.
- anotheryou 10y agoI hoped this was about high level future programming stuff :/ Like arguing with AI on the requirements of a new project it will implement.
- zuzuleinen 10y agoFor me a chair is important. I don't really care about perks and other stuff but knowing that I sit around 8 hours every day for a couple years in a good chair is as important for me as the work station. And in most of the startups I worked so far there were only cheap chairs not so good for my back. In a way I understand the owners: they have startup they should buy the cheapest things possible because they don't know how long their startup will survive, but I like when someone makes an effort to provide good working conditions for the programmers. I also used to care about the noise level, but again working in startups I had to get used to noisy open spaces.
- AstralStorm 10y agoSilly people who don't understand that furniture can be loaned or leased. Maybe you won't get something cutting edge in economics, but definitely very good still.
- narendraj9 10y agoOkay. So this is a meta-metaprogramming blog post.
- gnode 10y agoThat's a meta-meta-metaprogramming comment.
- caseymarquis 10y agothrow new StackOverflowException("This ends here!");
- Zarkonnen 10y agoBikeshedding. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/bikeshedding https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/bikeshedding
- joshwcomeau 10y agoI think that there's two distinct ideas here, and they're fused together. One of them (IMO) is valid, the other is not. "Programmers spend too much time attention-seeking, or debating online, instead of actually writing code" is a valid topic to debate over; I can see arguments on both sides, but it's certainly a thing that could be argued. The work we do is more important than all the meta-stuff surrounding that work. "Programmers are too pampered and we should just give them all shitty old computers in shitty offices without perks", though... workspaces are important, as are the tools. A large monitor means I can have more stuff open at once, and I know that I'm more productive when I have an external monitor than when I don't, and I need to cmd-tab a bunch between editor, terminal, and browser. Companies don't offer good equipment and perks because they're charitable, they do it because it produces results (more often than not).
- xapata 10y ago> produces results Conversely, companies that don't offer good equipment are making a terrible decision. I once worked at a company with a single 14-inch monitor on every desk. In 2010. I was astonished.
- collyw 10y agoPersonally I don't mind working on an average machine. I don't do anything with huge computing needs, and it shows where the bottlenecks are before they get into production. (Then the disk starts paging and I change my mind about having a better machine).
- xapata 10y agoCompute, I don't care about. Screen space is precious. Every extra window I can have open simultaneously increases my productivity.
- collyw 10y agoTrue, though for me its the keyboard. I can't seem to get into the flow on a laptop, despite the fact the resolution is better than my larger monitor.
- bcgraham 10y ago"When art critics get together they talk about Form and Structure and Meaning. When artists get together they talk about where you can buy cheap turpentine." - Picasso, supposedly Talking about this stuff is only natural. As for the rest of the OP, not knocking it (or the book), but it sounds like he just read Catcher in the Rye or something. Employees have been jockeying for status inside firms and across firms as long as there have been employees and firms.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lambdacomplete 10y agoTL; DR: buying a Macbook tricked me into going through a "dark" phase. It was worth all the money. This isn't necessarily true all the time, although it is in many contexts. For example millions of people are eagerly awaiting the new, shiny, same-as-before-but-slightly-more-expensive-and-with-a-couple-new-features, iPhone 7 but the number of people who get excited when there's a breakthrough in a particular scientific or technological field can be counted on one hand (and multiplied by 10^[2-4]). The explanation is pretty simple: I can get the iPhone 7 when it comes out but it's hard to get excited knowing I might go to Mars in 2060. I had a similar experience myself. As a human being I'm naturally inclined to, sometimes, consider short-term rewards more valuable than long-term rewards. They say the quickest way to change your lifestyle is to change the environment around you. In the case of software developers that environment is often their gear/tools. In my case it was my laptop. When I was still a student I was using the not-so-crappy-but-still-kind-of-crappy laptop provided by my university. The problem was not the laptop, of course, but the fact that I was doing something I didn't enjoy. One day, frustrated by the fact that a few Chrome tabs and PyCharm would literally devour RAM and swap alike, I started considering buying a laptop of my own. Fast forward to a couple of months later, and on the edge of a serious depression, I bought a shiny Macbook Pro with 16 GB of RAM. I started getting more into web development (I was doing research in a very specific field of cybersecurity), studied machine learning (and used it for my thesis project), found a very good job (where EVERYBODY was using Apple hardware) and slowly transitioned to doing web development full time. The Macbook acted as a trigger. I might have gotten the same results by moving to another country, changing house, changing friends, maybe by dropping college altogether, but that shallow, nonetheless very useful, purchase (I'd go as far as to call it an "investment") did the trick. I got my degree, I'm still working, and enjoying what I do, I even moved to another country eventually. Could I have experienced the same thing doing something else? Probably. But it's easy to say so afterwards. :)
- sguav 10y ago> Gotta have that 40" monitor, it's essential, can't work without it And I was thinking I ought to be content with my 27"
- douche 10y agoEh, you just need four of them, so you have (effectively) a 54" monitor...
- LeonM 10y agoI used to be that guy that proclaimed I could not work if I did not have 2 monitors of at least 21 inches in size... But, 2 * 21" (FHD LCD) became 2 * 24" (FHD IPS), which I upgraded to 2 * 27 (Apple 2560 * 1440), which I now consider to replace by 2 * 42" (4K). Have I became 10x more productive by it? No. Can I work without them? Sure. Do I enjoy working on those huge screens? Hell yes! And since screens are not that expensive anymore, why not? I spend 10+ hours a day in my office, so why not try to make that time the most enjoyable I can?
- koder2016 10y ago"...I spend 10+ hours a day in my office..." - I agree that there should be an upside to a statistically shorter lifespan.
- kayoone 10y agoI don't agree. Of course a car mechanic can do his work with just the most basic set of tools, but will he be as productive as someone using the newest stuff that enables him to work faster ? Probably not. There is actually value in having a faster computer, bigger screens and even better chair as a programmer.
- sagischwarz 10y agoThis effect is observable not only in the programming community, but in many others. Best example would be photography, where people spend much more time discussing their equipment and the newest lenses instead of going out and actually take pictures. I had to experience this for myself when searching for new hobbies. With most of them, I spent most time with the meta, e.g., which fountain pen to use for my writing or what the best ball bearings for my skateboard are. I think in comes down to "I want to be a writer, but I don't want to write. I want to be a photographer, but I don't want to take pictures. I want to be a skateboarder, but I don't actually want to skate." Why I want to be something but not actually practice the trade is another question (prestige, self-identification?). I wonder if others have experienced the same.
- livarot 10y agoAudiophiles - probably the most prominent example of them all.
- ontouchstart 10y agoThe opposite is real musicians.
- AstralStorm 10y agoYou would be surprised then by how snooty some musicians are about gear. You don't have a vetted guitar, amplifier, mixer or a microphone? Yep. That said, they sometimes have a point.
- splatcollision 10y ago"Listeningphiles" "Observingphiles" good point
- equalarrow 10y agoI have a friend like this. I've been in bands in the past and worked in (even built my own) studios. I seen and partaken the 24/96 vs. 16/48 debate (spoiler: that only matters in the studio). I've worked with high end mics, pres, dacs, boards, tape, etc. The big thing we tangle on is always digital vs. analog. Oh boy.... Zzzzz... I've cut tape and editing on analog sucks. Noise on analog is not ideal. Compression and 'natural' bottom end warmth are nice. But that's where it stops. Most of (all of?) these things can now be simulated by plugins. We don't even have to say digital has won because it's so obvious. Analog is there for the minority purists. This debate has between us has taken many hours over many years. Oh yah, let's not forget vinyl too!.. I've had to recently redirect the argument to musicianmanship, which I feel is really where the rubber meets the road. It all starts at the source. If your source sucks, then you'll have some work to do to fix it. Stuff like autotune, sample triggers, etc. In this way, analog is better as it will demand more of the musician's performance. Hard to swap out the kick drum on analog. All in all, I personally don't think any non-studio experienced audiophiles would know if something was recorded digitally vs. analog. There are so many things you can do now and unless you know those studio 'tricks', you can't even tell. This has already been the case since the 90's I think. Everything can pretty much be simulated, processed, filtered, chopped, moved, etc. One great resource for all this is Ken Andrews. Look him up. He's got a lot of great stories and insight on recording. My advice to my friend: learn the tools and use what make sense artistically. But debate for theory's sake is pointless in my mind.
- DanielBMarkham 10y ago"...he would only ever consider someone to be a good programmer if they had a twitch livestream about programming..." I don't do twitch. Come back to me in ten years if it's still around, maybe I'll have time for it. But I make videos of my programming and add commentary as I go. I doubt anybody watches it, but I found it most enjoyable -- makes me think and vocalize each thing that I'm doing. Plus it gives me a good excuse to talk to myself.
- chrisweekly 10y agoGot links to share?
- thecatspaw 10y agoplus it keeps you from getting distracted. I did have a twitchstream of me coding once. It was awesome. Not once I got distracted, even though noone watched.
- V-2 10y ago"If they don't have the shiniest Apple MacBook then they can't work. Never mind that their job involves typing letters into a text file, something you could have done on CP/M back in '78" I don't want an Apple at all, but I do want a beefy machine because my job doesn't only involve typing text you see - for instance I also need to build the result of all that typing, and if it takes ages, guess what, the time I waste waiting for it to complete is not worth whatever money they cleverly save by supplying me a "CP/M from '78" "To insult a new hire by providing only a single 4:3 monitor? I can't work like this." I can work like this, but I prefer two monitors. How much does a monitor cost anyway? Having two displays is much more convenient. I can program sitting on a kitchen chair, but I prefer an ergonomic office chair, because I spend a large part of my life at work and I see no reason why it should feel uncomfortable. Oh, how pampered I am! "- You were lucky to have a LAKE! There were a hundred and sixty of us living in a small shoebox in the middle of the road. - Cardboard box? - Aye. - You were lucky. We lived for three months in a brown paper bag in a septic tank." etc.
- Nursie 10y agoBuilding on your own desktop? That seems rather archaic. Well-connected and integrated access to a massive multicore build machine seems a little more modern. As time goes on (16 years as a dev now) I find myself a lot less concerned about this stuff.
- splatcollision 10y agoSometimes once in a rare while you want to be able to work totally offline, or in a low-connectivity environment. For example I'm currently on a commuter train on an hour+ ride into the city, and if I want to do everything locally, I can. Options are good. (PS: ask me about working remotely!)
- koder2016 10y agoI guess using some of my 8 logical cores for background static analysis is archaic now?
- V-2 10y ago
- TurboHaskal 10y agoSo I should be guilty for asking for a silent working atmosphere, a decent laptop and perhaps a second screen while the execs get the latest iteration of the iPhone every year. Right.
- gaius 10y agoThis is funny because no-one bats an eyelid at an "executive" demanding a corner office, an expense account, a company Mercedes, to fly first class... But God forbid a humble worker should beg for scraps.
- coleifer 10y agoAn executive is different from a salaried employee, unless you're a githuber or whatever. Get over it.
- jdbernard 10y agoIn what ways specifically, from a bottom-line point of view at a software company, is an executive different from a programmer that justifies the executive asking for a more pleasant work environment, but not the developer?
- coleifer 10y agoTo put it another way, I'm saying "The captain of the ship is as different from the guy swabbing the deck, as the executive is from the average employee". The captain's calling the shots on where the ship goes, the captain is aware of what the whole crew is doing, etc, etc.
- anoplus 10y agoReminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/1629/ https://xkcd.com/1629/
- krisdol 10y agoSounds like devops
- quickben 10y agoIf the author of that blog doesn't see the benefit of a larger workspace area (monitors, configuration, etc) then there is no point in reading anything else he writes. Why are stuff like this on HN?
- hellofunk 10y agoIn the audio and electronic music world, this is often called GAS -- Gear Acquisition Syndrome.
- Kapura 10y agoI came into this comments section to post about how I didn't actually know any programmers who acted as the author described, but in seeing the other comments I guess I've just been extraordinarily lucky not to have to work with divas. Of course I and others I know have preferences about chairs, keyboards, and monitors, but not so much that they claim they can't to their jobs. Quite frankly, I wouldn't want to work with somebody like that. Who wants to work with somebody who thinks their skill set gives them licence to bitch and moan? Who wants to work with somebody who bitches and moans, period?
- nanch 10y agoYou use the right tools for the job --- and when you're sitting in front of a computer for 8-14 hours a day, why wouldn't you want the best tools? Are you gonna build a new wood-piece with a hand-powered screw-driver? "You post an article about a new programming language, you'll get 10 replies. But start a discussion on what headphones you wear while you work, and ten-thousand people will rise up from nowhere, pushing the thread ever-skywards on a tower of upvotes" Not many people care about your new programming language, but everybody understands the importance of a good chair, monitor, or headphones, and when you ask people for an opinion, they'll express it. IMO, code with whatever you want, but I'll stick to my Herman Miller Embody, a self-modified 45g-uniform Realforce Silenced Keyboard, a 4K 30-inch dell monitor (UP3216Q), and 2 27-inch dells (U2713HM).
- equalarrow 10y agoI've had this debate with my wife before. She absolutely pummels her MB Pro from 2012. Keys are breaking, she has a gazillion windows open (including vmware since she runs an old quickbooks on windows), desktop completely covered in photos of family/kids. I look at how she 'works' and I think at first 'wow, what a mess'. But then it's clear it's totally just a lower rung tool for her business - she is not in the tech space. For anyone who doesn't program or create all day on a screen, it's hard for them to empathize. But all these things are real to me. Knocking 30s off a build can knock off 10-30 mins of wait time a day. It all adds up. On a scale from 1 - 10 (10 being an ultra maxed out everything machine) I usually hover around 7-8. I know after all these years that my concentration and execution are the most important thing I have and I don't need workspace things to get in the way of that. Sadly, headphones are a part of that now. ;-(
- melling 10y agoThat's the way people are about everything. Read many of the comments on HN and you will come to the same conclusion. We like to "bullshit" and tell anecdotes. This is fine for being social but it's a very inefficient way to learn and pass on knowledge. In all the noise, however, there is a lot to be learned so I decided to extract some of the information on various topics. For example, On the topics of standing desks, keyboards, RSI, etc, I've created some org-mode notes on Github. https://github.com/melling/ErgonomicNotes https://github.com/melling/ErgonomicNotes
- peterkelly 10y agoThis article is the perfect example of the problem it describes. Very meta.
- draw_down 10y agoSome people I've worked with switch between vim, emacs, Sublime and back again, for weeks at a clip, and can rattle off the finer points of each. To each their own, I suppose. And those damn clacky keyboards of course. Not a real programmer if you don't have one of those.
- calgoo 10y agoSince I switched to an MS ergonomic keyboard and mouse, I never want to go back to a normal keyboard again. Have one in the office, and one at home. All wrist pain that I had gotten from normal keyboards, and especially working directly on the laptop went away in a matter of hours.
- Secretmapper 10y ago> When did the messenger become more important than the message? Never? The arguments presented are really just hyperbole that applies to all industries. Yes I can code with an old machine, yes I can code with a small monitor, but give me a beefed up OSX and two monitors and I'll be insanely more productive. Why shortchange something that will pay for itself almost immediately?
- dsr_ 10y agoI'm in charge of acquiring equipment for all of our employees -- and I can tell you that tastes vary, but once a person has a good environment set up, they tend not to change it unless forced to do so by hardware failure or similar external event. One programmer asked for 3 1440P 27" monitors, a specific trackball, and maxed-out RAM. We had to figure out support for a new video card for that. Four years later, I think it's time for an upgrade to SSD, but they are not likely to think about it until I suggest it. Everything works, and they are comfortable, so they are productive.
- reitanqild 10y agoAgree with much of this but the expensive equipment thingy is partly like the wedding ring: you don't need it, but you don't want to work for someone who is to cheap to give you a decent machine. Chances are if they want to shave USD500 of your equipment once every three years they will also want to fleece you everywhere else to. Says the man who works off a single laptop that he hates, I know my company cares anyway. ;-)
- ciroduran 10y agoWhatever happened to "hardware is cheap, programmers are expensive"? https://blog.codinghorror.com/hardware-is-cheap-programmers-are-expensive/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/hardware-is-cheap-programmers-...
- falcolas 10y agoIt doesn't get as many views as a rant about how entitled we are.
- Avshalom 10y agoDepending on how you consider that phrase: A) victim of it's own success. Computing hardware is cheap, 10k desks + masseuses + on site food service + all the other perks that are constantly individually compared against "well it's only % of your programmers salary" all started adding up B) phones made people remember that the user's hardware matters more than the developers build farm.
- falcolas 10y ago> the user's hardware matters more than the developers build farm The user doesn't have to recompile their code every few minutes to do testing (or every few seconds for intellisense and other coding aids). Developer hardware still matters. I can be productive without a masseuse. I can't be productive when it takes five minutes to run unit tests because my laptop sucks.
- hlandau 10y agoThis is a misuse of the prefix "meta". "Meta" does not mean "reflection over X". It means "X about X". Saying "metaprogrammer" means "programming about programming". The conventional use of the term "metaprogramming" is correct; unless you can claim that discussing desk chairs is somehow programming about programming, the use of the term metaprogramming to describe this is simply erroneous. (I'd also like to add that deliberately trying to fracture a word into having two completely different meanings just because you think that word sounds cool is to deliberately reduce the accuracy and unambiguity of human communication and perpetrate a damage to the English language, which is pretty obnoxious.)
- gjm11 10y agoWay back when, in ancient Greek, "meta" just meant "alongside" or "next to" or "after". Then Aristotle wrote a book called "Physics" (though its subject was broader than what we now call physics) and another book whose title has been lost, about more abstruse things. It was typically shelved next to the "Physics" and listed after it in catalogues, and it was alleged that Aristotle thought its contents should be taught later than those of the "Physics", and it therefore came to be known as "Metaphysics": the thing that comes after the "Physics". Because the stuff in the "Metaphysics" was felt to be deeper and more advanced than the stuff in the "Physics", "meta-" came to mean something like "beyond" -- with indeed a connotation of "X about X", but by no means always. "Metamathematics" is mathematics about mathematics, but "metapolitics" is theorizing about politics, not doing politics about politics. (The above may sound ridiculous, but it really is where this usage of "meta-" comes from.) I agree that it's weird to take "metaprogramming" to mean "discussion of things like office furniture, big monitors and text editors", and that "metaprogramming" already has a meaning and that that isn't it. But the problem isn't that "meta" can only mean "X about X"; that simply isn't true.
- FrankyHollywood 10y ago"Computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes" Edsger Dijkstra
- jaimebuelta 10y agoThis is quite a straw man argument. The points are a distorted version of reality... why people complain about their tools instead of programming? Well, tools are important... I like to wait less time to see my program compile and I want a good keyboard so I keep RSI under control. These are relevant parts of my profesional life that, yes, are not exactly programming... Sure, people like to argue about these things because everyone have an ass and an opinion about chair and non Swift developer don't have a lot to say about Swift, and sometimes too much... But this is pretty much a textbook example of a straw man argument...
- klagermkii 10y agoI will have a stronger opinion about chairs and keyboards not because I think they're more important, but because I have more experience with them. And that experience is far easier to gain. Most of the consequences of choosing a particular programming language or technique will only come out months or years later, and often those results will have a very muddy connection between cause and effect. I'm way less likely to go on a forum and talk confidently when I would have needed to do multiple projects taking years to have a definitive answer. On the other hand give me a keyboard for a day and I'll happily wade into an argument about it after typing a few thousand letters on it.
- _nalply 10y agoAnd I thought this post is about writing programs that write programs. Metaprogramming.
- al2o3cr 10y ago"When did the messenger become more important than the message?" About five minutes before complaining about how the message isn't important any more became more important than the message.
- Jtsummers 10y ago> Never mind that their job involves typing letters into a text file, something you could have done on CP/M back in '78. Gotta have that 40" monitor, it's essential, can't work without it. To insult a new hire by providing only a single 4:3 monitor? I can't work like this. I had a boss once that thought programmers just typed away for hours, how hard could it be? This portion is like that. Programming, well software engineering, is much more than that. I have a half-dozen spec documents to pull in from. I have databases to look at. I have log files to parse through. I have code to read and write. Yes, this is all primarily text. But it's not just typing. Using a single 15" 4:3 monitor is like trying to steer a submarine with the only knowledge coming in through the periscope. But you have to turn the whole sub to rotate the periscope. It's the extra monitors, or let me print off 5000 pages or so of text and bind them and keep them on my desk at all times. Probably more, I'm on several projects. And the bindings won't last. I need to see content on page 100 and 712 at the same time. Oh, and then I'll have to print out each revision unless they're provided with a good diff. Or don't let me do either, require me to keep way too much information in my head and let me fuck up the project. EDIT: That said, his other points may be valid. But I've never met the people that fit his description. I've "programmers" who don't program. I've worked with them. Well, I've worked, they've hung out. But the cafe stuffs and other things, I've never seen anyone that cared. Chairs, maybe, but he had a bad back so that was a valid concern. > Some of the best programmers I've ever worked with don't have twitter accounts. It's almost unthinkable, isn't it? How can they possibly be one of the top programmers in the world, building the most successful projects out there, without being seen to be doing it? You can write beautiful code, the best code in the world, but it doesn't mean a damn today if you didn't blog about your new standing desk. I also find this a little ironic, reading this metaprogrammers blog deriding metaprogrammers with a "follow me on twitter" link at the bottom.
- collyw 10y ago>I had a boss once that thought programmers just typed away for hours, how hard could it be Just look at the movies. "Hackers" always manage to break in to remote systems by typing lots into a terminal very fast. The more difficult the system, the faster they need to type. (Mr Robot has been a refreshing change to that stereotype).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- GoToRO 10y agoThere are things that you will understand only when you have become a very good programmer. What this article says is "I have no idea how that must be" together with "There are so-so programmers that imitate very good programmers without knowing why.". I agree with the last one, not with the first one. For example the more time you spend programming, the better you get but also the more important it becomes to have a good chair, desk, tools. Especially the chair, it is a health problem! Then there are the perks he complains about, like food. They say 20% of your energy is consumed by the brain. What you eat directly affects how good you think and how much you can produce with your brain. Almost all the perks I have seen at top companies are nothing more than a recognition that employees are more productive if you give them these perks. It's all about money.
- pyrale 10y agoI consider this article to be the über meta-troll. Writing a blog entry discussing about how the community discusses about things surrounding their jobs rather than actually doing it, rather than actually doing one's job is either a very clever pun, or very short-sighted. This entry also documents how one-liners can get a bit confusing.
- gorogue 10y agoI actually found the post to be mostly true - at least for me. It struck me on a personal level because I find myself talking about being an indie game developer. I have cool hardware, all the game programming books, and some interesting prototypes, but I still haven't shipped a game. Talking about it is just easier and more fun than actually doing the work.
- wtbob 10y ago> I've seen artists who demand the luxurious corner office, with the luxurious view, and then put paper over the windows to stop the light coming in. I've seen companies buy MacBook laptops for every employee, even though they're never taken away from the desks. Well, the artist probably has a Mac laptop, with the horrible glossy screen, which basically requires that there be no light in the room …
- dschiptsov 10y agoThe older term "blogrammer" seems better.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoI've yet to see any correlation at all between executive pampering - typically many orders of magnitude worse than hypothetical developer pampering - and productivity.
- kabdib 10y agoMy group at Microsoft was notorious for not spending money on hardware. I did some math. If the money they spent halved my build time (easily possible at the time, since we were on spinning rust and they wouldn't spring for SSDs "because everyone will want one, and then what?") then they could afford to buy me a new computer every couple of weeks, more often if you computed the $ lost from the average imputed load (of $500K/year) of an employee. Bean counters. Feh.
- dev360 10y agoThis happened to me at Citrix. I had to bring in more ram to put in the computer because it was just unbearable to run Visual Studio. Some places don't give a crap, you just throw more people at the problem.
- gaius 10y agoAt a previous employer, one of my colleagues needed a bigger HD. He spent months struggling to get it and ultimately gave up and made do. But I was wise to the ways of this company, and I also needed a bigger HD, so I simply requisitioned a whole new PC and it arrived the next day. Its about whatever makes the paperwork easier...
- fizixer 10y agoYou could rant all you wanted but why did you have to give a bad rep to the term 'metaprogramming.' I think what you described can adequately be called something like 'hipster programming'.
- turbo104 10y agoTLDR: Some things are more important than others, but it depends on the person and/or domain. I think a few of these items are a bit more than debating the unimportant. I don't personally feel like I need "the perfect" setup, however there are a few things that I think make me leaps and bounds more productive. Working on a few older platforms that you have to build locally can cause some machines to really bog down and chew up a ton of your development time - taking us back to the the old, "hardware is cheaper than programmers" concept that another commenter mentioned. There have been many productivity experts saying that in every field, having an extra monitor can give you huge efficiency gains. I find I got the most gains adding up to 3 monitors.. the 4th wasnt as much of a gain. I think this is domain dependent though. When working as the sole developer on small websites for clients as a side business, I really only ever use two monitors at most. Headphones, keyboards, and chairs I think are the most "diva" things to spend a bunch of time on. Yes, the chair has to be comfortable, the keyboard has to be accurate, and the headphones have to work for your work environment. However, like delivering software, sometimes good enough is better than perfect. Having an office diner of any form I think is a productivity play. If you are hungry, you are not at your best. If you have to figure out what you are going to go out and get you are taking more time - plan what to get, travel to get it - instead of just grabbing something quick across the office and eating it at your desk. I want to be productive. Not productive to the max, navigating through every single minuscule inefficiency, but making changes to get the most gain. Everyone has their preferences and friction points. If you are pissed off at your tools a good portion of the time, you probably aren't going to be as productive.
- vegancap 10y agoFor the record, I use Senheiser C500 headphones. They cost about £30, but the bass response is fantastic for an in-ear bud.
- oz 10y ago>You might have thought that metaprogramming meant macros, type introspection, that kind of thing. Nope, I'm hijacking the word for today: Not hijacking. Overloading. ;)