5 ms·
Housing Plans in California & New York face resistance from construction unions
- twblalock 10y agoUnions shot themselves in the foot here. Some of the new construction projects would have been run by union shops. Now, they won't happen at all. Net result: fewer union jobs than there could have been. At some point, the unions will need to realize that stuff is going to get done with or without them. They can be part of the process, or not. If they are part of the process, they get some jobs out of it. This should have been a no-brainer.
- themartorana 10y agoAlso, support for unions is waning. Here in Philadelphia, union support is at an all time low. They were rendered toothless in recent elections for the first time ever, and a series of bad press (arson, assault, and destruction of property by union members) and continued ties to organized crime have worn thin sympathies. I also imagine that in difficult economies like ours, the "right" to a job or work over someone else is not looked at favorably when so many are un/under-employed. At this point, unions seem to be the only ones around here that still support unions around here.
- twblalock 10y ago50 years ago, they could have gotten away with this. Now, the demand for housing is so high that the unions can only delay the inevitable. Ironically, the NIMBYs and the unions have ended up on the same side of the housing issue. Most union members I know would be unhappy about being on the side of the privileged and established, and against the working-class people, for whom home affordability is of primary importance in CA and NY.
- hudibras 10y ago>Now, the demand for housing is so high that the unions can only delay the inevitable. The unions agree with you here, that's the whole point. The demand is so high that the developers will soon agree with the unions' requests in exchange for a slightly smaller profit.
- twblalock 10y agoNo, the developers will agree with everyone else except the NIMBYs and the unions, because union workers are a minority of workers, and they don't do a better job than non-unionized workers. In fact, they often do a worse job, because unions protect bad workers who could not survive outside of a union. The days when unions could get their way in these kinds of matters through outright bullying are long gone, and good riddance to them!
- jseliger 10y agoAlso, support for unions is waning. Here in Philadelphia, union support is at an all time low. They were rendered toothless in recent elections for the first time ever, and a series of bad press (arson, assault, and destruction of property by union members) and continued ties to organized crime have worn thin sympathies. For good reason. They prevent accountability among police: http://reason.com/blog/2014/08/14/police-unions-produce-rules-that-protect http://reason.com/blog/2014/08/14/police-unions-produce-rule.... They also prevent educational innovation: https://www.amazon.com/Special-Interest-Teachers-Americas-Schools/dp/0815721293 https://www.amazon.com/Special-Interest-Teachers-Americas-Sc... and pr event urban schools from even functioning. As the topic article points out, construction unions are attacking the housing supply. Should it be a surprise that anyone who pays attention is unhappy with unions?
- twblalock 10y agoI generally agree with what you are saying, but I should point out that private-sector and public-sector unions are very different animals.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoMaybe its because the public looks down upon unions that the middle class is slowly sliding into destitution? [1] [2] I'm definitely not a fan of unions, but besides the movement to push minimum wage up to $15/hr across the country, I don't see any organized groups continuing to push the salary threshold at which overtime pay is required, reducing the number of hours in a work week (which is f___ing insane we're still working ~40 hours a week with how much productivity has grown since the 60's), and so forth. Either unions or political activists must fight for these labor protections; pick your poison. [1] http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/12/09/the-american-middle-class-is-losing-ground/ http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/12/09/the-american-middl... [2] http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/12/09/459087477/the-tipping-point-most-americans-no-longer-are-middle-class http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/12/09/459087477/...
- techdragon 10y agoThe 40 hour work week isn't a productivity related number... It's a cultural construction born from early 20th century union political efforts. For instance in Denmark, the work week is typically 32 hours and has been this way for decades... Works fine for them... Not sure how well it would work in a culture like America where working as hard as possible is considered a good thing... Regardless of how stupidly obvious it is that this screws up work life balance, individual stress levels and by extension individual health, in the country with the most fucked up health care system in the western world...
- vacri 10y agoThere is also the point that most of the big battles have been won, now. The workplace is incredibly safer than it was 100 years ago. Workplace and wage laws are much more mature. There is welfare for the sick and the aged (to varying degrees depending on country). Apart from squabbling over the exact dollar rate for work, there isn't much in the way of big ticket items for unions to get solidarity over. My own personal experience with unions: 'I have a wage problem I need your help with' "You're only a part-time employee. We have to rate the full-time employees more, and we don't have the resources to help you, so no" 'But I pay the same as anyone else. There is no discount for being a part-timer' "(crickets)" So much for solidarity.
- praptak 10y agoThey obviously are a part of the process. And, assuming this stuff will get done with or without them, their strategy is the right one - get as much as possible out of it. In this case it's wage guarantees.
- twblalock 10y agoPeople who kill the process entirely cannot be considered a part of it. The next laws that pass regarding this issue will circumvent the unions. If they wanted a seat at the table, they would not have taken such extreme measures. There is a difference between hardball negotiating, and destroying the very thing the negotiation pertains to.
- cpncrunch 10y agoImpossible to read without subscribing. Incognito doesnt work. Clicking on google search link doesnt work.
- wmil 10y agoClicking the Google search link is working for me. Did you install some privacy proxy that may be screwing with referrer headers? Or is there some new requirement they're checking?
- gameofdrones 10y agoYou're holding it wrong. https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0&q=Construction+Unions+Stymie+Low-Income+Housing+Plans+in+California%2C+New+York https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0...
- mturmon 10y agoHmm, the CFG bookmarklet worked for me...https://blog.umur.io/2015/03/02/paywall-bypass-bookmarklet-come-from-google/ https://blog.umur.io/2015/03/02/paywall-bypass-bookmarklet-c...
- drifting 10y agoHere is a link to the full article: http://www.wsj.com/articles/construction-unions-stymie-low-income-housing-plans-in-california-new-york-1472376601 http://www.wsj.com/articles/construction-unions-stymie-low-i... In the future, copy the URL and paste into new.google.com and click on that link to get the full article
- gameofdrones 10y agoThis one instance might be so (unions are imperfect human endeavors), but this article comes across as thinly-veiled MSM/establishment strawman/false equivocation via the pernicious, irrational, data-free worldview which completely ignores the net positive force unions had in the bloody struggle for worker pay and working conditions in the 19th and 20th centuries. See also: "Inequality for All" and "Where to Invade Next?"
- twblalock 10y agoUnions did a lot for working people. But that's not relevant to the question of whether or not they are on the right or wrong side in this particular case.
- hueving 10y ago"helped in the past" != "helpful now" Burning coal has been a tremendous help to society, but that doesn't mean we should continue to do it when we find better alternatives for each of its use cases. Can you name some of the advancements unions have brought to employees in the US over the last 10-20 years? Does that outweigh their anti competitive nature that has led to companies moving manufacturing out of unionized areas entirely?
- icantdrive55 10y agoOff the top of my head, try being a non-union Electrician, Plumber, etc. in San Francisco for a day. At the end of that day, you will drop to your knees, and thank god for those lefty unions. At the end of a few years, you just might be able to afford a house. Actually San Francisco has a lot of union jobs, and they arn't moving to China. Personally, I think people in tech will look back, and wish they had some Union protection. It's the one profession I'm shocked hasen't completely moved overseas. What's the better alternative? America is better now because got rid of a lot of unions? Yes--a lot of products are made where your boss can get maximum ROI. They are made overseas for a lot of reasons, including lax laws concerning every aspect of that widget. Employee health/happiness/economic viability--who cares. Enviornment--who cares. Ability to pay taxes--who cares. Who cares as long as it's cheaper. Sometimes the cheapest is not the best for society as a whole?
- joe_the_user 10y ago"In California last week, legislators and interest groups declared dead a measure pushed by Gov. Jerry Brown to allow certain apartments with some low-income units to sidestep the state’s environmental review process. " It sounds like unions objected to using "low income housing" as an excuse to "sidestep the state’s environmental review process." I would also. Environmental review shouldn't be an excuse to engage in NIMYBism but environmental review is important to prevent projects that are environmentally destructive. It sounds like every interest group involved here is using "low incoming housing" to ram through the "reforms" they're after.
- twblalock 10y agoThat's a mischaracterization. The law Jerry Brown proposed dealt with "as-of-right" zoning, i.e. if a parcel of land has been zoned for housing, and someone wants to build housing on it, they can do so without the NIMBY neighbors holding up the project indefinitely with frivolous lawsuits and "environmental" reviews. Unfortunately, Brown attached a low-income housing restriction onto it, but it was definitely a step in the right direction. Real environmental review, by qualified people, happens when the land is zoned in the first place. Most "environmental review" lawsuits are not about the environment at all. The real environmental experts already had their say, or else the land wouldn't have been zoned. Most of these lawsuits seek a new review, often for bullshit reasons, and are filed by NIMBYs to bully the developers into giving up on developing the land by piling on years and millions of dollars of litigation. If that fails, they fall back on "quality of life" and noise complaints.
- sologoub 10y agoThat's not how it works, especially in hot markets. Zoning is not absolute and the current process allows for all kinds of variances and exceptions. The Pen Factory project is an excellent example. Local NIMBYs defeated a really neat project that even included low income housing. The original developer said "screw it" and sold the property to a developer that is now doing a by the books and within exact letter of zoning project that will result in a lot of office space and no mitigations for extra traffic or anything. No reviews will stop it. The environmental reviews cannot be used as an effective NIMBY weapon is the developer is using original zoning. Instead, most project I have seen in LA push boundaries for profitability, often resulting in legal fights with locals. Source: http://urbanize.la/post/construction-underway-santa-monicas-pen-factory http://urbanize.la/post/construction-underway-santa-monicas-...
- atemerev 10y agoIf they continue to be uncooperative, just show them this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZnTQMzDvTgc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZnTQMzDvTgc I'd suggest this will improve our (i.e. demand-side) negotiation chances.
- bradleyjg 10y agoI don't know anything about the California controversy and I certainly don't think union workers should mandated on new construction in NYC, but I was glad that tax deal died in Albany. It was a terrible program. Under it billions of dollars of tax revenue over decades which otherwise would have been owed by extremely wealthy people often on their third or fourth home was forgiven and in exchange a few hundred affordable apartments in some of the most expensive neighborhood were handed out to lucky lottery winners. It was about the least efficient affordable housing program imaginable. A much much better idea would have been to collect the full owed property taxes on the new buildings for billionaires going up in Manhattan and use the money to do more good for many more people. Mostly in the outer boros where the dollar goes further.
- GarrisonPrime 10y agoIt would depend on how well that money was managed. If history is any guide, I suspect not well.
- dpark 10y agoIt's hard for me to imagine the government being simultaneously too incompetent to spend tax money sensibly but competent enough to direct an effective lottery based affordable housing program. If you suppose that the government can't spend taxes wisely, then you seemingly must also suppose that any alternative affordable housing program would be run into the ground by the same incompetents.