5 ms·
I cannot agree more, I do the same, and invite everyone else to do so. - Useful as a canary of which website has been breached - Useful as a canary of which w
by cm2187 10y ago
I cannot agree more, I do the same, and invite everyone else to do so.
- Useful as a canary of which website has been breached
- Useful as a canary of which website sold your details
- and if your details are in the wild, you can stop the spam by deleting the address
Credit cards should work the same way: a unique authorization code specific to this vendor or this transaction and useless to any other actor.
- markdown 10y ago> Credit cards should work the same way: a unique authorization code specific to this vendor or this transaction and useless to any other actor. Isn't that how chip-and-pin works?
- cm2187 10y agoExcept that the merchant still gets to see my credit card numbers (both sides). But it's how paypal works. The merchant only get an authorization code from paypal, and this code is useless to a hacker.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> the merchant still gets to see my credit card numbers (both sides) With chip and pin? I don't think they do.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoIn the UK the numbers are printed on the receipt - part obfuscated on the customers copy, fully shown on retailer copy. So whilst the retailer may not touch the card they still get everything except the magic 3 digits. Where I work you need the 3 digit security code and some address numbers (which you can make up) to properly process a transaction without the card.
- chrisseaton 10y agoYes that's what I said - they don't see both sets of numbers.
- tzs 10y agoChip and PIN cards can support tokenization, which prevents the merchant (or anyone who has hacked the merchant) from seeing the card number, but they are not required to do so. I haven't seen any numbers on what fraction of cards use tokenization. Something to keep in mind is that when chip and PIN was developed to combat credit card fraud it was card present fraud that was the big problem, either by someone using the stolen card itself at a brick and mortar merchant or making a counterfeit cart by writing the stolen number onto a blank card and using that at a brick and mortar merchant. Card not present fraud, where the number is used but not a card such as at an online merchant or a mail order merchant or telephone order merchant, was much less common. Chip and pin made card present fraud much harder because it was much harder to obtain blank chip cards and the equipment to write a stolen number to them, and it made using an actual stolen card harder because of the PIN.
- cm2187 10y agoChip and pin is not for online transactions, but in-store transactions. The merchant can see your credit card and would often manipulate it themselves.
- stfnfhrmnn 10y agoI also use a Unique-per-service email address with Paypal, and I noticed that Paypal actually passes on that email address to the retailer when I pay with Paypal. I receive order confirmation emails (from those retailers) and quite a few unwanted newsletters to my unique paypal address now. I have no idea what Paypal is trying to achieve by passing on this fairly personal piece of data. I always have to enter a separate email address with the retailer anyway, and because of this scheme, those two of course never match.
- syshum 10y ago>>>I have no idea what Paypal is trying to achieve by passing on this fairly personal piece of data. For years the Paypal API sucked, and even today their are many companies that do not have full integration with paypal, so this is a way to match payment records as for 99% of shoppers the email address for the order/account will match the paypal email address.
- throwanem 10y agoPaypal is great at that kind of unintentional disclosure. Six or eight years back, because I liked what she had to say, I used it to donate to someone who was then speaking under a pseudonym as a result of some fairly credible threats. Imagine my surprise when, in the process of transferring funds, Paypal showed me her full legal name and domicile address in the UI! Of course I let her know about it, and I seem to recall her saying she'd addressed it successfully, but if she described how, I no longer remember. It quite astonished me that this was even a thing that could happen, though. One hopes it no longer does.
- ramblerman 10y agoThis sounds like she just set up her full name and address with paypal. It's like her giving out her email address and it being firstname.lastname@gmail.com I'm not sure the fault lies with the service.
- throwanem 10y ago
- znebby 10y agoFor credit cards, check out privacy.com I recently started using it, works great.
- crypt1d 10y agoThis looks pretty cool, but seems like they are invite-only for now... Any chance you can drop an invite for a fellow HNer? :)
- jontas 10y agoI've got an invite, contact me via the email in my HN profile and I'll send it over.
- crypt1d 10y agoI just checked their sign up page, turns out they are only available in the US for now :( But thanks anyway!
- znebby 10y agoI found an early access code on their twitter: "NETTED". They posted that 1st August, so I'm not sure if it still works, but give it a shot!
- ruraljuror 10y agoNifty. Discover Card offers this--or at least did when I was using it.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThey got rid of it.
- tmd83 10y agoWondering how this works. If one is using different number per transaction where they are getting so many free numbers?
- raverbashing 10y agoIs there a service (email host) that can give you "infinite email aliases"? (Yes, I know about the '+' in gmail, but I suspect the word is out on it)
- ikeboy 10y agohttps://dnt.abine.com/ https://dnt.abine.com/
- MandieD 10y agoA Small Orange does this cheerfully, even for the smallest shared hosting plan. You can then go into cPanel to configure a catch-all account for the domain you're using. Biggest downside to ASO: you have to pay $7/yr extra on domain registrations to make them private. So I register with Hover and host with ASO.
- ryanplant-au 10y agoI use Google Apps for Work on my domain, which lets me forward all email to any address on that domain to my inbox. That way I can use adobe@ryanplant.net, github@ryanplant.net, fitbit@ryanplant.net, etc.
- samch 10y agoI do this exact same trick and have been using it for years. It led to a couple of brief and somewhat awkward phone calls with local business owners when I asked them rather pointedly about them sharing my information with third parties. I also take this one step further and have inbox rules to automatically send all promotional email (from sites I'm interested in) to the trash folder. If I want a coupon for a website I frequent, I'll just search my trash for the latest offers from that company. Google conveniently purges messages from the trash folder every 30 days or so, and I don't have to worry about a massive backlog of promos.
- qznc 10y agoThe problem is, I have yet to someone who accepts '+' in email address.
- 10y ago
- Spooky23 10y agoRe: credit cards, unless you insist on using debit cards for some reason, who cares if they are compromised. If someone steals my credit card, AMEX has a problem. I'll take reasonable care, but I'm not going to generate transaction specific numbers or whatever unless there is a strong incentive to do so.
- _asummers 10y agoI wish that it was much easier to generate temporary credit card numbers for all transactions. Like upon entering real number it would generate one and swap it for you.
- mi100hael 10y agoI believe that's pretty much what Apple Pay and the like do.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoCorrect. My android pay says "a virtual number ending in xxxx was used to make this purchase." It would be nice if it was a token instead of an actual credit card number. I have no idea how is implemented.
- feklar 10y agoMany had this feature (and Paypal for a while) but dropped it for some reason. My guess is they want to encourage subscription/repeat billing or some kind of fraud was rampant generating temporary numbers.
- krupan 10y agoand AMEX passes the cost of that problem to all AMEX customers. You are still paying for it in the end.
- willstrafach 10y agohow so? when a card is fraudulently used to make purchases, AmEx is not refunding you from their own pockets. they take back the money from the merchant it was fraudulently spent with (a chargeback). no loss at all on their side.
- krupan 10y ago"a unique authorization code specific to this vendor or this transaction and useless to any other actor" Sounds a lot like a bitcoin address.
- rspeer 10y ago...except not traceable, works with people's payment systems, sends actual US dollars, and doesn't have a 5% chance of getting stolen.
- krupan 10y agoThat's an amazing system you just invented, I wish it existed :-)
- rspeer 10y agoFine, "not traceable by arbitrary people on the Internet". I know the credit card company and everyone they share your data with can see your transactions, and that's a problem some may wish to avoid, but that is still a much smaller number of people who can see your transactions than Bitcoin. Bitcoin does not inherently include privacy.
- krstck 10y agoI wish phone numbers could work this way. When my personal data gets leaked or sold, just revoke access to that particular token.