12 ms·
G.E., the 124-Year-Old Software Start-Up
- akhilcacharya 10y agoThe fact that they air commercials to try to hire developers continually amazes me. I don't think I've seen that before.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CyberDildonics 10y agoYou would think it would be cheaper to pay more or give better benefits.
- hanniabu 10y agoThese commercials are made to lure tech talent by letting them know they're more than the industrial mechanical company they used to be and need people with modern tech skill sets as opposed to knowing how to sling a hammer.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoAt a smaller scale, certainly. If you're talking thousands of developers, marketing yourself as a good place to work becomes cheaper than paying well (i.e., actually being a good place to work).
- halomru 10y ago>paying well (i.e., actually being a good place to work). I don't think good pay and good place to work are synonymous in any way. They happen to be correlated because both are methods to attract talent, but one does not cause the other.
- gaius 10y agoYou can bet they paid zillions to McKinsey or someone, to absolutely minimize their costs for doing it.
- leeoniya 10y agoi find those commercials really weird. "Digital and Industrial" i think speaks more to EEs (of which they have plenty) than to software developers, ML experts, and/or data scientists.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cylinder 10y agoThose commercials have been weird from the start. They make the parents / relatives / friends seem dumb to the point of parody and the "developer" very condescending.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoto my ear, D&I refers more to PLC guys, who are probably closer to being industrial engineers than either EEs or software guys. I've talked to PLC vendors before; they aren't familiar with what it would take to actually do ... more ambitious industrial control. Basic stuff like filters and modest machine learning is a bit beyond what they offer. It's ladder logic and cabling. PLC inventories are measured in decades, not years. It's honorable work, but it's not to be confused with software development.
- mrebus 10y agoThose adds seemed weird to me. I program in the oil/gas space I couldn't imagine thinking working to built some app would be better that actually contributing to real world production. My den at my place is full of aerial shots of all the facilities I programmed. Every time I look at them I am filled with tons of pride.
- dasil003 10y agoThose commercials seem pretty tone deaf to me. I mean the one where his friends don't think he'll still be a programmer because he's working for GE, or the one where his dad doesn't think he can lift a sledgehammer. I get that they're trying to be funny and poke fun at themselves, but there's an undercurrent of condescension and patting this kid on the head that is very off-putting to me as a software engineer. After reading bradrydzewski's comment about the culture at GE it's making a lot more sense. GE just doesn't get software engineers.
- jstepka 10y agoI thought the ads were quite effective. They were saying, yes "apps" for your phone are topical. The point of their commercial was "we work on big crazy complex shit and you can be part of solving a huge challenge". The photos in this article of their manufacture engineering plants amaze me. Now couple those projects with sensors that are starting to giving off TBs of information in an hour and you can start to realize the scale of problems you could be working on at GE. In another 5-10 years, many of the folks grinding it out in silicon valley, or other startupy things will realize they have a desire to have a family and will want to apply their talents towards more meaningful projects than "apps" that do not require being part of silicon valley. Their commercials and this article painted the perfect picture of what's possible at GE and outside of silicon valley in my mind.
- perseusprime11 10y agoThey are trying to fake it till they make it. It's a strategy in itself.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe purpose of those ads is not to attract developers. The purpose of those ads is to invest in GE's brand by creating the impression that young smart developers want to work there. If the ads do attract some developers, that's great too, but that is not enough return to justify the (huge, enormous) cost. These ads seek to do for GE what the "Think Different" ads did for Apple in the 90s.
- NhanH 10y ago> The San Ramon complex, home to GE Digital, now employs 1,400 people. The buildings are designed to suit the free-range working ways of software developers: open-plan floors, bench seating, whiteboards, couches for impromptu meetings, balconies overlooking the grounds and kitchen areas with snacks. It's official now, we're just chickens to the world. So the meme finally sticks and now we're screwed for the next decade? Who do we blame for the idea that "impromptu meetings" and those baloney is the way of working for programmers?
- billmalarky 10y agoBetter to be a free range chicken than a caged chicken.
- dev1n 10y agoThis is true.
- eudox 10y agoActually, cubicles are a good thing.
- nerdponx 10y agoAgreed, there is nothing as distracting to me as an open floor plan. I take every opportunity to work at home that I can get, because my productivity is so much higher when I am out of the office.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agodepends who you work with. I've been working with really immature loud new grads at my current company and the open floor plan is awful. I just want to work and they yell across the room to talk.
- nerdponx 10y ago
- mathattack 10y agoThere are a lot of positive things about GE but let's not call it a startup. It's just not wired that way.
- BooneJS 10y ago> “We had to be more capable in software,” Mr. Immelt said he decided. I hate to be snarky, but I suspect this is not how GE Digital actually came about.
- gist 10y agoActually I hate to be snarky but big CEO's like Immelt that is kind of they way they operate. By gathering and processing big thoughts and issuing directives. It's probably one of a thousand things that he said to people, the other 999 the troops found out and told him didn't have any merit.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoIt's hard for me to think of General Electric without also thinking of Jack Welch and those massive, massive layoffs.
- Spooky23 10y agoPlus the legacy of purposeful pollution, stuff like stack ranking and other scumbaggery. They were a customer of mine, they used to incorporate pencils into leases of capital equipment to reduce tax exposure.
- davidf18 10y agoThey should hire as CEO someone who helped build a software startup into a large company to show the appropriate leadership. Otherwise there will be too much corporate inertia and the old way of doing things. Like Google, they should open up a large tech office in NYC, where many top level software people want to live.
- dadro 10y agoThey are moving their corporate HQ to Boston where many top level software people DO live.
- davidf18 10y agoI lived in Boston (Inman Sq, Cambridge, later Back Bay, Boston) for 5 years after my undergraduate education. NYC is far, far more interesting and exciting than Boston. As an indirect indicator, NYC draws far more VC than Boston.
- cloudjacker 10y ago"As an indirect indicator, NYC draws far more VC than Boston" Far more, he says Anyway not true NYC has alot more capital floating around but the subset of it that is VC isn't more than Boston
- iammaxus 10y agoDepending on the data that you look at, NYC and Boston are pretty close. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/01/global-startup-cities-venture-capital/429255/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/01/global... More importantly, Boston is much heavier into manufacturing technology, hardware, B2B software, etc whereas NYC is more focused on consumer, retail, fashion, etc. Boston is pretty clearly a better choice for GE. In reality GE's HQ in Boston will represent a tiny fraction of their global employees, though, so it doesn't really matter. https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2016/03/11/huge-but-its-future-headquarters-will-anything-but/INqV8GezulQDnQI1tKBxFJ/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2016/03/11/huge-but-its...
- jacques_chester 10y agoPredix is built on top of Cloud Foundry. GE are a Foundation member and one of the major investors in Pivotal, which in turn is the majority donor of engineering on Cloud Foundry. By way of disclosure, I work for Pivotal. None of this should be seen as official comment. So the key thing is: from where I'm sitting, GE are actually serious about this. Really serious. They are not alone. There's this cliché that big companies are all sitting around, waiting to be disrupted, blissfully unaware that someone in the Valley is going to kill them. It's getting to be a less and less plausible strawman. Those business leaders are reading the same books, hearing the same ideas and -- crucially -- many of them are consciously seeking out people who can teach them (including, I guess this is a disclosure, Pivotal Labs, our consulting/coaching wing). Enterprises now want to disrupt themselves, because it 1) hurts their existing competitors and 2) creates moats against startups. The strawman that giant enterprises are ignorant and ripe for disruption because of their arrogance -- the classical model of hubris -- isn't true. Hubris cuts both ways. It's the Valley that's becoming lazy and complacent, assuming that they have a monopoly on interesting problems, on big revenues, on agile and lean development. The barbarians used to be at the gates of Rome. Now the Romans are at the gates of the barbarians, and they're much more heavily armed.
- BurningFrog 10y ago> The strawman that giant enterprises are ignorant and ripe for disruption because of their arrogance -- the classical model of hubris -- isn't true. I'll buy that. I still think they are ripe for disruption because they are giant enterprises. I can't think of any examples of big bureaucratic organizations with a settled culture transforming into something different and better. Normally they get replaced.
- jacques_chester 10y agoThe longevity of these kinds of organisations is a hint that they've survived other disruptions before. We're engaging with more enterprises at Pivotal than we used to. They're all different. Some "get it" really quickly and pow, off they go. Most of our repeated Labs engagements with such customers are because they're trying to transform as quickly as possible by seeding teams all across the org. Others enterprises need, uh, repeated examples. Some will presumably never get it. And yeah, they'll find one day that the party is over. But, to repeat, they're all different. Applying a single rule (enterprise slow, startup fast) to heterogenous situations is a going to pay rich returns ... but not to the venture funds.
- vnfkcmchdjxnc 10y agoYou know you're in a bubble when a company manufacturing jet engines and locomotives tries to rebrand itself as a big data web startup.
- mighty_atomic_c 10y agoHa! When you out it that way, it is very funny, but makes me a bit nervous.
- gaius 10y agoOr when a company that's just a website is worth more than chains of actual, physical hotels.
- lgleason 10y agoThey tried setting some some similar innovative type of tech offices during the .com boom. The offices were closed down and GE went back to their corporate roots. My guess is that history will repeat itself.
- dap 10y agoUsing sensors inside industrial equipment to optimize maintenance schedules and reduce downtime seems among the less-bubbly business ideas to me.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoYou'd think, wouldn't you? I'm exiting that market post-haste.
- simula67 10y ago> Tech giants, including Amazon, Cisco, Google, IBM and Microsoft also have their eye on the industrial internet market, as do a bevy of start-ups. This explains a lot of recent interest in IoT. Big companies like GE saw what happened to companies like Kodak and want to defend their profits. They could be entirely wrong, computing may not turn out add much value in these industries. But GE probably don't want to leave that to chance.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIndustrial is a pretty staid, slow moving market. I'm out of it as soon as the movers get here. It's fantastic, thrilling work but you can't get the people in power to grok what you're doing. It's sad and hard to do, but I've told a colleague who's trying to go into this market ( we were both laid off this year ) "no", because the overall culture isn't ready for it.
- tedmiston 10y ago> Today one of San Ramon’s most important projects is to build a computer operating system, but on an industrial scale ... The project is central to G.E.’s drive to become what Mr. Immelt says will be a “top 10 software company” by 2020. Does anyone know of such a list that's a genuine reflection of reality?
- devonkim 10y agoThe "top" idea is really murky because there's so many ways to define leading. I'll make a large bet that GE Digital will not be top at the following for developers due to so much inertia in IT and software in the company being cost-centric rather than innovation-centric: - Pay / comp - Perks - Perceived difficult technical problems They may win on number employeed (they just announced a big software development office in India) or perhaps when comparing these figures to competitors like Honeywell, Caterpillar, Phillips rather than the big, high value brand software companies. This isn't to say that this means failure. Perhaps they can win on cultural perception (say, work-life balance) or career growth and capitalize upon a backlash against Silicon Valley engineer lifestyles. But everything I've seen about Predix from a customer and engineer perspective, which is what they're betting an awful lot on, is hardly compelling to me.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThis reminds me of my company. The IT department is also calling itself "Digital" now and they are pushing themselves more and more into all company divisions. But they are managed by people who don't have passion for or understanding of technology. Sometimes it feels like the leadership is afraid of technology. They just know that "Digital" and "Big Data" are big now and they have to get into it. It reminds me of the internet bubble times when lots of companies did "internet" without knowing what it really means.
- lgleason 10y agoThey've been saying this for years. Also, I've seen some companies get on the list that were far from the best to work at by gaming the system.
- ww520 10y agoDidn't GE used to do stack ranking review and fire the bottom 10% annually?
- brandonmenc 10y agoYes, but you had a few chances to get out of the bottom. You had to be a "C-player" for something like three consecutive review periods before you were let go. (source: my father was a manager at GE for decades)
- protomyth 10y agoDo they still use stack ranking?
- rhizome 10y agoGE under Jack Welch essentially invented stack ranking and its attendant hardline firings.
- chrisbennet 10y agoDoes anyone know if they fired the bottom 10% of the C suite?
- throwaway65498 10y agoThrowaway, as I work for a company that competes with GE in this space. This is GE's business model. When they want to enter a space, they throw money ($B) at it until they have a business. They tend to prefer organic builout, but they will buy companies or partner if they think they can't win organically. If you're willing to do that, you almost always get some traction, just because you have unimaginable resources and are willing to adjust your tactics if the initial gambit fails. They tend to do a lot of advertising for key businesses - this is why you see GE Aviation billboards in airports, and GE Oil & Gas ads in Houston. The model has worked pretty well in the past - a good example is GE's entry into commercial jet engines in the early 70s. A good example where it failed was GE's computer business in the 60s. I can't prove it (just a feeling), but I think Predix doesn't really have what it takes yet. We've spent a lot of time studying it, and it doesn't seem to offer real value to customers yet. That doesn't mean it won't get there eventually. However, if Predix doesn't do well, we expect them to go on an acquisition spree to buy a few of the winners. Bently Nevada is a good example of that play - GE controls something like 70% of the machinery protection market. They didn't build it, they just went and bought Bently. GE is clearly signaling that they badly want to be in this market, and I think it's pretty likely they'll eventually get there.
- tootie 10y agoOr finance? They just finished unwinding GE Capital after failing at it for 15 years.
- xapata 10y agoSome years (pre-crash) GE Capital made more than the rest of the company combined. Not sure that's failing.
- snowwrestler 10y agoGE Capital was quite successful. GE powered it down because it put them above the threshold for Fed regulation under Dodd-Frank, and they did not want to deal with that.
- mrebus 10y ago
- kqr2 10y agoGE had a commercial blitz during the recent Olympics touting that they are a digital company: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDbfudoXjBM&list=PLxRhTjvLlyoIXJLwUxoQFx7Erz_FUPkJ9 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDbfudoXjBM&list=PLxRhTjvLly...
- bradrydzewski 10y agoI spent 10 years working at GE before I left for SF and the startup world. I was a software engineer at a time when GE was shipping software engineering jobs to India to cut costs. The GE vision for software engineering was that of an assembly line, staffed by large quantities of low wage employees. GE outsourced the majority of its technical jobs to offshore firms. I remember hearing a statistic that for every 1 GE employee in the technology department there were 4 offshore consultants. The role of GE employees in the technology department shifted from a technical skill-set to a managerial skill-set. Many of my co-workers had degrees in finance and marketing, and had never written a line of code in their life. The lack of technical expertise within the organization created what I would call a culture of fear, where people feared the software they managed because they didn't understand it. The official term for offshore software engineers was GDC. I have no clue what the acronym stood for, but over time it certainly become a derogatory term. I remember being mocked by my co-workers for writing code and being nicknamed a GDC (as in, why would you do the work we pay people pennies to do). It was almost like a caste system within the company, where these GDC employees were low paid and looked down upon by many. The offshore model certainly was ineffective and the result of employee discontent, however, the practice was continued and mandated at the executive level. Then the economy crashed. GE decided it was finally time to bring jobs back to the US and hire software engineers. Why? Because they were able to take hundreds of millions in federal tax subsidies from US tax payers. (As an aside, someone mentioned GE moving its HQ to Boston to be closer to engineering talent. Taxes are still the main driver here) GE soon began hiring US software engineers at a number of designated centers where they were segregated from the rest of the company. The interesting thing is that culturally these employees were largely treated like their GDC predecessors. The perception of software engineers being low-wage assembly line employees was, in my opinion, just too engrained into the company culture. So when GE describes this transformation to a software company, I believe the most important aspect of this transformation will be changing the company culture and employee attitudes toward software engineers. They will need to undo a decade long effort to turn engineering into an assembly line.
- weaksauce 10y agoI don't know if it was your division or not but if you were working on ifix software for hmis I can see why this approach didn't work well. Absolute trash software. Not that rockwell's offerings are any better.
- keithpeter 10y ago"Matt Krause, the plant manager, said that last winter, when a snowstorm shut the factory for a day, the sensor network detected that the plant had consumed 1,000 pounds of argon, an inert gas used in coatings for parts. The leak was fixed, saving $350,000 a year." By my (suspect) arithmetic, that is about 200 cubic metres of Argon at STP in one day. Do they have the stuff on mains around the factory?
- iheartmemcache 10y agoNot a materials scientist but argon-oxygen is a common first step in plasma cleaning surfaces (critical especially for allowing whatever you want to CVD to adhere properly to certain metals) before applying primer. (It's also used in nitride hardening aluminium.) Considering how large GE is, I wouldn't be surprised if they had it 'on tap' in a PLT automation network and they take bulk delivery from a supplier every month or two. and some bad process engineer forgot to add a sensor check in loop (or his manager just told him to "screw it, argons cheap, no need to add a flow meter to this process" as a cost cutting factor).
- lgleason 10y agoI worked on one of the projects that C3 was involved in as a GE employee and agree completely with Seibel's assessment. Some things I observed: #1 I watched a top software development company that was doing a great job get fired because they told GE that a desired deadline was impossible. One of the reasons the non-technical manager who fired them gave for the termination was that he didn't feel like they wrote enough lines of code. #2 A very corporate culture. Developers could not wear jeans in the office. You needed come to work in business casual or dressier attire. And this was one of the innovation centers. #3 A "corporate" rollout of TDD where a bunch of enterprise developers who hated TDD were given TDD training and then had no requirement to use it for 6 months....plus none of the other practices that go with it. In the end most devs never adopted the practice. (I am a TDD advocate and trust me I tired to get them to use a different approach but it was like talking to a wall) #4 Crazy bureaucracy to get anything done. Servers need to be in a private double secure cloud (for non production non sensitive components) and developers worked for over a year with out any actual servers to run code on, and were not allowed to stand up servers under you desk as a stop gap due to corporate security. It would even take weeks to even get basics like office supplies that had to go through a special workflow. #5 During this period of no servers, I was in charge of getting the CI infrastructure set up. One time I had a six sigma black belt ask me the status of the project. When I told him it was on hold due to lack of infrastructure he said "Lack of servers is no reason for not being able to roll out CI in our organization" #6 Lots of training for things not needed for your job. Six Sigma (the only useful thing was lean which could have been taught in a quarter of the time). There was a good 20-40 hours of mandatory training per year (at least) for things relating to corporate compliance, safety etc., but not things relating to your job. #7 For one project the use of Javascript was prohibited in favor of using a server side technology that generates it because the enterprise architect thought it would not be realistic to expect Java developers to learn or be able to also know Javascript. #8 It was like pulling teeth to get time off to attend a conference even if you paid for it with your own money. #9 Lots of C-player engineers were promoted because they could play the politics while the good ones who actually could get things done/code left. All of this was over a 2 year period just a few years ago, after Immelt declared they were a software company at one of their newly established "Innovation/Centers of Excellence". Needless to say I have moved on to more interesting work. Though this is a little better than what was described during their outsourcing binge I just don't see GE ever really being able to take on software effectively. Their corporate culture is just not set up for it. They would be much better either having completely separate divisions that they own a stake in but do not manage in any way/shape/form or partnering with companies that do software well. I would love to be wrong, but my guess is that a few decent engineers will join based on the slick ads, and maybe a updated office, things will fall apart and they will move on.
- graffitici 10y ago> Tech giants, including Amazon, Cisco, Google, IBM and Microsoft also have their eye on the industrial internet market, as do a bevy of start-ups. The article doesn't mention any startups. Any ideas what startups could be potential disruptors?
- beilabs 10y agoTravelled to China from Ireland to work with a Chinese software company. Dragged in to work for GE, ended up across a lot of their divisions from 2005 for a few years. Worked out of Atlanta for some time They did not have a software culture at the time, everything was outsourced. Project managers did not have any clue of how to manage a software project professionally, they struck me as more financial / admin types. India and China were like wolves and GE threw projects to them expecting the lowest cost to emerge as the winner. Office was always dead on Friday, there was a culture to often work from home but not actually work. From my understanding at the time they used to cut 10% of the worst performing staff every year, I believe they were one of the worlds largest employers at the time. My biggest peeve was their culture of having meetings just to have meetings....I think this issue can be found in most large enterprises. My cousin now works for GE in Australia and says 'they are trying to become a startup'. I'm not convinced, it's pretty cool to be called a startup but true startups will only thrive in GE if they are left alone by management and allowed to utilise large resources. It can work, small teams can make great inroads for these types of organisations.
- wcummings 10y agoPR piece, bleh.