4 ms·
Next, go after the public colleges? Other than brand, do they do a better job? Spend more than 30% of income on actual educational expenses (like IIT does)? I d
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Next, go after the public colleges? Other than brand, do they do a better job? Spend more than 30% of income on actual educational expenses (like IIT does)? I doubt it.
{edit}
Seems like US Universities are about 1:1 faculty vs staff. Up from 2:1 40 years ago.
- qaq 10y agoGiven the continuous grows of administrative personal and cutting of faculty positions the quality of the job they do is deteriorating quickly.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoHow about 'fully funding public colleges' instead so that kids don't have to go into crippling debt to go there.
- logfromblammo 10y agoJudging by history, this would be seen as a license to artificially inflate costs, such that the university system would become a machine for extracting money from the public treasury and placing it into private hands. You must have some feedback control, wherein the amount of public funding is dependent upon some objective criterion that measures the extent to which the public college provides a useful service to the public. For instance, give the college a percentage (that decays exponentially) of the income taxes collected from their alumni. Schools that focus on teaching the knowledge and skills that actually make students employable would then be able to more freely provide tuition discounts to students, expecting that the recurring revenue stream after graduation would make up for the lesser amount collected up front. They all hound their alumni for money all the time, anyway.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoJudging from history, cheap colleges in the post-war decades worked just fine for the boomers.
- ccallebs 10y agoThere were fewer students, fewer colleges, and lower enrollment rates. A big reason why college costs have risen is due to the artificial demand created by subsidized loans.
- logfromblammo 10y agoJust as a gas will expand to fill its containing vessel, costs tend to grow to meet the available budget. If 100% of the university operating budget for student instruction is guaranteed by the state, you might be surprised at how often the seats in the lecture halls need to be replaced. Rather than being reupholstered after 10 and 15 years, and replaced after 20, they are replaced every 5 years. The profitable business moves from instruction to instruction support services. Maybe the dean is part owner of a company that specializes in lecture hall seat installation, or in a landscaping company so large it can only handle entire zoos, universities, and corporate office parks. Money without a vigilant guardian eventually gets taken. This is why pouring more stupid government money into anything should be done with extreme caution, because it often invites corruption, in order to get a space at the trough. College costs have risen because they could rise. The subsidized loans don't empower the students; they just enrich those with the power to capture the subsidy. The money would have been far better spent on building out new universities, or increasing the student instruction capacity of existing universities. That would have driven down student costs--rather than ensuring that any rising costs could always be paid by debt--and the stupid government money would have been flowing to those younger academics who are now perpetually wandering in tenureless adjunctland.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y ago> Money without a vigilant guardian This is called the "board of regents" and "the state legislature."
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoFewer taxpayers too and a much-lower per capita GDP.
- nostrebored 10y agoYou're mistaking the purpose of most public colleges -- it is not to educate students, but this is a service that they provide. ITT on the other hand, is only attempting to teach.
- VLM 10y agoI'm not sure the money is there to chase. I got an associates from a "public county tech", basically a public non-profit variant of the general ITT model, and it was about 1/10th ITT price, even today. The associates degree was worthless in the market by itself, but 56 of the 64 credit did transfer because they worked very hard with the state uni system and one of the local private colleges and accreditation boards. If you take the ITT story, make the teachers actually teach to the accredited standard such that credit transfers "work", and cut the price 90%, it's not that bad of a deal. With tuition at $3K or so per semester, its hard to accumulate $50K in ITT style loans at a "public county tech" when a semester of school takes about half a year of part time employment at minimum wage... I would imagine there are places to live without "public county tech" schools, but without educational institutions and other than importing them from us, where do you get your welders and electrician apprentices and similar?