9 ms·
For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan
- jkot 10y agoI think most people would have very short retirement in Manhattan. They would run out of savings.
- pavlov 10y agoAlso, fitting most people on a small island is difficult.
- yodsanklai 10y agoActually, I've always wondered how they manage to pay their bills. Of course, there are tons of super wealthy people in Manhattan, but there are also many elderlies that don't look particularly well-off. I suspect they've owned their apartment for a long time, or that they pay little rent. Maybe they receive social benefits from the city...
- imgabe 10y agoRent control is probably a big part of it.
- sotojuan 10y agoAs imgabe said, a lot of older families (both in age and amount of time living in Manhattan), at least in the Upper West Side, have rent control, are in low income housing, or something similar. If you ever walk around the Upper West Side, farther away from the park, you'll see a ton big, tall apartment complexes. Huge ones with hundreds of families, if not more. I doubt everyone there makes the mid or high $100ks it takes to rent an apartment there now as a new resident.
- yodsanklai 10y agoActually, a friend of mine lives in such a building. His building is in very poor condition (various problems such as bed bugs infestation, defective heater...). Most tenants there prefer to keep a low profile and don't complain to the landlord. The rent is not controlled, but pretty low ($600 for a small crappy room with shared bathroom). It seems most tenants are middle-aged hispanics. No retired people there.
- sotojuan 10y agoAh interesting. Yeah, they never looked like nice buildings to me. I always wondered who lived there.
- awareBrah 10y agoCan someone explain to me, why this exists. How come, as a new resident I need to pay 3x the amount of rent compared to someone who has been there for a while. As a landlord wouldn't I be mad that the going rate is much higher? Can someone explain to me as I've never understood how come this happens or why it is the default. Why not just have free market? Forgive if it's obvious, I would love a lay-mans explanation
- tacostakohashi 10y agoBecause politics. Yes, the landlord will be mad, but for every one of them there are dozens of happy tenants. The tenants getting a preferential rate will live there and vote/lobby to protect the system for generations. The new guy paying 3x probably came from elsewhere, and will return there shortly.
- rincebrain 10y agoRent control, as it exists in NYC, is a damper on how fast rent can rise (both when you're in a lease, and during vacancies of a property between tenants), for people and properties whose income/rent are below certain thresholds where the government considers them to be either paying for or capable of paying for luxury apartments. Rent control lets you have some reasonable expectation that you can plan expenses for more than a single lease term, as well as attempting to limit how much damage to the economics of the surrounding area real estate prices are going to do (it's a commodity that is hard to increase the supply of in any great quantity, and demand far outstrips supply...this probably would eventually stabilize, but it'd be quite messy in between, and probably not in a net positive way for the city). Absent rent control, the lower bound of prices would go up, the ceiling would not go down.
- hueving 10y ago>Absent rent control, the lower bound of prices would go up, the ceiling would not go down. Pretty vapid statement. The ceiling is whatever the arbitrary asking price is for something overlooking central park on the 100th floor of some high rise. Nobody cares about the ceiling. The question is what does it do to the market price in general for a specific size apartment. It will cause a price decline because so many more apartments will actually be on the market. The current price is where supply is meeting demand so if you increase the supply the price will decline. Of course it will screw up the people on rent control since they likely won't be able to afford it.
- Spooky23 10y agoRent control. My great aunt paid something like $180/month for her apartment when she died in 2003. She had lived there since circa 1940 and raised 6 kids in it! The key is to have a support network so that you can remain in your home. Nursing homes and homecare in NYC are a horror show for a variety of reasons.
- sndean 10y agoOr, I wonder, could their running out of money keep them working (in some small capacity, part-time, etc.)? And if they keep working in some small way, does that allow them to avoid the rapid decline in life expectancy that normally follows retirement? http://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/news/20051020/early-retirement-early-death http://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/news/20051020/early-retir...
- smacktoward 10y agoYou're looking down this telescope from the wrong end. It's not that living in Manhattan itself somehow extends your life, it's that only very wealthy people can afford to live in Manhattan -- especially in retirement, when most people are living on a fixed income. And in American society, having great wealth means you also have access to things like high-quality food, great medical care, assistive technologies, all of which are things that really can extend your life. So if Manhattan suddenly became affordable and hordes of ordinary retirees moved in there, you wouldn't see all those ordinary retirees suddenly start living longer, you'd see the average life expectancy for retired Manhattanites drop as the crappy food and medical care the proles get drag the numbers down.
- msandford 10y agoArticle might as well be titled "to live long, be rich" How they managed to completely overlook the "hidden" confounding of being very wealthy and retiring in Manhattan is rather impressive.
- Chinjut 10y agoThe article isn't making any claims about retiring to Manhattan causing increased lifespan. It isn't even intended as a scientific article at all. I suspect many here only read the headline? It's one man's personal essay on their decision to retire to Manhattan and their enjoyment of it. [Tl;dr: The use of "long life" in the title (probably not even chosen by the author) is figurative, not literal.]
- dwaltrip 10y agoIt's a lifestyle piece, not a societal analysis.
- donretag 10y agoYou are forgetting the hundreds of thousands that have a rent controlled/stabilized apartment.
- otoburb 10y ago
- brooklyndude 10y agoThe actual life expectancy in NYC is actually not too bad. > New York City's life expectancy rate has increased by three years since 2001, far greater than the nationwide increase of nearly 1.8 years over the same period. https://www.mikebloomberg.com/news/life-expectancy-for-new-yorkers-surpasses-all-time-high/ https://www.mikebloomberg.com/news/life-expectancy-for-new-y...
- yodsanklai 10y agoI used to live in upper west side and some of the delis there looked like retirement homes at times. I loved the diversity of cultures and generations there. Unfortunately, not everyone is wealthy enough to retire there. Another place where I was surprised to see lots of elderlies (many more than in Manhattan) was Hong Kong. Many retired men hanging out in traditional restaurants.
- parasitius 10y agoHK is kind of an odd example, though, because it is a city-country. It's not like you have a "Florida" to go off to when you are old. You're either in HK itself or in a foreign country (ESPECIALLY China)
- trungonnews 10y agoDo they live longer because they walk around more often in Manhattan?
- cperciva 10y agoThat's probably part of it. Another factor might be that you can't retire in Manhattan if you're poor.
- yodsanklai 10y agoMaybe because they have fun doing all kind of things that keep them going. I remember a friend of mine whose roommate was 60. She told me that 60 in NYC is like 40 somewhere else.
- SmellTheGlove 10y agoThey live longer because you need money to live in Manhattan, and socioeconomic status is correlated with life expectancy!
- sjg007 10y agoThat's part of it.
- jonathanedwards 10y agoMost notable for me is when I go out to a restaurant in Manhattan I see many tables full of grown ups and seniors having lively discussions. In SF it's like that Star Trek episode where a virus kills off all the adults and leaves only children.
- electic 10y ago...kills off all the adults and leaves children at the dinner table on their cell phones.
- _delirium 10y agoSouthern California is a lot more age-balanced in that respect than the SF Bay Area. Depends a lot on where you go, but plenty of places in L.A. and San Diego are full of older people. Especially certain times of day, e.g. breakfast at any diner is mostly older people.
- raldi 10y agoThe data disagrees with your assessment. Population by age range, SF vs LA: 20-24: 3.8% / 8.1% 25-34: 21.5% / 18.3% 35-44: 16.3% / 15.8% 45-54: 14.0% / 11.6% 55-64: 12.4% / 7.0% 65+: 15.2% / 9.7% SF vs SD: 20-24: 3.8% / 9.0% 25-34: 21.5% / 17.7% 35-44: 16.3% / 16.2% 45-54: 14.0% / 12.1% 55-64: 12.4% / 7.0% 65+: 15.2% / 10.5%
- rak00n 10y agoThat means a recent grad in San Francisco will have a harder time dating girls around his age and dating pool will increase as he approaches 34.
- raldi 10y agoThis smells to me like confirmation bias. The actual demographic data shows SF skews older than Manhattan: Population by age range, SF vs Manhattan: 20-24: 3.8% / 7.4% 25-34: 21.5% / 22.7% 35-44: 16.3% / 14.6% 45-54: 14.0% / 12.8% 55-64: 12.4% / 11.4% 65+: 15.2% / 14.4%
- danso 10y agoI was pretty depressed about leaving Manhattan and at the thought that if I ever came back, I wouldn't be as young as I was or have as many friends (many have also left to start families elsewhere). Reading this essay reminded me of all the days I could walk around for hours by myself, not knowing a single person or expecting to meet anyone I made eye contact with ever again, but still enjoying myself just the same. If I'm at that age where most of my close friends and family have passed and I have the money, I would definitely love to live my last days in Manhattan. edit: Another characteristic of New York is the rate of change. Construction is never finished. I still keep in touch with my roommate on FB and she's constantly posting photos of decades-old restaurants and businesses closing shop, and she's been in the apartment for almost 30 years. I'd have that same disappointment/outrage when my favorite places shut down but -- as long as they aren't replaced by sterile condos -- I've loved the variety of new stuff that came in their stead. Living in NY definitely makes you realize that nothing is forever and just about everything can be forgotten or replaced, and you learn to be at peace with it.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> all the days I could walk around for hours by myself, not knowing a single person or expecting to meet anyone I made eye contact with ever again, but still enjoying myself just the same. This is one of the things I love best about the city. If I want to be alone, but out in public, I can be. I don't have to worry about running into some acquaintance and having to make small-talk when all I want to do is go for an urban nature-walk.
- dagw 10y agoI've very recently moved from the city to the suburbs and I've probably spent more time making small talk with my neighbors in the past 10 days than I've spent making small talk with my neighbors in the 10 preceding years, despite the fact that then number of people who could be considered my 'neighbors' has dropped by an order of magnitude. I am really not too sure how I feel about this.
- omilu 10y ago
- Jack000 10y agoAs a tourist my immediate impression is that the infrastructure is quite old compared to other world cities (why are the subways so hot?) and the touristy areas are a lot dirtier than I would have expected. There are also some NY-isms that I haven't seen in other American cities (terror alert levels, garbage bags piled up on sidewalks, ubiquitous taxies, tourists literally everywhere) I like how it's basically a microcosm of the entire world, and you can reach all of it without a car, but I'm not sure it's worth the inconveniences plus 3x cost of living.
- rayiner 10y agoNew York had one of the first subway systems in the world. It's not air conditioned because they didn't have AC at the turn of the 20th century. The street grid was also designed without alleys, hence the trash bags.
- davidf18 10y agoUpper West Sider here: Subway cars of course have AC. Older cars sometimes break AC but the newer ones have backup compressors so that doesn't happen. I do think they could at least have some high speed fans in parts of the subway stations, esp. for the elderly who don't tolerate heat as well as others.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoNew York City is a great place to be old and either healthy or rich. Otherwise, you run into problems not addressed in the article - such as the tremendous lack of handicapped access in the subways. We lived at 145th on the ABCD line. There's precisely one escalator that takes you from the lowest platform to the mezzanine, skipping the mid-level platform in between. Then there are stairs to get to street-level. There are no elevators. So when my father, in his 70s, came to visit us, he had a hell of a time getting down the stairs. We ended up specifically planning trips so that we would arrive on the lower platform, so we could take the escalator. All the walking does have health benefits, but if you're not capable of it, you better live near some accessible stations, or you end up being reliant on cars and access-a-ride (which, granted, I know nothing about - maybe it's fantastic.) Having typed all that, I'd rather be old and feeble here than, say, in Dallas, where I have to drive, until I'm no longer able to, and then have to rely on others for transportation. I'd gladly take a 20-minute journey down a stairwell that takes others 20 seconds for the freedom it would afford me.
- susan_hall 10y agoAbout this: "Certain Manhattan neighborhoods (I live in one on the Upper West Side) have already achieved NORC (“naturally occurring retirement community”) status." I also live on the Upper West Side. What surprises me is that everyone my building appears to be under 40, certainly everyone is under 50. It reminds me of when I lived in Brooklyn. But I expected it in Brooklyn. I didn't expect such a youthful building on the Upper West Side.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoSame here, for the most part - but I live in a coop, and I fully expect that 90% of its residents plan on retiring either in their current apartment, or moving to a slightly cheaper place and subletting their current apartment to pay for the rent. The neighbors across from us bought two units over two decades ago, and joined them. They're a couple with two teenaged kids, and what is almost certainly a 3-bedroom apartment that will likely be paid off by the time the kids go off to college. I envy their awesome position :P
- cmurf 10y agoHaving lived there, I always thought the same thing. The gotchas though... For one it's a filthy city, really. Noise, light, and air pollution. Piles of older buildings still use heating oil to operate their boilers, the soot gets everywhere. Blow your nose, it comes out gray. But OK, OK, no place is perfect. I think the biggest problem is on what sort of retirement plan does someone move to NYC, Manhattan in particular, and buy or rent a place for maybe 20 years? It's like...um?
- mahyarm 10y agoMany old people downsize to a condo because: 1. The kids are out and the house is too big for them. 2. They are usually one floor units and have an elevator. 3. They don't have to maintain nearly as many things. And a place with a metro is good if you can't drive any more.
- cmurf 10y agoI get all of the other logistical arguments why Manhattan works well for old people, I've seen that first hand. But a 1 BR condo in Manhattan is in the $3500-$4000/month range. What sized house is that they're downsizing from? Because if it's in Colorado, that's a 5BR 4000+ square foot house. If it's Tennessee, Missouri, Georgia, you've got that on a dozen acres, with a guest house, a barn, and horses, and staff. Median retirement income in the U.S. is ~$31k per year. So again, they're doing this how? Great idea if you're old and reasonably wealthy. This is not something the typical old fart is going to be doing for retirement.
- almostApatriot1 10y agoThere are a lot of mentality ill elderly people in NYC, and unfortunately, many seem to be forgotten and left to their own devices. The city can definitely be very taxing on the mind.
- agentgt 10y agoMy parents are in just now in the process of retiring. They have an apartment in NYC and a house in an expensive suburb in Boston. One of the reasons why they are going to have to stay in NYC before moving for some time is to continue to make additional money (ironically). They just don't have enough money yet to retire the way they want and/or not ready to retire. They just don't want live in the South despite my some family members urges to. From visiting NYC and having family live there I would gander that there are three groups of retirees. 1. The super wealthy that probably have another mansion somewhere else and generally were born into money. 2. The rise the corporate ladder but in debt most of their lives 1980's yuppies (not born into money but have the ambition) 3. The never left the city born and raised and probably have family owned businesses/property. My parents coming from absolutely zero money are from the second group. After growing up in "privileged" areas in the ugliest smallest house in the neighborhood with working parents I can observationally say it is amazing how many people that are wealthy that can retire that probably didn't really earn their wealth or at least were significantly aided. There are a lot of trust fund retirees all over and there are a lot of retirees that want to retire like them. I'm not saying I know for sure the author had/has the silver spoon in his mouth and thinks everyone can afford NYC (group 1)... but simple googling of his name certainly paints a picture of that (his father was a medical doctor and he went to Harvard... maybe scholarship but I doubt it).
- JDiculous 10y agoYou need to be rich or have a rent-subsidized apartment to retire in Manhattan. I love Manhattan. I've lived here for 4 years. But I'd never consider retiring here unless I was rich enough to have a nice apartment (minimum $3,000/month for anything decent). Even then I'm not too sure I'd stay here because the little things do wear down on you - the dirty smelly overcrowded streets, subway stations that are as hot as saunas in the summer, ghetto/homeless people everywhere, constant obnoxiously loud sirens, shabby old infrastructure and housing stock, etc. But I do love the fact that you don't need a car, and there's an energy to this city that I haven't experienced anywhere else. I just don't like when people use this as an excuse to ignore its weaknesses. It's 2016 and most people here live in old tenement buildings.
- Maven911 10y agoAmen to that. I live in Astoria so I don't end up spending as much but I am always amazed how many people buy into the greatest-city-on-earth mentality and ignore all the shortcomings.
- somberi 10y agoFor the benefit of Non-New-Yorkers: NYC is a spread of 5 administrative sections called boroughs; Manhattan is the smallest and Queens is the largest (5X landmass of Manhattan). 6X more people live in the 4 outer boroughs when compared to Manhattan. Posts below, which mention cost, often talk about Manhattan. As you might have guessed, other boroughs tend to be cheaper and are well connected via Subway and MTA bus systems. More than half of New Yorkers do not own a car (ref below), and even those who own patronise the public transport significantly for their work commute (no data, but personal experience from having lived there many years). If you remove the car ownership, and strain on time and resources that come from living in the suburbs, living in NYC is cheaper, as long as you don't consider Manhattan alone as NYC. Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borough_(New_York_City) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borough_(New_York_City) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_most_households_without_a_car https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_most_... Edit: Typos and population.
- bogomipz 10y agoParts of other boroughs might be cheaper but the desirable parts of Brooklyn(Cobble Hill, DUMBO, Williamsburg, etc) and Queens(LIC) aren't any cheaper than Manhattan. There was a time when you could say Brooklyn was cheaper than Manhattan but that hasn't been true in a long time.
- davidf18 10y agoThere has been a concreted effort by the Dept of Health to improve health outcomes beginning in 2001, so we are seeing results. MPOWER is a plan that dramatically reduced tobacco use. There were attempts to lower the consumption of sugar-added-beverages which significantly contributes to obesity. The legal attempts failed, but the publicity of the legal challenges has contributed to a decline. There are many FQHC (Federally Qualified Community Health Centers) here so that essentially everyone has access to care (of course the elderly have Medicare) all of these things help to increase the life expectancy in NYC. As pointed out by others, this is a mass transit and walking city, often the mass transit is far faster than using one's car or a taxi (depending on the time of day). For a Meetup I was attending a couple of weeks ago, I received an Apple Warning to leave 40 minutes early because of heavy traffic. It took me 15 mins by subway and a short walk. A number of the apartments are old and the lowest of these buildings are "walk up" eg, no elevator which also leads to lots of exercise to keep one healthy.