7 ms·
Think You Bought Red Snapper? Don’t Be So Sure
- finid 10y agoBehind a paywall. What's the point of posting it here?
- ddeck 10y agoClick on the "web" link at the top of this HN page and then go to the article from Google. WSJ isn't pay walled if Google is the referrer.
- woliveirajr 10y agoI get a "subscribe or sign in"
- ephextom 10y agoTry a clean browser instance?
- woliveirajr 10y agoYep. Anywhere. Perhaps it's paywalled outside USA?
- just_observing 10y agoAcross the Atlantic here and it opens directly in a new tab. That's with uMatrix blocking several scripts though.
- sbierwagen 10y agoThat used to work, but I just tried it and it didn't work for me.
- nsns 10y agoDoesn't work anymore. At least not outside the US.
- matt_fleming 10y agoI'm a new user and I read the FAQ. They like "original sources." Many of the top-quality sources are pay walled. I happen to pay for the WSJ because I like reading first-hand quality reporting. If there's a discussion link that's pay walled, you can choose not to participate, or simple read the comments and try to pick up something about it. You could also go to your library and see if they have access to the Wall Street Journal. Or google for the article and see if it was picked up elsewhere.
- DanBC 10y agoI don't know if the WSJ still counts as having a paywall with a workaround. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989 > Publications like NYT, WSJ, the Economist, and the New Yorker have paywalls that leave ways for readers to work around them. Such stories are OK to post to Hacker News. Yes, the workarounds are a nuisance, but the loss of many substantive articles would be worse. In the future, when someone doesn't understand this, please politely direct them to this thread or to HN's FAQ [1], which now makes this explicit. > Complaints about paywalls are off-topic here.
- nerdponx 10y agoPeople like to level criticism at wine drinkers for subjecting themselves to placebo effects. Now what about fish eaters? If you can't taste the difference between red snapper and tilapia, why ever buy red snapper? Obviously there are environmental and health reasons to choose one fish species over another, but is that doesn't seem to explicitly be the problem here.
- coldtea 10y ago>Now what about fish eaters? If you can't taste the difference between red snapper and tilapia, why ever buy red snapper? Well, there's absolutely different taste between some species of fish. Nobody would misunderstood a swordfish for tilapia for example. Now, some fish are more alike in taste, so that one would either not see much difference in picking one over another, or even attribute the difference from what they expected in this particular catch/bunch they bought being blander. After all, taste can vary between different items of a single species of fish too (depending on where it was caught, how it was raised, what it ate, age, etc.).
- koolba 10y ago> Now what about fish eaters? If you can't taste the difference between red snapper and tilapia, why ever buy red snapper? Obviously there are environmental and health reasons to choose one fish species over another, but is that doesn't seem to explicitly be the problem here. Read up on Tilapia farming a bit and you'll never touch the stuff again in your life. The majority of farms pump the frys with hormones to force them all to be males (vs random mix of male/female). This is because males are generally larger, grow faster, and leads to a more uniform product. Not every farm does this (I think there are some in the USA that don't) but the bad apples have poisoned the entire barrel for me. Since I can't tell where it's coming from I won't eat it. Tis a shame too as it's a relatively hardy fish and it can be raised on a purely vegetarian diet. Taste wise I'm not sure if I could tell the difference between real Grouper and whatever is the knockoff. Would be a fun test to do at home as Grouper tastes awesome. If there's a cheaper substitute that's just as good, I'm all for it!
- sbierwagen 10y ago
- dbalan 10y agoApparently it's not limited to fish industry. A lot of ingredients are substituted behind the scenes and recipes altered when crossing geographic boundaries. [1] https://nypost.com/2016/07/10/the-truth-behind-how-were-scammed-into-eating-phony-food/ https://nypost.com/2016/07/10/the-truth-behind-how-were-scam...
- Grazester 10y agoI could tell the difference between red snapper and tilapia. I dislike this fish and the texture doesn't seem quite snapper like(at least the times I had it). When I moved to the us for school I was surprised to find it on the menu at restaurants instead of snapper. I tend to not like it when restaurants try to pass off one fish for another to me. In the Caribbean a restaurant gave me marlin instead of sword. I think just about anyone would be able to tell the difference since sword can be a much much softer flesh fish. I lived in the Caribbean where my grandfather depended on the sea. Fishing for a living. He caught only these reef fishes. My father a retired sea captain, bought a fishing boat and fished mainly yellow fin tuna but of course marlin and sworn would end up on his lines as by catch. I think a lot of people here in the Caribbean who still eat fish would be able to differentiate between cooked fish. Blue tangs fried are my favourite reef fish...sorry Dory.
- Something1234 10y agoYou can eat blue tang? I didn't know that was served. I thought it was just a display fish.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- feld 10y agoIf you've never had the real thing you'll never know you're being duped. That's the problem. Fish, shrimp, olive oil, Parmesan, balsamic...
- hammock 10y agoShrimp?
- stevula 10y agoFrom the article: Shrimp is so bad that Olmsted rarely eats it. “I won’t buy it, ever, if it is farmed or imported,” he writes. In 2007, the FDA banned five kinds of imported shrimp from China; China turned around and routed the banned shrimp through Indonesia, stamped it as originating from there, and suddenly it was back in the US food supply.
- sampo 10y agoBut what is it that is bad about the shrimp? Is it a particularly unhealthy variety of shrimp? Or do they contain traces of poisonous chemicals?
- hammock 10y agoThanks to you both. Looks like the use of antibiotics and carcinogenic chemicals is an issue. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cms_ia/importalert_33.html http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cms_ia/importalert_33.html At restaurants I don't think I've ever seen imported shrimp (don't really eat at chain restaurants). I'll have to pay closer attention to the source in the frozen bags I buy from the grocery.
- prostoalex 10y agoI've read Olmstead's book and his beef (pardon the pun) with shrimp is how easy it is for bad players (who stuff their product with carcinogens and various unsafe chemicals to achieve maximum yield) to repackage, relabel and trans-ship their stuff to get a stamp from a new country of origin. When the FDA banned the import of bad shrimp from China http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/06/28/AR2007062801280.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/06..., imports of Philippines and Indonesia shrimp skyrocketed (sometimes beyond those nation's total shrimp harvesting numbers). Upon inspection it was same old carcinogenic shrimp. Honey, tea and spices of unknown origins are also frequent targets of dilution in order to boost the margins.
- berntb 10y agoIs this an opportunity for a startup? Help crowdsource payments for random DNA tests of the food at local stores. Fish and olive oil, to start. If a group of people know everyone involved and do a round robin for who collects the samples and which lab to send them to, it should be more trustworthy than any alternative. (The samples need to be sent in without packages, so employees at the testing labs can't call the stores and charge for faking the tests.) Edit: Hmm, the business opportunity might rather be with automating lab tests..?
- theli0nheart 10y agoCool idea, but it'd far cheaper, faster, and more reasonable to just have people who know what foods actually should taste like run the "tests" as opposed to running full blown DNA analysis.
- berntb 10y agoDoes that include olive oil? I am not certain I'd know the difference... :-(
- theli0nheart 10y agoHah. I'd think so. I couldn't tell the difference either, but I'm sure there are people who can. :)
- berntb 10y agoHow do you find people like that? How can you trust them? They aren't so common I'd imagine -- but I sadly know far too few professional cooks. :-) Edit: According to my googling, it seems even experts often fail the taste testing of olive oil. I guess you could wait a few decades and see how your arteries are doing -- or use a lab.
- CartyBoston 10y agoFish yeah but extracting useful DNA from olive oil and other processed foods/ingredients is not straightforward.
- shambala 10y agoAnybody know if I can do a DNA test on food at home? How can I build a lab at home?
- sampo 10y ago> Anybody know if I can do a DNA test on food at home? How can I build a lab at home? A MinION sequencer from Oxford Nanopore is $1000. With this alone (and a kit of chemicals and enzymes to prepare the sample) you can sequence DNA, but sequencing a random piece of DNA may not help you in identifying the animal or plant species used in a food product. So probably you need to use PCR to amplify a suitable piece of DNA, so you know what you are sequencing. For this you need enzymes, which probably cost in tens or hundreds of dollars for each use, and then in principle you can do PCR "by hand" (I have done this) with the enzymes, some test tubes and 3 water baths kept controlled in certain temperatures. Or buy a machine that cycles the temperature in a controlled manner. They are really just thermal cyclers, but they are commonly known as "PCR machines". You can get a used one for about $1000. Then at least one micropopipette (surprisingly expensive, almost $200, or buy used) and some glassware etc. If you have the knowledge, $3000 to $5000 should have you up and running. Some stuff, like enzymes, are consumable, so you need to use more money to restock when the lab is running.
- dccoolgai 10y agoJust went on a charter a few weeks ago for snapper. Probably the best way to go if you enjoy fishing and find a good boat - you can easily come back with 40+ pounds of fish for around $100. Same with Speckled trout.
- sparkzilla 10y agoDid you hear about the woman who went on a fishing trip with a bunch of rednecks? She came back with a red snapper.
- Drdrdrq 10y ago>... the study shows that the problem isn’t primarily with the people who catch or wholesale the fish; it’s with the stores and restaurants that deal directly with consumers > Another easy tip: Buy American when possible. The U.S. is far and away the world leader in fishery management, safety and sustainability, and fish caught in the U.S., from Alaska to Cape Cod, are better regulated for purity and more likely to be labeled accurately. How would buying American help if the problem is in B2C companies, which are presumably all local anyway? While there probably exists a problem with mislabeled seafood, this looks like a propaganda article to me.
- bitwize 10y agoNo thanks, Kuni, I'll take what's inside the box.