16 ms·
How Nextdoor reduced racist posts
- eknight15 10y agoGreat to see design changes that have a positive social impact. I really like Nextdoor, it's one of the few social networks I feel good using.
- TheGRS 10y agoOur company recently did a trial of looking for unconscious bias when we are making decisions, especially in terms of hiring practices. We all took a test to see if we had any unconscious bias toward gender and then discussed our results as a group. What really stuck with me is not that we have these sort of tendencies, but how shocked most people were at their own results. Most men in the room trended toward a bias toward men and women toward women. That shouldn't be that surprising really, but many were very disappointed in their results. I've been thinking it would be good to do another round of that with the race test, especially considering how predominately white our workplace is. I don't believe everyone is actively trying to be racist or sexist (though some certainly are), but we might not realize that we're doing that on an unconscious level. The tests are available here if you'd like to give it a try yourself, doesn't take very long. https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/selectatest.html https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/selectatest.html
- enoch_r 10y agoImplicit association tests have little predictive validity--that is, if we know that someone has more "unconscious bias" in an IAT, we should expect zero difference in their behavior. See: http://www.law.virginia.edu/pdf/faculty/reassessingpredictivevalidityoftheiat.pdf http://www.law.virginia.edu/pdf/faculty/reassessingpredictiv... https://www.researchgate.net/publication/239732934_Predicting_Ethnic_and_Racial_Discrimination_A_Meta-Analysis_of_IAT_Criterion_Studies https://www.researchgate.net/publication/239732934_Predictin... http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/sjop.12288/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/sjop.12288/abstra...
- nikcheerla 10y agoGreat studies. I always felt something was off about the IAT and couldn't tell exactly why. Maybe it primes us for racism/sexism/whatever it's testing?
- ee8aq3g5c6 10y agoI think many people posess a self-image that race is not a salient characteristic in their thoughts and they describe this as being "not racist". There is a premise in discussions about race that being racist (judging someone because of their race) and acting racist (treating someone differently based on their race) are two different things. We act not-racist to prove that we are not-racist in our brains. The accusation of racism can be rebutted by the argument that you can't read my mind. The implicit bias test shows that either this brain-focused definition of racism is wrong, or we need to accept that we are more racist that we would like to admit.
- newscracker 10y agoI like tests like these that can potentially point to internalized prejudices and biases. Knowing one's biases can cause pain and disappointment if we see that what we think of ourselves, and what we truly are, are two different things. However, having taken one test (just now), I was left with the feeling that these tests may probably not be very accurate for everyone. When I tried it, I did it more from a memory point of view to associate the word and category. I didn't even think about the sequences and any implicit connections. Of course, my result came as "little or no bias", which I do agree with because I have thought about these for a long time and have been contemplating biases (and biased thoughts/decisions) that were not clearly obvious in the past. What I'm not sure of is the applicability of this methodology for all kinds of people.
- tomjen3 10y agoImplicit assertions test is often used to "prove" biases, but honestly I have never seen a large (or any) number of publications that proves it works.
- beat 10y agoMost people are carrying racist/sexist biases. Very few are aware of it. It's really challenging to address.
- allendoerfer 10y agoInside the German version there is a test for biases against Western or Eastern Germany. I knew that I had a bias, but I was surprised that I found it that difficult when moving a bunch of Eastern German cities to one group to associate negative things to the group with the Western German cities. The test might not be totally fair, though. Is it actually a bias if it is based on facts? Soviet architecture, higher unemployment, high rate of extremism, lower buying power, less people, people moving to the West, the list goes on and on. I think stereotypes and preconceived notions are bad most of the time, but I see no reason to get rid of the ones that are actually true for political correctness.
- Mithaldu 10y agoWhat is the german version of nextdoor? I've never heard of such a thing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Jarwain 10y agoI think he's referring to the german version of the implicit association test
- awl130 10y agothe test is fair if the goal of reducing racial bias is not to reduce crime but to achieve a more integrated society. in the long term, if such a policy contributes to a more integrated society, then more crime in the short term is deemed an unfortunate but necessary sacrifice. this is, in essence, the implication of such social pressure.
- int_19h 10y agoThe test is totally fair in a sense that it does detect bias. What you're actually saying is that the bias itself is fair. Now, normally, it would depend on whether the facts that you're citing are true and relevant or not. I don't know enough to judge that. But secondly, even if the group bias is fair, it's still problematic when you apply it to a specific person. They do not necessarily have to be representative of their group average, and you owe at least giving them a shot to demonstrate that.
- pilom 10y agoFinally! This was one of the reasons I stopped actively using Nextdoor. My neighborhood in Denver is composed of a large group of elderly white people (who all seem to use Nextdoor somehow) and then a diverse group of people who have moved into this lower income neighborhood as the old people have passed away. The amount of profiling was painful. We had a black mentally handicapped man get picked up by the police because he asked a neighbor to borrow a ladder and she posted to nextdoor that she thought her house was getting cased to be robbed (and the police and Nextdoor have a partnership in our area). Hopefully this helps some.
- trose 10y agoOMG Arvada is pretty bad too. We had some hispanic kids causing trouble in the park and people were trying to organize on NextDoor to go confront them with baseball bats. We're talking about 13 year olds here... It's definitely been used as a safehaven for paranoid old white people.
- smsm42 10y ago> black mentally handicapped man get picked up by the police because he asked a neighbor to borrow a ladder I think there's a problem with the police, not Nextdoor, here. I mean, ok, somebody asked to check out suspicious person (and police, with their experience, should know how (non-)reliable such reports usually are) and they did. But picking the person up - which I understand means detaining the person - is decision that the police officer responding is making. No reporter can make such decision. And if this decision leads to innocent man borrowing a ladder being detained - this is not really reporter's fault, it's the police being unprofessional.
- randomanybody 10y agoIt's interesting how different neighborhoods can be in the same city. In Seattle, my old neighborhood's board (First Hill) was vastly different than that of Ballard, to the point where I wasn't sure my friends who lived there were talking about the same site. The latter sounded like it was filled entirely with militant, yet simultaneously skittish NIMBYers, while mine was filled with park get-togethers and lost puppies. And since you could only see one neighborhood, the other experience was invisible to me.
- techsupporter 10y agoI live in the Central District of Seattle and a friend, who made an account and lets me log in so I can read, lives in Wallingford. The differences are appalling. The CD has its share of minor crime but reports of suspicious activity are accompanied by descriptions beyond race or, sometimes, security camera output. This is mixed in with posts about giveaways, contractor recommendations, and Metro bus reroutes due to construction. Meanwhile, my friend's account showed lots of posts like described here. Oh, and the slagging on the homeless was just vile. I have screenshots of several examples but I don't want Nextdoor to go all Erica Barnett on me and ban accounts so I leave them out. But the police department had a lot more "community forums" on the Wallingford part of Nextdoor than the CD's...
- walrus01 10y agotl;dr: overwhelmingly white suburbs are full of thinly veiled racism and xenophobia, shocking news.
- steveeq1 10y agoSaying people in overwhelmingly white suburbs are racist is racist in and of itself. You shouldn't generalize people's behavior based on the color of one's skin!
- walrus01 10y agovisit the Issaquah highlands some time....
- steveeq1 10y agoBy that same logic, I could say "visit compton sometime" and you would probably cry racism.
- nsxwolf 10y agoThat sort of reasoning doesn't apply when you're talking about white people. You are talking about the only group that enjoys and benefits from a unique privilege they cannot opt out of, regardless of how they may feel about other races.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agomore like, how nextdoor ignored the needs of its users, shot itself in the foot, and made itself irrelevant. you're all suspicious. you're all idiots.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lagadu 10y agoI didn't know what nextdoor was (nor do I live where it exists) but I see what seems to be a fundamental error: - They claim to have reduced "racist posts" by 75%. - They say they accomplished this by asking extra questions whenever a racial descriptor was used. In other words they simply made it harder to post when using a racial descriptor than not and claim this is a great reduction in racist posting. As a software developer I'm well aware of one thing: the more complicated I make a feature's interface be, the fewer people are going to use it. Without them having enabled the extra difficulty for all posting regardless of having used the racial descriptor or not, they're simply looking at people who don't post more using race not because they're racist but because they're placing an artificial hurdle associated with that. Now, if they simply wanted for people not to describe race they should've simply removed it from the options; they seem to be so proud of effectively doing that but in a (thinly) veiled way, as I understand it they're saying that any posts that include race of the individual are racist. Am I missing something obvious here?
- smallnamespace 10y agoYes: the questions they're forcing people to answer when they mention race in a post are not empty roadblocks that simply add friction to posting, but are also meant to sharpen the poster's thinking process by forcing them to focus on aspects other than race. That seems like a much more reasonable and even-handed approach than just simply saying race should never be mentioned.
- godshatter 10y agoI think they should go one step further. Instead of requiring two or more of a given list of descriptors if race was mentioned, just require three or more of the given list in the example image (with the age, build, and race questions added) no matter what. Then everyone gets to think about what makes someone suspicious. There may be biases related to how people dress, or what hair style they have or what age they are or even what their build is that can also be reduced by this method. Singling out the race question as one that needs to be handled delicately is the wrong way to go, in my opinion.
- oldmanjay 10y agoWhile I laud the goals, it's sort of disappointing to see such adherence to the idea that suppressing the expression of racism is going to fix it.
- ap3 10y agoA racist crime report will have real world consequences though - it's not just thoughts in someones head. It will involve other people and potentially the police.
- beat 10y agoRemember, these kinds of racially biased reports can get people killed. That's not insignificant.
- smsm42 10y agoReports don't get people killed. People (usually, police) shooting other people get people killed. Reporter has no control (unless they specifically and purposely misrepresent the situation, e.g. falsely reporting somebody firing a gun when they have none) over police actions. The police should bear the responsibility for the outcomes, not reporters or online platform or any other factor that did not actually make a decision to pull the trigger.
- st3v3r 10y agoReports lead to those people getting killed. And the reporters absolutely should bear some responsibility when they report someone simply for being black in the wrong neighborhood.
- smsm42 10y agoReports never killed anybody. You can't kill a person with a report. Police is not some mindless robots that are programmed to kill on a press of a button. They are humans, and they should bear full responsibility for their choices, not somebody who asked them to perform their direct function (for which they are paid from the same person's money, btw).
- pavlov 10y agoThis could work on HN too. A simple list of combinations of keywords (such as "Node.js" and "shit") detected in a comment submission could trigger a confirmation dialog: "Are you sure this is a meaningful contribution?"
- MustardTiger 10y agoIt is interesting the extent to which leftists seem to believe they can control people's thinking by controlling their expression. As though I will cease to be racist if you don't let me post racist comments on your website. Doesn't it actually work the other way around? Changing people's thinking changes their behavior.
- beat 10y agoInteresting that you used "leftist" as an implicitly derogatory term here. Think about it.
- nikcheerla 10y agoI was under the impression that 'leftist' (like SJW) is a derogatory term used for people who would likely call themselves 'liberals' or 'progressives'. Just like I've never seen someone unironically call themselves a 'fundamentalist'.
- kmicklas 10y agoI think leftist and SJW are not necessarily considered derogatory by those who identify as those things.
- beat 10y agoThe intent of the OP was derogatory. Doesn't matter what the recipient thinks.
- int_19h 10y ago"Leftist" is just bad grammar, really.
- djeikyb 10y agoIt doesn't detract from your point, but.. I've been around hundreds of people who use the term fundamentalist proudly as sort of an advertisement for their brand of christianity. They looked askance at other flavours of christianity, believing those to have drifted from the fundamentals of the religion.
- daenz 10y agoSide note, brilliant marketing. This is such a hot-button topic, that although I disagree fundamentally with their solution, it will definitely have a lot of people talking about it. I wish he had gone into more details about what counts as a "racist post." He seems to imply that people were just saying "black dude walking around." But would "black man peering into parked cars" also be flagged? And do those extra barriers, existing solely because of the word "black", lower the reporting rate of those kinds of posts?
- steveeq1 10y agoYes, I was thinking this exact thing. They're making things better on one metric, but (possibly) making things worse on another. The article doesn't really address the issues of false positives.
- clifanatic 10y agoOr "man peering into black cars".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 10y agoWell, it looks like they define racist post as: The company decided to define it as descriptions of criminal behavior that don’t have sufficient description, i.e. “dark-skinned man broke into a car” or a detailed description of someone, including race, that fails to describe them doing something sufficiently criminal. I.e. it is a description that mentions race and lacks either: a) specific criminal behavior or b) other non-race details. In this case, no wonder that forcing people to provide these details reduces number of such posts - it's practically guaranteed by the very definition! I also wonder about this: Nextdoor is aware of “two instances of racial profiling that had slipped through its algorithms in the last few months.” Nextdoor is a pretty large network. And they have quite a lot of people there, tens if not hundreds of thousands at least. And only two cases of profiling in several months, less then one case per month over whole network? It's either nextdoor users actually are nearly saints in this regard, at least compared to regular population, or they are humblebragging, or the problem itself is really minuscule, or they are blind to it.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoI had to quit Nextdoor. The same small cabal of loudmouths was overwhelming the forums with strong (yet uninformed) opinions, reflex hatred of anything signalling change, and a general seething that bordered on xenophobia. I expect some NIMBYism, but this was outrageously militant hatred of the future masquerading as quaint pride. Nextdoor also seems to give people strange priorities for civic engagement. Winning an argument on Nextdoor doesn't change policy...speaking at Council/School Board meetings does, or better yet, running in an election. Lots of people on our local Nextdoor seemed frustrated that the Council were voting contrary to some conclusion that was reached on the site. They failed to realize they needed to be making arguments where it mattered - at Council meetings, not online in some private forum.
- fapjacks 10y agoRight, exactly! The one thing Nextdoor taught me is that people are truly just as awful as you could imagine. I have lived in nice neighborhoods -- as I imagine a fair amount of HN readers do -- and the blase of outright totally racist posts just... Well, it was just shocking, and I have to say that I'm not shocked by very many things. That some people know that they're posting to their physical neighbors and still saying the things they say... It's almost like they live on another planet altogether. Now, another very weird thing is that I've moved into a new neighborhood literally down the street from my old one, and I was equally shocked to learn that this particular neighborhood is totally reasonable, and I haven't even seen a single racist hate-post. Nextdoor definitely exposed me to the racist, backwards reality of living among old, wealthy, scared, white people.
- mavhc 10y agoUse it to lie to them about when elections are. The thing that's worse about elections being won by idiots and racists is now you know that most people around you are idiots, racists, or happy to stand next to the racist idiots.
- fapjacks 10y agoI regret that I can only upvote your comment a single time.
- ebfe 10y agoAre you equally sympathetic to stories of harassment of white people by black people? A white person, after all, is far more likely to be harmed by a black person than a black person is to be harmed by the police. When you hear whites tell stories of harassment by black people, do you make sure not to minimize their experiences?
- hackuser 10y agoThe premise of this question is false. I object to the harassment of anyone, regardless of the color of their skin. Who would object to preventing the harassment of people with black skin, and why? There's a massive and historic problem of black-skinned people being harassed (and much worse) by police and civilians. The evidence is overwhelming. Therefore, we need to put great effort into solving it. The idea that there is a competition between races is not only absurd but well-established to be highly damaging; the results are very bad for everyone. Stopping the harassment of black-skinned people helps everyone. If there's a competition, it's the hateful vs. the great majority who are civilized, regardless of skin color (or religion or sexual preference or country of origin or anything else). I'm on the side of the civilized. If we built a wall to keep out the hateful, think how many problems would simply disappear.
- ebfe 10y agoThe premise of this question is false. I object to the harassment of anyone, regardless of the color of their skin. Who would object to preventing the harassment of people with white skin, and why? There's a massive and historic problem of white-skinned people being harassed (and much worse) by black-skinned people. The evidence is overwhelming. Therefore, we need to put great effort into solving it. The idea that there is a competition between races is not only absurd but well-established to be highly damaging; the results are very bad for everyone. Stopping the harassment of white-skinned people helps everyone.
- hackuser 10y agoNo, that is false and there is no equivalence. White people were not slaves, were not subject to segregation and its cousin redlining; were not and are not suffering widespread exclusion from education, finance, housing, healthcare, government, employment, and most other aspects of society; were not lynched; are not subject to harassment, assault and imprisonment by law enforcement due to their skin color (of which there is overwhelming evidence). Look at a photo of the US Senate, or almost any state or local government; a photo of Fortune 500 CEOs or people who work in SV or Wall Street, or elite university faculty and administration: If you meet a police officer, note their skin color, and that of the DA, the judge, the appeals court judge, the legislators who write the laws that they all enforce. You can see who understands, protects and furthers the interests of white-skinned people when they are threatened. Also, despite your implication, I said that I oppose the harassment of everyone, which of course includes any group you name.
- hackuser 10y agoThe Washington Post covering the same story: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/08/26/how-this-social-network-for-neighborhoods-is-trying-to-fix-its-racism-problem/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/08/26... ---- And also the WP covering a similar problem in Georgetown (a wealthy district in Washington): * The secret surveillance of ‘suspicious’ blacks in one of the nation’s poshest neighborhoods https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/the-secret-surveillance-of-suspicious-blacks-in-one-of-the-nations-poshest-neighborhoods/2015/10/13/2e47236c-6c4d-11e5-b31c-d80d62b53e28_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/the-secre... * The black man arrested in Georgetown because he looked like a shoplifter https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/the-black-man-arrested-in-georgetown-because-he-looked-like-a-shoplifter/2015/10/16/0a93fd00-7409-11e5-9cbb-790369643cf9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/the-black... * Georgetown social network accused of racial profiling is suspended https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/georgetown-social-network-accused-of-racial-profiling-is-suspended/2015/10/19/7a8865a2-7674-11e5-b9c1-f03c48c96ac2_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/georgetown-social-netwo... (Wow. What is the shortest possible Washington Post URL?)
- tptacek 10y agoI didn't even know Nextdoor was a thing until I saw this post. Where, once logged in, would I look to see random people being reported as suspicious by my neighbors?
- mercutio2 10y agoWell, you can't get an account until you validate your postal address, then you only get access to posts from your neighborhood and adjoining neighborhoods. Once you've signed up, if you install the app, you can configure push notifications about crimes in progress. You can also get emails for urgent things, if you prefer. Whether this improves, or diminishes, security and quality of life relative to reading your local newspaper's coverage, is unclear to me. Even when it's not subtly racist or ageist profiling, I've never found the alerts to be actionable. But the hyperlocal idea is at least an interesting one.
- eli 10y agoIt's basically just a listserv. The quality and content of the posts depends mostly on which of your neighbors happen to have joined.
- thescribe 10y agoI wonder if they're just scanning for the word "black" or other races too. Edit: I answer my own question pretty quickly but it led to a second thought. I'm curious if the reduction is just people not reporting things because there are more steps now.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoIt says right on the article. "Others actually had their posts scanned for mentions of race (based on a list of hundreds of terms Nextdoor came up with)" Edit: You edited your post. Your original comment I was replying to said something along the lines of "I wonder if they're just scanning for the word "black" or other races too."
- thescribe 10y agoShoot sorry about that, I hadn't seen your comment. I'll revert my post.
- randyrand 10y agoI understand that it's racial bias to assume that someone is more likely to commit a crime given the color of their skin, but at the same time given that thats a reasonable assumption, I also think it's very reasonable to put your own safety above social progress. Are my priorities not inline?
- jecjec 10y agoIs Nextdoor wise to pursue this end? (pdf) http://2kpcwh2r7phz1nq4jj237m22.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/Color-Of-Crime-2016.pdf http://2kpcwh2r7phz1nq4jj237m22.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-c... Synopsis: http://www.amren.com/the-color-of-crime/ http://www.amren.com/the-color-of-crime/
- jomamaxx 10y agoWho decides what 'racism' is? It's a pretty tricky thing. Should our corporate overlords be making this decision? Outside of hate speech, which has some legal parameters, this is pretty tough. Especially if it's people's personal communications. Some people think that speaking out against 'Black Lives Matter' is racist, while others think that 'Black Lives Matter' is in fact racist. It's a thin line.