8 ms·
Goldman Sachs: Don't Blame Us
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoWhat bullshit. 1. Goldman blew up AIG by making AIG post collateral based on market prices (for bond insurance AIG had written). Because this is only fair. 2. Goldman got the feds to pay off the insurance at 100% value, not market value. Without an insurable event happening, and without executing the insurance by delivering the bonds. 3. Goldman used the pay off to buy the bonds. At unspecified prices, presumably market prices if we read between the lines. 4. "Qualified investors" knew what they were getting into massive risks buying certain instruments. They were well informed and knew how to investigate and rate risk properly. But when Goldman bought bond insurance from AIG, they were shocked, shocked to find AIG could not pay.
- AmericanOP 17y ago2. If I recall, GS expected and was prepared to take the hit right before bailout bonanza.
- afterburner 17y agoI'll bet they knew they'd be among the first to benefit from bailouts if there were any at all though, given the Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson was an ex-CEO of GS.
- Estragon 17y agoYou can't blame them for bullshitting. They've been dodging responsibility for this kind of thing for at least the better part of a century, and it seems to work for them. http://books.google.com/books?id=YoXZWqBIIE8C&pg=PA64 http://books.google.com/books?id=YoXZWqBIIE8C&pg=PA64
- idm 17y agoIt's still okay to blame them for bullshitting. I assume your point is that they've never experienced negative outcomes for their previous bullshitting, so there's no reason for them to do anything different, and I'd have to agree...
- yummyfajitas 17y ago1. Two multinational corporations staffed by highly sophisticated investors came up with a contract. One corporation then enforced the terms of the contract. How evil. 4. The "qualified investors" knew that the contract might obligate them to pay out large sums of money. If you bet money on a horse race, you better plan for losing. On the other hand, Goldman (and everyone else) did not expect gigantic AAA counterparties to go bankrupt. If you bet money on a horse race, you might not plan for winning but then having the track going bankrupt.
- jbooth 17y agoI'm sure that Goldman was capable of whipping out a pocket calculator, figuring out how much money was going to pay out and figuring out that that's more than the GDP of some european countries. "Nobody could have predicted" is the worst kind of excuse. Also, when entities go bankrupt, usually all of their debtors get a % of the money they're owed, because if they could get paid everything, then there wouldn't be a bankruptcy. The feds should have told Goldman and everyone else "Here you go, 50 cents on the dollar, take it or leave it". They would have taken it and everything would have been fine.
- vlod 17y agoNo everything would NOT have been fine. There was a real fear in the market. By 100% backing any bank that failed, the FEDs allowed the flow of money to continue through the economy and it said a very clear message that everyones money is safe. Imagine if everyone thought their money was not safe in their bank accounts. That everyone started taking out all their money. The system would have collapsed.
- Daniel_Newby 17y ago"No everything would NOT have been fine. There was a real fear in the market." For good reason: many large financial institutions were based on fraud. People were worried that there was nothing backing up their deposits because there really was nothing backing up their deposits. "By 100% backing any bank that failed, the FEDs allowed the flow of money to continue through the economy ..." No, to prevent a panic you back up depositors. "Worried that your checking account might evaporate, that you might not be able to make payroll because they stole your money? Don't worry, our printing press has you covered. And the crooks? They be goin' to jail." The inflationary costs would have been eye popping, but they would be over rapidly, and a foundation of trust would have been laid for future growth. Instead they bailed out the con artists with taxpayer money. This will either have to be covered by punitive taxes for decades (destroying business recovery through low profits), or by massive inflation at some unknown time in the near future (choking off business recovery through fear). Meanwhile the institutionalization of fraud creates direct fear that prevents reasonable speculation.
- steveplace 17y agoAIG FP made AIG blow up. GS maybe threw some firecrackers in.
- stretchwithme 17y agoThe real problem is not that Goldman Sachs knows how to exploit bubbles or that they sell bad products or turn to the government when their gambles don't pay off. The real problem is that our government seems to be at the beck and call of Goldman Sachs and entities like it. Congress has even surrendered its responsibility for our money to the Federal Reserve, a scheme hatched by bankers that created the bubble leading up to first great depression.
- borism 17y agotin foil hat alert!
- cynicalkane 17y ago"First great depression"? The "first" great depression had the Dust Bowl, mass migration, people starving to death right in public, shantytowns popping up everywhere, and 25% unemployment. The "first" great depression had a 30% decline in GDP. When was the second great depression?
- pw0ncakes 17y agoI call this the Petty Depression. It's not nearly as bad as the depression of the 1930s, but it's worse than a recession. Recession is the predictable, brief, and necessary period of creative destruction and contraction in a functioning economy. It causes some people to get laid off, but they usually get better jobs within 1-3 years, and the economy as a whole improves. This is something else, and will have a long-term scarring effect on the nation. The fact that "petty" means both small (which this one is, as far as depressions go) and mean-spirited (price-gouging on housing with young families at the barrel-end) means it fits surprisingly well.
- stretchwithme 17y agohow about we see how this goes before we declare it healed? The government borrowing massively to keep the government sector expanding and is paying people to consume in an effort to convince everybody that things are recovering. This is not sustainable and only worsens our situation. One day, we must face up to our debts. We'll be very lucky if interest rates aren't jacked up on us. And, as in Japan, it seems they want to keep the zombie banks alive and avoid acknowledging the extent of the problems.
- hackermom 17y agoIt's so hilarious seeing bankers and investers pointing finger elsewhere - especially Goldman Sachs, of all the greedy, evil people...
- AmericanOP 17y agode facto monopoly, at minimum.
- lrm242 17y agoGreedy, sure ok. But 'evil'... seriously?
- pw0ncakes 17y agoGoldman Sachs is pretty fucking scummy, but not substantially worse than the rest of Wall Street; anyway, the pace-setting for scumbaggery was set in the past by many firms that don't even exist anymore. The only thing I would call evil about GS is the way it is managed to convert its economic power into political power, thus preventing proper regulation of the banking industry, and that's the government's fault (and ours) as much as it is theirs.
- AmericanOP 17y agoFinally some macro on HN :) I can buy the argument that Goldman didn't see the subprime coming since they were initially exposed (or so the story goes http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2010/04/wall-street-excerpt-201004?printable=true¤tPage=1. http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2010/04/wall-str...) Because of this, they were the first big bank to see the coming pop, and acted. However, while their CFO may be the most "frustrated" he's ever been during his 30 years as a Goldmanite, I'm the most frustrated I've ever been in my 23 years as an American. To see this bank make millions every day because a luiqidity-at-all-costs monetary policy issues taxpayer debt to TBTFs as near-zero % interest loans which they use to jack the DOW to all time highs is ridiculous. Yes, the US government is totally unable to tackle the country's financial problems which creates opportunities for I-banks like GS, but I can hardly believe the right path requires a bonanza for these guys. Non-CNBC headlines consistently point to a blatant conflict of interest between fiscal policy and wall street profits (today: http://www.zerohedge.com/article/guest-post-tim-geithner-sniveling-scamster. http://www.zerohedge.com/article/guest-post-tim-geithner-sni...) They want to play the dangerous game of squeezing the heart of our nation during a time of impending crisis.. look to Blackwater for PR advice. Obligatory: http://creattica.com/photoshop/ut104/18473 http://creattica.com/photoshop/ut104/18473
- pasbesoin 17y agoYour second link needs to drop the trailing period: http://www.zerohedge.com/article/guest-post-tim-geithner-sniveling-scamster http://www.zerohedge.com/article/guest-post-tim-geithner-sni...
- rrhyne 17y agoThey saw it coming. They shorted the same subprime products they were selling. GS bankers are on tape saying they will murder the client on a specific deal related to these shorts.
- DuncanIdaho 17y agoJury, you've heard every word, But before you decide. Would you look into those mother me eyes, I love you, for you my love, For you my love. Don't blame, The sweet and tender hooligan, hooligan, 'Cause he said that he'd never, never, never, never do it again. He was a sweet and tender hooligan, hooligan, Because he'd never, never, never, never do it again. -The Smiths, Sweet and Tender Hooligan
- julio_the_squid 17y agoI approve, Duncan Idaho.
- johnohara 17y agoI don't know whether the actions of GS, AIG, Citi, BoA, Lehman, Merrill, Countrywide, New Century, the Fed or anybody else involved in the slicing and dicing of mortgages constitutes treason but they sure betrayed my trust and confidence in financial institutions, breached my faith in financial markets, and made me realize that investing with these organizations is treacherous. I'm sure the good people of Iceland would agree.
- vlod 17y agoHuh? you lost me. Care to explain how you got from mortgage slicing to treason?
- stretchwithme 17y agohe said he DIDN'T know if it constitutes treason.
- vlod 17y agoAlthough technically he said he 'DIDN'T know', then why did he think it was worth while saying it? He wanted to use the word 'treason' in his argument for affect, without taking responsibility for it's use. Too bad. I'm calling on it. It's like me saying "I don't know if obesity is related to use of baseball caps but i've lost my trust in the government". Yeah.. it's ridiculous.
- sever 17y agoThis situation makes me so mad my teeth hurt, but I don't think Goldman is at fault. They were no better or worse than other i-banks, interspersing themselves into the money flow, probably sucking out more value than they were creating -- I think so. The fault is with the government for bailing them out. They should be bankrupt, shareholders wiped out, company carved up and sold off, making room for better companies. Instead the government decided to give them billions (which they paid out as bonuses to themselves). It was ludicrous, the government gave them 100 cents on the dollar for AIG. Why 100, why not 120, why not 200, it would have made just as much sense.
- vlod 17y ago"Goldman vigorously disputes that it could not have survived if the government hadn't paid it in full" Maybe you missed the part in the article where they said they could have survived without the money. Also the TARP money was pretty much forced on them http://goo.gl/N7SP http://goo.gl/N7SP (businessinsider.com)
- stretchwithme 17y agothey would have survived, but they certainly would have had a big loss without that 12 or 14 billion payoff from AIG.
- clammer 17y agoWeird, no one seems to blame our own government.
- stretchwithme 17y agoI did if you check my first comment.