3 ms·
It's true that ego depletion has a question mark over it these days. It's also true that Sierra's conclusion has value: > ...I've created interactive marketin
by throwanem 10y ago
It's true that ego depletion has a question mark over it these days.
It's also true that Sierra's conclusion has value:
> ...I've created interactive marketing games, gamified sites (before it was called that), and dozens of other projects carefully, artfully, scientifically designed to slurp (gulp) cognitive resources for... very little that was "worth it". Did people willingly choose to engage with them? Of course. And by "of course" I mean, not really, no. Not according to psychology, neuroscience, and behavioral economics research of the past 50 years. They were nudged/seduced/tricked. And I was pretty good at it. I am so very, very sorry.
> My goal for Serious Pony is to help all of us take better care of our users. Not just while they are interacting with our app, site, product, but after. Not just because they are our users, but because they are people.
...nah, it'll never catch on. Where's the value prop here?
- sitkack 10y agoI can't use Adobe products for any serious amount of time, they induce rage followed by narcolepsy. I give the theory some credence, but I wouldn't call it "ego depletion". The mechanism I think consumes glucose in the brain 'the fucks' and once exhausted can't be replenished without rest.
- nnq 10y agoHa! Same for me. Even hated the news of them buying Fireworks... good insight as they eventually killed it. But once you learn the keyboard shortcuts and start to think in terms of "what group of things would I want to manipulate / apply the same effect / transformation, to all at the same time" instead of "how things make logical sense to be grouped together", and also "what tasks are more common for real-life professionals using this program" instead of "where would that option make sense to be based on what it actually does". There are 2 UX/I games to play: (1) improve the UXI for current professional users that you know will pay for your product, and rely on professional network effects for growth, and (2) improve the UXI for new users, optimizing for adoptions, but accept that lots of the new users will never be "professional" users, will never pay a lot of money for it, and some of their feature requests will be expensive to develop but will result in no increased profit. Hint: Adobe is obviously playing game #1 and they are also slaves to their past mistakes, and on top of that their current user base includes a huge number of "artsy, not so logical, and profoundly change-averse" users. Hence all their products can only induce rage and/or mind-numbness in people like us :)
- sitkack 10y agoThere are two horrible flaws with Adobe products 1) the undo buffer only undoes actions against the media. The application UI has just as much or more state in it. I need undo to also work against settings and UI placement. 2) they expose way too much. The feature set that is visible isn't tuned to the needs of most users. Almost everyone needs to constantly dig through menus. The UI should be task specific and configurable on a per project basis.
- closed 10y agoInterestingly, the glucose idea is one that is often thrown around with "ego depletion", but there are several problems with it. If the replicability issues are set aside, there are many articles which suggest people's beliefs about "ego depletion" change the observed effects (e.g. [1]). More importantly, there's good reason to believe that early studies in support of the glucose hypothesis did not make sense [2]. 1: http://pss.sagepub.com/lookup/doi/10.1177/0956797610384745 http://pss.sagepub.com/lookup/doi/10.1177/0956797610384745 2: Slate article, but mentions some key studies, http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story/2016/03/ego_depletion_an_influential_theory_in_psychology_may_have_just_been_debunked.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story...
- sitkack 10y agoI don't say this with a basis in evidence, only how my brain feels after attention/focus overload. It could very well be something else. The feeling is analogous to using up all the ATP in your muscles.