5 ms·
There's CPU's that do memory, integrity checking to contain attacks. They're designed for stoping software and peripheral attacks mainly but consider RAM untrus
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
There's CPU's that do memory, integrity checking to contain attacks. They're designed for stoping software and peripheral attacks mainly but consider RAM untrusted. They could probably be modified to deal with the new attacks.
- userbinator 10y agoECC RAM has been around for a long time and may reduce, but not eliminate the risk. The problem is that the RAM is fundamentally defective.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI know what the root problem is. I also know it comes from an oligopoly of companies that only care about money, probably have patents on key features, and operate in a price-sensitive market. Fixing root cause might be tricky unless you could be sure via contracts of volume deals from cloud and other big buyers. Meanwhile, small teams in academia are building CPU's that knock out those and other issues. Worth bringing up given the fix you want isnt doable for most HW dedigners. RAM vendors might eventually use it as a differentiator but that's not guaranteed.
- tsukikage 10y agoYou can't entirely blame the providers for only caring about money; the consumers that choose the budget hosting options for critical applications must surely share some of it. Server grade hardware is certainly available to cloud/VPS providers, but it turns out people are unwilling to pay $2 for a VM if there's one going elsewhere for $1.50.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"the consumers that choose the budget hosting options for critical applications must surely share some of it." The customers expect the RAM they bought to work correctly. They might have even read papers on ASIC verification where the hardware companies brag about all these techniques they use to prevent recalls like one Intel had. The issue is that the companies stopped doing or reduced verification on specific components to reduce costs. What they bring in on the chips is way more than it takes to do that. So, the reason must be greed driving the profits up a little bit. This one is the companies' fault. I'd have assigned blame differently if we were talking security of regular, consumer products or even operating systems. Verification of repeating pieces of hardware circuits is an industry-standard practice, though. Except for RAM providers apparently.
- willvarfar 10y agoEncrypted RAM is offered by the newest Intel server-grade CPUs (SGX, Skylake) and the next AMD server-grade CPUs (SME, Zen). One of the main use-cases for these technologies is trusted computing in a cloud environment - the customer can assert that the hardware is securing the program state from the eyes of the computer owner!. However, the cloud is actually made from cheap commodity boxes without server-grade anything! ;) Encrypting RAM pages would prevent the hypervisor from deduping pages between virtual machines, and this would be very negative for cloud providers who want to up the occupancy on each box as much as possible... In a few years, or perhaps longer, perhaps proper DDR4 and other immune memory will be mainstream in clouds. But until then, it seems we'll have a cloud fitted out with increasingly aging cheap machines with no rowhammer immunity.
- makomk 10y agoDon't think I've seen any non-server-grade processors in even the cheapest bargain-basement VPS hosts. (Low-end dedicated is different.) Cramming as many VMs into a big server as possible seems to be too important to their cost structure for that.
- willvarfar 10y agoWe perhaps only disagree on what is "server-grade" vs what is sold for servers. Google, for example, are famous for making big data centres out of cheap commodity boxes, and I double Amazon are any different. I certainly know the rackspace blades I've played with didn't make my grade of either! :)
- tristor 10y agoI can't make any claims to contrary about other providers, but I know at the very least that at one point not in too distant past the primary systems used for Rackspace Cloud hypervisors were Dell R720 rackmount servers. Maybe not the most amazing hardware, but considering how common they are you can hardly refuse to say they're "server-grade". The newer OpenCompute stuff is also clearly well-made hardware.
- 10y ago