5 ms·
1. Two multinational corporations staffed by highly sophisticated investors came up with a contract. One corporation then enforced the terms of the contract. H
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
1. Two multinational corporations staffed by highly sophisticated investors came up with a contract. One corporation then enforced the terms of the contract.
How evil.
4. The "qualified investors" knew that the contract might obligate them to pay out large sums of money. If you bet money on a horse race, you better plan for losing.
On the other hand, Goldman (and everyone else) did not expect gigantic AAA counterparties to go bankrupt. If you bet money on a horse race, you might not plan for winning but then having the track going bankrupt.
- jbooth 17y agoI'm sure that Goldman was capable of whipping out a pocket calculator, figuring out how much money was going to pay out and figuring out that that's more than the GDP of some european countries. "Nobody could have predicted" is the worst kind of excuse. Also, when entities go bankrupt, usually all of their debtors get a % of the money they're owed, because if they could get paid everything, then there wouldn't be a bankruptcy. The feds should have told Goldman and everyone else "Here you go, 50 cents on the dollar, take it or leave it". They would have taken it and everything would have been fine.
- vlod 17y agoNo everything would NOT have been fine. There was a real fear in the market. By 100% backing any bank that failed, the FEDs allowed the flow of money to continue through the economy and it said a very clear message that everyones money is safe. Imagine if everyone thought their money was not safe in their bank accounts. That everyone started taking out all their money. The system would have collapsed.
- Daniel_Newby 17y ago"No everything would NOT have been fine. There was a real fear in the market." For good reason: many large financial institutions were based on fraud. People were worried that there was nothing backing up their deposits because there really was nothing backing up their deposits. "By 100% backing any bank that failed, the FEDs allowed the flow of money to continue through the economy ..." No, to prevent a panic you back up depositors. "Worried that your checking account might evaporate, that you might not be able to make payroll because they stole your money? Don't worry, our printing press has you covered. And the crooks? They be goin' to jail." The inflationary costs would have been eye popping, but they would be over rapidly, and a foundation of trust would have been laid for future growth. Instead they bailed out the con artists with taxpayer money. This will either have to be covered by punitive taxes for decades (destroying business recovery through low profits), or by massive inflation at some unknown time in the near future (choking off business recovery through fear). Meanwhile the institutionalization of fraud creates direct fear that prevents reasonable speculation.
- vlod 17y ago"For good reason: many large financial institutions were based on fraud." Where's the fraud in these investment banks? Maybe your referring to the brokers (in the high street) who actually sold the subprimes to people buying houses? Maybe.. but that's certainly not investment banks. The article says: "and instead dealt only with hedge funds, insurance companies, and large financial institutions, so-called qualified buyers that, under SEC rules, are expected to understand the risks." They sold it to people who can understand these financial instruments. "because there really was nothing backing up their deposits." FDIC was backing up their deposits, well to 100K at least. "This will either have to be covered by punitive taxes for decades" The Treasury just didn't give them free money, they sold them warrants (AFAIK). The money is starting to come back in. The US Treasury just made $8B in profits from Citibank: http://goo.gl/rM9E http://goo.gl/rM9E
- codexon 17y ago1. When anyone loans money or buys an insurance policy, they are subject to counterparty risk: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/counterpartyrisk.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/counterpartyrisk.asp What is evil is that if it was you instead of Goldman Sachs, AIG would have paid you pennies on the dollar instead of the full value on paper. 4. See #1. Counterparty risk is part of every deal. Example: If you took a bet from Joe Sixpack that would probably pay $1000, but possibly $10 million (more than his life time earnings), the US government would not, and should not, be using taxpayer money to pay you $10 million in the worst case scenario. Unless you happen to be Goldman Sachs.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe post I'm responding to is not criticizing the bailout, it is criticizing Goldman for enforcing it's contracts with AIG. For the record, I'm not defending the bailout, I've always opposed the bailout, and one of my highest rated comment on HN ever is a snarky post criticizing the bailout.
- codexon 17y agoit is criticizing Goldman for enforcing it's contracts with AIG It is nowhere near the financial norm to expect companies to have the government pick up the tab for failed counterparties. Why can't people criticize Goldman for doing that? Can I not criticize multi-billion dollar companies for putting former members into high ranking officers to influence the politics? Can I not criticize connected donors that break laws and then are able to get a pardon from the President? Just because they can, doesn't mean they should.
- vlod 17y agoSo what your saying is that the CEO who used to run the most successful bank on Wall St and probably knows more about financial markets than the majority of people shouldn't be used to run the FED? Who would you want to run the FED? An elected politician? :)
- jimbokun 17y agoMy understanding was that the money paid to Goldman came out of the pockets of the American taxpayer, through AIG and into Goldman's pockets. Sure, AIG owed Goldman money. But when AIG went belly up, why did the U.S. taxpayer step in to pay Goldman in AIG's place?
- yummyfajitas 17y ago"Goldman colluded with Bush and Pelosi to rob America" is a very different claim than "Goldman tried to collect money that AIG owed them". The former claim implies Goldman is evil (nearly as evil as Bush/Pelosi). The latter claim does not.
- jimbokun 17y agoAre they mutually exclusive? It is perfectly possible that Goldman colluded with Bush and Pelosi (no Obama?) to get money into AIG that they knew would then flow into their pockets.
- vlod 17y agoThe FED believed that if AIG was not saved then the whole system would have collapsed and the flow of money would have seized up. e.g Small companies that call to banks for short term loans (to pay payroll for example) would not have any more left and would close up shop.
- anamax 17y ago> On the other hand, Goldman (and everyone else) did not expect gigantic AAA counterparties to go bankrupt. Greenspan says that evaluating counter-party risk was SOP at the private institutions where he worked before joining the fed. He claims that he knew more about the state of his competitors when he was in private biz than he did about the state of the same institutions when he was in the fed. > If you bet money on a horse race, you might not plan for winning but then having the track going bankrupt. You may not plan for it, but it happens. More to the point, it doesn't matter whether Goldman planned for it - they were willing to take the profit, so they should take the loss as well.
- Daniel_Newby 17y ago"1. Two multinational corporations staffed by highly sophisticated investors came up with a contract. One corporation then enforced the terms of the contract. How evil." Yes. Goldman knew the contract was fraudulent. They signed it to create a bogus asset that they could list on their balance sheet, allowing them to speculate using what should have been reserves. If AIG could not pay, they would simply write it off and lose a pittance (the few percent they paid AIG), small compared to the returns they could get on the speculations. If by some miracle AIG did pay, Goldman would throw a party where it rained money and cocaine. "On the other hand, Goldman (and everyone else) did not expect gigantic AAA counterparties to go bankrupt." First, a proper financial investigation ("due diligence") looks into the risk that the counterparty will spend all the money on fast cars and hookers. Second, if Goldman did not expect bankruptcies, then why did they buy insurance for bonds they did not own? Buying a derivative by itself is not a hedge, it is speculation.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYes. Goldman knew the contract was fraudulent. Do you have any evidence for this? Also, expecting an AAA rated multinational corporation to pay their debts is hardly a "miracle". Second, if Goldman did not expect bankruptcies, then why did they buy insurance for bonds they did not own? Home "owners" defaulting on mortgages is not the same thing as AIG going bankrupt. Goldman expected the former, not the latter (at least according to the article).
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoThe evidence is that they made a one-way bet with an insurance company, rather than a hedge with a derivatives trader. That's like buying fire insurance for a smoking building that somebody else owns. They knew anybody with a few $100k could buy a AAA rating -- they were buying them themselves.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe evidence is that they made a one-way bet with an insurance company, rather than a hedge with a derivatives trader. That's like buying fire insurance for a smoking building that somebody else owns. You are accusing Goldman of speculation, not fraud. Incidentally, insurance is a derivatives contract. Any insurance company is a derivatives trader, AIG Financial Products in particular.