4 ms·
Money is a [bad] stand-in for value. If "AI" is doing most of the work we have today both mental (programming, financial, etc) and physical (building homes, unc
by Someone1234 10y ago
Money is a [bad] stand-in for value. If "AI" is doing most of the work we have today both mental (programming, financial, etc) and physical (building homes, unclogging toilets, picking up litter) then people would just shift to work which does continue to exist (e.g. creative endeavours) and put value on that instead.
No matter how much you automate and how many jobs are displaced there will always be an infinite amount more work and different jobs will be assigned different values artificially.
To get specific, very few people are needed anymore to supply all the food/water/basics of life to a society. It is all already heavily automated. But are less people employed or are working hours shorter? No. We just found new ways to occupy our time and assigned those a value.
Take the Star Trek universe (where they got rid of money). There's a lot of unanswered questions about that concept, for example how do you divide up land? And who's to say running a wine vineyard is a more productive use of a plot than building a science facility (in particular with replicators in this context).
The more the deep you get into these questions the more artificial the way human society is structured seems. I legitimately think that people will always have jobs/work and there will always be some kind of compensation, but that work will move further and further away from the core resources that keep a society running (and the jobs themselves will have less and less actual value).
- jomamaxx 10y ago"Take the Star Trek universe (where they got rid of money)" The Star Trek universe is basically ridiculous on this concept. There is absolutely nothing wrong with money - moreover, it's basically nutbars to talk about getting rid of it. Money is a medium of exchange so that when we accumulate 'value creation' we can apply that to things we want, rather than have to barter for them (I'll trade you 2 hours consulting for a new pair of shoes). Money is extremely useful. Star Trek got rid of it for ideological reasons - Gene Roddenberry was a little bit of a communist. Those ideas used to be popular i.e. 'If we only got rid of money everything would be fair'. As far as 'division of land' - it's not just land - it's everything. ALL surpluses need to be divided somehow. Unless a centralized state entity steps in and decides all prices (i.e. Soviet Union), well, you let people exchange their services for 'social credit' (i.e. money) and then let them exchange the money for other things and services. "The more the deep you get into these questions the more artificial the way human society is structured seems. " There's nothing 'artificial' about it. It's called 'comparative value' and it's a cornerstone of capitalism.
- monknomo 10y agoWhat about gold pressed latinum? Sure seems like money to me, and for a utopian money-free society the Federation folks always seem to have a few strips for the Ferengi
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Take the Star Trek universe (where they got rid of money). They didn't in the "Star Trek universe" -- money is frequently used in the universe, and often things involving it are part of the plots of episodes. They may (or may not) have done so on Earth or within the Federation more generally (there are mixed indicators, but people at least frequently claim that is true from Next Gen on [actually, I think the first reference is in STIV, though in context that may be a joke more based on the character's immediate circumstances]; its pretty clearly not in TOS, and I think that there is a specific reference to a purchase being made on Earth in STII.)
- pjlegato 10y agoYes. See, for example, Ferengis, a Star Trek race that are obsessed with money.
- pjlegato 10y agoI generally agree, but I wouldn't call the current structure artificial. That means it was somehow planned by a central artificer to have its current structure. The current social structure is rather the result of a very long and decentralized evolutionary process whereby older ways of doing one specific thing were piecemeal replaced by newer attempts, which then either spread or died off. Of course, vestigal parts remain, and sometimes they cause problems.
- flukus 10y ago> No matter how much you automate and how many jobs are displaced there will always be an infinite amount more work and different jobs will be assigned different values artificially. Something that always gets missed in this is the limits on our ability to consume more. We can't eat more, we can't watch more TV because there isn't enough time in the day. The only growth area in consumption lately is gadgets but upgrading them is showing signs of diminishing returns.
- monknomo 10y agoI used to be really excited about new gadgets, but I'm totally unmoved by a slightly thinner phone that does roughly the same thing my old one did. It isn't like 2000, where I would _need_ a new graphics card to play a new video game, or I could get an ipod and not have to haul around a backpack full of cd binders
- jpetso 10y agoI could still get excited about a new phone that sends less data to advertising companies, or that supports a wider range of open standards than the previous one, or that exposes more of its internal tech for developers to use or improve. Perhaps once these devices stop getting better, it will be easier for a community-driven open source OS to occupy a a viable 1-3% market share and make the tech work for us rather than for the rent-seeking companies that own this space today.