8 ms·
It's not the TV manufacturers that don't like that concept it's that consumers don't like the concept. Every TV is a "dumb display", consumers wanted more featu
by dogma1138 10y ago
It's not the TV manufacturers that don't like that concept it's that consumers don't like the concept.
Every TV is a "dumb display", consumers wanted more features.
Sony, LG, Samsung and w/e would love nothing more than to sell you only a panel with video input ports but that is not what people want to buy.
People are constantly buying the most feature loaded TV's even at the expense of getting lesser panel quality, inch size and various other things.
- mnutt 10y agoIf that was the case, they could sell a TV with 5 HDMI ports with a Chromecast pre-plugged into one of them. But I suspect after a year or two people would buy a new $35 Chromecast, rather than replacing their entire TV.
- dogma1138 10y agoThey can still do it, most people don't use Chromecast most people want the YouTube, NetFlix, W/E logo on the box. And they sell a TV with 5 HDMI ports because their competitors sell 4, this what happens when you have a features arms race, there are only what 2-3 panel makes so most TV's are pretty identical (like Cars that you only have a few chassis/wheelbase for each price range) so to have the advantage they load the TV's with other features like more ports, better WIFI, more this more that (just like cars which sell you BS things you don't need).
- int_19h 10y agoChromecast doesn't have to be a literal Chromecast. It just has to be some kind of dongle that uses a standard interface (e.g. HDMI, and maybe USB for remote command handling), and can be upgraded on its own. Of course, the TV manufacturers don't want to do that, because they profit when you have to upgrade the entire TV.
- dogma1138 10y agoThey don't want to do it because the consumer would not accept it as a solution because the minute that their competitor ditches that dongle and puts those features internally they have the "advantage". Sunny sells you dongles that take a port, buy symsyng and have all your ports for other devices. If you are an advanced enough user that you can use a streamer/dongle/set top box or w/e it doesn't matter what the TV has as long as it comes with display input ports. For the majority of the shopping channel BIG BOX mart consumers this isn't really an option and they want one box that does everything even if it's not the most optimal solution. What you are asking for is simply something that the TV maker has no reason or interest to do not because they are greedy but because they don't want to deal with that. They aren't stopping you from buying whatever dongle you want so what exactly is the complaint? The majority of the cost of the TV is still the tuner, panel, and LED and optical assembly the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper. If somehow removing those features would allow them to focus on more important things I would understand but in reality it doesn't add up to much if anything.
- ghaff 10y ago>the 11$ SoC they use for the smart features won't make the TV's cheaper And that's the good news in all this. I can buy and use the TVs of my choice and the reality is that I don't really need to pay a material premium because they have YouTube which may or may not continue to work after some day in the future. So I can choose to ignore those features if I want. It's not really a choice between buying SmartTV for $X and DumbTV (which is otherwise equivalent) for $X/2.
- Silhouette 10y agoMy concern about the "smart" TVs isn't things I can ignore, it's things I can't. For example, I don't want a TV with its own network connection, a built-in camera and microphone, and hideously insecure firmware right in my living room. Literally the only controls I ever use on my TV are power/standby, volume, and input selector. Everything else already comes from external sources like a set top box or PVR or Chromecast, and it's not like only A/V nerds have that arrangement. I just want good video, good audio, and decent manufacturing quality and longevity. How on earth did we lose the plot as badly as we seem to have with the "smart" marketing?
- ghaff 10y agoMaybe. I'll accept that TV manufacturers have convinced many consumers to pay attention to the arms race over features. But were consumers really clamoring for 3D, for example? I haven't been on the market for a TV for a few years but I'm not convinced that a lot of people see more apps on a TV as a critical selling point.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoBut were consumers really clamoring for 3D, for example? No they weren't. IMO it wasn't worth the extra money. After all, just how many times can someone re-watch Avatar? Most other 3D movies weren't actually shot in 3D, they were just faked in post production. Here's a headline that shows just how dead 3D is: With a bullet to the head from Samsung, 3D TV is now deader than ever It may shamble forward zombie-style for a few more years, but without the world's No. 1 TV maker on board, 3D TV is doomed. http://www.cnet.com/news/3d-tv-is-now-more-dead-than-ever/ http://www.cnet.com/news/3d-tv-is-now-more-dead-than-ever/
- ghaff 10y agoI actually have a 3D TV that I got on a pre-Christmas sale. My story is that I didn't really pay a premium for the 3D aspects of the TV (which included glasses) and I'm sticking to that story :-) I think I've maybe watched a half dozen 3D movies on it. I've watched a few films that did a good job with it. But they're few and far between.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe reason why most people avoided them especially the "passive" ones is that the "filter" they used on the panels made the normal TV experience slightly worse if you are pedantic about image quality. The image tends to be bit more fuzzy and dimmer than on 2D displays but again it's a compromise some of the latest 3D TV's pretty much are indistinguishable from 2D only panels but overall the lack of content was what killed it rather than the performance of the TV itself. Sure you still have some viewing angle issues which might make some living/TV room setups not optimal for 3D and most TV's only came initially with 1-2 pairs of glasses and if it was a active 3D setup (had an active switching component inside of them) they could be somewhat expensive but if the content was there it wouldn't matter. If there were more 3D blurays and DVD's out there and especially if Netflix or any other streaming service would have supported 3D content (3D streaming is still not a solved issue somewhat) the outcome would've been different. Overall once 3D content is going to be easily streamable (and it's being worked on) and "glassesless" 3D/Stereoscopic panels become slightly cheaper it might make a comeback. Avatar was a nice experience but overall even in the cinema many people avoid 3D atm simply because it's still not there, these issues would be solved eventually and when every content would go through stereoscopic processing it would look pretty nice :)
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoBut if the average consumer compares the Sony and LG 'smart' TVs with YouTube and Netflix and 47 other apps to a by extension 'dumb' Samsung display, they won't pick the Samsung, even if it has better panel quality that can't be readily quantified or seen on the hypersaturated demo. Well, you and I might buy the Samsung, but most consumers aren't as informed or as savvy with a Chromecast.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf I'm buying a TV for my mom neither would I. If you want a "dumb" display then buy a display it's a product category of it's own and virtually every company that makes TV/Panels sells them e.g. http://www.necdisplay.com/category/large-screen-displays http://www.necdisplay.com/category/large-screen-displays these are the ones that they sell for display purposes for advertisement, boardrooms etc. but they are not "TV's", some of them have slightly better panels than some TV's some of them don't.
- khedoros 10y agoThey're also much more expensive, have fewer input options than my current (dumb) tv, and have some remote configuration options that would more conveniently be put into menus, in a consumer device. So...what's the point, besides pigheadedness over not buying a "smart" TV? It's not like there's a way to even go see what I'm buying before I do it. I'm not a big fan of smart devices, but I'm not going to pay more for a display with "meh" connectivity that doesn't really seem to be optimized as a home entertainment device. Although annoying, it makes more sense to buy the smart TV and ignore the extra features.
- IANAD 10y ago> consumers wanted more features Maybe so, but I never personally asked the TV manufacturers for a smart TV. Who I think came up with the idea: TV manufacturers. Selling hardware that has software/firmware, that will become obsolete in 4-8 years, will result in more TVs sold in 4-8 years than would have been. We just got rid of a TV that we've had since the late 1990s- about 18 years. It was not smart. We just bought a smart TV and I'm betting we won't get more than 8 years out of it.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf you were OK with a TV for 18 years you would be OK with another TV for 18 years. This is simply a fallacy the fact that the software would become obsolete doesn't make the TV obsolete as long as it can still receive a video input and display it - this has nothing to do with the "smart" features of the TV.
- IANAD 10y agoI have one of the "newer generation" smart TVs driven by Roku's interface- completely. In other words, you turn the TV on with a Roku remote and when the TV comes on, you see the Roku interface which you must use to choose which HDMI or game port to use, etc. I like the interface a lot, but I bought it knowing that at some point, it will not be as cool as it is now. It will probably get in the way, as I'll have to use the Roku remote to browse via the old Roku OS to the port with the box that is the new browseable streaming OS. Maybe the Roku one will get borked by a system update because my hardware is unsupported- I don't know; I hope that doesn't happen, and have had a good experience with my old Roku external box, but it is a possibility several years from now. Years ago when I bought a TV, never did it cross my mind that "one day the user interface is going to be obsolete".
- red_admiral 10y agoHere in the UK, the BBC has something they call the "red button" feature - most of the time, it just brings up "teletext 2.0" with some news headlines etc. but when there's something like the olympics on, you can use it to switch between coverage of different events. On my "dumb" TV that is not and never will be connected to the 'net, this feature works fine and has done so for years. On my friend's "smart" TV, the red button feature has been replaced by an "app" that we had to update and fiddle with to get it working, and it won't do anything at all without an internet connection despite the key feature just being a kind of switch between two sub-channels, both of which are served over the usual aerial/cable. You can't even turn this off to get the normal red button back.
- TrevorJ 10y agoI think it is more a matter of manufacturers wanting to sell TV's sooner than a 5-10 year life cycle. To do that, you have to come up with new features to try to entice.
- killbrad 10y agoDo you have any evidence of this? I've never ever talked to anyone that wanted a feature like this in their TV. The manufacturers have incentive, but the consumers aren't asking for it. And -all- of the interfaces built in to TVs for such things I've used are terrible. Hell, most TVs still can't make a remote/on-screen UI work reasonably. People can talk to their voice agents ("hello assistant, who is the president of the USA") on the toilet and generally expect a reasonable answer. And yet we still have to point some wand at an exact spot on our TVs, press buttons, and hope they register and change channels.
- aedron 10y agoI actually have a 2012 Bravia. It has a webcam and a Skype app. When we get a Skype call, a little popup appears in the bottom left corner, and I can accept/decline with the remote. I can then carry out a video call in either full 50 inches or composited with the TV signal. Coolest thing ever. Digital recording is a great feature too, plug in a USB stick for storage then control and manage recordings with the remote. I actually like to have everything integrated, rather than having to fiddle with my OSMC, which, as an example, in the case of recording would need its own signal input. My only (yet pretty big) issue with the Sony software is that it is slow to start up. From turning on the TV until it will respond to the remote is easily 40-50 seconds, long after the picture appears. You can't even change the channel or volume. And, oh yeah, the YouTube app has been broken for years, but I use the OSMC for that.
- pmontra 10y agoWhat happens when you're on a Skype call on the TV and want to move to another room? I guess it's like with the old wired phones, you don't move. A 50" display is cool but a tablet or a phone are usually better suited to answer calls. The only smart feature I'm using of my LG TV is playing videos from USB sticks. It doesn't have some audio codecs common in MKV containers, but when it works 40" is better than a tablet screen. BTW, the LG is quick enough at starting up. I usually keep it completely off, not in standby. Switch on the power, push the remote, get the image: 9 seconds. Maybe on par with old analog CRTs. I never enabled WiFi because of the terms of service. Even if they are not as invasive as other ToS I saw from other manufacturers, they are way more than they should. I should use the TV to watch things, not to be watched. I already have the PC, tablet and phone for that :-) and at least I can fight there with adblockers and the like. I have a Raspberry 3 connected to the TV and I could do YouTube with that (it's quite OK). Still the tablet is much better. I could chromecast to the TV but it's not worth the trouble.
- tudorw 10y agoagain, if manufacturers engage in the most basic 'mine is bigger than yours' playground games then it's not surprising that the users, who love shiny things, are not making a decision based on fact, if instead of releasing a new shape box every year, they really focused on a consistent product line then they could delivery incremental improvements and show users over time why their product is the better 'viewing experience' which is what it's all about really!
- 1_2__3 10y agoWhat possible evidence do you have of this? It sounds wholly speculative.
- 1_2__3 10y agoWhat possible evidence do you have of this? It sounds wholly speculative.
- s_kilk 10y ago>> consumers wanted more features. Do they though? I mean, everyone I've asked just wants their Microwave to have two dials, Power and Time, yet no such thing exists on the market. Instead it's a sea of bullshit Microwaves with bullshit "value add" features. I'd wager the same is true of TVs, and myriad other consumer products. The end-users just want simple tech that works for years on end, while Product Managers and Designers want to boost their own status by sheparding these mindless "improvements" into production.
- ebiester 10y agoPeople would flip their shit if their microwaves didn't rotate anymore, for example. But what "Value Add" features are you talking about that are non-trivial to implement?
- marcosdumay 10y agoIt's not a microwave, but... I've lost my fridge manual and have no idea how to set its clock anymore - so it's just there, blinking, for eternity. Yes, I brought this fridge model because of "features". I even did a feature comparison while searching for a model. The caveat is that all the features I looked for were related to chilling things, or easy maintenance. I would pay extra for getting rid of the clock - and more yet for just some different software that displayed temperature instead of time.
- cududa 10y agoHave you considered using the internet to find a copy of the manual?
- outworlder 10y agoNot entirely true. At work we have a microwave oven with a single dial for time (haven't bothered to even check if it has power settings). It also doesn't rotate. It's branded as a "commercial microwave oven" or something.
- hsivonen 10y agoDoes customer demand drive "overscan on HDMI" by default, too? Who are those people?
- 4ad 10y agoThis is pretty much the best argument I've heard on this issue. I always hear "people want this", but there are "features", like "overscan on HDMI" that nobody wants, and yet these features exist. It's the manufacturers who are pushing shit down the throats of people.