5 ms·
Don't bite the hand that feeds you and wants to hand you stacks of cash. "We’re seeing it transformed into something that risks becoming like every other techn
by paulddraper 10y ago
Don't bite the hand that feeds you and wants to hand you stacks of cash.
"We’re seeing it transformed into something that risks becoming like every other technology park."
That would be...educated population, business growth, tremendous financial gains for existing property owners.
What exactly is he worried about? Traffic?
- m3rc 10y agoMaybe he's (rightfully) worried about housing prices. He doesn't really have a problem with cash-flow, he does have a problem with an insanely bubbled housing market that collapses the moment the tech bubble does
- mzs 10y agoHousing bubble did not burst when the tech bubble did last time. That's why I moved to IL. My options were under water, stock was rapidly falling, I had another kid on the way, and I still could not afford a mortgage anywhere near Menlo Park with decent schools. The housing bubble burst later during the financial crisis.
- ng12 10y agoHis primary concern is keeping housing prices high. It's very clear that Mayor Burke's objective is to make Palo Alto a city for the elite. http://sf.curbed.com/2016/8/23/12603188/palo-alto-mayor-housing-interview http://sf.curbed.com/2016/8/23/12603188/palo-alto-mayor-hous...
- maxxxxx 10y ago" tremendous financial gains for existing property owners." That's a problem to me. Next generations get screwed.
- paulddraper 10y agoSure, but it sounded like the mayor was looking out of the concerns of existing residents, not you. His logic was backward.
- ng12 10y ago> Traffic? Clearly not. The downtown tech crowd are the only ones walking/biking to work.
- redwood 10y agoOn the contrary... The hand that feeds Palo Alto is a culture of entrepreneurship. Downtown Palo Alto in particular, with its easy access to Stanford University, venture capital, and many smaller office spaces, has long been a major incubator. Companies like Palantir that take over all this previous incubator-like space are in fact a threat to the very hand that feeds Palo Alto. Further, once you're big enough that you provide your own services (caffeteria etc) you threaten the viability of downtown businesses that cater to smaller offices. Also, once inevitably companies like Palantir do make their move to a proper office park somewhere, that will mean a glut of suddenly open office space in Downtown Palo Alto. This isn't healthy either... it's better to ensure that there is always a fairly stable amount of demand and vacancy...
- julesqs 10y ago> Companies like Palantir that take over all this previous incubator-like space are in fact a threat to the very hand that feeds Palo Alto So build more space.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoWhere? Downtown Palo Alto is saturated...and building up won't solve saturation on Alma, University, Page Mill etc. Palo Alto has simply maxed out its carrying capacity...businesses like Palantir would be better off looking at areas like the emerging business park near San Jose Airport, where Apple has already committed to building a campus with even more square footage than the Spaceship campus.
- apsec112 10y agoIt would have more carrying capacity if it let people live closer to where they work, reducing commute distance, and if it didn't keep threatening to sue public transit providers: http://paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/01/27/palo-alto-opts-not-to-sue-caltrain http://paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/01/27/palo-alto-opts-not...
- pcwalton 10y ago
- madmax96 10y agoBecoming like every other technology park is __bad__. Slightly off-topic, but I'd argue that right now we're in a bubble and that many technology companies are over-valued. Everyone thinks they're a unicorn. Unfortunately, most of them are wrong. Wanting to keep your economy diverse is a wise decision in that situation. For every boom, there is an equal and opposite bust. Wanting to control growth is not unreasonable, and it is reckless to allow growth without any sort of oversight.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoThey are worried that a tech company will collapse or move and leave downtown in a shambles. This happened in Mountain View with SGI. Tech companies will also cause rents to explode, driving away many independent businesses....so oddly enough, tech companies may create a dead zone accidentally.
- dogma1138 10y agoBecause industrial parks don't have babies. A tech park is at the end a less smelly industrial park. It hinders natural population growth other than employees moving in. Cities need families that will make babies because it roots the population down. A city full of young professionals that are only tied to their employer is a really bad thing. Once the economy slows down or their employer isn't the bigest bestest place to work for the flock moves on leaving a lot of empty office space and single bedroom condos.
- hackuser 10y ago> Don't bite the hand that feeds you and wants to hand you stacks of cash. Who is getting handed stacks of cash? I imagine it's not many low/middle-income residents, who simply have to leave. There are positives and negatives for all options, but it's disingenuous to imagine there is no downside to gentrification. EDIT: It's a similar issue to the U.S. economy as a whole over the last 30 years. There's been tremendous growth in aggregate, but in particular only for a relatively few people.
- azakai 10y ago> educated population, business growth, tremendous financial gains for existing property owners. What exactly is he worried about? Traffic? He's probably worried about skyrocketing rent, and overall increases in the cost of living in the area. It pushes middle class and working class people out. The result is a Silicon Valley where firefighters and teachers and retail workers can't afford to live in the area. In general, it's reasonable to consider what the optimal rate of office space growth is. If it's matched by a growth in the necessary infrastructure around it - housing, but also public transit, etc. - then it can be great. Unchecked office space growth by itself isn't necessarily good.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]