4 ms·
I'm in a country where everyone can easily find out everyone else's salary. I find it weird (because I'm American). Also, unions are more common, but different
by Broken_Hippo 10y ago
I'm in a country where everyone can easily find out everyone else's salary. I find it weird (because I'm American). Also, unions are more common, but different because management will also often have unions, so they are the ones that do the negotiating. This means the process and facts and figures are much more open.
And while I find it weird, this does also mean that pay scales are more appropriate and fair. You can have seniority plus merit based pay, for example, so long as you are honest about what qualifacations people need to meet to earn more pay, and also lessens the gap between women and men's pay.
Some of the gap between women and men will take societal change, and most likely take laws and such to force people's hand to do it.
- sokoloff 10y ago> this does also mean that pay scales are more appropriate and fair It means that the pay scales are more equal. Whether or not that's fair is unclear as determining fairness requires determining a significant component of performance and results. Paying a mediocre developer and a superstar developer (or salesperson) the same amount is equal, but is not fair, IMO.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoYou are correct on the definition of fairness, and no system is perfect. But at the same time, it doesn't mean that the pay scales are unfair. I think it encourages folks to be upfront about how they determine payrates, raises, and bonuses. However, the things you describe are more things left up to the employer - and the even-out payscales are in place especially in factories and other such professions. Not necessarily fair, but at least some of those jobs are more difficult to differentiate concrete pay systems as well. In my opinion, such systems mean one needs to be able to back up the claim that the superstar is superior. Salespersons are easier to measure in this sense, especially if they make commissions. Developers? Simply have standards and be upfront about how said standards affect pay, and apply those. Measurable experience, results, error rate, speed, or whatever measures you have.
- sokoloff 10y agoI want my coworkers focused on creating business value and trusting that they'll be rewarded for that, not trying to figure out how to game the system to close the most tickets, write the most code, write the fewest bugs, get the most fake wiki edit points, or whatever "objective standards" I could come up with. http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-11-13 http://dilbert.com/strip/1995-11-13 The "via leadership judgement" system absolutely has its flaws (including people trying to game that), but IMO it's the worst system to use, except for all the other systems we've tried.
- tcoppi 10y ago> The "via leadership judgement" system absolutely has its flaws (including people trying to game that), but IMO it's the worst system to use, except for all the other systems we've tried. Right now, at least with highly in-demand skillsets, it is more like "another company's leadership's judgement".
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoIt is possible to find balance in there. Not all systems fit all workplaces. The main point I was trying to make is that whatever is used should be fair. If everyone's pay is public, it might not be uncommon to ask "why does person A make more than me?" And There has to be things you can point out (I suppose you can keep quiet, but it probably doesn't foster a wonderful environment). And if they ask how they can increase their own pay or their own job performance to make their pay better, it really needs to be more than, "just suck it up": In addition, the employee has to realize they probably won't catch up to Person A because they weren't doing the necessary stuff from the beginning.
- st3v3r 10y agoPaying one developer more simply because they're better at negotiating isn't fair either. As is, we really don't have good ways of determining one developer is clearly better than another.
- sokoloff 10y agoBut you know it when you see the outliers, right? You know who you'd want to go form a 3-person highly technical startup with. You know who else you'd never want to work with if your personal livelihood depending on them performing in a crunch. I admit that I can't judge who is 10 or 20% better than another developer. I can tell who the 5-10x outliers are. Maybe under other circumstances or at other companies different people would shine, but I'm at this company and under these circumstances.
- kasey_junk 10y agoIs it true that most Americans work in "non public" salary environments? All government employees, most union employees & many big company employees in the USA work with public salaries.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoyes and no. Some professions have a 'salary' - as in, they get paid the same amount regardless of how much they work. The other sorts, yes. For example, I worked in a call center. Nearly everyone started at the same rate, raises were scheduled, and everyone got the same percentage, dependent on how long you worked there. Pay was capped. The way to earn money was to have some sort of promotion or transfer. A lot of factories are set up in the same way. It gets a little fuzzier in retail sectors. In the states, this is often (but not always) result of having a union for the employees.