7 ms·
‘The Market Is Saturated’: Brooklyn’s Rental Boom May Turn into a Glut
- slackstation 10y agoMakes me feel better about my rents. I pay about the same here in Los Angeles except I'm walking distance from work and have the beach and sunny weather. $3400 is the median for the high end there, here is about the higher end of the high end unless you start counting the ridiculous places near the beach. But, then if you want an ocean view in Santa Monica, be prepared to shell out $10k/mo or more.
- beachstartup 10y agoit doesn't cost 10k/month to have an ocean view in santa monica. there are smaller units in the 500-1000 square foot range for a lot less than half of that -- i live in one. there are lots of "normal" old 1950s/1960s style apartments with ocean views, it's not just the ridiculous marble-clad ultra-lux units that everyone sees when they drive by.
- jseliger 10y agoI pay about the same here in Los Angeles except I'm walking distance from work and have the beach and sunny weather. In most of LA you also need a car, which AAA estimates to be around $9,000/yr in TCO terms. L.A. is slowly but surely building out a real subway system, and maybe when the purple line is done it'll be more practical to live without a car in LA, but that day is still a ways away.
- koolba 10y agoThe trainageddon™ coming in 2019 isn't going to help Brooklyn rental prices either: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/train-shut-18-months-starting-2019-article-1.2725118 http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/train-shut-18-months-sta...
- CPLX 10y agoThat's completely irrelevant to Downtown Brooklyn, which this article is about, and as mentioned is an incredibly well connected area for transit. It has far better train service than the vast majority of Manhattan.
- dguido 10y agoIt could result in a huge influx of people from north brooklyn, where there will be no trains, moving to south brooklyn to get to the trains you mentioned.
- kchoudhu 10y agoIf anything, the L train shutdown is going to drive prices up in downtown Brooklyn as lease-terminating refugees from Williamsburg move downtown in an effort to keep living in Brooklyn.
- chris_7 10y agoI'm one of those people leaving, but I definitely wouldn't consider downtown Brooklyn, it's not really a place (in the Jane Jacobs sense). My experiences walking around there are generally negative. the roads (Flatbush and Atlantic especially) are monstrosities that are not scaled for humans, and are unpleasant to walk along. Buildings are massive, set back, and imposing. It fluctuates between overcrowded and creepily empty. Williamsburg is a (gentrified, yes) place. An empty side street is not creepy or deserted feeling, it's pleasant, and there will probably be some people milling around outside of an Okonomi-type place somewhere on the walk. There are stoops and the like. Anyways, I see places like Park Slope and Fort Greene as more likely locations for people leaving Williamsburg.
- kchoudhu 10y agoI'm not disagreeing with you: I moved way the heck out to Bay Ridge for exactly the considerations you mention. That said, a lot of people move to New York for work, and care about one thing only: how long it takes to get to and from work. The supply of places 10-15 minutes from lower Manhattan is surprisingly limited, and downtown Brooklyn is likely to come up on any shortlist of places to look when searching for apartments.
- kchoudhu 10y agoIt'll be a glut when the cost of an average two bedroom rental 15 minutes away from lower Manhattan costs $2000. Until then: build, build, build.
- Finnucane 10y agoNever going to happen. NYC will always be expensive, no matter what. Buildable land will always be limited and expensive. Labor will be expensive. Materials will be expensive. Developers will always seek to maximize profit, so billionaires and Wall Street trader waving bonus checks and looking for investment-grade properties are going to get served before you. And you know what happens when developers perceive a 'glut' of apartments at the profitable end of the market? They stop building. The market doesn't promise that it will provide whatever you want at a price you can afford--it only promises to provide what it can at prices that are profitable to the seller.
- StriverGuy 10y agoDevelopers would also rather see their buildings empty than charge below market rent for fear of seeming like a 'low end' property.
- billpaetzke 10y agoYep. And the way the developers--on Bravo's Million-Dollar Listing--think, they not only want market price but also to set a new record for market price (per square foot).
- TulliusCicero 10y agoOf course they want that; who wouldn't want more money for their business? But competition can drive the price down just like any other sector, and allowing for more housing to be built means more competition.
- billpaetzke 10y ago
- tvanantwerp 10y ago> That means a one-bedroom, one-bathroom place can be had for $3,428 a month; a two-bedroom, two-bath apartment goes for $5,057. When the rent for a two-bedroom apartment exceeds the US median household income ($rent is $60,684/year, median income in US is $53,657), it doesn't sound like that much of a housing glut to me.
- kowdermeister 10y agoI had the same quote on my clipboard. It's still pretty insane. I'm from Budapest and I pay around 150$ / month :D (yeah, I split)
- flubert 10y agoOr you could get a place all to yourself... $45/mo mortgage, 924 sq. ft.: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/5-Preston-Park-Rutland-VT-05701/92022395_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/5-Preston-Park-Rutland-VT-... $90/mo mortgage, 1513 sq. ft.: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/25-Merritt-Ave-Kingston-NY-12401/32836408_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/25-Merritt-Ave-Kingston-NY... $78/mo mortgage: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/221-Mckinley-Ave-Williamstown-NJ-08094/2101576538_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/221-Mckinley-Ave-Williamst... $87/mo mortgage, 924 sq. ft: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/81-Barbara-Ave-Prospect-CT-06712/57984181_zpid/ http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/81-Barbara-Ave-Prospect-CT...
- spaceflunky 10y ago> $87/mo mortgage, 924 sq. ft: http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/81-Barbara-Ave-Prospect-CT.. http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/81-Barbara-Ave-Prospect-CT.... $87 PLUS $396 HOA fee to live in a mobile home in the boondocks. Yea no thanks...
- flubert 10y agoAlways fun to get a different perspectives on what boondocks mean to different people... https://goo.gl/maps/C1LBxd61R9y https://goo.gl/maps/C1LBxd61R9y
- S_Daedalus 10y agoI feel like the author of this piece doesn't have a grip on the reality of 90% of Americans, or more.
- Finnucane 10y agoFortunately, 90% of Americans don't live in New York.
- S_Daedalus 10y agoUnfortunately New York isn't the only place pricing people out of a home. By the way, About 2% of Americans live in New York City alone. At least 1% are not having a great time with rent that outstrips their potential earnings.
- civilian 10y agoAs long as we're being pedants, it's actually more like 2.6% (8.406 / 318.9) of Americans who live in NYC. The author does have a grip on reality, I think it's just they aren't talking about what you want them to talk about.
- S_Daedalus 10y agoI don't think that opening with an insult is in the spirit of what this site is about, do you?
- lobster_johnson 10y agoThey describe the "1-2 months free" phenomenon as something new, but that has existed for at least several years. It's the way they coax people into these new developments. (Why people think that's attractive, I don't know; given the absurd prices, it's a drop in the ocean if you intend to live in the same place for a while.) I've never seen three months offer, so maybe that's what's new.
- Nav_Panel 10y agoI live in Brooklyn (not Downtown Brooklyn, though) in an old building with a totally new (gut renovated) interior. My flatmate and I are paying above market rent, but not that much (only a few hundred more per person), and it's worth it for the amenities (duplex apartment, central AC, no issues from "deferred maintenance"). We got a month free and have no broker fee. With these conditions, we're actually paying pretty close to market rent. I probably wont be sticking around for longer than 2 years, so we got a pretty decent deal all things considered.
- 35bge57dtjku 10y agoIt sounds like you're paying an extra month or two or more of rent every year, from the 2 * 300$ per month extra you're paying.
- Nav_Panel 10y agoOk, let's figure this out. Market rent in my area (Bed Stuy) is $2200/mo for a 2BR. I'm splitting $3000/mo. Let's assume I'm staying 2 years and that the $2200 apartment would charge one month's rent as a broker fee (standard practice, often higher). I got one month rent free for my apartment and no broker fee. $2200/mo room * (12 mo * 2 years + 1 month of broker fee) = $55000 total for 2 years. $3000/mo room * (12 mo * 2 years - 1 month free) = $69000 total for 2 years. So, the difference is $14000 / 2 people = $7000 per person over 2 years, or $3500/year over market rent. This comes out to 2-3 months extra per year per person. ... The real question is, is it worth it for what I'm getting? I made the decision that yes, thus far it's worth it. Could I have gotten something cheaper? Sure. I was paying less when I lived in Manhattan ($900/mo!). But I like having central air (very few NYC apartments do), I like having no neighbors above/below my bedroom (I DJ/produce in my spare time and I wouldn't want to bother anyone. Also in Manhattan I had a situation involving a neighbor upstairs...), I like living across from the train (cheaper apartments are at least a few blocks walk), and I like having a good amount of space to myself. It's nice to have roof access, and the apartment is quiet and bright. As a software developer I'm making enough to not feel strained budget-wise. I think it makes sense to spend a little extra on living in a nice place. Lord knows there are enough crappy apartments in NYC.
- cbr 10y agoBuilding enough housing that rents start to come down is a great thing, and it's frustrating that they're pushing the negative angle here.
- mwsherman 10y agoI live in one of those buildings. It's about 12 minutes to work in downtown Manhattan if the train timing works out. I am unclear if this article is quoting the "net effective" rate, where the free month is amortized over a year. Mine is around $2750 effective, while monthly is around $2950.
- civilian 10y agoFingers crossed that Seattle heads for this direction! I've been trying to imagine a scenario which would cause Amazon not to hire for 2-3 years, (and thus tank housing prices? hopefully?) without hurting my own (software engineering) career prospects. I haven't come up with anything yet.
- finid 10y ago> Brooklyn, he said, is still “the coolest place on the planet.” Does that include Brownsville and East New York? Brownsville is were Mike Tyson and Riddick Bowe grew up. Tough neighborhood
- eric_h 10y ago>> Brooklyn, he said, is still “the coolest place on the planet.” >Does that include Brownsville and East New York? Most people who say that are neither from New York nor have ever been to either Brownsville or East New York, though they may have seen a documentary that described them (and continued to pretend that places like that don't exist in their sacred, hipster Brooklyn). Brooklyn is cool, don't get me wrong, but "the coolest place on the planet"? Surely not. You don't hear the sound of someone getting murdered by gunshots 1000 ft away from you while smoking a cigarette on the stoop in "the coolest place on the planet" (true story) (I'm not a native new yorker, but have lived here, in three of the boroughs, for 15 yrs)
- finid 10y agoFor the 15 years you lived there, how many times did you venture into Brownsville or East New York? I don't even remember any attraction for anybody not resident in those two places.
- eric_h 10y agoNever, but I did live in the neighborhood to the west of it (Crown Heights) for a few years (where the shooting I mentioned happened). Crown Heights is much more gentrified now than when I lived there.
- finid 10y agoHas that gentrification extended to the rough area between Eastern Parkway and Atlantic Ave.?