4 ms·
A friend who is a patent lawyer gave me a short spiel on why software patents are bad. I'll repeat it. We have two types of intellectual property protection. P
by Gibbon1 10y ago
A friend who is a patent lawyer gave me a short spiel on why software patents are bad. I'll repeat it.
We have two types of intellectual property protection. Patents and copyright. And they are oriented towards too different categories.
Copyright is designed to create a working market for artists, writers, musicians, etc. These people's work is characterized be low output and hit and miss success. A writer might complete a two dozen works and two of which make any money. So you need protection on the order of a human lifetime.
Patents. Patents are totally misunderstood. The core of a patent isn't an idea. Nor is it the answer to a question, how do we do X. Really the core of the patent is the question itself. Knowing which questions are important is what is hard. And patents traditionally apply to physical things, because the physical world is very hard to reason about. It takes a lot of work to figure out and that is what needs protection. The proper period of protection is the course of a product lifecycle. So 20 years, something like that.
Software doesn't fit into either of these. Primarily because for most software the output is determined very mechanically from the requirements. (Unlike, gee a flying car would be nice, or write me a beloved novel that people will still buy 50 years hence). And software ages like yesterdays fish. His comment is, Windows 3.1, 25 years old and who cares. But it's copyrighted for another 75 years.
So software needs it's own category of protection, yes but that is much shorter.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoNot bad except that there really is no reason to reward people with a lifelong monopoly via copyright. The term in the Act of Anne that first formalised copyright was 12 years and I think that was long enough.
- Noseshine 10y agoWhile I too am against software patents, I have some issues with one line of reasoning here. > software ages like yesterdays fish That is not true for a lot of software. The example has been very carefully selected, of course the most widely distributed piece of software that heavily interacts with the hardware, itself being developed at a rapid pace, changes a lot. However, a lot of commercially used software has a much more glacial pace. That is especially true for internally used software with no outside market, where a business simply has no reason to invest as long as it works. Decades old software is quite common - and with the aid of VMs we'll keep a lot of it for even longer now. I also miss even the attempt to show that even if I would just accept the statement at face value it would be relevant to why software patents are bad? (Again, a statement I actually agree with.) If it's obsolete a patent for the now obsolete piece of software should be less of a problem: > His comment is, Windows 3.1, 25 years old and who cares. ...because as you write, "who cares"? My main problem is that the entire concept is fuzzy as hell. For example, US patent law excludes "abstract ideas" [0], but software is an abstract idea. Looking at an early example for a software patent "...efficient memory management for the simplex algorithm...implemented by purely software means" [1] I can't find otherwise. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patent [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patent#Early_example_of_a_software_patent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patent#Early_example_...
- lordnacho 10y agoDoesn't that argue for an ad hoc expiry? Product cycles in mobile phones and washing machines are different.
- PatentTroll 10y agoYeah, it's an impossible to implement idea. Lawyers would game the hell out of that system.
- Finnucane 10y ago"These people's work is characterized be low output and hit and miss success. A writer might complete a two dozen works and two of which make any money. So you need protection on the order of a human lifetime." Whereas programmers are always successful? And the reason given here for "protection on the order of human lifetime" is spurious, since the longer copyright terms are more for the benefit of corporate, rather than individual, creators. Commercial viability has no bearing on whether a work is eligible for copyright. There's really no aspect of software that couldn't be covered by copyright, except perhaps the requirement of 'novelty'--certain categories are not copyrightable, but in the case of software, its really the novelty of the whole work that counts. The important thing about copyright and patents here is that they're supposed to be mutually exclusive--categories of things that are patentable are not copyrightable, and vice versa.
- PatentTroll 10y agoEh, the term isn't the worst part of software patents. Obviousness and bad law are the worst parts. The term only exacerbates the issue