4 ms·
Allegations that Chompsky was unfair to Dan Everett? Dan Everett is a primarily media-phenomena and fraud (in a whole variety of ways). His claims about the Pi
by joe_the_user 10y ago
Allegations that Chompsky was unfair to Dan Everett?
Dan Everett is a primarily media-phenomena and fraud (in a whole variety of ways). His claims about the Pirahã has been debunked at this point. The main thing is that Everett used the tactic of presenting himself as an outsider challenging a "great" man (who naturally has many enemies).
In considering Everett's dubious claims, take into account that Everett isn't an expert on tropical languages but a missionary who got an impression of one language and leverage this into an entire career.
- k2xl 10y agoWhere have you read that his claims were wrong and have been debunked?
- pastProlog 10y agoEverett himself debunked Everett. Originally he said Piraha was recursive. Then he changed its mind and said it wasn't, thus, all of Chomsky's theories are wrong. He learned to speak Piraha training to be a Christian missionary, not as a linguist. His talk here was with a conservative author, not a linguist.
- k2xl 10y agoEverett was chair of the dept of languages, literatures and cultures at Illinois State and former chair of the linguistics department at university of pittsburg...
- Khansike 10y agoUp to you whether to accept the conclusions of this article, or Everett's reply, or the reply to the reply (all linked from this site): http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/000411 http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/000411
- daniel-cussen 10y agoI know, by name and face-to-face, a serious university professor, a linguist and "expert on languages," as you put it, who does know Dan Everett and does not think he's a fraud. He was proud of knowing him, in fact.
- mcguire 10y ago"...presenting himself as an outsider challenging a "great" man (who naturally has many enemies)..." Are you saying Chomsky is the underdog?