3 ms·
TOS != legal right to block access to public data. Especially when it's crawled, where one is not expected to read the TOS. It's equivalent to having a docume
by Groxx 17y ago
TOS != legal right to block access to public data. Especially when it's crawled, where one is not expected to read the TOS. It's equivalent to having a document posted in the bathroom of a restaurant that says that by walking into the building you forfeit your right to see.
Too bad it didn't go to court, he could've countersued then. There could be definite personal damages because of all this, and because FB is flexing legal-might it doesn't have.
And I cry bullshit on FB trying to protect privacy. Why then is everything public by default when a new feature comes out? At every step of the embiggening process, FB has royally screwed over their users' privacy.
- techiferous 17y ago"And I cry bullshit on FB trying to protect privacy." Absolutely. That's why I rarely use it; I've read their privacy policy (especially the privacy policy concerning facebook applications) and realized that if I wanted something to be just between me and my friends, facebook is not the place to do that.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI too am dubious of Facebook and avoid posting anything especially private there. But being on Facebook, I also know that most of my friends are much less careful about this and I am happy that Facebook makes some effort to protect their rather foolish trust. It would be better for them to protect themselves but still...
- Groxx 17y agoBy picking something interesting, which anyone can still do (and far more invasive uses as well), and making a big deal of it? This is a publicity stunt, more likely, because his work spread quickly, and normal people started to notice that this said things about them.
- Daniel_Newby 17y ago"TOS != legal right to block access to public data." You seem to be arguing that Facebook should only be able to choose between "everything goes" or "hidden behind a contractual login wall". However in the U.S. the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act requires computers to be used only with the owner's authority. The key is that authority can be conferred by means other than a formal contract, and instant monetary damages apply only to access control violations. This is good! It lets you use public services without a barrier to entry or legal risk. If the provider does not like it, they have to suck it up until they find out who you are. Then they can order you to stop, and if you stop the matter is over.