9 ms·
To clarify for all the other non HD-video nerds, this seems to be regarding DCP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Cinema_Package https://en.wikipedia.org/w
by contingencies 10y ago
To clarify for all the other non HD-video nerds, this seems to be regarding DCP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Cinema_Package https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Cinema_Package not HDCP:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content_Protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content... (which is already broken, and was itself the industry response to the breaking of DVD CSS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Scramble_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Scramble_System).
The use of DCP seems to be limited to very high resolution releases. HDCP is still what current era consumer hardware uses, and it's totally wide open.
As always with DRM, it's defective by design. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defective_by_Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defective_by_Design
If you can view it, you can copy it... it's just a matter of time, motivation, and desired quality.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoThe point of DRM is to make that time, motivation, and quality equation not make sense. Every day that a new videogame stays off Piratebay is an extra day of full revenue. I'm not defending DRM, but it's important to know one's enemy.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoI agree in principle, but I think the adage that "Every day that a new videogame stays off Piratebay is an extra day of full revenue" is a bit of a false equivalency.
- robocat 10y agoThere is almost a controlled experiment here (similar data to many economics papers). For each movie, copies are released over time and a correlation can be looked at between quality of rip, distribution by file sharing, and box office receipts.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThat would actually be an interesting study. The "problem" is that it would obviously show that the impact of torrenting is much less than one lost sale per download. And reflect that even the downloads that are lost sales are offset to some degree by the people who download to sample and then buy when they otherwise wouldn't have, and the free promotion from the people who downloaded it talking about it with other people etc. The result is that the likely "negative impact" would be small or could even be positive, which isn't the narrative Hollywood wants to spin. Because they actually want DRM for entirely different reasons than that, specifically because it allows them to control content delivery and thus prevent independent content from being displayed on equal footing with big studio content.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> The point of DRM is to make that time, motivation, and quality equation not make sense. Every day that a new videogame stays off Piratebay is an extra day of full revenue. This can't be true as written, as long as people expect it to show up there eventually. Every day it stays off piratebay is an extra day of revenue intermediate between full and "already out on piratebay" levels. The DRM works because the value of these things appears to be greatly time-sensitive -- most of the cost is already getting-it-right-away, which DRM can protect, rather than the fundamental timeless value of the product, which DRM can't protect.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- taneq 10y agoIs that true, though? I'd expect that the people who only download cracked games will wait for the game to be cracked and up for download, no matter how long that takes. The people who download games to trial them and then buy the ones they like will likewise wait until they can give it a shot before potentially wasting money. The last group, those who buy legit copies of games at or near release, are going to buy it no matter what.
- 2bitencryption 10y agoWhen it comes to watching movies, I will take the path of least resistance. Not even for moral or philosophical reasons; I'm just lazy. Netflix/Amazon/[streaming site] is easier than pirating is easier than buying a Bluray disk at a store, so that's the order I'll do things in if I want to see the film badly enough.
- badwolf 10y agoI don't even own a DVD/Bluray player. If I can't find it on a streaming site (whether subscription service like Netflix, or buying it, ala Amazon) Then... :-/ Hoist the Jolly Roger. It's frustrating wanting to give money for something, and not being able to.
- vocatus_gate 10y agoI have a friend who has an approach I like. He buys the Blu-Ray from Amazon, usually used if possible, then immediately goes and pirates it on to his home media server. When the disc arrives, he tosses it in a box that sits in the corner and never touches it again. This way he made a legal purchase and exchanged money, but still gets a DRM-free high quality copy to move around to his various devices.
- i336_ 10y agoThat's a really cool approach, but taking the time to rip the disc means you get the extras and other features that were on the disk, along with a significantly higher quality encode of the content. If the focus is on quantity and diversity, I can understand just getting a decent-bitrate MKV or MP4 of just the film, but it might be worth it to see if there are Blu-Ray rips of the media in question "around" before just grabbing what's out there; at the very least, complete (and perhaps even decrypted, since that's finicky) rips have reasonable value on private trackers. I'm guessing this sort of thing has probably already been taken into account.
- ekianjo 10y ago> a new videogame stays off Piratebay is an extra day of full revenue. Yes and now, You cannot say that people who pirate games are necessarily going to buy the game if it were not "free". That's the argument used by the industry to justify DRM and it makes no sense whatsoever since the market would be like 100 times bigger if you calculate things this way. It would not.
- nazka 10y agoIt's a great idea, but I don't know if it's like that for video games though. They may earn more money, but when they fail to code a proper backend and the launch breaks their system, they lose even more. Like for the last SimCity.
- _pius 10y agoThe use of DCP seems to be limited to very high resolution releases. The DCP is just a digital print (what movie theaters play for digital releases instead of the reels of film that go with analog releases). It's not really about resolution per se, it's just a term for the whole package that the theater gets.
- e12e 10y agoTo add to this - a typical cinema release is a pretty big file - frame-by-frame encoded as jpg2000 in 4k. Often shipped on hard drives, or downloaded via dedicated fiber lines. They key material is distributed separately, and allows for fine-grained control of play back (eg time of day - to the point that if a screening is sufficiently delayed, it may sometimes have to be cancelled if a new key can't be acquired in time...). This all works due to proprietary hardware - the modifications to the 4k cinema projectors that enable decryption almost at the lens/imaging chip can cost as much as the projector itself, doubling the price of the projector (last I heard from around 15k to 30k USD). With a more sane key distribution (no master keys in equipment, like with dvds) - I don't believe DCP is likely to be cracked in the same sense CSS was: probably the more likely scenario is that some insider leak some of the distributors private keys which would allow certain releases to be cracked - but would likely also trigger key roll over. Also worth nothing that the DCP format is pretty nice, has optional encryption - and you can make your own. With the right contacts you can view your own footage on on a cinema screen :-) See eg: http://www.knuterikevensen.com/?p=2559 http://www.knuterikevensen.com/?p=2559
- ddt_Osprey 10y agoa typical cinema release is a pretty big file - frame-by-frame encoded as jpg2000 in 4k. Often shipped on hard drives, or downloaded via dedicated fiber lines. This is not a show stopper. All you need is one unlocked copy to drop in the open, and then everyone can work on it, and get it packed up in a more reasonable format. This all works due to proprietary hardware - the modifications to the 4k cinema projectors that enable decryption almost at the lens/imaging chip can cost as much as the projector itself, doubling the price of the projector (last I heard from around 15k to 30k USD). So, yeah, that's great, but the only level of piracy that could deter is the pixel-perfect variety. A motivated individual with a comparable budget could probably optically extract a high quality duplicate with an expensive digital video camera (and perhaps even a beam splitter), and pull signal from the speaker transducers with professional audio recording equipment. There'd be no real need to tamper with proprietary hardware or intrude on the chasis of the projector. With reasonable equipment, it's likely that a person could reproduce a re-recording of a movie that is very-nearly indistinguishable from the factory source, perhaps except for negligible artifacts that might irritate only the holiest of true believers.
- oldmanjay 10y agoI find it amusing that after all these decades people are still willing to claim some sort of moral high ground in defense of their desire for entertainment.
- mickronome 10y agoFilmmakers themselves talk about movies being culture as well as entertainment, and without piracy, being part of contemporary culture become (even more) a matter of your disposable income. So regardless if it is moral or not ( what is moral is not easily established in a global context ) we can ask if piracy does more good than bad for society ? Is there an even better alternative ? In the end, copyright is based on laws created by governements as trade agreements, rarely involving the voting public when it's not a dictator or monarch making the rules. In effect copyright is a matter of law, not moral, and sometimed the law is not moral. In this case, I stay my judgement as it can only cloud the real issues. Personally I think everybody who is not an adult, without a job or a home should by default be allowed free access to anything we call culture. Being part of society is - which everyone should be - is down to having a shared context. The so called entertainment is a major part of this, and without access to it you become an 'other', the outsider. Moral or not.
- zizee 10y agoSome people believe that copyright infringement is a morally acceptable response to copyright terms changing from limited to effectively infinite duration.
- rrrazdan 10y agoCopyright on a song or book is like ownership. Imagine a scenario where you mould from clay an amazing aesthetically pleasing shape. Do you think that it should be taken from you after a set time period?
- hx87 10y agoNo it isn't like ownership, because I can make a perfect copy without taking away yours. After 3 years or so showing off your clay sculpture and making money from it, why should I be able to make copies freely?
- legulere 10y ago> If you can view it, you can copy it... it's just a matter of time, motivation, and desired quality. And exactly the time and motivation needed is why DRM can work in the end. Modern DRM schemes like AACS employ methods to change keys for new works. So when crackers find a key that allows them to circumvent the DRM scheme they can't publish it or it would soon get useless and they would have to do the work to extract a key again. This is probably what we're seeing here. This means that for consumers the DRM stays effective. They can't do copies of things they legally bought.
- ddt_Osprey 10y agoModern DRM schemes like AACS employ methods to change keys for new works. So when crackers find a key that allows them to circumvent the DRM scheme they can't publish it or it would soon get useless and they would have to do the work to extract a key again. Okay, just think about this for a minute. Who would EVER care about a cipher key, when YOU STILL NEED TO EXPOSE THE RAW PIXEL RASTER, AND AUDIO CHANNELS TO THE END USER, IN ORDER FOR ANYTHING TO BE VALUABLE AT ALL? Users will always eventually get the whole thing in the clear, in straight-up plain text somehow, eventually anyway. And all anyone needs is a buffer big enough to capture it, and it's trivial to assemble one. You need to be able to watch a movie with the naked eye, and hear the sound with your ears. That's how movies work. It's trivial to capture the raw data, and people have been living with NTSC quality picture and sound for decades. This is not about perfectly matching the SHA256 hashes of the original MPEG artifacts. People just want a copy, and it's easy to skim one, somehow, one way (cracking) or another (brute force direct copies of the image frames and pulse code samples, at the signal source).
- jonah 10y agoYes, of course, but it's a lossy copy since you're de-compressing and then re-compressing the content. (At 4k is that as important? I dunno, I'm not a movie fanatic.)
- ddt_Osprey 10y agoI would not say a brute force copy must be necessarily lossy by default. In theory, if the picture is revealed on a display, upon which the full pixel raster can be distinguished for every frame (in real time or slower), an optical capture may be performed, which preserves the original fidelity of the image, and one need not recompress as lossy for peers who have the capacity to receive the full duplicate. All images are eventually revealed optically somehow. Such images may be captured directly, and corrected and restored according to original quality, if you have good video equipment. Only one good copy needs to make it into the open, and then the cat's out of the bag.
- Matthias247 10y agoI don't know DCP, but from reading wikipedia it's something different than HDCP: HDCP is encryption during transmission (like SSL), e.g. encryption while transferring the movie data through the HDMI cable. It is not used for encrypting data on a storage medium (like CSS, and apparently also DCP are).
- Aissen 10y agoRegarding HDCP, while 1.x is currently wide open, I'm not aware of any "crack" of HDCP 2.2, the currently required version for 4k content. There might have been keys leaked, but key extraction is only getting harder, with devices embedding keys deeper into the chipsets, with software/hardware video paths inaccessible from traditional OSes, etc. Also, I would be surprised their isn't a watermark in there that will point to the cinema who leaked the version.
- maccard 10y ago> As always with DRM, it's defective by design. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defective_by_Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defective_by_Design It depends on what the desired outcome of the DRM is. A prime example of effective DRM is Denuvo [0]. Loosely speaking, there are two main groups of people who pirate games - those who would buy it otherwise, and those who wouldn't. There's not much you can do about the latter group, so they're not really worth considering. The former group however are the potential lost sales. The sales for a AAA video game usually peak on release or very shortly after, and fall off a cliff very quickly., If your DRM system manages to keep a crack for your game from being leaked for the first few weeks of its life, you will capture many of the people who fall into the "might buy your game" category. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denuvo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denuvo
- annnnd 10y agoThe DRM for games is altogether another beast than DRM for movies or audio. Games are interactive so while cracking them should in theory always be possible (unless they are server based), the cracked version represents a possible threat to the users. Did really someone crack the software for the fun of it or is it malware? With movies such concerns are limited to exploiting bugs in movie players, so attack surface is much lower. Also, all one needs to do is capture the output and write it to file. The "hack" is quite trivial with proper equipment.