3 ms·
Besides the sanctity of old people as a reliable voting block, why is age discrimination a problem? If companies are stupid enough to not hire good candidates,
by koolba 10y ago
Besides the sanctity of old people as a reliable voting block, why is age discrimination a problem? If companies are stupid enough to not hire good candidates, or under pay the ones they do hire, then they'll lose out against the better companies that don't do those things.
Plus, it's my understanding[1] that it's not discrimination to refuse to hire someone for being "too young" or "too inexperienced". How is that not discrimination if the bright eyed youngster is equally qualified?
[1]: If there's someone with the appropriate legal background, please correct me if I'm wrong.
- paulrosenzweig 10y agoI think your argument that discriminatory companies will lose out to companies willing to hire more broadly is flawed for a few reasons: 1. Markets are not perfectly efficient. If Apple decided not to hire female engineers they wouldn't immediately be overtaken by another company that can use access to a larger labor pool as a decisive advantage. Even if this would be a disadvantage because other companies would hire women, they might still win due to other advantages. 2. Often the same prejudice that affects hiring is held by the customers. If a restaurant in a racist community refuses to hire minorty workers, they might do better than other restaurants. This makes it even more important to enforce fair hiring practices judicially.
- michaelt 10y agowhy is age discrimination a problem? I for one expect to become old at some point.
- koolba 10y ago> I for one expect to become old at some point. So what? You're scared people won't think you can keep up with those young whippersnappers so you need the government to step in? Those same rules would be the ones that held you back when you were younger because companies would be forced to hire, or not fire, incompetent old people. Or is this like a tiered system you feel you've paid your dues, having passed that stage of your life where you're classified as "young", and now want to reap the rewards the old people have been dangling in front of you?
- lsiebert 10y agoDiscrimination law doesn't protect incompetent people, Incompetence is always a reason to fire someone, and inability to do the job is always a reason to not hire someone. It only protects competent people from incompetent racist, agist, sexist or other discriminatory idiots.
- koolba 10y ago> Discrimination law doesn't protect incompetent people, Incompetence is always a reason to fire someone, and inability to do the job is always a reason to not hire someone. Sure they do. The threat of a discrimination lawsuit has a non-zero price tag and documenting evidence of incompetence, to present if you do get sued, is an added cost as well. > It only protects competent people from incompetent racist, agist, sexist or other discriminatory idiots. And it increases the overall cost of everything for the vast majority of us that aren't racist, ageist, sexist or other discriminatory idiots.
- lsiebert 10y agoif you believe the vast majority of people don't ever discriminate, then, setting aside the issue of systemic discrimination, by all means cite some studies to that effect. I can cite studies that show significant differences for gendered names, for african american names, and, just because this is aging we are talking about here, here's just one study on job applicants of different ages https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10724770 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10724770 That's not to mention things like implicit association tests that show evidence of unconscious bias. https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/ https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/
- kasey_junk 10y agoAge discrimination laws (or really ant discrimination laws) are not about being fired or not hired because of incompetence or inability. Companies are perfectly free to not hire someone because they can't do the work.
- 10y ago
- lsiebert 10y agoMarket forces work with rational actors, assuming the difference between the rational act and the irrational act are large enough. Discrimination is inherently irrational, but it's pernicious because the effects on the company aren't nearly as big as the effects on the discriminated person. And in some cases, discrimination may be beneficial to the bottom line if every company does it, like redlining in the 1960's or high interest rates for black people in the 2000's. As to why it's a problem? Because we want everyone to get a fair deal. If you need an argument beyond the moral one, or the one about what sort of country do you want to live in, how about because economic growth at the macro level tends to increase when barriers to employment, capital and other resources are decreased. Since we know that discrimination is irrational, laws aimed at preventing discrimination as a barrier to employment and capital serve to increase economic prosperity at the cost of reducing what you correctly characterise as stupid behavior.
- WhitneyLand 10y ago>why is age discrimination a problem? 1). Same thing that's wrong with racial discrimination and LGBT discrimination, etc. 2). It's illegal. 3). It's stupid and hurts our economy by making it less efficient. 4). Reverse age discrimination: This is wrong and inefficient also, but unfortunately legal. If you face this it's highly annoying but there are strategies to work around it. It might require changing jobs but you can usually find someone who appreciates your talent if it is truly something special.
- koolba 10y ago> 1). Same thing that's wrong with racial discrimination and LGBT discrimination, etc. Honestly I think those laws are all bullshit too. If people want to be racist assholes they're going to do it anyway and all this does is create work for lawyers. Vote with your minds and wallets and go work for places that treat people fairly and shop at places that do the same. > 2). It's illegal. That's not a valid reason as to whether something is a problem. At one point it was illegal for woman and blacks to vote, did that make it "good" to have those laws? > 3). It's stupid and hurts our economy by making it less efficient. The government's track record of making anything more efficient through legislation is effectively zero. > 4). Reverse age discrimination: This is wrong and inefficient also, but unfortunately legal. If you face this it's highly annoying but there are strategies to work around it. It might require changing jobs but you can usually find someone who appreciates your talent if it is truly something special. If that's acceptable remediation for young people faced with the same issue in reverse, why do those other classes you mention need special treatment? Why can't gays, minorities, and old people "work around it"?
- kasey_junk 10y agoOur experience with other forms of discrimination show that the markets do not correct this way.
- pipio21 10y ago"why is age discrimination a problem?" In my opinion, people get used to everything, bad times and good times. People that have been fortunate enough become entitled to it and believe the world needs to sustain their lifestyle forever, if necessary by law. I was extremely lucky in my twenties and could earn as much as an experienced professional at the end of his career. I was educated, young and brilliant,tall and attractive, traveled person who speak several languages and hard working who dominated the new technologies. This was something like a dream, not possible before technology made it a reality for me to compete with old people. You simply get used to the lifestyle and believe it is normal. But as you get older of course if companies could replace you with young people, they will. This fact that you loved when you were young and benefited you, now looks like a treat to your lifestyle. I continue being lucky(and I have my own business), but I have seen people make assumptions about their luck being eternal, with bad consequences. Like football players or film actors that could earn tens of millions of dollars in a year. Instead of realizing how lucky they have been they start believing they deserve it. When they stop playing sports or a famous actress is replaced with someone younger, they get depressed, become drug or alcohol addicts...
- skywhopper 10y agoFor the same other forms of hiring discrimination are a problem. The market doesn't solve every problem. For groups that are significant minorities within a candidate population, discrimination in hiring is unlikely to lead to a severe enough shortage of good workers to outweigh the unthinking unfairness of explicit or implicit discrimination. Further, if _no_ companies are hiring a certain group of people, then there will be no impact at all. In any case, it's morally wrong, regardless of market impact. Refusing to hire people who are "too young" is also a problem, but it's far, far less common. Discrimination against qualified candidates for being "too old" is extremely common. Typically we would want to focus on the bigger problems first, but obviously attempts to bring age discrimination problems to light will probably help at both ends of the spectrum.
- WalterBright 10y agoI don't want to work for someone who doesn't want me. Why should I give my valuable time and expertise to make someone who doesn't like me rich? No way.