4 ms·
Most relevant Internet bodies are noncommercial organisations, like ICANN, IETF, RIPE, ARIN, APNIC, AFNIC, LACNIC, the various Internet exchanges (xxCIX), some
by okket 10y ago
Most relevant Internet bodies are noncommercial organisations, like ICANN, IETF, RIPE, ARIN, APNIC, AFNIC, LACNIC, the various Internet exchanges (xxCIX), some DNS registrars are noncommercial too. But someone has to run the actual cables, manage customers, host servers, etc.
I'd say the Internet has a very good balance between commercial interests and the noncommercial "public good". So good in fact, that some very restrictive governments choose to opt out and create nationwide intranets (China, Iran, ...)
- borkborkbork 10y agoChina and Russia are doing this largely to avoid Western cultural and political influence. Their choice to opt out does not necessarily imply that we're structuring our networks in the most just or efficient way.
- sliverstorm 10y agoIt does imply that we are structuring our networks in a way that doesn't have the capabilities for restriction that they would like.
- borkborkbork 10y agoThat's correct. We don't enforce restrictions on political speech or deviant pornography, for the most part. But we do enforce intellectual property restrictions that largely benefit Western corporate interests.
- okket 10y agoTo me it is a testament for the resilience and sane architecture of the Internet as we know it that restrictive governments can not achieve their goal without changing the underlying structure of their part to a central controlled version. Other technologies like the radio or telephone were centralised by default, so much more "dictatorship friendly".
- borkborkbork 10y agoThe U.S. government seems to have no trouble achieving its commercial and surveillance goals under the current architecture.
- okket 10y agoReally? I only hear western governments whining that encryption threaten their surveillance powers [1][2]. [1] http://bigstory.ap.org/article/7d57f576e3f74b6ca4cd3436fbebf160/comey-fbi-wants-adult-conversation-device-encryption http://bigstory.ap.org/article/7d57f576e3f74b6ca4cd3436fbebf... [2] http://www.theverge.com/2016/8/24/12621834/france-germany-encryption-terorrism-eu-telegram http://www.theverge.com/2016/8/24/12621834/france-germany-en...
- borkborkbork 10y agoYour argument assumes it's not within their power to end this threat. In fact, the Senate proposed a bill that does just that [1]. There's nothing inherent to the current architecture that prevents the government from compelling companies to do their bidding. We've seen that time and time again with NSA surveillance. The crux of this article is that the Internet was largely funded by the public, then handed over to an oligopoly of telecoms in the 1990's. There's nothing about this arrangement that protects average users. In fact, it is partially responsible for the U.S. having the slowest average broadband speeds of any industrialized nation [2]. [1] http://www.dailydot.com/layer8/encryption-backdoors-legislation-richard-burr-diane-feinstein/ http://www.dailydot.com/layer8/encryption-backdoors-legislat... [2] http://gizmodo.com/why-americas-internet-is-so-shitty-and-slow-1686173744 http://gizmodo.com/why-americas-internet-is-so-shitty-and-sl...
- badsock 10y agoIn BC, Canada the provision of electricity and water are by provincial/municipal governments, have very similiar requirements in terms of running wires/pipes, and in my experience have delivered much better services. They don't constantly try to gouge me. I've had to call their support lines maybe a few times my entire life (as opposed to many tens of times for telcos). And I really don't see how sending bits could be more difficult than delivering high voltage or pressurized water.
- zdw 10y agoThis is exactly right. Most services that lend themselves to a natural monopoly (because most people only really need one power/water/phone/internet line to their house/business) should be implemented as a publicly run infrastructure with value added ISP's on the end. The current vertical integration of internet providers impedes any new competition. Arguing for integration is like saying that all roads should be owned by the "Road Company" that also happens to be the "Car Company" and you can only use an expensive car you bought from them on their road.
- wonder_er 10y ago> The current vertical integration of internet providers impedes any new competition Wouldn't the government owning the service be the ultimate impediment to new competition? I'm not defending ISPs, but lets not too quickly throw them under the bus. Also, your casual throw-away comment: > Most services that lend themselves to a natural monopoly ... should be implemented as a publicly run infrastructure Requires the government forcibly taking over quite a few large companies. That's a weighty request, and would be exactly the opposite of what we should want to see in the world.
- damptowel 10y ago> Requires the government forcibly taking over quite a few large companies. That's a weighty request, and would be exactly the opposite of what we should want to see in the world. Yet this is exactly what happened in developed countries in the 20th century, now many of these are again privatized with the predictable loss of efficiency and increased bureaucracy (supporting frameworks, arbitrage, watchdogs, etc...). In my country the privatization of public transit and energy companies has been a total disaster. I remember when I could get things done without being pingponged between 12 different parties, things that used to take a day now take weeks.